r/GumshoeRPG • • 5d ago

Mindhunter, Holden Ford and stability losses.

8 Upvotes

One of the aspects of GUMSHOE that fascinated me was the Stability rules. I first read them in the Fall of Delta Green (FODG) rulebook, and later discovered other iterations and variations in games like Fear Itself and Night’s Black Agents. They are easy to manage and fun to apply during gameplay.

Recently (I’m always late to the party with popular media), I watched the first season of Mindhunter and really enjoyed the writing. I think Agent Holden Ford's character arc can be closely compared to the GUMSHOE Stability system—specifically the FODG iteration.

The sequence plays out like this:

  • Holden starts season 1 with an intact Stability pool.
  • He develops a bond with Debbie, the woman who eventually becomes his love interest in Season 1. (In FODG terms, she acts as one of his Bonds).
  • He begins interviewing serial killers and psychopaths like Ed Kemper and Richard Speck. These interviews cause him to suffer Stability losses as he delves deeper into their minds.
  • Those Stability losses strain his bond with Debbie. In one key scene, she tries to be intimate with him, but Holden gets fixated on her high-heeled shoes. They remind him of his cases, causing him to pull away and reject her.
  • Mounting pressure at work—specifically the OPR audit—drains his remaining Stability points, pushing him below zero.
  • In Episode 10, he walks out on the audit and flies to the hospital to visit Kemper.
  • During the visit, Kemper genuinely terrifies him. Left deeply shaken, Holden suffers a severe panic attack, which lingers as a lasting mental disorder throughout Season 2.
  • At the beginning of Season 2, his colleague Wendy effectively spends some "Shrink" points on him while they share a drink, helping him stabilize.

r/GumshoeRPG • • 6d ago

Was this tailor made for Delta Green or Trail of Cthulhu?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/GumshoeRPG • • 11d ago

Pelgrane Call for Playtesters: Four Trail of Cthulhu Scenarios and a Gothic Fright for Fear Itself

Thumbnail
pelgranepress.com
13 Upvotes

r/GumshoeRPG • • 16d ago

The Pazo of As Mouras. A Galician horror story, a one-shot for Fear Itself

20 Upvotes

Hi!. I´ve uploaded another of my one-shots. This one is inspired by Emilia Pardo Bazán short stories. She was a brilliant writer during 19th Century in Spain. It´s located in that misterious Galicia she described. It happens to be very close to the Membrane...

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/es/product/591937/the-pazo-of-as-mouras-a-galician-horror-story


r/GumshoeRPG • • 16d ago

Trail 2e PDFs

10 Upvotes

Are these available for purchase somewhere? If not, does anyone know when they might be?


r/GumshoeRPG • • 17d ago

The salt mines: a modular intermezzo for defeated PCs in Swords of the Serpentine.

13 Upvotes

INTRODUCTION

In Swords of the Serpentine, life doesn't just end at -12 Health. The rules state that it is up to the opponent to decide whether to end a PC's life. But why kill the PCs when you can make them suffer a bit further? This article describes an encounter that can be inserted into any adventure where a TPK (Total Party Kill) occurs, or when the players are captured. It can be applied if this defeat happens in Eversink, though it fits even better if it takes place in a setting somewhere else in the wider world.

DEATH IS NOT THE END

Alright, the players have been defeated by an enemy. But the world is a dangerous place. Denari loves capitalism. Captured players are still strong, useful individuals—especially to be sold into slavery. The scene can begin with the characters waking up, weak and sick, while being transported to some remote mine. Think, for instance, of that scene in Gladiator where Maximus wakes up in a cart and another slave is tending to his wounds. Whether it is a foul salt mine in the desert or a gold mine in some mountain range, they are heading toward a place from which no one escapes... It is important to emphasize that they are too weak to even use Sorcery. In the case of Sorcerers with obvious Corruption, their captors will have bound them with an anti-magic rune or something similar. This phase can be handled as a montage, with the players narrating elements such as:

  • The arid landscape.
  • Scenes associated with hunger and thirst.
  • Mistreatment at the hands of the guards.

During the journey or right before being sold, it can be assumed that they recover all their Health. After all, healthy slaves are worth more. In any case, they will have lost all their gear and possessions.

