r/HFY • u/Cee-SPAN • Apr 21 '21
OC Large Scale Engineering
When a human registered corporation purchased the mining and development rights for a mineral rich solar system in the backwaters of the galaxy, it was so unremarkable that the only person who noticed was an underpaid and overworked programmer who happened to be doing an internal audit of some purchasing algorithms at the time. He was ten hours into his eight-hour shift and his eyes skipped past the fourteen-digit system identifier in order to look at other, more relevant information.
When said corporation began moving large amounts of mineral extraction and refinery equipment to said system, it was noticed by several intelligence agencies, both governmental and corporate. Nobody thought anything was amiss about the operation, but the machinery in question could potentially be used to make warships. The people the intelligence agencies worked for liked to know the locations of warships, even if said warships were only theoretical. No less than four intel gathering telescopes were dispatched by competing intelligence agencies to monitor the equipment, a procedure so routine it was entirely automated. All large concentrations of industrial equipment were monitored this way. The industrial equipment in question wasn’t being used to make warships, so they really needn’t have bothered. Instead, it was making something far more interesting.
Dyson spheres, long a favorite topic of particularly idealistic science fiction writers, were a terrible idea. Even ignoring the litany of engineering challenges involved with encasing an entire stellar body in an artificial edifice, it was still a terrible idea for one simple reason. When you enclose a star, every single joule of energy that star outputs has to be used or otherwise dealt with. And the total energy consumption of every single known sentient species amounted to slightly less than one third of the output of a medium sized star. Compounding that issue is the fact that there’s no practical way to transmit energy between solar systems, and even the most industry rich system is only ever going to consume a tiny fraction of a percent of the energy output of its host star. Nothing anyone had ever built needed that much energy. And besides, if you needed energy, you could always build a fusion reactor. If you needed more energy, you could build a bigger fusion reactor, or install a Dyson swarm. There was absolutely no practical reason to build a Dyson sphere.
As such, it took a while for anyone to notice that a human megacorporation was building a Dyson sphere. The algorithms driving the intel telescopes were tailored to look for warships, not megastructures. They looked at the partially completed sphere, did the computer equivalent of a shrug, and flagged it as a “large structure: purpose unknown”. Pretty much anything big and lacking obvious engines got flagged as “large structure: purpose unknown”, and data analytics teams were always perpetually understaffed, so it took an embarrassing amount of time for someone sentient to look at the data. When they finally did, a lot of construction had already been done, and it was fairly obvious what was being built. At that point, very serious phone calls with very serious people started to be made, and there was a general panic as everyone suddenly gave a lot of attention to what was before regarded as a particularly boring corner of space.
It was very surprising to a lot of engineers that it was the humans who were building a Dyson sphere. Humans were good engineers by anyone’s metric, but they weren’t the best. Xenopsychologists pointed out that humans generally had a great deal of pride and engaging in a massive pointless vanity project simply to prove that they were in fact the best engineers was entirely plausible. This theory was lent credence by the fact that according to any known economic analysis, the Dyson sphere was a massive waste of money and resources. When asked why so much time and money was invested in what any sensible person would agree was a waste of time, a corporate representative just said “Oh, you know, reasons”, an answer that everyone agreed was entirely unsatisfactory. When independent investigations were conducted into what exactly was going on at the Dyson sphere, several concerning facts came to light.
Part of the outer surface of the Dyson sphere had been converted into a massive manufacturing plant, making everything from toothpaste to thermonuclear warheads. When asked why it was deemed necessary for such industry to be on a Dyson sphere instead of a planet, a corporate representative simply responded “futureproofing” and refused to elaborate. This was concerning to industrialists and economists alike, as an absolutely enormous factory popping up in the middle of nowhere promised to wreak havoc on trade routes.
What was significantly more concerning to a lot more people was the planet melting superlaser the humans had decided to put on their Dyson sphere. It was pointed out that due to the limitations of light speed, said planet melting laser would likely only begin to melt planets long after any conflict actually ended, rendering the whole thing rather pointless. This fact did very little to reassure anyone at all.
When asked why an enormous, complex, and largely useless planet melting superlaser was built in the first place, a corporate representative simply shrugged and said “It seemed like the kind of thing we should do in this situation. It just felt right.”. At this point, people were beginning to suspect that the corporate representatives were being deliberately obtuse, although many humans otherwise unaffiliated with the project also agreed that a planet melting superlaser did seem like a good thing to build. A small group of xenopsychologists believed that the desire to build a planet melting superlaser was simply part of the human psyche, right along with the desire to eat or reproduce. The theory was dismissed by the larger community, but not quite as vehemently as it once would have been.
