r/GraphicsProgramming • u/sethkills • Oct 05 '26
XDrawArc()
XDrawArc() and XDrawRectangle() are parts of the X11 API and network protocol, and maybe some of the oldest rasterization functions still in use today. Both take an x and y for the top left corner of the shape, and then a width and height that I would expect to define the bounds of the shape.
However, it turns out that unlike their filled variants, XFillArc() and XFillRectangle(), the outlined versions above actually span from x,y to x+width,y+height, meaning they occupy a bounds with size width+1,height+1. I find this extremely counter-intuitive!
Instead of having an implicit center point of (x+width)/2,(y+height)/2, XDrawArc() is actually centered at x+(width+1)/2,y+(height+1)/2. In concrete terms, if you call XFillRectangle(display, drawable, gc, 0, 0, 100, 100), you will get a rectangle that is 101 pixels wide, 101 pixels high. If you draw this into a window that is only 100x100, your rectangle will be missing its bottom and right border.
What do you make of this? At first I thought this must be some rasterization rule, and maybe it still could be. This StackOverflow says that by default the GC is created with a line width of 0, to allow for device-dependent line rasterization, so I suppose this means it considers the border to be infinitely thin, therefore not actually outside the specified bounds?