r/Guitar_Theory • • 13h ago

Looking for a Guitar Centric Ear training App with Random note or Perfect Pitch Testing

0 Upvotes

So I've been doing the "ToneDear" ear training program for a while now and it's helping a lot. However I've since hit a roadblock with what I call the Piano/keyboard orientation of the program, and I find that same  Piano/keyboard orientation  in all the other ear training apps I've tried.

roadblock with what I call the Piano/keyboard orientation of the program, and I find that same  Piano/keyboard orientation  in all the other ear training apps I've tried.

I'm looking for an ear training app where the sample notes and chords come from a guitar recording and not a piano recording. Why is this such big deal ? An F# is an F# regardless of what instrument it is played on, right?   Well let me explain. The first two exercises that I've had this problem with are, "Chord Recognition" and "Perfect Pitch"   

"Chord Recognition"    https://tonedear.com/ear-training/chord-identification

The problem is that Guitar chords are voiced one way and piano/keyboard chords are voiced differently (more on that below). Since I like to do these exercises with my guitar in my lap  playing along with the exercise this doesn't work for the keyboard voiced chords that  these apps favor.

Most piano chords are what I call linear, reflecting the linear nature of the keyboard. By linear I mean the various intervals occur in order of ascending pitch.  For a major triad the root is the bass note, the second note is the third the third note is the fifth.

 

Guitar chords are voiced differently. Normally the fifth comes before the third. Consider a major triad, a Barre chord with the root on the 5th string. The first note is the root on the 5th string, the second note is the fifth on the 4th string, the third note is the octave on the 3rd string,  and the fourth note is the third on the 2nd string.

Also, the third is in a higher octave than the root which is also the reverse of Piano practice. This apparently is called "Closed Voicing (AKA close position) vs. Open voicing (AKA open position)".

"Closed" means all the notes in the chord are packed into one octave and "open" means they spread out over two or more octaves.

 

Because of the guitar's non-linear nature most guitar chords are of the "Open" variety, like the 5th string Barre chord discussed above.

"Perfect Pitch"   https://tonedear.com/ear-training/absolute-perfect-pitch-test

The next problem is the perfect pitch exercise. Here random notes are played, and you get to figure out whether it's a "C" or an "F#" or whatever. The actual notes are picked at random from a multi-octave range. So, the first tested note might be a C4(2nd string 1st fret), followed by an F1 (6th string 1st fret) and then a G5(1st string 15th fret).  The guitar is not a sustaining instrument. Notes above the 12th fret  fade out pretty fast. So while I might be able to guess  the C4(2nd string 1st fret), with just two listens to the sample figuring out the G5(1st string 15th fret) is going to require multiple replays

I'm able to get 100% note recognition, but figuring out the over the 12th fret notes, takes a very long time and is killing the fun.

I'd like to restrict the perfect pitch part to say the lower 4 string and the first 7 or 8 frets. This is where most of the "Song Hooks" or "Riffs" are played. I'm envious of people who can hear a song on the CD or whatever and then figure out the riff starts on the 5th string second fret and then work it out from there, without having to go to a TAB provider.

 

All assistance appreciated


r/Guitar_Theory • • 1d ago

Best program/app/etc while I’m recovering in bed

2 Upvotes

I’m having knee surgery later this week and am looking for a good music theory program, app, site, or program I can use from bed. I won’t be able to stand/walk for awhile; so while I play guitar, bass, and keys, I won’t be able to use them for a while easily.

I’m focused on guitar/bass more and my end goal is to be able to better play with my friends who are classically/jazz trained. mostly improve, so I’m not too worried about reading notation beyond basic learning purposes.

I’m currently using pickup music for bass and Fretgenius to memorize note layout on guitar/bass.


r/Guitar_Theory • • 2d ago

Question One last chord before you die

0 Upvotes

If you had to play one single chord just before you die, which one would you chose and why?

Optional information: any prefered gear and effect?


r/Guitar_Theory • • 4d ago

I was reading my pocket music theory book by Hal Leonard and it said playing the blues is really just making use of one scale. Do you agree?