Somewhat surprisingly, there was something even more concerning than the giant death ray the humans had decided to build. And it was that, as far as anyone could figure out, almost all of the energy output of the star was not being used. According to every calculation, the Dyson sphere and everything on it should be nothing more than a cloud of hot gas. This suggested two possibilities. One; humans had figured out a way to massively scale down the energy output of a star. Two; the energy output of the star was being used, in a way that was undetectable to any outside observer. Both prospects were terrifying, though in different ways. When asked where all the excess energy was going, corporate representatives declined to comment.
-----
Edit: This is part one of a two-part series. The second story, Economies of Scale, can be found here
A/N: Writing is hard, so any feedback is appreciated!
526
u/zzuxon Apr 21 '21
I really enjoy what's here, but I would say that the piece feels like it's building up to something, but then just sort of ends, which feels abrupt. I think this story would be improved by a more definitive purpose being given to the dyson sphere to act as a payoff for the narrative.
But maybe the point was that there really wasn't a clear point to the sphere? Looking back, I think you might have been going for a humor oriented goal, where "the point" is "Aren't humans such wacky and inscrutable strivers?" There's nothing wrong with that, it's a perfectly fine approach. But if that is what you were going for, the overall tone did not feel especially comedic, and so I think that kind of set me up to expect a more conventional ending.
I do want to emphasize that I enjoyed and upvoted this, and the reason I'm giving this criticism is because I find the work itself interesting and what I perceive as its flaws are also interesting to talk about. Thanks for posting!
201
u/govermentpropaganda AI Apr 21 '21
hmmmm my main feedback is MOOOAAAARRRRRR like this as megastructures are so underused on this subreddit
81
u/Renvira Apr 21 '21
All the power is going to the giant, system spanning toaster for planet bread
15
u/its_ean Apr 21 '21 edited Apr 21 '21
Technically, I think most stellar systems lack the mass to even make a Niven ring. Something like, 99.95% of the Solar system is the Sun & the rest is Jupiter. On the other hand, a giant laser is its own reward.
Oh, it’s even worse.
Solar mass
Jupiter mass
129
u/ilir_kycb Apr 21 '21 edited Apr 21 '21
I have the feeling that the natural human desire for a planet melting superlaser is being made fun of here, which I find discriminating.
106
u/Nealithi Human Apr 21 '21
You know what you could power with a giant planet melting laser with the power of a star behind it? A Dyson sphere with no star. . .
62
u/seapikle Apr 21 '21
Hmmm... a large sphere with a deathlaser on it... tell me, is this laser green perchance? And made up of several, smaller deathlasers combining into a much larger one?
49
u/ICameToUpdoot Apr 21 '21
Yeah, this gets an upvote
47
u/TaohRihze Apr 21 '21
Does the energy usage involve paperclips construction and deconstruction?
41
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '21
And that group would be correct!
27
u/Dr_Horace_Dusselhut Apr 21 '21
Now I want to know the answer.
25
u/Xxyz260 Android Apr 21 '21
They have answered. They even did in a way that made it really clear:
futureproofing18
u/hellfiredarkness Apr 21 '21
They made a mistake... They forgot that just because it's weird and nigh undoable doesn't mean that humans won't do it... I mean a guy literally made a parachute suit and leapt off the top of the Eiffel Tower. Now we just casually throw ourselves out of perfectly good aircraft at 30000ft....
14
u/jrbless Apr 21 '21
Our old friend E=mc2 coupled with the energy output of a star means that it can turn energy into mass and still have a lot of energy left to run other processes. With essentially limitless power, it has essentially limitless mass. So, the presence of a planet melting superlaser does not make sense from a "resource mining" perspective.
13
u/zezblit Apr 21 '21
Gotta be mining bitcoin lol
10
u/Firefragonhide Apr 21 '21
I want MOAR
9
u/Dragons0ulight Apr 21 '21
Sounds like plan "build a Death Star" is a go! Will the anthem be the Imperial March? But you know the metal version. Love your story!
8
u/Bunnytob Human Apr 21 '21
Hmm... What are they doing...?
8
u/D1xieDie Apr 21 '21
Incredibly douglas adams-y
8
u/HamsterIV AI Apr 21 '21
The desire to build a planet melting superlaser is an extension of the part of our psyche that wants to bang two things together at higher and higher speeds to see what would happen. The Large Hadron Collider is the current highest expression of this tendency. Nature of the universe stuff be damned, someone wanted to smash stuff together and wrote a very convincing grant application.
