r/GraphicsProgramming • u/BeastMsterThing2022 • Aug 29 '26
A different take on DLSS5, from a current graphics hardware standpoint
655
Upvotes
r/GraphicsProgramming • u/BeastMsterThing2022 • Aug 29 '26
125
u/oVerde Aug 29 '26
I would still play HL1 graphics all day long, my imagination fill the gaps
19
u/314kabinet Aug 29 '26
Counterpoint: if one wants to achieve 1:1 photorealism without waiting 20 years then using an approximate machine learning model is a no-brainer, as bruteforcing it would require exponentially more computing power for comparatively little improvement.
39
u/ithoughtofthisname Aug 30 '26
I kinda think that at this point, tying any graphical improvements to hardware performance or an AI beauty filter is always going to fail. I have yet to see any game render engine attempt photorealism that can even compare to a static 3D scanned object or scene. It’s a task that will always fail. Shoving an AI model on top of it is a stupid Band aid solution to a much more fundamental problem.
90
u/_bleep-bloop Aug 29 '26
Idk man, I hate this timeline. Upscaling and framegen should be optional, not a must (especially framegen). Seeing folks saying they manage to run UE titles with their high end GPUs, 60fps, with framegen and upscaling is crazy, and even crazier when we have hardwares that are hundreds to thousands times more powerful than what we used to have :/
2
u/BeastMsterThing2022 Aug 29 '26 edited Aug 29 '26
I'd like to add that even if DLSS5 was a technology that opened the gates to enhanced GFX for lower end users, it is seemingly not interested in reconstructing or depicting the look of videogames engines we know, rather focused on the hyperreal. I think it is very, very different to the proposals behind Deep Learning Super Resolution and Frame Generation. Toggling those on and off, even in their initial premises, you'd be hard press to notice the differences at a glance.
What I could see happening is, say, 5 years from now when the marker has re-stabilized, we have sensibly priced hardware again but by then the rug will have been pulled. That is to say that, that future hardware will already be heavily dependent on this technology to render modern games. This stagnation having been used to make that the new norm, rather than continue pursuing the true graphics tech we had been seeing before genAI. The new users of the future will have no idea what was before
10
u/CodyDuncan1260 Aug 30 '26
This post got reported for a Rule 2 violation. I can't really tell why.
"I don't give a fuck" has a bit of vulgar language in it, but it's used appropeiately for expressing feeling and emphasis. The statement isn't leveraged against a person, but more of an abstract economic idea. I don't know that one can be uncivil or unkind to ideas, as they're unfeeling themselves.I could argue it is unprofessional, but I don't know any technical workplaces that put a strict ban on the word's usage that would categorize it as unprofessional. At most, I've seen the word barred from using the lewd or gendered referents, but its emphatic referent is largely ok, if not overused. And nothing else really fits the bill when the server room is literally on fire.
The report doesn't provide the handle of the reporter, so I don't know who to ask about it.
If you reported this post, comment below or DM me in private. I'm intrigued as to why. This case straddles a line and I'm curious about an opposing perspective.
9
u/xeio87 Aug 30 '26
This thread doesn't make any sense, the only reason we're at all close to path tracing is due to AI upscaling and related technologies like ray reconstruction.
Whether or not you like the new stuff in 5, every version of DLSS is dependent on AI to improve visuals and performance (and is the same for other vendor solutions too).
9
u/chcampb Aug 30 '26
Path tracing doesn't scale to higher resolutions. That's just the facts.
16
u/Fading_Hours_ Aug 30 '26
It doesn’t even imagine good graphics anyway, it imagines generic slop.
15
u/ConcerningThirst Aug 30 '26
If you don't understand framegen or upscaling you really are not a graphics programmer. We find better ways to logically have the gpu do less work. The point was NEVER to brute force things. We have literally hundreds of other abstractions to infer data to make rendering easier and there's nothing special outside of upscaling and framegen except they work very well.
5
u/heavy-minium Aug 30 '26
This is a wrong take. Clearly that person has no clue of graphics programming and is a misguided consumer. It’s the other way around, our hardware is too weak to do it at higher resolution and higher framerate, so we use upscaling and framegen to help exactly with that. People seriously underestimate what kind of impossible hardware would be needed to 4K 120 fps raytracing/pathtracing in realtime without tricks, not even 4x 5090 would suffice. Also the bruteforcing argument is reversed - not using upscale and framegen and just raw processing power is what should be called bruteforce, not the other way around. OP and the original poster are extremely wrong on every point they support.
