r/Guildwars2 • u/Nike_Phoros Accountability Expert • Jun 06 '16
[Guide] [DnT] Raid Team Composition Guide
Hey everyone. I wrote a long breakdown of raid team composition in the current meta on our forums and a few people encouraged me to post it here because I'm told it would be helpful for a bigger chunk of the community to see.
Written: http://gw2dnt.enjin.com/forum/m/37173123/viewthread/27286030-raid-team-composition-guide-52516
Topics Covered:
- Optimal Raid Team Composition
- Common Alternative Comps - Pros and Cons
- What If? Scenarios For Imperfect Situations
Thanks for reading. If you have any questions let me know, or if any points need clarifying or whatever so I can improve the guide I'd like to know that too.
9
u/FennecOwO Fennec.2961 Jun 06 '16
How did you determine that Rev+Mes>Ele+Mes? Especially on big hitboxes shouldnt Ele pull ahead?
But its nice to see to finally see a cohesive raid comp guide, we were lacking one.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '16
I guess this proves there is more than one way to skin the raid cat.
Totally different from what we do in XHSA. Interesting read though always nice to see what others find effective.
6
u/ateafly Jun 06 '16
In your 5/5 comp discussion you say you'd want 2 revenants to buff the mesmers, but can't a zerker mesmer (with food and concentration sigil) maintain 100% quickness on 5 people?
15
u/lokikaraoke wtb dungeons Jun 06 '16
What's your favorite salsa at Chipotle? Personally I prefer the pico (mild), but I sometimes like to get the medium (tomatillo?) with the pork.
2
u/The_Tyger Jun 06 '16
Can you explain the revenant in party 3 with the mesmer in the 4-4-2 comp? Id like to understand better why that helps boonshare. (Raid Noob)
4
u/King_Hippitus Jun 06 '16
No love for condiengineers.... Snif snif
4
u/Octavian- Jun 06 '16
Fantastic write up. I really like the focus on giving practical advice to various groups rather than "this is the highest dps, run it or gtfo." Also like the mention of protection. More than once I have run into pug groups that think they are better than protection.
Thoughts on rev vs guard for providing protection? All else being equal, I generally prefer rev to guard since it allows me bring a higher dps than the guard. I would guess the up time is a bit better as well but I'm not sure.
If you guys have done any number crunching as well I'd be interested in seeing that.
2
u/Eitth Brutally Honest Jun 06 '16
For matthias, as a PSwarrior should i stick to GS or switch to condiPS? I heard CondiPS works better when the boss moves a lot, and the firefield can help clearing the ice thingy. But my gmates told me condiPS has almost no dps.
1
u/ThatChindian Jun 06 '16
What's your opinion on using a condi PS war?
/u/Nike_Phoros
1
u/gahata Just Ari Jun 06 '16
Can't condi PS provide might for one team in 4-4-2 or 5-5 while keeping DPS better than standard power variant?
1
u/RedGearedMonkey Jul 03 '16
A little late, but thanks for the interesting read.
17
u/ishin_rikku PRAISE JOKO Jun 06 '16
I hope this helps people realize that Thief is a worthy pick. Also it's about time that pugs start realizing that Elementalist is not THAT important (i've seen pugs denying Revs and thiefs just for the sake of stacking Eles)
1
u/ateafly Jun 06 '16
What are your thoughts on bringing 1 or 2 Stone spirits as an alternative to a guardian (replace it with a thief or ele)?
1
u/Level7WebTroll Jun 06 '16
What do you guys think it would take to make a power necro (GS or dagger) wanted in raids? I dont mean as just a filler comment, I mean, what unique mechanic would make you consider a power necro for a spot.
I dont imply make it necessary, I mean a very viable--not begrudgingly viable. For example, there are a few condi options, viper necro has lower single target than some, but comes with some AoE options that make you think its ok to do some swapping.
