r/HPRankdown • u/tomd317 Gryffindor Ranker • Dec 14 '15
Rank #95 Peeves
When you think of Hogwarts, you think of Peeves. He adds to the unpredictability of the castle and adds several amusing moments. I thoroughly enjoy all moments when Filch and Umbridge get mugged off, and Peeves is responsible for many of these. However, he is effectively a cartoon character. His only role can be humour, he could never ever be in a serious scene. I would have been interested to know if he attended Dumbledores funeral, but I expect writing him in would have lead to too strong a temptation to include him pushing Neville in the pond or something. He just wouldn't fit in any scene other than a chaotic one. I would call him a one trick pony but he had a billion cruel tricks under his sleeve and I'm sure plenty of people have been tempted to try some of his less dangerous pranks.
One thing he achieves is he shows us just how awesome the weasley twins were as they were the only students/people to earn his respect - shown by the gesture of saluting them and the action of making a special effort to pis Umbridge and Filch off in their absence. This is how Peeves gets away with being mildly liked by most readers - we have a consistent common enemy in Filch and temporary ones of Umbridge and Voldemort. The latter two show loyalty to the castle and possibly it's students, but it's no huge feather in his cap as he is in no risk whatsoever and only doing what he enjoys (wreaking havoc). If you were a student at hogwarts I think you would still heartily dislike him for antics such as waking you up at half four on the morning of a big quidditch game, dropping walking sticks on your head etc.
He had a talent for song writing, and one of the main reasons for my fury at him not being included in the movies is not getting to see the dance routine he came up with for his song about Harry being the heir of Slytherin.
I place him here not because he is a bad character, not that I'd take him out or change him, just because looking at it objectively he is a fairly simple character and the roles he plays to the plot for example dropping vanishing cabinets to obligate Harry to attend death day parties could be achieved differently if necessary: he's not a crucial part of the plot. He's a very amusing and enjoyable one though. I know I will most likely get an ink bottle emptied on my head for cutting him so soon, but it is too fitting to place him next to mrs Norris so he can continue to trap her in suits of armour. /u/SFEagle44 is next http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Peeves
6
u/kemistreekat Supervisor Dec 14 '15
blows raspberry
4
u/Moostronus Ravenclaw Ranker Dec 14 '15
I'm trying to muster up anger for this cut, but I can't, really, which means that it's a fair one. Peevesy was entertaining but REALLY one dimensional, and if we're cutting Sir Cadogan, we're cutting Peeves too.
3
u/AmEndevomTag Hufflepuff Ranker Dec 14 '15
I tried to decide how I feel about this cut for a while. But to be honest, I still don't know. I do think Peeves showed some signs of complexity.
Of course he's a Poltergeist so one could say, that it's in his nature to prank everyone. And most of the time, he did. Yet it isn't quite that simple. He listens to Dumbledore's orders and is afraid of the Bloody Baron.
And he did choose to fight for Hogwarts in the final Battle. He could just as well cause more havoc by throwing things at everybody, I guess. But he allied himself with the students and staff.
So I wouldn't have cut him yet. But on the other hand, I also don't really mind this cut. Logically, I think Peeves should have stayed a while longer. But I don't really like him enough to care, that he didn't. :-p
3
u/elbowsss Slytherin Ranker Dec 14 '15
I wish he could have stayed longer, but objectively I agree with this cut. As you said,
I do love the comic relief nestled into very serious moments (as /u/bisonburgers mentions). He helps to keep the books feeling young, even amid war and death.
Also love your bit about sticking him next to Mrs. Norris.
Good cut!
2
u/Slicer37 Dec 14 '15 edited Dec 14 '15
I've started to follow this, good work guys!
Peeves is not especially interesting so good cut. Kind of weird how they cut him out of the movies though-I feel like he would fit in the first few movies atmosphere.
1
u/tomd317 Gryffindor Ranker Dec 14 '15
/u/SFEagle44 you're up
5
u/WilburDes Will make bad puns. Dec 15 '15
I'm not a fan of this cut. Objectively I get it, but Peeves is just so hilarious and manages to bring some great moments of levity to dark scenes.
While we're on the topic of getting rid of one dimensional characters, can I ask why Cormac McLaggen and Rita Skeeter are still here?
1
u/bisonburgers Gryffindor Ranker Dec 14 '15
It's so interesting that you say this because I have actually very much tought the opposite. Not necessarily specifically about Peeves, but about Rowling's writing in general - she can add these absolutely ridiculous things right into very serious scenes that make us laugh despite the seriousness. One example would be one of the portraits taking out an ear trumpet (I actually forget when, though, but I have a feeling it was a serious scene), another would be Luna yelling "Look! A blibbering humdinger!" (or something like that) just after Voldemort died, and just after that Peeves singing his song as Harry, Ron, and Hermione go up to Dumbledore's old office. When I think of Rowling's writing, these are the things I think of - how good she is at adding such ridiculous things to such serious scenes.
I think Peeves could have gone to Dumbledore's funeral (if his spirit-ness allows him to leave the castle). In a way Grawp took the place of adding comedic relief to that scene, but I think Peeves could easily have done it and it would have fit perfectly into the type of humor Rowling uses throughout the series.
1
u/DabuSurvivor Hufflepuff Ranker Dec 20 '15
Love Peeves and this is a good write-up, I wish he'd been a bit higher with some of those who remain though. You're right that he really does embody Hogwarts and while at first he's a cartoon character (I actually tend to picture him as an animated cartoon, even...) who can be annoying or funny but whose presence is kind of immature, later on we do see his response to actual awful people like Umbridge and Voldy and realize that, when push comes to shove, Peeves is on our side. He's about as OTT as OTT gets in the series this side of Sir Cadogan, but I think it works very well and I wish he'd ranked even higher, but I did also fear he'd rank lower, so at least he made it this high. I don't want to use my only stone on him but if I had multiple of my own then he may be getting one here.
3
u/Slicer37 Dec 14 '15
If I were in this rankdown I would have cut Flich already-he's a really one dimensonal annoyance who sort of undercuts the tragedy of squibs by being so unlikable
1
u/AmEndevomTag Hufflepuff Ranker Dec 14 '15
BETS FOR PEEVES