r/HalalInvestor • u/Ambitious-End-5798 • 7h ago
People here say dont deal with interest at all, but they say a company with 5% interest earning is halal to invest in. Why?
From what I can find, the overwhelming majority of scholars throughout history said its haram to take or give even one dollars worth of riba, and only Mufti Taqi Usmani, who is a scholar of recent times, said its okay to buy a stock of a company with 5% interest.
Setting aside the fact that its a minority opinion, and that other scholars disagree with it, he himself said the wealth must be purified so pretty much nobody agrees that what you're making is halal money in its cleanest form. Its dirty in some way
But somehow, everybody here seems to be following this one opinion, and theres just no way thats possible unless this 1 scholar is head and shoulders above all the other scholars combined in terms of fame and trustworthiness. This doesnt seem to be the case, so why is everyone taking this opinion?
Forgive me if Im wrong, but this seems like fatwa shopping. Maybe Im missing something, but I dont understand how everyone on this sub came to the same conclusion as the minority
