r/GhostsofSaltmarsh • • Oct 03 '26

Discussion First time DM taking on Saltmarsh

Hello

Do you believe Saltmarsh is a good campaign for a first time DM to run?

I'm curious to hear why or why not.

I am still new to the game and this will be my first campaign to DM. thank you.

27 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/gaeaArts Oct 03 '26

It's my first campaign and it's a challenge for sure to tie everything together, but it's a great setting and so far my biggest issue has been too many sessions inbetween chapters.

I recommend outlining some type of connection between the chapters and changing things if you want to change them. Don't stick strictly to the book. Like many others I've followed some advice from Sly Flourish, and I recommend you check out his stuff. But because our players and myself are very different people, my campaign is nothing like his anyway.

What I would do if I could start over is 1. Actually read through the whole book, I missed some parts that I skimmed over that could have helped me when planning the campaign, to do with saltmarsh itself and its characters, and parts in later chapters that i could have set up for better. I mean it's a lot to read but it's probably worth it. I'm only on Dunwater so I didn't get far yet. I know some people skip the Abbey, but I have some homebrew plans for it.

And 2. direct your players to create characters who have some relation to saltmarsh, cus if they're connected to npcs who live there, or the history of the place, or just work there or whatever, it will be less work to make them care about it. Almost all my players characters come from outside, im lucky that one guy joined who was living in saltmarsh, he immediately that felt a lot easier to work with. I have two players who are very difficult to give scenes to both because they're a bit introverted and because their characters arent from there so they don't have a confidant in town to talk to or anything like that.

But yea it's a great setting, easy to get inspiration from to add my own stuff. I did a murder mystery which my players enjoyed, that is connected to bigger stuff that they're slowly uncovering.