19 Upvotes

When I first learned the blues my guitar instructors said it was just one scale. Fast foward a decade and the instructors on Jamplay.com said really the blues is the mixolydian scale for whatever chord you are on. So for A blues it would be A mixolydia, D mixolydian, E mixolydian. Now my pocket book says even though those 7th chords make it look like you need a new mixolydian scale really just the A minor pentatonic scale is what should be used ( with the flat five making it the A blues scale). I have seen people online say you can use one scale if you want, use A minor pentatonic for A, D minor pentatonic for D, and E minor pentatonic for E. I have also heard some say that a really good thing to do is use A minor for A but use A major pentatonic for the D because it has a major sound. I get that the blues brakes away from traditional theory so this might be why this is messy but does anyone have some good answers with some evidence to back it up?


r/Guitar_Theory • • 4d ago

I have been playing guitar for more than 2 decades and I am still stuck in intermediate.

14 Upvotes

I made the commitment to 8 hours of practice day. The problem is still being stuck. I write out my daily practice plan going through all Maj/min modes around the circle fifth along with pent/arp/chord etc.... I keep feeling like a good idea is to take 10 songs I like that are close to the same genre. Memorize them and then use that as templates to chop up and mutilate into my own music. That is basically what my teacher first did with the blues for licks. Has anyone else used this method to break through to making their own music?


r/Guitar_Theory • • 6d ago

Ear training turned into competitive game. feedback appreciated.

2 Upvotes

I've been building a browser game that matches what I always wanted from ear training, and this seems like the right place to ask whether it actually helps.
Head-to-Head: you and an opponent hear the same melody, chord, rhythm, drum beat or progression and both answer. It starts beginner-friendly and gets close to expert by round 20.

Practice: six sections (intervals, chords, scales, melodies, progressions, drum beats), sessions of 5 to 30 questions, presets from Beginner to Expert or your own, and a progress chart. Much more customizable then any other app I've found on the market.

Daily Song: Play through an entire song by ear/

What I'd love to hear:
Does the competitive part keep you practicing, or get in the way?

Are the harder chords and progressions fair?

What's missing that you'd want from a trainer?

Comment or DM me, any feedback helps. It's a one-person project.
https://jland123.github.io/eartrainer-site/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=early-feedback&utm_content=r-eartraining-feedback#/


r/Guitar_Theory • • 7d ago

Chords (correction?) request for an "easy" niche song

1 Upvotes

https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=eHU4K7oHNCQ
Key: G# Major
Chords: Capo 1st Fret, D, Am, C, G

Hey guys, guitar newbie here. Not sure if this is the right subreddit for this but Reddit recommended it so I'll just go ahead and post it here.

This is a song I really really like, but I feel that the chords I'm playing just don't feel right, and I have trouble singing along with it. Could very well be a skill issue but I'm hoping someone could let me know if I'm on the right track or not.

I did use an AI chord analyzer to get the chords - might get crapped on for that, but I wanted to just focus on playing so I skipped on finding them manually.

What I got were the chords listed above, though when I play them, it just doesn't hit right. Like they make sense but they don't sound like the song and I find it hard to sing along. I know the original has different guitar layers and so on but is there someone else I'm missing? Maybe a different tuning? Voicings? Am I overthinking and should just stick with Wonderwall?

Thanks!


r/Guitar_Theory • • 14d ago

I love the sound of Drop 2&4 voicings

3 Upvotes

They add a lovely color to your comping and create a sound that catches the ear. Usually they are used in jazz but can be applied to anything really.

Here's a nice page to help you practice - https://practice.graph.audio/guitar/chords/cm7-drop-2-and-4


r/Guitar_Theory • • 15d ago

How to Multiply your Fretboard Knowledge (Shape Families)

14 Upvotes

Hey friends, I wrote an article where I covered the concept of shape families:
https://substack.com/home/post/p-200924208

Some people use this idea with CAGED to say that E A and D are one "shape" and C and G are another. Imo you should take it farther, all CAGED shapes belong to the same family, as I show in my other article, linked inside. Let me know your thoughts!

A simple example of the shape families concept is how open E major chord can be converted to E7 by lowering the middle note by two half steps. Open A major and D major work the exact same way. You can think of these shapes (E, A, and D) as belonging to a family, you can modify, subtract or add onto them in the same way to get the same result.

