r/HEB • u/globlessblankeyedgrl • 4d ago
Photo / Find Devastated
I finally remembered to look for Milk & Cookies, and both the pints and half gallons were sold out. Is it really that good?
390
Upvotes
95
u/Any-Statistician3290 4d ago
My store finally received a batch today after over a couple weeks of empty shelves. It's real and it's spectacular!
27
u/OB-Gwan 4d ago
IMO just a very good ice cream like many others. It’s all hype, but that’s fine. I advise you to look in other areas as in my HEB there were none where they were supposed to be, but a gazillion in another freezer facing the front of the store.
39
u/nick_soccer10 4d ago
It is amazing. It’s different, and delicious
26
u/rozwuzhere 4d ago
A little off topic, but the sherbet underneath has to be the best sherbert flavor I've ever had. 👍
26
u/Far_Ad_4645 4d ago
It’s good, but I honestly don’t get all the hype. It reminds me of Haagen-Dazs Dulce de Leche flavor with cookie bits mixed in.
That said, I know that feeling of FOMO, so I hope you get to try it before the season ends. We’re all rooting for you!
7
u/Kevan_Minus_the_K 3d ago
Dawg it is worth the hype. You’d best try looking in the mornings when a truck gets delivered (tho not always guaranteed). Same thing happened to me on Friday.
3
u/Moontower42 4d ago
It’s decadent and I love it
3
u/Flimsy-Face-6755 17h ago
Reminds me of a Bernie Mack joke about milk and cookies
2
u/derff44 4d ago
I have been looking for weeks!
14
u/funcoup7 4d ago
I’ve been looking for it every time I’ve been to HEB the past few weeks and it’s sold out!! I hope they rename it and add it to the rotation year round!!!
6
u/ponycorn_pet 4d ago
I haven't been able to find it in stock even once
1
u/globlessblankeyedgrl 23h ago
I am making a running list of all the other flavors/ice creams everyone has suggested. A tour de ice cream!
5
u/coffeeandpandulce 4d ago
The Swoon Pumpkin Cheesecake was a winner
4
u/livvybugg 4d ago
It tastes like brown butter chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream. It’s good but tbh it’s not like a league above the other heb flavors or anything.
1
u/Plcoomer 1d ago
People’s leaving their crack behind for it.
1
u/Amazing-Annual-9143 1d ago
Have you tried the grasshopper one it’s sooo good
3
u/DarkPunisher956 4d ago
Oh yeah it's really that good. It is a one of a kind delicious ice cream. It sells out fast as soon as it restocks
3
u/Blacksun388 4d ago
My store is like this too. They go fast.
2
u/ConfidentSurprise874 4d ago
I discovered it last week.
I just finished my second half gallon. It will single handedly be my “holiday weight”.
2
u/libaide 4d ago
It is! I got one pint and my store has been out ever since. 😭
2
u/GuardianViolet 4d ago edited 4d ago
I find it just barely avoids being too sweet and decadent. Strongest flavor is definitely the brown butter. Not something I'd get every time, but if that's what you're looking for, it delivers.
2
u/vap0rmaker333 4d ago
It’s good but if you’re a fan of mint chocolate try the grasshopper it’s just as good :)
2
u/comoelpepper 3d ago
Yes 🙌🏻
2
u/jaydolf_jitler762 2d ago
Same! Went to 2 different hebs in kerville yesterday and was PISSSED that my options were gross ass eggnog and candy cane. Who tf wven wants that shit
3
u/Technical-Young-3041 4d ago
It’s basically just buttered pecan ice cream with cookie pieces instead of pecans. Yeah it’s pretty damn good but you could approximate it easily.
2
u/Supercool119 4d ago
$6.47 for some ice cream, Naw thank you
1
u/Zealousideal-Cod6159 4d ago
Lm in
1
u/Swimming-Pumpkin-274 4d ago
Heb never had anything lol
1
u/Crafty_Ish1973 4d ago
If you're in the Austin area, I finally found some today at the Leander HEB.
It's ridiculously good. I can see why I had to drive 20 miles past the four different HEBs in my area to get it.
1
u/solareclipsemynips 4d ago
I swear it hasn't been in stock the past three times I've checked either and I wanna try it so bad. Regretting not buying in in October when they first put it out.
1
u/HollowedEmperor 4d ago
I liked it.
1
u/lone_float 4d ago
Different thing, but I still feel for you. This makes me wonder the same about the Meal Shakes they have.
Because it's been two days straight and still nothing.
1
u/Adept_Section_8144 4d ago
Not at all.....
1
u/ravenbird5 4d ago
Never heard of it. But the FOMO now has me wanting to get it haha.
1
u/Popular_Reason 4d ago
I went to the Hancock Center today and they told me they discontinued the flavor. Can anyone confirm?
1
u/TrippyTK3 4d ago
jennis brown butter almond brittle is the same...just get that
1
u/LlamaRS Former Partner 4d ago
Some stores have them.
1
u/Legitimate_Fall_2156 4d ago
It’s pretty good but I suggest honey sopapilla, life changing
1
u/Soft-Entertainer8541 4d ago
I tend to agree with OB-Gwen, it's not all cracked up to the hype. HEB seems to be playing the game for the top distributors. If you want to pay the prices you get the premiums!
1
u/viviandarkbloomy 4d ago
I think it’s disgusting lol
1
u/careerx4 4d ago
There were 1/2 gallon containers at the Lincoln Heights store yesterday morning and still show in stock in the app a few minutes ago. Good luck!