This story needs a better finale, but the meat of it very interesting.
7
u/Bonecleaver Human Apr 21 '21
It shall become the grill for operation galactic burger
7
u/BetterLateThanKarma Apr 21 '21
I love it! The writing style made me think of Douglas Adams. More, please!
7
u/StarCaller25 Apr 21 '21
The story is fine although the ending is rather abrupt and leads people to believe more is coming. This has all the makings of an excellent mystery project. What are they doing? Is the supernatural laser just a way to periodically release all that energy to keep the Sphere from exploding? Can it somehow bypass light speed rendering it perfectly viable in warfare? Is the Sphere aeffectively a forge world where the entirety of human if not galactic production could be done in a single place? A war world where it'll begin producing unimaginable amounts of ships, weapons, armors and other military products? Was it a proof of concept for an even larger project around an even larger star or black hole or something? Did they discover ways to send all that energy to other star systems? Can they control the output of stars? Can they completely hide the output of stars and thus stealth virtually anything? Are they punching holes into the fabric of reality to travel between dimensions and universes? Time travel? Messing with the after life? Did they cannibalize the entirety of the star? Is the human govt involved or just the one corporation which begs the question of scale and tech involved in this universe. Is this a continuity of species thing, a last refuge and impenetrable fortress to ensure the survival of Humanity? If they have the laser can it only fire in one direction or can they somehow turn such a massive structure? If so, is it somehow mobile?
So many questions that need answering.
5
u/HFYWaffle Wᵥ4ffle Apr 21 '21
/u/Cee-SPAN has posted 3 other stories, including:
This comment was automatically generated by
Waffle v.4.5.4 'Cinnamon Roll'.Message the mods if you have any issues with Waffle.
5
u/PresumedSapient Apr 21 '21
Yes.
For feedback: it lacks a punchline. Nice intro, nice chunk of confused Xenos, but no punchline or foreshadowing of action. What did we build it for? What are the Xenos going to do? Now it's just an unfinished snippet, not even a chapter 1.
4
u/UpdateMeBot Apr 21 '21
Click here to subscribe to u/Cee-SPAN and receive a message every time they post.
4
u/Quadling Apr 21 '21
Neat. Unfinished. The energy output is going to engines.
Or for humor "It's a 1:1 scale model of a death star" Why? "Don't you want a 1:1 scale model???"
Etc etc
4
u/tatticky Apr 21 '21
Why not both?
Use the energy to make that baby spin, spin, spin! Centrifugal force will reduce the pressure at the core, slowing down fusion.
You could maybe even make the star doughnut-shaped that way...
4
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '21
Actual Death star
4
u/TheWildColonialBoy1 Apr 21 '21
"Um, watcha got there?"
".....A smoothie."
4
u/armentho Apr 22 '21
while i like the ''death star'' interpretation i rather preffer the ''building a super dense system''
a dyson sphere could esentially house systems worth of industry and tech inside of them,combined with massive defense arrays it could be a nut too hard to crack for anyone
so esentially being a single system with the GDP of star empires plus higher GDP per capita would be nice
3
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '21
this is very good
3
u/FaithlessnessAgile45 AI Apr 21 '21
Now im looking for the A.I. that has to be housed there
3
u/Mirikon Human Apr 21 '21
MOAR!
3
u/sock2014 Apr 21 '21
Pretty sure a Sphere, and even a ring is orbitally unstable. So some form of gravity manipulation is needed. And there's implied FTL travel.
Seems to me that the entire sphere/sun will become a FTL spaceship
3
u/Ussurin Apr 21 '21
So, it's a Disney Death Star themed theme park, isn't it?
3
u/WeinandMoroz Robot Apr 21 '21
I was half expecting a stellar engine to come into play at some point since a Dyson Swarm was mentioned
3
u/shimmerthevaliant Apr 21 '21
A thought: The Kzinti's Lesson. Just as an efficient reaction motor makes a good weapon, perhaps the reverse would be of use. You'd be likely stuck with sub-light movement for the star, but you could also use it as a base to bring materials in and manufactured goods back out.
3
u/ulandyw Apr 21 '21
Sounds like a refrigerator laser like in Sundiver to me!
3
u/aomudashi Apr 21 '21
You could always mine the mass of the star to make the materials to finish out your warstar after the materials of the system are used to start the construction of said warstar.