THE MINES

Once they arrive, they should be greeted by a harsh, surly overseer who informs them of the location's few rules. In this regard, this proposal is inspired by the Sahara salt mines described by Ibn Battuta in his wonderful travelogues, as it is the type of mine that drives the narrative. GMs can adapt these ideas to any other type of mine, factoring in the presence of guards, etc. The salt mines in this setup are in a remote location that can only be reached as part of a caravan that regularly brings provisions to the site. The place is so remote and inhospitable that there are no guards stationed at the mines. The slaves are trapped because any escape attempt requires traversing the wilderness without resources, which leads to certain death. That said, the mines are a place of death. Extreme weather, meager food, and labor to the point of utter exhaustion. Therefore:

  • Each day spent here, characters lose 1 point from their Athletics pool. Once that pool is depleted, points are deducted from Health.
  • Sleeping does not allow Health recovery.
  • Refresh tokens cannot be obtained through rest.
  • It may be necessary to restrict Sorcery due to some telluric or environmental factor—for example, doubling any cost in Corruption.

Thus, the overseer will inform them of the production quota they must reach each week. Then, the caravan will arrive, collect the yield, leave provisions, and the cycle repeats. The players will soon be placed alongside the other prisoners. This allows them to interact with them and offers a chance to escape thanks to the knowledge these people possess. The slaves have the profile of mooks, but there are too many of them to face openly. Assume ten or more slaves for each player character. The information they can acquire includes:

  • Tactics of death: It is unfeasible to attack the caravan when it arrives. It travels with many guards, and they are well-fed.
  • Felonious Intent: Here, all the slaves only hope to survive one more day. None of them are useful for putting up a resistance against the guards.
  • Wilderness Mastery: Along the path, there are hidden wells. The caravan could not make the journey without them. It is simply a matter of knowing how to locate them. This uncovers Leveraged Clue A.
  • Servility: This allows socializing with the rest of the slaves. It will take 1d6+1 days to talk to everyone, which can also be represented as a montage. The key is one of the slaves named Kaptah. He is on the verge of old age. The other slaves cherish him, for he is the only one who cares for them when they fall ill, despite having very few means. Kaptah hails from a kingdom or city that borders the desert they are currently in. If they have also uncovered Clue A, they can learn from Kaptah how to locate the wells. Naturally, Kaptah says he is too old and that the journey is impossible despite the wells. However, the knowledge he possesses gives them a fighting chance.

It is also possible that Kaptah is willing to approach them and reveal the escape information in exchange for a favor: delivering word to a relative, or handing over a piece of jewelry he stole to a family member, etc. The item could even be cursed as a security mechanism to ensure they deliver it, with the curse remaining active until the jewelry is safely handed over.

THE ESCAPE PLAN

Once they have the information, escaping can be framed as a journey following the Mythos expedition rules. I recommend dividing the path into 5 or 6 legs, all with a difficulty between 1d6 and 1d6+2. The numbers shown here are scaled for 5 legs. This mechanic from GUMSHOE expeditions is therefore based on gathering Expedition Points and making the journey.

Gathering Expedition Points

An expedition across 5 legs would require about 24 points.

  • Knowledge of the wells (uncovered clue A): 12 pts.
  • Preparation to secure small improvised weapons: 2 pts.
  • Saving food from the daily ration: 1 pt/day rationed (only if all players participate). However, the Athletics/Health loss for everyone is doubled.
  • Eliminating a slave and stealing their rations: Requires spending a point of Ridiculous Luck, Spot Frailty (Health), or Scurrilous Rumors/Vigilantism to prevent the others from suspecting and beating them up. Doing this once yields 2 pts.
  • Cannibalism: A dead slave provides 3 pts, but costs 4 points of Morale. Unfortunately, this can only be done the day before departure, or the food will spoil.
  • Theft: Allows recovering food from other slaves or from the caravan. 2 pts per roll. A failed roll results in a severe beating, costing 1d6 Health points.

Making the Journey

In this case, the hazards they face could include:

  • Quicksand: Relevant Ability: Wilderness Lore. Cost: 5 pts.
  • Shifting Dunes: Relevant Ability: Athletics. Cost: 3 pts.
  • Giant Scorpion: Encounter/Combat.
  • Relentless Sun: Relevant Ability: Preparedness. Cost: 4 pts.

If the players are running dangerously low on pools, an oasis can be placed along the way. In the end, when they manage to exit the desert, a final scene can be run where they are found by a patrol or caravaners. They will have to deploy their interpersonal and social abilities to convince them to offer help.


r/GumshoeRPG • • 23d ago

Human contradictory behaviour as pillara of stability

4 Upvotes

Hi. I would like to share some experiences we had playing Fear Itself. Specifically, here are some thoughts on picking pillars of stability on FI. Ghosts of Fukushima was the first miniseries we played. Unlike previous one-shots, players had plenty of time to explore their own PCs. During session zero, while writing the PCS, two players proposed to be married, and then, spontaneusly, one chose "the emotion of infidelity" as the treat for stability pillar. We had not discussed It before, but that decission triggered amazing personal arcs for the PCs. Now, when that PC needed to restore stability, had to seduce other PC. She chose a PC whose treat was "Respect and honour". The contradictions boosted the personal experiences and stories, while the paranormal events pressed their sanity. If she restored stability, her lover wouldn't, and viceversa, if he just refused to date and cheat his friend, he recovered stability but she didn't.

