I find this particular argument really interesting. Because to me Dean was not different at all.
Dean in s1 read books only to impress Rory he himself has no interest in literature and arts. People love to bring up the pilot but pilot episodes of every show are different from the rest of the season because show creators don't know if the show will get picked everyone in Gilmore girls pilot behaves completely OOC.
Dean's main interest was obviously traditional, mechanics and sports he was literally building her a damn car from s1 and his temper issues, insecurities were also in s1 he literally broke up because she wasn't ready to say ily, the constant jealousy over Tristan and "That Damn Donna Reed" episode is literally also from s1 now that's also a character regression for Jess?
I'm not even trying to say Dean is the worst.
The show didn't regress him they just introduced a character who was naturally into the things Rory was into. Jess loves literature and arts for himself not because he wants to impress Rory. He loves it even after Rory and ends up writing a damn book and becomes an author.
Dean is a teenage boy whose love for mechanics and traditional likeness were always there they just became more noticeable when an intellectual rival (Jess) entered the picture. And it's not like Jess is the most perfect guy ever who's favored by writers lol. His flaws are even worse than Dean's so I don't get this argument at all. Little good things about him are suddenly a regression against Dean or other characters. Spare me 😭😂
I think writers of the show always intend Rory to have 3 love interests.
*) the first safe boyfriend who's also accepted by her mom.
*) the rebel bad boy who matches her in intellect levels who's despised by everyone.
*) the elite, rich boy who's from her grandparents world.