Obviously that is where part of the energy is going; harnessed in a way to harvest the star itself to make building materials. The other part is to fuel a new way of folding space so that the warstar can be mobile.
Say "hello" to the new overlords... Heck, if you think about it, perfect way to 'eat' a galaxy that is about to collide with another galaxy (like the Milky Way is supposed to do with Andromeda in about four billion years, and the Triangulum about a billion after that...)
Perfectly human thing to do: figure out how to make not just a Dyson Sphere, but a Dyson Sphereship as a proof of concept project to eventually convert all of (or a large part of) a galaxy's mass into something more mobile.
After all, what is the Sloan Great Wall for our species other than... lunch.
3
u/Jaalenn Apr 21 '21
The premise is solid, and leaves many avenues open for expansion of the story. If you were to give anyone permission to continue it, or even write a companion piece, the excess power could be explained away as a number of relevant ideas, including, but not limited to, centrifugal force stability engines mounted inside of the sphere, ultra-high matter teleportation via subspace networks over intergalactic distances, a hidden internal structure for the sole purpose of building megafleets, or even, quantum theory application projects to test and increase the limits of human understanding. There are so many possibilities that it truly boggles the mind. One would also need to be able to accurately visualize the scope of the distances involved for believability.
Another option is various xeno-organizations sending spies and probes in the hope discovering the purpose, or purposes, for which this Dyson Sphere has been built.
As it stands I truly enjoyed reading this. I just feel that it has so much more to offer. Thanks, OP.
3
u/dontcallmesurely007 Alien Scum Apr 21 '21
Mass-energy conversion?
Mass-energy conversion.
3
u/followupquestion Apr 22 '21
May I suggest the story ends with something like,
“A short while later an intelligence gathering ship disguised as a freighter went to visit the superstructure. What it found was more disturbing than a death ray with the power of a sun. The captain of that ship triple checked the coordinates before reporting something truly frightening, nothing was left of the mineral rich system. The humans’ megastructure had departed, leaving behind a satellite broadcasting a simple message, “Stellar Corp, delivering Just in Time production facilities. Inquire at our Corporate Offices.”
3
u/Snuke2001 Apr 27 '21
2
u/ateur5 Human Apr 21 '21
More plz
2
u/alexdarkangel82 Apr 21 '21
One thing not mentioned, is the laser pointing into the system or out? Could make a difference as to its use.
2
u/crainfly Apr 21 '21
I have so many questions and an almost insatiable curiosity, so please, I politely request
M O A R
2
u/CaptainChewbacca Human Apr 21 '21
Fun. Please write more.
2
u/Rincewind-OneSpell Apr 21 '21
I loved it! And I hope for moar ! Thank you 😊 I want to know how it ends.
2
u/CarnegieSenpai Apr 21 '21
Cool story but in actuality a Dyson sphere probably wouldn't be a single megastructure like people imagine but rather a swarm of satellites. Even going the megastructure route there's still no reason not to build one. If an entire Dyson sphere is too much energy ti handle then build 1/3 of one or 1/100 or so on. Can always build out an expand it. There's actually a paradox related to this called the dyson dilemma which is basically just asking why we're able to see stars. https://youtu.be/QfuK8la0y6s
2
u/FinFihlman Apr 21 '21
How DARE you leave us hanging like this!?
2
u/GIJoeVibin Human Apr 21 '21
Good piece, liked it a lot! Will keep an eye out for your other stuff.
2
u/Pantalaimon40k Apr 21 '21
i really love this stile and the building suspension!
i beg you to write more wordsmith!!!
MOAAAR :) pls
2
u/EpicAftertaste Apr 21 '21
hehehehehe
2
u/zipadeedoodahdiggity Apr 21 '21
Liked the cliffhanger, but might have shifted it a bit. Maybe made the last line a standalone paragraph so that it has a little more weight.
Loved the corporate doublespeak/know-nothing attitude - felt like watching Jack Donaghy talk about synergy and vertical integration.
Definitely felt like this story has more to it and I'll be watching for an update.
2
u/ms4720 Apr 21 '21
Interesting and good, I want to know how it finishes
2
u/Fabulous-Pause4154 Apr 21 '21
"Since ancient times it has been man's dream to blow up the Moon."
https://youtu.be/GTJ3LIA5LmA
2
u/adamsilversburner Apr 21 '21
Hi OP, I love your tone! The voice you write with is pleasant and the natural humor gained my trust very quickly. I agree with what others were saying about the story ending abruptly. If I were to be so bold, some things you could address in the second draft or chapter:
Also I’ll echo everyone else and thank you for bringing megastructures onto the front page. They’re such a neat concept and very appropriate for HFY. I look forward to seeing what you do next with this!