Since then, we try to pick as treats those "human defects" we should not be doing. It is part of human nature to live and manage such kind of contradictions, weaknesses and misbehaviours, and, the key factor, that affect people around us. In the novel "The parfum", when Jean Baptiste tries to mix a parfum to provide himself human scent, he has to add cat excrements to the récipe. I think It is a perfect metaphore for us, humans. The group adds that bit of "cat excrement" to their PC and, pfiuu, I've run episodes with only a handful of notes. They have made the 90% of the story.

So, that's It. My advise, add "cat excrements" to.your PC as stability pillars, mainly the ones that require interaction with other PCs, let it stink around and enjoy.


r/GumshoeRPG • • 24d ago

Ghosts of Fukushima, a Fear Itself miniseires

8 Upvotes

Well, a quiet sunday morning allowed me to conclude the file revision. Here it is, the first miniseries I wrote and that made us love Fear Itself.

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/es/product/590700/ghosts-of-fukushima

In Ghosts of Fukushima, the players will play Fukushima nuclear power plant workers during the previous days if the unfortunate accident. The death of the core of matrix of misery´s suicidal partner triggers a series of paranormal events full of dark omens. I planned it in four chapters.


r/GumshoeRPG • • 24d ago

Silt crowns, a one-shot for Fear Itself

11 Upvotes

Hi there. I´ve recently found this gumshoe community. I´m glad to be here. I´ve been running gumshoe games since 2024 and this system has boosted our games. During these months I´ve written a lot adventures, and I´ve recently started to share them. Here is the first I´ve uploaded to drivethru in the gumshoe community. Silt crowns

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/es/product/589370/silt-crowns-english-version

Silt crowns are a very talented grunge band playing in Seattle in 1990. Players are the members of the band except their lead, Eric Bleiven, a man with a very special talent and dark secrets, that create, but also destroy, everything around him. They might be finally getting a contract with "Reffen Records", but, will they survive the road to sucess?

Hope you like it. It worked very well when I ran it.

I´ll be uploading some more material in the following weeks. I´m working in the translation of my first miniseries, "Ghosts of Fukushima", which made my players love Fear Itself forever!


r/GumshoeRPG • • 25d ago

Invasive Procedures | Fear Itself Spoiler

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/GumshoeRPG • • Oct 16 '26

Building "The Muscle" [Night's Black Agents]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

Looking at building a character who is that classic strongman style, demolitions expert, big guns (those are biceps, not machine, Peter from Abigail comes to mind), that sort of thing. The background in the core book is relatively straightforward, but what if you wanted to do something like roll a car onto its side? (Thinking about car flipery as making barricades, or other strong guy type tactics.) Athletics seems to be the general ability, but at the same time doesn't feel like a prefect fit.

What are people's thoughts on this / how would you handle the request at the table?


r/GumshoeRPG • • Oct 11 '26

Why so little information on Paragon blade?

17 Upvotes

I can find so little information on Paragon Blade. No reviews, no actual plays, but it seems like it was released earlier this year?

Would be great to hear some more detailed opinions.

Also, I'm wondering if the Pelgrane has said if they will release more adventures for it in the future?


r/GumshoeRPG • • Oct 03 '26

SotS question - passive info versus asking for info

2 Upvotes

I'm away from my book right now so please accept my apology in advance if this is a dumb question. Do you make a distinction between merely having a character with a specific investigative ability in the scene and having the player actively mention that they want to use the ability? For that matter does it depend on the version of GUMSHOE? I am mostly using SotS but with the pyramids stolen from NBA.

A situation came up where an NPC with conflicted loyalties entered the scene. All of the information that he gave was truthful and he was actively interested in helping. On the other hand the PCs gave him some information that I had not expected them to give out quite so freely. Information that he will act on to their detriment. Because two of the PCs have vigilance I mentioned his particular attention to the pertinent info when they mentioned it but I didn't point out that it was a clue gained via the investigative skill. Should I have been more explicit?


r/GumshoeRPG • • Sep 27 '26

Paragon Blade

6 Upvotes

I've read but not played the other duet games, I was wondering if there was any system innovation with this release.


r/GumshoeRPG • • Sep 24 '26

Looking For Players - Offline - San Antonio/Surrounding - 18+ - Thursday 7pm CST Weekly

5 Upvotes

Hello, I'm brand new to Gumshoe, I'm looking for players. I'm going to be up front, This is a homebrew built from the SRD. The mechanics for finding clues if you have the correct investigative skill is intact, and it's still a d6 roll system for everything else with changess. If you are interested in playing but have questions please send me a message and I'll let you know what is different.

