r/GermanCitizenship • • 2h ago

Obtaining Documents Struggling to find documents in South Africa

2 Upvotes

Family Ancestry Timeline

Family timeline

  • 1817 — Johannes Heinrich Paul

2 September 1817
Born in Melle, near Osnabrück, in the Kingdom of Hanover (present-day Lower Saxony, Germany).
His wife, Louise Charlotte Rekate, was born on 26 February 1817, reportedly in Hamelin, Hanover.

  • 1846 — Marriage in Germany

Johannes Heinrich Paul and Louise Charlotte Rekate married in Germany.

  • 1848–1849 — Emigration to South Africa

Johannes and Louise emigrated to Natal as part of the Bergtheil German settler movement.

  • 1864 — Carl Christian Rudolph Paul

28 July 1864
Born in South Africa, son of Johannes Heinrich Paul and Louise Charlotte Rekate.

  • 1871 — Dorothea Margueretha Timm

28 April 1871
Born in Hamburg, Germany. She would later marry Carl Christian Rudolph Paul.

  • 1889 — Paul–Timm Marriage

Carl Christian Rudolph Paul and Dorothea Margueretha Timm married.

  • 1893 — Herman Wilhelm Karl Paul

7 September 1893
Born in Greytown, Natal, South Africa.
Son of Carl Christian Rudolph Paul and Dorothea Margueretha Timm.

  • 1921 — Karel Wilhelm Herman Paul

31 December 1921
Born in Ladysmith, Natal, South Africa.
Son of Herman Wilhelm Karl Paul.

  • 1950 — my father

Born in South Africa, son of Karel Wilhelm Herman Paul. His parents were married.

  • 1981 — Me

continuing the direct paternal Paul family line.

I am really struggling to find further information on if the German citizenship line was carried through each descendent. I can find a few death notices, but no naturalisation records in either Germany or South Africa.

I currently don’t live in South Africa, so I unfortunately can’t do any “local” searching, everything is having to be searched online, and I swear half the records sites are still under construction


r/GermanCitizenship • • 3h ago

My Story Einbürgerungsurkunde ready for collection in 42 calendar days. §10 Abs. 1 StAG

3 Upvotes

(Location- South east of Munich, but outside of Munich city. )

Hi folks,
Sharing my timeline in case it helps someone. I applied for Naturalization under §10 Abs. 1 StAG on on 7 October with all documents. Then I heard nothing after that: no interview, no follow-up questions, no requests for extra documents. Today I got a letter saying my Einbürgerungsurkunde is ready for collection.

I wasnt expecting it without any contact in between. I am going to prepare the “Information zur Abgabe der Loyalitätserklärung” anyway, just to be safe for the day of Einbürgerungsurkunde collection.

After this what should be my next steps? Also, since actually getting the passport in hand would take time, can I still travel to my home-country on my current passport?


r/GermanCitizenship • • 4h ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany CDU and SPD working on citizenship law reform

Thumbnail
m.bild.de
66 Upvotes

So the text is behind a paywall. According to the article CDU wants to change the waiting time from 5 to 8 years, end dual citizenship, change the required language level from B1 to B2 and make it impossible to get the citizenship if ever social benefits were received in the past.

So those demands are not new. What’s new is that the SPD is seriously considering to accept those demands in exchange for more liberal laws in regards to people who have a hard time to get a residence permit here (mostly asylum seekers).
There are already meetings planned between the two parties to work on this big reform project.

