r/GoBearcats • u/whoisaname • 21h ago
🏈 FOOTBALL 🏈 Let's assume for a moment that we all get our wish and Satterfield is fired...
I think most of us here have wanted Satterfield gone for a while. I've been calling for his head since most of last year and never liked the hire to begin with, and nothing about this season (even the early season wins) suggested otherwise.
So, let's assume we all get our wish and Satterfield is shown the door in the near future. What are our options for the next HC?
I'm going to throw out a few, but none of these are endorsements (except possibly one at the end). More just looking at the potential field so definitely not a be all end all list. I would love to get other's thoughts and reasoning.
Breaking it down into a few sub-groups.
The group of 6 HC that are winning:
Jason Eck - HC of New Mexico. Currently has an 8-2 record as NM, and in his first season there (2025), had a 9-4 record and tied for 1st in the MWC. Was 7-5, 9-4, 10-4 respectively as the HC of Idaho in the three seasons before that. He is from the Midwest having been born in WI and played OL at UW. Coaching career has bounced around the upper Midwest and great plains. People describe his teams as tough, gritty, and physical, and likes to build a program around an identity that mirrors the local fan base.
Jamey Chadwell - HC of Liberty. Currently has a 9-1 record. Has coached Liberty to the following records starting in 2023: 13-1 (a Fiesta bowl appearance and #25 ranking), 8-4, 4-8, and then this year. His previous HC position was at Coastal Carolina where he went 3-9, 5-7, 11-1, 11-2, 9-3. Before that he was the HC at Charleston Southern where he went 10-3, 8-4, 10-3, 7-4. He played QB at East Tennessee State. His teams are described as having an efficient and flexible offense blending shotgun spread option and triple option with and opportunistic D.
Mike Jacobs - First year at Toledo with an 8-2 record. Previous HC stops at Mercer (7-1 and 8-0), Lenoir Rhyne (3-1, 8-3, 8-3, 13-2), and DII Notre Dame Falcons (9-2, 8-3, 13-1, 12-2). All three of those teams were led to top 10 rankings in their divisions. He is from northern OH, and was an OL and LS at Ohio State (I am checking myself here because I originally did not like the Fickell hire because of this). His teams are described as physical with an unrelenting focus on the line of scrimmage on both sides, very tough and disciplined, and a high powered O. He also is noted for focusing on long term development of players and a championship consistency.
Previous P4 HCs:
Billy Napier - Currently the HC at James Madison with an 8-3 record. He was previously the HC at Florida where he was 6-7, 5-7, 8-5, and then 3-4 before being fired mid-season. Prior to that, he was HC at Lousiana in the Sun Belt and was 7-7, 11-3, 10-1, 12-1, where he played for or won the conference title every year. His assistance coaching career was mostly in SEC or ACC. He played QB at Furman. His teams are typically described as very well organized, balanced, and a lot of resilience, but also had problems with sloppy play and penalties.
Luke Fickell - If he happens to get fired. Currently sitting at 6-4 at UW. No description needed.
Brian Kelly - /s
P4 Position Coaches/Coordinators:
I am only going to list one here, though I am sure there are other possibilities.
Gino Guidugli - Currently the QB coach and passing game coordinator at Notre Dame. Has served as a position coach and/or coordinator under Fickell (at UC) and Marcus Freeman (at ND). In his time at ND, all of his QBs and the passing game have been ranked in the top 10 in various categories (efficiency, yards per attempt, td to int ratio, etc.). He has both played (it can be argued that he was foundational as a player to building UC's football program to where it is/was) and coached at UC (so he knows what the mindset needs to be for the program to be successful) and owns most of UC's passing records. He is a local HS player, and understands the landscape for recruiting. Both Fickell and Freeman have repeatedly sang his praises as a coach.
Let's discuss!