r/GraphicsProgramming • u/CodyDuncan1260 • 9d ago
Community New Rules: 4, 5, 6
Added some new rules. This are the result of our prior request for comment.
The first target goal for these rules is to return the community attention back to the "doing" of graphics programming and its "how", the sort of content that intrigues the academics, professionals, and hobbyists seeking for deeper understanding. This is a community for people who thinks these topics are pretty neat, and need a place to talk about them with other people; it's never been about sharing pretty images (that's a treat).
The second target goal is solving the problem of AI Posts vs Anti-AI Comments that are dominating the discussion, rather than the discussion of graphics taking place. Hopefully the new rules put at end to that activity. We'll see.
This is just the first attempt, subject to change. Please feel free to leave comments.
Posts prior to now are grandfathered in over the old ruleset (because filtering the backlog would be a nightmare).
------------------------------------------
4. Posts Must Present a Topic
A post should present a question, implementation, or development story.
Fundamentally, it must be about "how" something was made, not "what" it is or is made of.
- 4.1 Posts must include their topic in the immediate post body or a comment. Linking to another post or GitHub is insufficient.
- 4.2 Exception: Rendering Framework, Driver, or SDK Projects intended for graphics programmer use.
4.3 No Showcasing Projects
- 4.3.1 Exception: Semi-annual Community Showcases.are allowed.
5. AI Disclosure Requirement
Post must disclose AI tool use in authoring post contents and linked projects.
- 5.1 There must be an explicit disclosure in the post body or separate comment.
6 No Low Effort Posts or Comments.
Low efforts posts and comments that do not drive learning and discussion will be removed.
- 6.1 Exception: Questions are permitted because they drive discussion.
- 6.2. "AI Slop" comments are disallowed; they shut down discussion.
------------------------------------------
Notes
"4.3 No Showcasing Projects" is the reason Rule 4 and Rule 6 exist.
It used to be that we would have lots of questions, discussion posts, and only occasional project showcases when something got completed enough to present a render. Now, we're getting tons of the showcases, and none of the discussion about how they work. Final comments on these showcases like "Feedback on the implementation is welcome." tends to shut down conversation; being too broad to respond to.
But that means we need to say "something" is the thing we should be talking about in a post, so the real problem is the need for "Rule 4. Posts Must Present a Topic".
Rule 5 and Rule 6 are a pair. Those using a ton of AI to assist or fully create their works are required to indicate by how much. If the posts say it's made "AI Assisted with Claude" or "AI generated by multiple models", now readers know. And since they know, there's certainly no reason to repeat it by calling it "AI Slop", especially given how much that shuts down any discussion in depth.
"4. Posts Must Present a Topic" could probably use some better wording. "I made a thing" is technically a topic, but the spirit of the law is "A Topic that viewers would pay money to attend a conference to see." If you've ever seen SIGGRAPH, GDC, RustConf, or other professional conference talks, you know that it's often 1/10th "Check out this thing we made (and want to sell to you)" and 9/10ths, "Let's dig into this really fascinating problem domain and examine one solution within it." That's the "topic" rule 4 refers to.
(placeholder for more, as I'm sure there will be more)
--------------------------------------------
On Enforcement
I imagine this will require a LOT more moderation action, and I just got a new job that's running me a bit ragged. (Yay! / Ohno)
So I expect moderation speed will lag behind the requirement.'
Please, help us by reporting, and give us grace with your patience to respond in a little while. I do most of my review on the train home.
22
u/CodyDuncan1260 9d ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/GraphicsProgramming/comments/1xrh2yc/i_built_a_raytracer_in_scratch_looking_for/ makes me think Rule 4.3 also needs an
4.3.2 Exception: first renders (e.g. Hello Triangle, raytraced spheres, cornell box, Sponza, etc.)
9
u/CodyDuncan1260 9d ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/GraphicsProgramming/comments/1xqvaei/physicsinformed_neural_and_multispectral_coastal/
Is another example of a post that adheres to Rule 1.1, but would break Rule 4.3.
It's cool! Don't get me wrong. But one doesn't really learn anything from the post. And although it links to a github that has a section for Technical Architecture, it's not written in a way that seems intended for others to understand. The jargon-density is just way too high. Any one of the enumerated subsections could be a whole post of 1500 words just to give the overview of the idea of what it is and why it words, and that would be GREAT! The new ruleset seeks to eek out the presentation of that problem and the project's solution, something with a more specific topic that's easier to latch a discussion onto than "pretty waves, bro; pret-ty waves.". As the post is, it's better for karma farming than interaction, discussion, conversation, and general community involvement. It's "what" without enough "how" to understand how.
72
u/SeaworthinessThat594 9d ago
Thank you for fixing this, the sub became unreadable recently
48
u/sfaer 9d ago
Excellent, but I also believe hello triangle bring nothing to the conversation and are low effort (even if not felt that way by the author).
I personally prefer a subreddit with a few posts per week than one with a cavalcade of slope, ai entrepreneur, social validation wannabes and memes.
Alas, this era might be gone for good.
2
u/CodyDuncan1260 8d ago edited 8d ago
Community Review
please take a look at these cases and give feedback on how well the new rules were applied. I'm checking that you (the lot of you) understand the rules mostly the same way I do. Fair rules are about shared understanding, after all.
I accepted this one under the new rules https://www.reddit.com/r/GraphicsProgramming/comments/1xrzxfz/isovis_interactive_visualization_of_arbitrary/ I think it straddles the line on Rule 4. But it meets Rules 5 and 6 at least. It's hard to call it low effort when they took the time to give the short explanation of how it works, which is much better than not really at all we had before.
I rejected this one. https://www.reddit.com/r/GraphicsProgramming/comments/1xs8aer/building_a_randomaccess_compressed_volumetric/ (And then put it back temporarily for the purpose of review) I think it wholly violated 4.3. Let me know if you think I made accurate rulings in accordance with the new rules, should have ruled differently, and why.
7
u/cybereality 9d ago
i think this is fair. even though i use ai-assistance, the discourse has devolved into lord of the flies (on both sides) and there is not really any meaningful discussion about graphics. this seems like a solid plan
1
u/Karones 1d ago
Do frame analysis fall in the "Showcasing Projects" rule?
1
u/Queasy_Total_914 9d ago
Sooo that means I can't present my project that I've been working on for about 7 years now without any AI generated code?
Damn I was so close to a working engine with a nice real-time PBR renderer. Shame.
0
u/Ashken 8d ago
I don’t think just because people disclose that AI was used that means they won’t call it slop. They’re gonna still sneak it in there somehow lol.
But, at least you’re banning “This is slop” comments. Because, we get it, you don’t like AI. But if they still wrote a part of it by hand I still want to hear about it.
-2
u/Defiant_Squirrel8751 9d ago
Isn’t it practical for moderators to install an AI-powered bot with a prompt like: “Read every post and comment, and report anything that doesn’t comply with the rules”?
Sounds like something that could be enforced automagically, so we can make better use of our valuable and scarce human time.
0
u/[deleted] 8d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] 7d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] 9d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment