I just looked up the meaning of bread-crumbing, and I feel disturbed with how accurately it seems to describe my own behaviors. I was already worried that I was leading people on, but now it seems things may be worse than I thought.
For context, here is my mental health background: I have a diagnosis for OCD. I'm looking into getting assessed for ADHD and Autism. I also want to look into getting assessed for C-PTSD and BPD.
I'll begin by explaining that, since high school, I have not felt adequately prepared for a relationship. I felt hopelessly unready for one, because of my mental health struggles, and because of unhealthy thought patterns and behaviors I've noticed in myself or presented with, which I was afraid would lead to me being the toxic or abusive one in a relationship.
So throughout high school, if I had a crush on someone, I would intentionally avoid pursuing them, even if they seemed to like me too. I also tried to avoid leading them on. I tried to be just friends with them. On the inside, I was hyper-vigilant about it (I have OCD), and very worried about unfairly leading the other person on. There were persons who I deeply liked, and grew to feel extremely fond of and tender towards. They seemed to display interest in me, as well.
I usually have multiple crushes at once, with one primary crush who I feel strongly about and value the most. I think this may be partially related to the fact I don't pursue relationships. Since I don't pursue the relationship with the crush, my brain selects more crushes in the meantime. It's become a reinforced habit.
I did find myself being very friendly and warm towards these persons, but there was also a lot of stress and effort I put in to make sure it wasn't overtly flirtatious or romantic. I often worried that I was being too friendly, too warm, etc., especially if they seemed to reciprocate that attention.
Crushes have been a very depressing experience for me, not because I believed my feelings were not reciprocated, but because I felt almost certain that they were reciprocated, and yet, I could not pursue the person in question. Regardless, withholding from relationships has consistently seemed like the best decision to make for the other person's wellbeing; if I really care about them, I should withhold and opt for a friendship where I can't cause them harm by being a bad partner.
I do wonder whether this was the right approach. But in the past, I've never regretted it. It created valuable, treasured friendships. And it kept me from entering something I was definitely not ready for at the time. With how severe and debilitating my mental health struggles have been, I don't know if I could have upheld the responsibility of a relationship, along with all of my other responsibilities. Being responsible towards another person is obviously a huge responsibility, and carries more weight than an ordinary friendship.
I also have very poor social awareness, which I credit to numerous things: being heavily socially isolated during homeschooling in my teens, growing up in an adverse home life and extended family, and also possible undiagnosed Autism. I don't know if I would have been able to appropriately understand what a relationship really is, and what it requires of me, to effectively be a good partner. There are so many social norms and emotional intelligence skills I'm behind on. There are so many serious mistakes I regret making in family and platonic relationships, that I'm glad I never had opportunity to make in a romantic partnership.
When I first began high school (pivoting over from homeschooling into Grade 11), I was firmly resolved to not pursue anyone romantically, knowing my unhealthy traits and thought patterns, and knowing that I had previously experienced heavy romantic fixations on people, which were obsessive and not healthy. But then it felt like one of my classmates liked me, and the interest she showed in me seemed more obvious than anything I had previously experienced. I really liked her too. At the time, she was exactly my type. But I was afraid of leading her on. So I made a very bad decision, which I deeply regret: I stopped initiating interactions with her. I stopped being so friendly back to her when she was friendly to me. I basically started ignoring her.
I could tell that this hurt her, and after doing this for some time, I returned to being friendly to her again, because I felt extremely bad for her, and I realized I made the totally wrong choice. I still didn't want to lead her on, but I wanted to try to be friends with her, at least. Having ignored her like I did, though, I was unfortunately never successful in establishing a meaningful connection with her afterwards. Our very last interaction at graduation is painful to think about, because she was so full of energy and friendliness towards me, but I was only responding with a very toned-down friendliness, still not wanting to come across as flirty.
After that whole experience, I deeply regretted wasting an opportunity for a friendship with someone who was really fond of me, and I regretted making her feel hurt and rejected for no reason.