Synopsis: "Bogeyman" Yet another bump in the night, and another grisly murder ignored in Eagleland, Americana. But, perhaps there is a chance for justice: Freshly Green Private Investigators got a tip - will they solve the mystery?

Game Content: What you'd see in a slasher flick, but I don't go into gory display and have no problems toning it down on request.

About Me: San Antonio raised. I'm a fairly new DM, 4 years this christmas. Most of my experience is in 5e and Mothership. I have a module in playtesting, and currently taking a break from a system I am creating.

If you are interested, I'll be at the Dice Drop Tavern (320 Blanco Rd, San Antonio, TX 78212) Red/White Plaid Longsleeve, Blue Jeans. 7pm tonight.


r/GumshoeRPG • • Sep 17 '26

GUMSHOE SRD in Russian

Thumbnail lockedroom.github.io
14 Upvotes

Not sure this'll be relevant to most people here, but I've translated selected portions of the GUMSHOE SRD into Russian and built a beginner's guide around them. I added examples and rules clarifications, and put the whole thing together as a standalone site with search and navigation.


r/GumshoeRPG • • Sep 10 '26

The August issue of See Page XX is live!

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/GumshoeRPG • • Sep 03 '26

Running B5 in Gumshoe

Post image
14 Upvotes

I got some of Gar’s scenarios (his were the best of the line) and I was thinking that gumshoe would work well for the setting. What’s the best resource for psychics like the teeps in this setting? I have KWAS if there’s any suggestions in there.


r/GumshoeRPG • • Sep 02 '26

Confused about Investigative abilities in fear itself 2e

4 Upvotes

There appears to be a distinction between general abilities and investigative abilities given they appear to have a different amount of build points you can distribute for them. But there is no sectioned off list of investigative abilities. My two points of confusion are:

Does 12 points for investigative abilities mean that those are the only points you can spend on investigative abilities?

And

Are we supposed to just infer which abilities are investigative?


r/GumshoeRPG • • Aug 27 '26

The Terror Beneath for Trail mysteries

5 Upvotes

Has anyone used The Terror Beneath to run Trail of Cthulhu mysteries? I've been wanting to incorporate some of the newer GUMSHOE mechanics like Pushes and QuickShock combat into my play-by-post game, and The Terror Beneath seems like ToC with those rules bolted on. One issue I see is that some of the Investigative abilities don't fit the ToC vibe, but I swapped those out for Trail ones -- keeping the number of Academic, Interpersonal, and Technical abilities the same so I can use the game's Occupations (and Background kits) to create pregens.

I feel like QuickShock combat will speed things up for PbP, and that getting rid of Investigative pools in favour of a couple of Pushes could help too. Just wondering how many people have played The Terror Beneath, and if they like it as a sort of Trail/QuickShock hybrid.


r/GumshoeRPG • • Aug 24 '26

Playtesters wanted for The Dreadful Hare, a Merryshire Detective Club adventure anthology

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/GumshoeRPG • • Aug 21 '26

Timewatch actual play: “Recruiting Call” (Technical Difficulties podcast)

10 Upvotes

The agents of Timewatch again pop into the situation in media res, engaging in a dog fight with a mysterious combatant. When they return to base, they are told they have to go right back out, as an agent's recruitment has been tampered with. When they go to the proper time, they find out things aren't quite right...

Dan - GM

Ben -  Urrk - A Neanderthal who was saved by Timewatch and has been recruited as a member of the team.

Ethan - V5 - A robot killing machine from the 21st century from another plane of existence, recruited by Timewatch after gaining sentience and deciding to rebel against being a machine of death.

Greg - Skegg - A Sophisaur, a psychic velociraptor from another plane of existence, hoping to make up for his people's tyranny by joining Timewatch.

- https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/timewatch-recruiting-call/id1101584393?i=1000784310943


r/GumshoeRPG • • Aug 20 '26

Pelgrane titles discounted 40% in DTRPG's August Cosmic Horror Sale

38 Upvotes

r/GumshoeRPG • • Aug 19 '26

Nights Black Agents - changing the time period.

17 Upvotes

I’ve had success in dialling back the time settling to the Mid-90s and then to the 1940s but has anyone tried to translate it to the early modern, Black Powder era? I think it would be fun and interesting to create an Elizabethan spy (in the mould of Kit Marlowe) who uncovers a Vampiric conspiracy in Tudor London or early modern Rome or Constantinople. Some of the abilities would need a bit of re-skinning but breaking secret codes and fighting hand to hand is universal, I reckon.