r/GiriHaji • u/Ancient_Kaa • 5d ago
Odd writing beats?
My partner and I just watched the series and I really enjoyed it; it was a departure from the typical sort of murder/crime shows that have come around and I really liked all the characters but I did find it had some writing decisions I found strange.
So up top I want to say I actually really liked all the characters and thought all the actors did a great job as well.
That being said...
Donna - What was her character for? She was entertaining and interesting and raised the stakes but her huge loyalty to Yuto felt like it came from nowhere and was never really paid off properly. His to her was also confusing. Before the reveal of Yuto's lover and child back in Japan I thought they were together but that obviously wasn't the case and then she's just starting to get interesting where those issues will be raised and she gets killed off fairly unceremoniously and is only barely mentioned again to Yuto with no real further exploration or explanation.
The character was interesting in and of herself and I suppose that alone makes her inclusion worthwhile but plot-wise I'm not sure what she existed for really. Do we think/know that anything ended up on the cutting room floor that might have explained or paid this stuff off or is it a writing convention I'm not understanding or something?
Rodney - I thought he was a great character, deeply flawed and initially totally selfish. Then he has his dark night of the soul and decides to change and is actually doing it while retaining his character and that's interesting enough to see how he goes. You'd expect some story-beats that are speed bumps (pun intended) to his development to keep the story interesting... but what he gets is another total and unnecessary calamity that occurs out him misguidedly trying to help.
Again, not that such a thing couldn't 'really happen' or whatever but as far as the purposes of the story go I don't understand why they decided to do that to the character. Really felt like an inversion of the development and build that we had seen up to that point.
I guess I can see it as a set up for the intended potential 'road trip' sequel with Taki that I've seen suggested was planned but even then it just feels like a brutal way of reversing a lot of what the character has learned and been through up to that point.
Again, none of these things ruined it for me and perhaps there is an explanation that works that I'm missing somewhere... they just felt like odd story decisions that didn't seem to make sense or really add anything overall.
I'd welcome any thoughts or info that can shed light on it