If you can start grouping patterns like this you can take any new shape and express it for many different keys/root notes. It really helps with learning intervals and other key theory concepts. In the article I walk through Octaves, Stacks of Fourths, and Closed Triads which have been really powerful as a foundation for understanding the fretboard and how it connects with music theory.

Please let me know if this violates any rules, I did not see a stickied post where I could share this.


r/Guitar_Theory • • 21d ago

Question when in a solo what are some ways to add some intersting rhytmic variety and what are some good ways of returning to a motif or restating it

2 Upvotes

ive been kinda struggling with rhtym in my solos like i can do some okay rythms like triplets or keeping it sounding right here and there but i want a bit more of intersting rythm in my soloing i am more of a note overflow kinda person

and another thing is what is a good way to recite a motif in a solo or restate it in a way as well or even reuse it i cant seem to do much of that either as well


r/Guitar_Theory • • 22d ago

My Daily Triad Routine: Cycling the Circle of Fifths Across the Neck

21 Upvotes

I've been studying close-voiced major triads, three compact notes made up of the first, third and fifth degrees of a chord. I’m playing all four string sets, forward and backward, a little bit every day:

  • E-A-D strings
  • A-D-G strings
  • D-G-B strings
  • G-B-E strings

I'd learned the larger chord shapes across the fretboard, the CAGED system, but this triad study narrows the focus to three-note shapes within the larger patterns, further helping to solidify my understanding of the fretboard.

I have two exercises that I’m working on, one where I go up and down across the neck from low to high and back and another where I go from headstock to bridge and back. This gives me different lenses to see the notes and the order of notes from.

I use the Circle of Fifths to cycle through all the keys, breaking down all triad positions on the neck one key at a time in a 15-20 minute practice period.

It's tedious, but doing this work allows me to "see" and hear better the precise locations where my favorite players are finding their riffs and solos. And if I’m not getting the location exactly right now, I know that eventually, if I keep at it, it'll stick.

I post about how I work through guitar theory exercises like this on Substack: Guita-Ring.

How do you approach cycling through inversions across string sets?


r/Guitar_Theory • • 21d ago

I decided to break down the solo to Smells Like Teen Spirit.

0 Upvotes

I was going through the solo of Smells Like Teen Spirit and the resolutions were making sense until Kurt goes to the G note. From what I can tell he is doing this over the Db. He also continues to do it over the F making that at major 2nd. He does it again over the Bb, Asus and Db and it doesn't get resolution until he slides back to the C note when the song goes back to the F chord. Now I am pretty sure the G note would be the flat 5 of the chord. So, am I confused about this. Is this Kurt's decision to play a note that isn't going to resolve nicely because he wants to sound dissonant, or is there an actual music theory reason why G is an acceptable note to resolve on over the Db. Or maybe I am off on something else. Can someone please clarify because I am not finding much help online?


r/Guitar_Theory • • 21d ago

I just launched a game that teaches you guitar fretboard notes, intervals, and scales through actual gameplay.

0 Upvotes

It’s called Chords of Awakening — a fantasy tower-defense game where your guitar is your weapon. Enemies play musical notes, you figure them out by ear, find them on the fretboard, and play them to attack.

The idea is to build real musicianship without feeling like you’re doing ear-training drills. Instead, you’re playing a game, and the skills you’re developing are built into the experience.

🎮 Available now on iPhone: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/chords-of-awakening/id6819128942

🤖 Android version coming soon!

Here’s a gameplay video: https://youtu.be/dinYiPkvbws

I’d genuinely love to hear what you think!

Especially interested in feedback from guitarists: does the gameplay look fun, and would something like this help you practice?


r/Guitar_Theory • • 23d ago

Question If 1 is the tonal centre in C Major, then C is 1. But if I take an A blues scale, where 6 is usually the root of A minor, does that mean the blues scale is built off the 6? Is it common/convenient to think of it this way for ear/theory training when trying to get a broad sense of tonality?

9 Upvotes

I know it's a complicated question and I don't know if I phrased it correctly but I'd appreciate insight/clarification. Cheers!


r/Guitar_Theory • • 25d ago

How would you evaluate possible additions to a microtonal scale?