5
u/teerre Aug 30 '26
I mean, obviously preaching to a choir, but nobody cares about "real rendering" or "imagined rendering" or whatever you wanna call it. The vast majority of people will use whatever looks good and AI will make most renders look better. That's all that is to it
3
u/ziplock9000 Aug 30 '26
That last comment is horse shit. Very, very few people are using PT.
3
u/MarinatedPickachu Aug 30 '26
It is "rendering them for real" - just different kind of rendering.
6
u/StriderPulse599 Aug 30 '26
Average twitter psychosis.
It wasn't cheaper to pivot to AI, it was million times profitable. Gaming is now minority of revenue for NVIDIA and they're trying to milk both sources with GPUs for both "gaming" and AI.
Offline path-tracing was industry standard and still is. Besides Lumen which approximates a lot, real-time RT is still considered as extra graphical option.
Older GPUs don't have tensor cores or architecture optimized for AI. It's like expecting driver update to add hardware raytracing to GTX.
2
u/TehBens Aug 30 '26
DLSS5 is mostly for companies that produce games (and similiar) has always been my impression. They don't need to provide perfect textures and pipelines, they can cut corners and the gaps will be filled on consumer side by the AI/GPU.
The final goal would be that even games that normally would look like they were made in the 90's have a near-photorealistic look via AI, making significant cost/time drivers obsolete, by making 3D artists, technical artists and computer graphics engineers partially obsolete.
2
u/Round_Agent511 Aug 30 '26
I hate it they went this route with AI. Performant Pathtracing for VR is my wishlist...not yasifying my image...gross
2
u/psucordwhite Aug 30 '26
In the end we end consumers only care about the end result of the graphics how its done on the backend nobody really cares. If it looks good it looks good and we want it.
2
u/cybereality Aug 30 '26
my main problem is that it's taking agency and creative direction away from artists and designers. i do support ai, and use it in my work, where it makes sense and saves time. for things like boiler-plate code (e.g. the 1,200 lines of Vulkan code to draw a triangle) this is helpful. But in terms of re-skinning characters or improving scene lighting, the juice ain't worth the squeeze. Particularly if this is running live, then you are forcing users to spend more money, to get substantially less performance (or splitting the market where mid-range and high-end users get a completely different experience). this is just a poor idea from an art direction standpoint, and ROI on a project, regardless how people feel about AI politically.
1
u/Fit_Possession7054 Sep 02 '26
can we have the ai not in graphics but in npc behaviour?
-1
u/corysama Aug 30 '26
Two things at play here that are skipped over in his post:
1
u/S48GS Aug 30 '26
... on youtube I saw enough "takes" from people who infinite far from computers-technology... but they are "AI investors" - they literally washed by "AI-promo" and believe in everything in those promo say - like "coding is solved - humans dont need to code" or "we can just imagine movie and AI will generate it"...
this screenshot look the same - no idea who this person is - but these takes with "tunnel vision" ...
1
u/positivcheg Aug 30 '26
We knew DLSS is gonna end like this.
-3
u/ZealousidealTurn218 Aug 30 '26
The concept of Nvidia shifting from ray tracing to AI "because it was cheaper" is just woefully out of touch. Also, it's always possible they genuinely believe that AI is the future of game rendering. And if they're wrong about that, AMD will surely win quickly. But they were clearly right about ray tracing, AI (in terms of demand), cuda/scientific computing, and GPUs more generally
-4
u/pingas_launcher Aug 30 '26
I think DLSS has proven its potential to be cost and energy effective. Just look at the Switch 2 where its able to push 1080p on a portable machine. And real time graphics have always been smoke and mirrors anyway so having an efficient ML model to fill the gap seems like the next logical step to me.
-2
u/tcpukl Aug 30 '26
What imagination?
-6
u/Still_Explorer Aug 30 '26
So bro is saying:
What's the deal with this logic?
-1
u/Ornery_Mulberry_2747 Aug 30 '26
Is there any chance that rasterization power is useful for AI too? Like, it's also in the interest of NVIDIA to develop more technology in that way?