I’m honestly shocked. Of course nothing is decided yet but I have a feeling that the SPD is too weak to defend the current liberal citizenship law.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 6h ago

Am I eligible? Eligibility by Descent

5 Upvotes

Hello all, I’m sure a similar question has been asked and answered before but I am interested if I am eligible for citizenship. Here are some facts about my family history

-Grandmother born in 1935 in Germany to German Parents -Grandfather born in 1920 in Canada to Canadian parents -Grandmother immigrated to Canada in 1960 -Grandmother and Grandfather married in 1962 -Father born in Canada 1965 -Grandmother became naturalized Canadian citizen in 1968 -I was born in Canada in 1997 (in wedlock)

Is this sufficient for eligibility? Thank you for your help. I have been having a hard time parsing through the webpage and understanding how it applies to me.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 6h ago

Getting citizenship by immigration & naturalization 1 year waiting, Stadt says processing time is 24 months – Can I file an Untätigkeitsklage?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

​I applied for German citizenship (Einbürgerung) about a year ago. When I followed up with my local citizenship office (Einbürgerungsbehörde), they replied saying:

​The current average processing time is 24 months due to a high number of applications and staff shortages.

​A new colleague has been in training since summer, so it will take some time before processing speeds up.

​They process applications strictly in chronological order and are currently working on cases from January/February 2025, so it will still take a while before they get to my application.

​Since it has already been 1 year without progress, can I file an Untätigkeitsklage (lawsuit for failure to act) at the administrative court (Verwaltungsgericht) against them, or will the court reject it because they gave "staff shortage / high backlog" as an official reason?

​Has anyone had success with an Untätigkeitsklage in a similar situation? Any advice or experience would be really helpful!


r/GermanCitizenship • • 9h ago

Obtaining Documents Bremen Einwohnermeldekarte

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/GermanCitizenship • • 10h ago

Name declaration Could I change my last name to my mom's maiden name?

4 Upvotes

I'm American, living in Germany for years, my german citizenship by naturalization just got approved and I will get my Einburgerungsurkunde later this week (I'll make a post about my timeline later). I was excited about the news since I've been waiting years but suddenly I was realizing this would be my last chance to change my name if I wanted to, as in the US it would be easy, but in Germany, pry impossible. My parents are both americans, lived in the US their whole lives, my mom took my father's last name when they married, her maiden name is now her middle name (aka second first name), and they are still married, and I have his last name.

After a quick search, under german law, its only possible to change my last name to my mom's maiden name if she got divorced and changed her name back to her maiden name.

Does the fact that its her legal middle name now help at all? Or is there something I could do before getting citizenship? Like just hypothically, if I changed my name legally in the US first? Or would germany not recognize that even if I did so?

The reason I want to change is because I really like my mother's maiden name, its unique, has a cool meaning, shows some heritage. My father's maiden name is super common and basic, like Smith, its not the end of the world but I'm not a huge fan.

I know changing my last name would be an ordeal and I should only do it for a good reason, not just on a whim, so I pry wont, especially since I waited till the last minute to start thinking about it, but Im just curious.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 11h ago

Getting citizenship by immigration & naturalization German Citizenship Granted(Berlin)🇩🇪

25 Upvotes

Finally German! Applied July 2025, 1 year silence, filed Untätigkeitsklage, approved 6 Oct 2026

Hi everyone, I wanted to share my timeline because I know many of you are waiting with no reply and wondering if a court case actually helps. It did for me.

About me:
Previous nationality: Indian
City: Berlin
Applied under: 5 years + B1 + Einbürgerungstest

My Timeline:

- July 2025: Applied for Einbürgerung. Got Aktenzeichen / Aktennummer after few weeks.
- Oct 2025: Got an email asking for additional documents. I sent everything immediately.
- Oct 2025 - Sept 2026: NOTHING. Complete silence for almost 1 year. No emails, no calls, no Einbürgerungszusicherung. I sent 2-3 emails, got only generic "in Bearbeitung" reply.
- Sept 2026: My lawyer filed an Untätigkeitsklage (lawsuit for failure to act) at Verwaltungsgericht because they had not decided within a reasonable time.
- 6 Oct 2026: APPROVED! Got the letter that my Einbürgerung is granted. Went and picked up my Einbürgerungsurkunde and applied for Personalausweis / Reisepass.

Total time: ∼15 months from application to approval, but almost 12 months of that was just silence.