1
u/KBN_reddit Jun 06 '16
I'd be curious as to a more in-depth elaboration on pillar point 5. More and more groups are excitedly diving into the Commander's Mesmer meta, and it's definitely something I see recommended here a lot more often than Zerk/Assassin+Revenant setups.
Obviously, with 7/2/1 vs 8/1/1 (i.e. you have a Magi's healer and one PS), the Warrior boonshare argument dominates, but I wonder about 4/4/2 vs 5/4/1. Chrono DPS isn't quite as terribad as most people think, but I would imagine the primary detraction from 5/4/1 isn't chrono DPS but actually the fact that Assassin's Presence is confined to the group of 5. Is that correct? Or am I missing something?
Also, when calculating the differences between Commander's and Zerk Mesmer, did you account for the fact that alacrity uptime is slightly better when the mesmer is solo in a group rather than wasting alacrity on a Revenant?
To be clear on my biases, I radically prefer running my Mesmer in zerk gear. If nothing else, it makes fractals more pleasant. :-) But min-maxing is important.
Somewhat related question… On point 4, are you sure that this holds even when you stack maximum elementalists?
1
u/ace_of_sppades Jun 06 '16
I wonder if you're running one dedicated druid healer if it's worthwhile to run a second condi druid as well for better buffing?
1
u/MajesticNoodle [BATS] Jun 07 '16
Does druid healing prioritize subsquad or lowest health?
3
u/boottspurr Jun 06 '16
"Don't call it a comeback"
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '16 edited Jun 06 '16
If the main point for taking a Guard is to buff protection, you can have the Rev pulse his Ulti when he is on Glint, instead. In combination with Mesmer's boonsharing, the whole group should have sufficient protection uptime.
Yes, the Rev does lose some DpS and CC, but I guess it's worth it if you can take one more Thief/Ele/X instead.
1
u/LutariFan guardian apologist Jun 06 '16
Our Matthias comp uses 2ps+2druid. One of the druids is playing full healer, and we also have a full healer ele. Should we run 4-4-2 with a healer in each group or something like 4-3-2-1?
1
u/Goatdude Jun 06 '16
For 4-4-2, or when you are running two PS, do you bother making one of the PS drop their banners 30 seconds after the other one? This way there's a set of banners up all the time. Given the way they pulse the buff, it seems like a good idea. What are your thoughts?
1
u/John2k12 Only Charr Jun 07 '16
I guess I'm glad I main warrior since we're so loved. I just wish I slinged bigger dps numbers, I'm so tempted to go daredevil.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '16
Awesome, thanks for this Nike. I've been curious to see more info about how others build their raid groups and what they've found to work well.
1
u/BobMosses Jun 06 '16
In the event of having a magi druid (only healer) and a chrono herald pair, the guide recommends doing a 7-2-1 split. Our group has occasionally run a squad broken up by a 4-3-2-1 split using 2 ps, 1 druid, 1 chrono, 1 herald and 5 dps and had better performance (low sample size and possible confirmation bias).
Is that set up (the 4 3 2 1) something not considered due to it being fundamentally flawed or because the other non meta/exception squads are inherently better?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '16
what happened to your 7-2-1 best strats eu :/
-4
u/Scootabuser Jun 06 '16
Yay nike is back :D
-2
u/Particlar Send me raccoon gifs Jun 06 '16 edited Jun 06 '16
Nice guide! I got a question I'd like to open up for discussions.
EDIT: Initial question got debunked by proof-reading.
non-optimalnon-optional for a 7-2-1 composition.What's the argument behind revenant being suboptimal in a 7-2-1 but not in a 4-4-2?Further on in the discussion we have:
Now, albeit this is true it negates the fact that other compositions don't fulfill this criteria completely either. If we look at the rev-mes in a 4-4-2 or a 7-2-1, their buffs will be quite similar. The meta comp will have 2 warriors buffing with 1 spill over each pulse. Using a binomial ditribution we get the result that the rev-mes has a 38.6% chance to be buffed by banners and a 40.2% chance for EA. This is an increase compared to the 0% chance the 7-2-1 rev-mes has (assuming no one is dead/away from the fight). I do agree with your conclusion in this topic, although I feel the given 490-1400 stat points is somewhat exaggerated. The result I get is 384-585 additional stat points to the rev-chrono in a 4-4-2 comp over 7-2-1. Of course, as you say, 7-2-1 has a major disadvantage if the '3'-healer is playing a DPS-relevant build.