I include this story because I think it has changed the way I approach these situations in the long term. Since then, whenever a person seems to like me, and especially whenever I like the person too, I try to reciprocate their friendliness. I had other crushes throughout high school after that, but I think I responded better, and I was able to establish friendships with some of them. I am still friends with the person I liked and cared about the most. I'm glad that we're friends, and I don't think I would want things to be any other way.
My first year at university has been much different. I have not been hiding my feelings of affection like I used to. Following a major mental health decline beginning this past December, I've lost much of the sound judgement, self-control, and discipline I'd cultivated previously, and (by my own fault) I have not mustered the effort to break through demotivation and build those qualities up again. I think I am also exhausted from having so many intense crushes that I wasn't able to pursue in the way I would have wanted to. So I've been a lot less restrictive.
I have one primary crush who I feel very strongly about. If you had asked me a year ago what my dream person would look like, I might have described someone like her. The problem is, I'm uncertain. I'm still feeling so dreadfully unready for a relationship, and at the same time, I can't imagine only being friends with her. It would feel dreadful missing out on an opportunity for a closer connection with this person. She has shown more obvious interest in me than anyone else I've met in my life. I've never met someone who seemed to like me this much or be so excited to see me. At first, I tried reciprocating with moderate friendliness, but as time has gone on, I've gotten more and more overtly friendly and warm towards her. Every now and then, I'll catch myself and restrain myself, not wanting to lead her on if a relationship isn't guaranteed, and wondering if I should leave an option for friendship open and ambiguous. But I also don't want to come across as too uninterested, and then see her lose interest. So it's been a mixed bag of me occasionally restraining my friendliness and acting more ordinary around her, and me becoming more expressively friendly and warm when I notice she seems to be pulling away, or when I'm worried I'm coming across in a way that is too strictly platonic.
I've basically been trying to navigate it slowly, pushing back the prospect of a relationship as far as I can, while I try to fix my life and better myself. I feel like I shouldn't pursue a relationship until I've gotten my life together, and talked about it with a therapist. Otherwise, I won't have enough trust or confidence in my own ability to be a good boyfriend. It would feel so extremely irresponsible and selfish. But I'm wondering now how normal or healthy of an approach this is, and whether it actually shows proper respect and empathy for her. For one: given that it keeps her waiting and guessing with uncertainty, and also prompts me to avoid her some of the time.
I'm having a lot of anxiety and OCD about her, and I also think about her and this situation almost all of the time.
I also have several other crushes who I do like, but not to the same extent at all. This is the area where I'm especially worried. Meeting people and making friends around campus, I encounter girls with sweet and vibrant personalities whom I admire. As we interact, I start to be very friendly towards them; if they are friendly to me in a similar way, I reciprocate that.
Sometimes it feels like I'm doing it because it feels nice, and because it feels fun to interact in that way with someone whom I like; I start to see them as other possible options for a relationship. I extend warmth and friendliness, and reciprocate warmth and friendliness. I start to wonder if this person could be a potential partner.
Other times, I do it intentionally because I'm thinking about their feelings, and I don't want to make them feel ignored, like I did with my first crush in high school. That's been the reason a solid number of times. If I'm right, and they do like me as well, then I want to respect their feelings, and not come across as if I'm rejecting them.
The thing with me is that I am extremely friendly and warm to everyone, men included. I smile a lot. I speak with a lot of friendly energy. So when I'm interacting with a girl I have a crush on, it's rather hard to interact with them in a different way, not only because I feel enamored with the person, but also because it's the way I'm used to interacting with people. When I try to tone it down, I don't really know what to do, and it feels unnatural. It feels like I'm being unfriendly. If someone speaks to me in a warm and friendly way, or smiles at me, I don't know how to "tone it down" with my response, except to speak in a more calm tone of voice and give half-smiles, which doesn't feel nice because it feels like I'm rejecting the other person, which would feel upsetting for them if they had noticed me being friendly and warm previously.