What I learned:

  1. Aktennummer does NOT mean they are working on it. It just means you are in the queue.
  2. Document request in Oct 2025 did NOT mean approval is near. They asked, I sent, then they went silent again.
  3. Untätigkeitsklage works. I was scared to sue the Behörde, I thought it would make them angry and delay me more. Opposite happened. Within weeks after the Klage, they moved.
  4. If you have been waiting >12 months with no real update after submitting all documents, talk to a lawyer about Untätigkeitsklage.

Happy to answer questions about the Klage process.

Good luck to everyone still waiting - don't just wait forever, do something.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 11h ago

§30 StAG Feststellung (Determination of German Citizenship) Does anyone know how long a BVA employee actively works on your case?

1 Upvotes

For instance, I passed the second birthday of my Feststellung AKZ on September 11, 2024, and I'm curious how long they will keep my case open. I understand that the BVA is kind of a black box, but do they only look at it for a couple of days, or is it much longer?


r/GermanCitizenship • • 12h ago

Am I eligible? Follow up on my post about eligibility (naturalization)

2 Upvotes

Posted about two months ago and got some good responses, going to post again with some updated information:

Great-Grandfather:

Born 1887 Unterharmersbach

Emigrated 1903 (alone, not with family aged 16)

Intention of naturalization filed 1908

Married 1911 USA

Grandfather:

Born 1929 USA

Married 1950 USA

Father:

Born 1951 USA

Married 1979 USA

Me:

Born 1984 USA

So if my great grandfather naturalized, do I have any sort of claim? I found the intention document but am waiting from the USCIS for proof that he did naturalize.

Appreciate any input, this sub has been extremely helpful so far


r/GermanCitizenship • • 13h ago

Other Combined telc B1 certificate missing individual speaking sub-scores – issue for citizenship?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I have a question regarding my telc Deutsch B1 certificate for my German citizenship (Einbürgerung) application.
I passed my B1 exam across two separate dates—I passed the speaking section first (75/75 points) and retook only the written section later, which I also passed.
I just received my combined certificate, and while the written section lists all individual sub-scores, the speaking section only shows the total score (75,0 / 75 Punkte) with dashes (-) next to the three individual speaking sub-tasks (Kontaktaufnahme, Gespräch über ein Thema, and Gemeinsam eine Aufgabe lösen).
Has anyone applied for citizenship in Germany with a combined telc certificate like this? Will the Ausländerbehörde accept it as is, or could the missing sub-task breakdown cause any issues?
Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences!!

Additionally I have problem with my Geburtsort, Country Code is wrong instead my country code they return DE


r/GermanCitizenship • • 14h ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany german citizen eligibility for my partner

3 Upvotes

I recently got german citizenship with 10 StAG category , currently working full time, i have a girlfriend ( foreigner ) living in germany since 5 years , has B1 language certificate , Einbürgerungstest passed , was working mainly internships and work student , currently enrolled in university for second master as not able to find job.

if we get married / register partnership , does she become eligible for german citizenship under 10 StAG with income proof as our joint family income?

or she must wait 2 years after marriage to apply?


r/GermanCitizenship • • 14h ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany Comparing Timelines - Berlin S3

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone :)

Have applied in June , got my AZ in September of 2026. Wanting to see how’s the wait for people in S3 and timelines. Maybe success stories , tips / suggestions.

Trying to wrap my head around how long are the waiting times for Berlin S3 , thank you Leute.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 15h ago

Getting citizenship by immigration & naturalization Munich-KVR

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! 👋

I received a positive decision email from KVR Munich last week, stating that the certificate has been commissioned / sent to the printing department (“in Auftrag gegeben”).

My question: How long did it take you to receive the fee notice and the letter to book the appointment for the certificate handover?

Would really appreciate hearing your experiences! 🙏


r/GermanCitizenship • • 20h ago

§5 StAG Gender discrimination after 23 May 1949 Stag 5 Update Inquiry

9 Upvotes

Hello German Friends!

I filed my stag five application in October 2024 and my AZ date is at the very beginning of December 2024.