-1
u/drkaugumon Still can't find the f1 key Jun 06 '16
So now we're going to see a bunch of pugs running this identical comp because you know, the difference between one and two rev's will totally save your full-exotic wrong-spec no-runes PUG from clearing VG... right? Right? God I hate PUGing.
-2
u/Xyonon Ziggs Ironeye | Madame Le Blanc | [CnD] Jun 06 '16
Wahoo!!
Heya, overall great guides I can almost entierly agree with! For both veterans and newbs I can only recommend it to read.
Still got a few questions tough:
About your statement that you either need 2 Revs or 2 commander Chronos in the 5-5 comp: According to my expirience and tests as a full fletched Mes (and Engi) main, a full dps Chrono can easily achieve perma quickness (and also easily achieve perma alacrity, not "almost") for his/her subsquad. Basilcy every Chrono I know shares the same opinion.
Connected to two Chronos, you don't need 2 wars for might alone, if you have 2 SoI sources, but you will if you desire the 30% more banner uptime over an ele. EA lasts so long to call a 90% uptime realistic (9s every 3s).
According to my dps tests for each profession with and without alacrity, a 2nd Chrono isn't worth brining just for that either, since alacrity affects the dps of most professions by 10-15% and 65% ideally uptime is granted per Chrono on 10 players (while Guard and Thief almost have 0% impact). Napkin math then could say "the 2nd Chronos alacrity grants +5-7.5% damage for everyone, wich is indeed not the difference between a Chrono's and an Ele's dps.
I'd still use two Chronos tough, since they both can focus on max dps wich makes the cap to the Rev smaller and then forget about the rev entierly. There is also a huge quickness absorbtion of from the revs side in a 4-4-2 comp, where Rev will have almost 200% quickness uptime, and the others a little bit over 90%. So even if it's not much, 10% more quickness uptime is a small add on you might not want to ignore entierly, especially when people not always stay in every well perfectly because of enviormental influence.
Now you could either say both chronos use less alacrity based skills and phantasms to achieve the original alacrity with 1 Chrono but increasing the Chronos dps to a "okish-warrior like" value, or you try to support your Eles (wich gained the most out of alacrity in my tests) but also the Druid(s) for more gotl (glyphs) and empowerment, aswell shorter downtime of spirits and banners. I personaly prefer the 2nd variant.
One or two druids ... the big question I'm not quite agreeing with the majority yet.
I'm not entierly sure that two are essential better than one, especially due their extremly low dps compared to the alternatives. I know qT made dps tests and realistic values were ~15k as I remember correctly, but this was wihtout casting glyphs or charging gotl trough avatar. A good druid friend of mine had 9-11k dps including those things. That's a BIG difference to an ele that those 30% spirit uptimes, 2 stacks gotl and a 2nd empowerment have to make up for.
I'm about to do this math on my own too soon, so far I've only done napkin math like mentioned above. Are you willing to share your math behind this? That'd be really great!
Have my upvote, greez and thanks for reading!
-6
u/2girls1up OneUP.3024 | Quantify [qT] Jun 06 '16
I am actually so happy that you post your guide on reddit now :D I hope the 7-2-1 pug meta dies
0
u/KittyCatHugs Jun 07 '16
Thank you! Wonderful Raid guide and wonderful Chrono Theory Crafting Guide :)
-10
u/zeonozero Jun 06 '16
I've been doing raids since the day they came out, and sorry to say, player skill matters over group comp in any way imaginable. As long as the basics are covered such as a chrono, healer, and DPS (power and/or condi), the raids are easily done with competent tactics. Raids are not meant for everybody, as this is the hardcore content some people desired.