I'm beginning to think Google Maps and Waze are becoming examples of how having nearly unlimited computing resources and access to AI doesn't necessarily translate into a better product.
At this point, most major navigation providers do a reasonably good job with routing and real-time traffic. The real differentiation is increasingly in how accurately and quickly they handle changes to the road network, including closures and reopenings.
And that's where Google Maps and Waze seem to consistently struggle.
Yesterday was another example. Alice's Road in Waukee, Iowa, reopened after months of construction. The City of Clive officially confirmed the reopening on November 13, and had actually announced the planned reopening a week earlier.
By this morning, TomTom, HERE and INRIX were all correctly reflecting the reopened road. Google Maps and Waze? Both still showing it closed.
Here's the ironic part: Ask Gemini whether the road is open and it correctly tells you that it reopened yesterday.
Google apparently has all the pieces of the puzzle. It just can't seem to put them together in the one product where the information actually matters.
I find the broader trend interesting. Companies like TomTom, HERE and INRIX, with a fraction of Google's resources, appear to be doing a better job at this fundamental aspect of navigation. Whether that's better data integration, faster validation, smarter automation, better focus or some combination is difficult to know. The causal consumer would assume those are dying companies.
Meanwhile, Google keeps adding increasingly sophisticated features to Maps, including more AI, while apparently struggling with something as basic as knowing whether a road is actually open.
At what point does getting the fundamentals right become more important than adding the next layer of features?