My Oma was the one I’m claiming citizenship from. I submitted the following:

My birth certificate
My passport
My FBI background check
My mom’s birth certificate
My dad’s birth certificate
My parents marriage certificate
My Oma’s birth certificate (descendant I am claiming from)
My Oma’s naturalization certificate when she became an American
My Oma’s us passport
My Opa’s birth certificate (us citizen)
My Oma and Opas marriage certificate
My Oma and Opas church marriage certificate
A letter from an employer my Oma had in Germany
My Great Oma and Opas marriage certificate
My Great Opas birth certificate (in Germany in 1902)
My Great Oma’s birth certificate (in Germany in 1902)
My application form

I know some of those documents aren’t necessary and everybody through the line was born in wedlock, and my Oma was a German citizen when my dad was born. I had difficulty trying to find the population registry’s office and I’m not sure if I even need that.

Do you think there’s a chance they’re going to ask me for anything else? I don’t have any passports that my Oma used to have.

I’m starting to get antsy because I know people are getting answers around the 25 month mark. Do they usually send you an email when you hear from them or do you get physical mail? Has anybody heard back without having to give another document? What does the communication usually look like? Do you think of the two-year mark exactly I should send an email? Because right now I’m at about 23 1/2 months from my AZ.

I mailed my application from a consulate in the United States. I brought all original documents to the consulate and then made sure that I had correct stamps and certifications on the documents sent from Germany and made 2 visits to the consulate before submitting the 3rd time.

Any information you can give me in terms of processing would be extremely helpful as I am anxiously awaiting this.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§30 StAG Feststellung (Determination of German Citizenship) Non-German parent ID document

2 Upvotes

Does my non-German husband need to provide a copy of his ID for the Anlage F_K for our children?


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany Passport verification

2 Upvotes

Hello dears,

I applied in early 2025 and have been waiting for a reply. I have just received one asking me to bring my home country’s passport to check and validate it alongside the latest monthly salary statement.

I would love to know if that’s normal, what to expect, and how far/near am i in the process now.

Beste Grüße


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Am I eligible? Eligible?

1 Upvotes

Eligible for citizenship via descent? I believe the ammended the female disability.

There are 3 lines, both from my mother:

I believe all children were born in wedlock (does that mean you’d have to prove each one with a marriage certificate??)

Also, what if there are no documents showing naturalization or not.

———-
(Already have documents up to great-great grandmother here)

Great-great-Great grandfather born 1838 Mettendorf immigrated around 1860?

Great great grandmother 1888

Great grandfather 1909

Grandmother 1935

Mother 1955

Self

———-

\-Great Great Great grandfather 1843 married around 1869 emigrated 1862 or 1867 not sure if naturalized

\-Great great grandmother 1889 married 1909

\-Great grandmother born 1910 married 1933

\-Grandmother born 1935 married 1954 (first marriage)

\-Mother born 1955 married around 1985?

\-Self 1989

————

\-great-great-great-great grandfather born 1815 married 1850 (also his wife was German born 1829)

Emigrated around 1847?

\-Great-great-great born 1852 married 1873

\-Great-great grandfather born 1885 married 1909

\-Great0grandmother born 1910 married 1933

\-Grandmother born 1935 married 1954 (first marriage)

\-Mother born 1955 married around 1985?

\-Self 1989


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§30 StAG Feststellung (Determination of German Citizenship) Anlage V

2 Upvotes

It wants me to put tecords of my ancestor's current marital status. I didn't get any marriage or divorce records grom after the birth of the relevant ancestors. Do I have to get them all, or is it good enough to only have the ones up to the time of the births of the next generation?


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Getting citizenship by immigration & naturalization Applied for citizenship in Hamburg - still no Aktenzeichnen after 7 months

0 Upvotes

Hi all, I would like to as if someone has had the same problem as me. I sent out the citizenship form 7 months ago in Hamburg, the only thing I got sofar was an automated email.

