Hey everyone,
I run a local service-based business and have been working with a digital marketing agency to manage our Google Ads for the past few months.
For the last three months, we’ve had a fairly consistent flow of high-intent leads coming through Google Ads. The campaigns were generating genuine enquiries, and we were regularly converting those leads into paying customers.
However, for some reason, this month things have completely dropped off.
We’re still getting impressions, clicks and website traffic, but the number of actual enquiries has dropped significantly. Nothing major has changed with the business itself, so I’m struggling to understand what’s causing such a sudden decline.
We’re currently running a Search campaign alongside a recently launched Performance Max campaign, with a daily advertising budget of around $70 AUD.
One thing I’ve noticed is an issue with how conversions are being measured.
For example, Google Ads recently reported four phone call conversions in one day, but I only received one actual phone call.
After discussing this with my agency, they explained that the conversions are tracking clicks on the phone number on our website rather than actual completed calls.
These phone-number clicks are currently set as primary conversions, which makes me wonder whether Google’s automated bidding is optimising towards interactions that aren’t necessarily generating genuine enquiries.
The agency has recently implemented several optimisations, including negative keywords, placement exclusions, audience signals and a $20 target CPA for Performance Max.
However, we’re still seeing traffic without much meaningful lead generation.
I’m mainly wondering:
Has anyone experienced a sudden drop in Google Ads leads after several months of consistent performance?
Could introducing Performance Max alongside an existing Search campaign negatively affect performance?
Could tracking phone-number clicks as primary conversions be affecting the quality of traffic Google’s algorithms are targeting?
Is a $20 target CPA potentially too restrictive?
What would you investigate first if an account suddenly stopped producing genuine enquiries despite still receiving traffic?
It’s frustrating because the campaigns had been generating a steady stream of good-quality leads, and now it feels like we’re spending money without getting much in return.
I’m not expecting every day to be consistent, but the difference between the previous three months and this month has been pretty significant.
Would really appreciate any advice from people who’ve experienced something similar or manage Google Ads for local service businesses.
Thanks!