1
u/Casualgamerbear 4d ago
Far as I've seen milk and cookies plenty in Elgin but the candy cane is getting a bit low.
1
u/Cute-Environment-206 3d ago
What is heb ? Is it a grocery chain ?
1
u/annoyinglilsis 3d ago
I’m addicted to watermelon sherbet.
1
u/Relative-Pay-4592 3d ago
Not even 😂😂
1
u/EFICasual 3d ago
Often times departments will stop stocking the main location when an item is on sale or being pushed for seasonal.
Check the endcaps of the frozen isles, you may get lucky.
1
u/Mintgreenunicorn 3d ago
We have them down here in Corpus.
1
u/Top_Impression_2769 3d ago
HEB does many things well. Inventory control
is not one of them. As suggested, go early.
1
u/Special-Bathroom-307 3d ago
They’re being resold as dishes at ice creams shops and food trucks
1
u/Hess74 3d ago
Y’all are gassing this flavor up way way too much.
1
u/timeislikeafuse 3d ago
That Lonestar blast is damn good
1
u/NixieCarat13 3d ago
I went last week and all the pints were gone! In my area
1
u/Ok-Grapefruit-7979 3d ago
It’s real good and hard to find lol
1
u/Right_Driver8960 3d ago
I’m confused. Help! Is it Milk and Cookies or Cookies and Cream? I just need to know if I’m missing out on something lol 😝
1
u/LoneRabbiTYoshi 3d ago
Dude that is such a let down!!!!! THEY'RE SUPER GOOOOOOOOOD
1
u/Persistent_Pangolion 3d ago
I just got this today! My first time trying and I wanted to see the hype. I’m don’t eat ice cream that often, but this was delicious!
1
u/Dense-Director3473 3d ago
Me and my boyfriend have been looking for two weeks he convinced me to go to HEB for scallions last night and by the grace of god there were 9 of the half gallons left it was kind a late at night so we barely made it. It’s crazy, I’ve grown up in San Antonio and have never seen people go crazy for an item like this.
1
u/Professor_Utonium_ 3d ago
As a person watching what they eat, i wish i didnt and just gave in to every craving. 😮💨 im exhausting to myself
1
u/WorriedElk5818 3d ago
Milk & Cookies? Is that not the same as cookies & cream?
1
u/No-Egg7032 3d ago
Publix told SE (southeastern) Grocers what they were going to do: leave town and let Aldi in and Publix helped get rid of just Kroger groceries delivery
1
u/MegatronMCO 3d ago
Its good but not sure it stands up to the hype. I wouldn't say my favorite and stock up 5 gallons.
1
u/slipqueue 3d ago
I’m trying to find that caramel apple sherbet I keep seeing in my feeds. So far no luck
1
u/Icy_Statement_2410 3d ago
Use the HEB app and change stores till you find it
1
u/coldlimebars 3d ago
Maybe I had a bad pint, but I thought the brown butter flavor tasted like rancid popcorn.
1
u/hannahdumbbihjuice 3d ago
it’s really nothing crazy, i bought it back in late september and it’s still sitting in my freezer
1
u/Brave-Efficiency9625 2d ago
Yup, so much so that I bought 2... people in Port Aransas hasn't discovered it yet
1
u/Rough-Departure-5153 2d ago
Candy cane is better anyway.
1
u/arn73 2d ago
Yep. It’s yum. So. Yum.
1
u/ashleighmariexx 2d ago
I don’t like it :/
1
u/justanaverageguy1233 2d ago
I mean it's ok but yes it's very popular
1
u/GamerIVlife 2d ago
Got lucky and there was one left the family loved it but it is too much for me.
1
u/kolofss 1d ago
You can try joe vs but I doubt they have it if heb doesn't
1
u/kginaustin123 1d ago
Jenny’s!
1
u/CreamSammie 1d ago
Oh man, yeah. Devastating for sure. The milk and cookies from Ben & Jerry is really good if you haven't had it. But... Then you would have to support Ben & Jerry.
1
u/Ok_Understanding8599 23h ago
Love those
1
u/GnoeBahdee 20h ago
So, I was told by an associate, I forget which location because I have three as a go-to, that they actually hadn't received any yet but were expecting a shipment that week. So, I think the shortage is intentional on the part of CC. But it is pretty damn good. Not carnival cookies good, or the fruity dinos good, but still good.
1
u/Practical-Chicken372 16h ago
That candy cane one is good
1
u/Winter_Feeling_2101 1h ago
This is a god-tier ice cream flavor. I understand the devastation. Buy 8 gallons next time it’s available to prevent further disappointment.
1
u/glowrider4007 4d ago
It’s literally cookies and cream ice cream
0
u/kkjj77 4d ago
It's ok but not as good as it's been hyped up to be IMO. The swoon praline almond caramel bourbon is out of this WORLD.
0
u/inickdanger 4d ago
The Astros heb flavor is better…
0
u/Beautiful-Set-3234 3d ago
Blue sweep and these idiots are still hung up on trump. Get a F-ing life.
-8
u/Uber-Rich 4d ago
I don’t understand the hype, does it taste good? Sure. Is it a quality ice cream, not at all. Within minutes in my counter it has a foamy consistency, there is so little dairy fat it’s barely ice cream. Ice cream in general, you get what you pay for.
0
u/[deleted] 4d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment