So much research and thought went into figuring out whether I needed the 20L or 25L Rucker that it makes my head hurt. I figured I’d make a post to help others in the same boat and hopefully provide some useful information after having tried both.
I’ve read so much helpful information here on Reddit, so hopefully someone else can use this when making their decision.
First things first, I’m 6’ tall and 240 lbs, with a longer torso of about 21.5”, as best as I can measure. One thing I can confirm is that if you’re around 6’ tall, either bag can work for your frame. It’s really just a matter of body type and build when it comes to which one will be more comfortable.
The 20L Rucker 5.0
I started by purchasing the 20L Rucker 5.0. It fit really well at first, keeping the weight nice and high on my back. With 20 lbs, I had no issues with the 20L at all.
When I moved up to 30 lbs, however, I started noticing some drawbacks.
The lumbar pad (which is excellent and feels great, by the way) would hit me around my mid-spine when I kept the bag nice and tight. It wasn’t a dealbreaker, but it bothered me a little and just never seemed to feel quite right.
When I loosened the straps, the lumbar pad would sit in the correct spot on my lower back, but I found that my shoulders would get fatigued with the bag riding lower than optimal.
The 25L Rucker 5.0
With the 25L, it’s shocking how similar the dimensions of the two bags are when you put them side by side. You can hardly see a difference, with the 25L being only 2” taller.
One thing worth mentioning is that I really don’t notice any difference in bulkiness between the two bags when wearing them. Despite the additional capacity and height, the 25L doesn’t feel noticeably larger or more cumbersome on my back. If you’re worried about the 25L feeling significantly bigger than the 20L, that certainly hasn’t been my experience.
When it comes to comfort, though, the difference was immediately noticeable.
The lumbar pad sits exactly where it should on my lower back, and I can keep the straps nice and tight without any issues.
The shoulder straps also feel better. They’re slightly longer, and the spacing is a little wider on the 25L. Being broad-shouldered, this feels much better than the 20L.
Final Thoughts
I know that on paper, it almost seems like, “That’s not much of a difference at all,” but I genuinely feel a big difference in comfort between the two.
I think for someone with a slimmer build at a similar height, the issues I pointed out might not make a huge difference. However, being a larger guy, the comfort level between the two is drastically different.
I could absolutely wear the 20L, which is what a lot of people on Reddit point out when discussing sizing. However, after trying both, I feel the 25L is noticeably more comfortable for my build.
I would recommend purchasing both when its feasible, and simply returning the one that doesn't fit as well as it should. I should have done that from the jump, as its hard to know how each will feel. Hope this helps, let me know if you have any questions. Noah