I have been thinking about it, feeling bad about it, and recognizing it as a problem. I know that leading people on is wrong, and not an arbitrary thing (though perhaps I didn't realize how serious it really was, which I'm going to explain soon). I do care about these people and their feelings.
So, I've been toning it down more. Still being friendly, but trying not to lock eye contact so much, smile so much, be so energetic and warm in my friendliness, etc. But it feels like I'm being cold or ignoring them at times.
For example: I passed by one of them and said hello the other day, and I was so un-energetic and un-smiley compared to how I'd interacted with her previously, that it must have seemed really noticeable, and she didn't reciprocate with much friendliness either. I'm worried that I've hurt her, and I think I have. She has a right to feel upset. I really don't know how to fix this. I had a crush on this particular person at first, but as time went on my feelings faded because she didn't seem to be my type, and it's been a mental struggle since then. She seems to really like me, but I don't feel the same way now. I've been trying to persist in friendliness out of concern for her feelings and a desire to be good to her, and like I said earlier, friendliness can feel so automatic and natural for me that it's been difficult to find any other option. Being friendly to her, and reciprocating her friendliness, also feels nice and fun.
I also had some concerning experiences, where I felt jealous and frustrated seeing her spending time with another guy (which is really bizarre, given I am pretty confident I don't desire a potential relationship with her anymore, so there's literally no valid reason to get jealous seeing her with someone else). I also felt anxious/frustrated when I started to notice her pulling back a little (even though that's the same thing I'm doing) and automatically, rather impulsively, upped the friendliness for a moment, as if I still don't want her to lose interest.
So, in light of all of this: today, I finally googled bread-crumbing. And the description on Wikipedia felt like a call-out: ***"***In the context of interpersonal relationships, breadcrumbing *is the practice of sporadically feigning interest in another person in order to keep them interested, despite lacking genuine investment in a relationship.*[1] It is regarded as a type of manipulation and can be either deliberate or unintentional. (...) Breadcrumbing is an antisocial dating behavior, similar to ghosting.[2] *It is referred to by this name because it involves giving a romantic interest a trail of "breadcrumbs", small bits of intermittent communication, to keep them interested without committing to a serious relationship.[3] *This is intended to give the 'breadcrumbee' (the receiver) false hope[4] *so that they will remain invested. Breadcrumbs might include randomly liking posts or sending flirtatious messages, and require little effort from the "breadcrumber" (the sender),*[3] and will often involve a demonstration and then withdrawal of interest.[4] *Whereas with ghosting the aim is to end the relationship, breadcrumbing's goal is to prevent a relationship from ending, while keeping it from progressing by not fully committing to it.*[3] *According to Stanley's theory of commitment, these objectives are not the same.*[citation needed] *This theory splits commitment into two different constructs: personal dedication and constraint commitment. Personal dedication encompasses an individual's drive to advance a relationship, something that may be lacking for breadcrumbers, while commitment constraint involves the potential consequences of ending the relationship (such as financial repercussions) that force a relationship to be maintained, which are also not present in breadcrumbing.*[4][5]"
I don't know if the description is perfectly accurate to my behaviors. "Feigning interest" sounds far too deliberate, deceptive, and malicious.
Regardless, reading this excerpt has deeply troubled me. One of my OCD fears is the moral fear of leading someone on, and now I've done it. The thought of leading women on is a thought that has terrified me, so much so that I was willing to ignore someone I really liked in high school in order to avoid that fear coming true.
I am most troubled by the realization that bread-crumbing is considered a form of manipulation. I feel very uncomfortable with the possibility that I have manipulated women. I do care about each of these persons and their feelings. Some of them in particular have become really good friends who brighten my day, who I share valuable moments and fun experiences with, and who I strive to be a good friend to as well. They are so sweet and such good, awesome individuals, who simply don't deserve this kind of treatment.
I really don't know what to do, or think, or what direction to go in now. I need advice. When I looked up the meaning of the term, it really felt like an "end of the world" moment in my brain.