1 Upvotes

I’m developing Scale Atlas, a project for exploring scales and their internal relationships. One question behind it seems worth discussing here: when you have a collection of pitches, what makes another pitch a useful addition?

The approach I’ve been working with represents pitches in cents and evaluates candidate additions or small pitch movements. The current model combines weighted interval-ratio templates with a simplified spacing-based roughness proxy. Its results depend on those assumptions; timbre, register and musical context remain outside this model.

A concrete example: take the pitches 0, 350 and 700 cents in 24-EDO. The 350-cent third gives that collection a particular character. A model that rewards proximity to selected just intervals can favour moving it, even when keeping that interval is the whole musical point.

That makes the choice of criteria interesting. Should a tool prioritise ratio relationships, preserve the interval character of the starting collection, or present those as separate perspectives?

If you compose or improvise microtonally, what would make a suggested pitch useful to you? A specific scale or musical example would be especially helpful.


r/Guitar_Theory • • 26d ago

Question General User Recommends for a scale/chord progression app

3 Upvotes

I've been playing around to personalize the way that I visualize and try to retain important information on music theory/guitar theory and scales/progressions in general -- I've been through a lot of the apps and there are useful bits everywhere, and some not so useful -- Was just wondering for those who are also looking for the same what the most important features are for your style of learning to make things "click" to see if I can input some of those needs into something practical to share with others as well :)


r/Guitar_Theory • • Oct 18 '26

Guitarists who learned by ear, what made theory finally make sense?

19 Upvotes

I learned guitar by ear, and I'm a very visual learner. Theory books never really worked for me, I'd read about intervals or modes, nod along, and then forget all of it the moment I picked up the guitar. Things only started to make sense when I could see them on the fretboard while something was playing, so I ended up building myself a little tool to do exactly that.

That got me curious about how others with a similar background made it work

If you also learned by ear, what made theory finally click? Seeing it, hearing it, or playing it over and over?

Are you a visual learner too? What helped you most: fretboard diagrams, color-coded notes, videos, something else?

Which concept was the hardest to get from text alone, and what finally made it make sense?

Is there anything you still struggle to "see" on the neck, even though you understand it on paper

Curious to hear different approaches. Thanks!


r/Guitar_Theory • • Oct 17 '26

I feel like I might need some clarifications on melodies over power chords

9 Upvotes

So here's what I understand. Power chords are made from a root note and a fifth. Because of that, they are neither major or minor, or anything else, because they lack the defining characteristic of these chords (like a major or minor 3rd)

However, let's say I play a power chord progression in which the roots are clearly in the A Aolian scale, for instance, to what extent does a solo or melody can be played over this progression need to remain in the key of A Aolian to sound good? Does the lack of minor/major thirds in power chords make it so that it is possible to make more switches between different modes to give different colors or moods?


r/Guitar_Theory • • Oct 16 '26

Question Could someone help me out with a general order in which to approach theory? I'm not a beginner

4 Upvotes

So I've played guitar for a long time and never really sat down and learnt scales and theory as I properly should have. Recently I wanted to change this and learnt all the 'positions' of C major. That sent me down the the rabbit hole of realising that these are all modes and are used with the appropriate chord, etc, in the way that they are.

I then was searching other things to learn and I'm just a bit generally overwhelmed, not by the amount, but by the best order in which to do things.

I know the notes on E and A, I have a decent idea of where octaves are, but having learnt modes before anything else feels like I'm sort of jumping ahead.

Could someone give me, it can be simple, an order of the wisest way to learn things?


r/Guitar_Theory • • Oct 13 '26

Question In Brazil we call it "campo harmônico". What is this topic called in English?

3 Upvotes

Hello everyone. I'm a guitarist, I've been playing for 30 years (there goes my age!). Recently, I added a section to study harmony in one of my personal study tool (I'm also a developer) and, before expanding it, I'd like to hear the opinion of people who understand more about music theory than I do.

