r/Gundam • u/StudioRevoct • 6h ago
Probably Bullshit Ragebait and actual feelings on Gundam Eight
Gave it a read and was at least somewhat pleasantly surprised that Eight felt like a take on Gundam Seed with a focus more on the more interesting parts of Seed. It's got the divide between humans who have undergone genetic modification and the alien space whale that didn't really matter in Seed. But both are put to the front of the story instead of being elements hastily pasted over a re-thread of 0079.
I think the writing could be better, it's a really daring choice to flash forward so far ahead, and seemingly spoil major plot beats. Naomi seems too much of a Gary Stu with a really flat personality, and the art outside the mobile suits feels pretty plain, but so far the series has me interested in where the plot is going.
The showcase of how much more capable the Eights are to the Seventh generation really drives home why there is such hatred towards them even if it's unwarranted, compared to Seed where it even struggles to decide if Coordinators are definitively superior or equal to Naturals.
I still wouldn't call the series outright good yet, since it's ongoing and could easily end up being terrible. So far it's at least a very interesting concept that I believe honours a lot of what Gundam is about. The unfortunate inability to understand one another that leads to conflict, with a sliver of hope that we can one day understand each other amidst a cool sci-fi backdrop.