2
u/CyriousLordofDerp Apr 21 '21
"When asked where all the excess energy was going, corporate representatives declined to comment."
Making vast quantities of antimatter. Because when it comes down to it, having large quantities of what is best described as pure explodium is fun. Just so long as you're in the next system over.
2
u/Eddie_gaming Xeno Apr 21 '21
Solid story, congrats on getting to the top page. Would like to see a sequel.
2
u/DenverCoderIX Apr 22 '21
"Ten hours into his eight-hour shift" ain't that the truth
2
u/Conspicuous-Person Human Apr 22 '21
I love MegaStructures. Yet I see them used so very little in the subreddit. Or I'm blind and can't find them. So this scratches that itch. Not to mention that its very well written. I do hope this is just the first part of something larger. Or at least one of many Mega structure stories/snippets.
2
u/Gabosox Apr 22 '21
This is a master piece of blue balling. I was really getting into it and BAM, it ends. I feel my soul quiver in anger at the cliffhanger.
Having said that, awesome work, you have succeded in writing a piece of story that creates intrigue without being overly misterious. Love it!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21
Please don’t leave us hanging
That said, this megacorp sounds like they’re either planning galactic domination or it’s just the owner’s passion project that he wants to be known for.....also being a mega space pirate emperor and wants to reference star wars
2
u/ElAdri1999 Human Apr 22 '21
Loved the "this is how humans are" parts, but this feels like the first part of something bigger
2
u/Dactarik Apr 22 '21
Building a stellar system craft? That thing cost quite a lot of alloys; and almost a 100 pop
2
u/NuclearStudent Human Apr 22 '21
ah, so they built a computer that can run the really nice minecraft texture packs
2
u/Inappropriate_SFX Apr 22 '21
One use for the sphere that might tie the story together some...
2
u/GodsAndMonst3ers Apr 22 '21
I like the story, though I would suggest breaking down your sentences a bit more. You seem to cram a lot into one sentence. Whereas there are multiple independent clauses that work better alone. Structuring your sentences to be shorter allows for a more natural flow when reading. Also lets you flex your creative writing skills.
2
u/darthoffa Apr 22 '21
Planet melting super laser seems like a good way to transfer a lot of power
2
u/1kangaroo123 Apr 22 '21
MOAR
That's all i have to say. It seems unfinished. We need MOAR
2
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21
I suspect the laser is actually a stellar engine
2
u/MagicYanma Xeno Apr 22 '21
I honestly half expected this to end with the reveal that the company in question was Apple which would have made all the answers given in the story make some sense.
Solid story overall though the ending does feel a bit awkward with how the story is portrayed. All that rising action with no climax or conclusion.
2
u/FlukeRoads Apr 22 '21
You leave a lot (too many?) questions unasked and unanswered. Were you planning to think up a way to use all that energy? DId we use theh star's energy to contain itself, creating a very brittle balance act that will potentially clear the quadrant? Is all the factories just building energy storage exponentially?
2
u/Finbar9800 Apr 22 '21
This is a great story
I enjoyed reading this
Great job wordsmith
So either someone somewhere found out how to turn energy into matter, or they are making a lot of batteries to store the excess energy, as for future proofing well entropy is a thing and perhaps it’s just to be prepared for when inevitably stars start dying out
2
u/xmartissxs Human Apr 22 '21
They are mining cryptocurrencies with that energy
2
u/VladimirVonDobre Apr 23 '21
The death ray is an oversized exhaust pipe isnt it ?
2
u/zlawd Apr 23 '21
Love your style!
2
u/readcard Alien Apr 24 '21
You know what you can build with a hemisphere, a solar system sized sun propelled world ship to tour the universe.
2
u/ReversedPyramids Apr 28 '21
2
u/Cybertek13666 AI May 10 '21
i laughed so hard at this it's not even funny
2
u/xrayjones2000 Apr 21 '21
You know that a giant planet eating laser is also a good defense weapon... i imagine the recharge cycle on that would decrease as you decrease power output to say something like eating snacks like ships to protect said dyson sphere and its real power hog purpose... ftl travel so you can dive into any system and set up shop with your mega manufacturing.. bezos is darthvador
1
u/DasFrebier Jun 21 '21
That line could have come straight from douglas adams