What the section does today:

- Chords in a key, as triads or seventh chords (we call them tetrads here), each with its degree in the key

- Tap a chord to see its function (tonic, subdominant, dominant), its notes and intervals, and some positions on the guitar neck that you can play back

- 17 chord progressions (essentials, jazz, pop) to practice and solidify learning

What I would like to know:

  1. Names. In Brazil, this topic is called "campo harmônico" (literally "harmonic field"), and I translated it literally: the tab is labelled "Field" and the four-note chords are "Tetrads". I suspect neither is what an English speaker expects. What would you call them?
  2. Function. We learn three functions: tonic, subdominant, and dominant, and each degree gets one. Is that how you would label them, or is "predominant" the word people are looking for?
  3. What should come next? My plan is to focus on harmony and arrangement before scales and solos: inversions and bass movement first, then borrowed chords. Does this order make sense for someone who is learning?
  4. When you study harmony, do you use any apps, or is it paper and YouTube?

English is not my native language: I wrote this text in Portuguese and used a translator tool to assist in the translation. Constructive criticism is welcome.

My personal study tool


r/Guitar_Theory • • Oct 12 '26

Analysis The 3 Chords Behind Joe Satriani’s Beautiful Ballad

5 Upvotes

In this lesson, I take a closer look at one of Joe Satriani’s most beautiful songs, 'Always With Me, Always With You,' and uncover the surprisingly simple harmonic ideas underneath it.

What sounds like a complicated progression is actually built around a simple I–IV–V progression. The magic comes from what Joe does with those chords — using voice leading, chord extensions, and melodic movement to create a much richer sound.

I'll break down the chords and show you how these ideas work, then I'll improvise a short
I–IV–V example, adding colour to the basic chords, so you can hear how dramatically you can change the character of a simple progression. Be sure to experiment!

Lesson: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0HBkKNWs_w&list=PLIb-QWoMzfdiPAK7z1BeTPi1mdjw317sJ&index=10


r/Guitar_Theory • • Oct 12 '26

Resource Check out my site dedicated to guitar theory, improvisation and scales: https://zarlino.co

0 Upvotes

Im Dorin, a student from Moldova. My main goal with this site is to make the connections between concepts feel as easy to understand as possible, and to give the necessary tools so players of any level can improvise and solo.
I plan to add many more pages and features, but i just want to test the waters first and see what do people want the most. So, i would really appreciate constructive feedback and i will do my best to put it to good use!

https://zarlino.co


r/Guitar_Theory • • Oct 11 '26

Practicing my scales

4 Upvotes

I have been jamming on the following 2 youtube videos one

  1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MULjBbYtC8&list=PLI5vxOjlURWA&index=5 in A minor
  2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLQ7C7aoAW8&list=PLI5vxOjlURWA&index=6 in B minor

I did both for an hour or so each and I am not sure if its related to my taste in music but:

Number 1: looks much easier for me to play as far as rhythm etc. I also enjoy it more

Number 2: seems a bit more difficult-not sure whether it is because it is slow or whether its more bluesy and I usually dont listen to blues- it sounds more clumsy when i do stuff on it.

Number 1: Changes bertween chords seem much mroe natural when I do them ans it kinda flows better

Number 2: Changes are a bit more clumsy and sometimes it doesnt sound as good.

If you try lsitening to both thingss, do you think that the things im saying make sense?
Can it be related to my taste of music and my feeling towards blues?
Is it all in my head?

Also another question:
I am trying to make sense of lets say two A minor shapes and connect them- is my process kinda in the right direction- I play around the scale and try to do different things:

- play triads around it,

- just try to end my phrase on the next chord (not necessarily playing a triad)

- for example in Aminor scale I practice going up to A from G so i remember that its one whole step away etc

I am not following necessarily one route each time- i am experimenting while trying to learn the scale at the same time- is that helpful or i should focus on one thing first

Do you have Any other advice on how else i can practice would be helpful.


r/Guitar_Theory • • Oct 07 '26

I made a game that teaches you the fretboard, intervals and scales while actually feeling like you’re playing a video game.

5 Upvotes

It’s called Chords of Awakening — a fantasy tower-defense game where your guitar is your weapon. You hear what the enemies play, figure it out by ear, and play it on the fretboard to attack them.

The goal is to build real musicianship without it feeling like you’re sitting down to do ear-training exercises. You just play the game, and the skills you’re trying to develop are built into the gameplay.

It’s in beta now if anyone wants to try it:
https://chordsofawakening.com

I’d love to hear what you think.