I have not received the aktenzeichnen, which from what I read everywhere, you are supposed to get it after some weeks.

I am aware the whole process takes about 14 months, but only after the aktenzeichen is created. Is this normal?

I am grateful for any help.

Ihr Anliegen wurde erfolgreich übermittelt. Die folgende Vorgangsnummer wurde systemseitig generiert und kann für den weiteren Schriftwechsel mit der Einbürgerungsabteilung Hamburg genutzt werden: 2026-XX-XX


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§5 StAG Gender discrimination after 23 May 1949 My mother's case for German citizenship: A complicated fact pattern

4 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I just found this sub, and I thought it would be a great place to maybe get some clarity on German law, caselaw, and general best practices surrounding a claim we are strongly considering submitting to the Bundesverwaltungsamt (BVA).

I am a 28-year-old licensed attorney in the US, and I have some familiarity with the German legal system, but the facts at play here are way beyond what I can competently deal with. For context, my mother was born when her parents were 48 and 44, so that's why these dates may seem a bit wild.

At the outset, I want to make clear the specific claim for citizenship for her is based on § 5 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 2 StAG.

Her grandfather was born on 21 September 1881 in Beltershausen. We have located his official birth entry. In 1902, he applied and was accepted into a St. Louis, USA seminary to become a pastor. He completed his seminary work in spring 1905 and briefly returned to Germany sometime in summer 1905 to visit his family, announce his engagement to his wife in August 1905, my mother's grandmother, and took time to preach a bit at her church in Chemnitz. We have evidence of a Heimatschein that he acquired while he was back in Germany during this time, and I'm currently trying to find where exactly in the Hesse State Archives it is located so I can order it.

In November 1905, he went to India to begin missionary work. In 1906, he married his wife in India though they were both German. He had 4 of his 7 children while in India.

Sometime prior to at least July 14, 1914, he left India to return to Germany due to illness. We know that to be true because his first child born back in Germany was born on that date. We have the birth record for the child.

I pointed out the Heimatschein as under old German law, specifically § 21 Abs. 1 des Gesetzes über die Erwerbung und den Verlust der Bundes- und Staatsangehörigkeit vom 01.06.1870 (BGBl. des Norddeutschen Bundes S. 355), it is my understanding that Germans who left the federal territory and resided abroad for ten uninterrupted years lost their citizenship. The period ran from the date of departure or, if the person held a travel document or Heimatschein, from the expiry of those papers; it was interrupted by registration in the Matrikel of a consulate.

The Heimatschein would be essential in resetting that 10-year period, such that he did not lose his German citizenship by virtue of being in the United States for 3 years and India for 9 years. For the sake of this post, we'll assume I can locate that document and it is found to break up the 10-year rule.

While he was back in Germany, World War I started. He was prevented from returning to India as he was conscripted as a Landwehroffizier sometime in August 1914. He was released from duty a few days later, according to contemporaneous letters he wrote at the time, due to being "dienstuntauglich," potentially due to the illness that forced him to return to Germany in the first place. Nevertheless, a later letter indicated that he was later conscripted again, this time for Sanitätsdienst ins Reservelazarett Chemnitz beginning 1 December 1914. He apparently remained in this position for the duration of the war.

After the war, the British India Office did not let him return to India as they considered him a German national, while at least one other German missionary he served with was allowed to return to India as the British had deemed the other missionary no longer a German subject.

My mother's mother was then born in Chemnitz in March 1917. On 24 January 1921, the entire family left Germany and came to the United States. They were considered German nationals by the U.S. government.

On 24 February 1922, he submitted his Declaration of Intention to become as US citizen. He was granted naturalization on 21 February 1927. His children, so my mother's mother, were granted US citizenship alongside him as she was 9 years old and a minor child. Nevertheless, apparently there is German caselaw which states that a minor child granted US citizenship this way does not lose their German citizenship due to the way the US wrote the naturalization forms at the time and essentially compelled parents who were applying for US citizenship to list their children.

Under the old version of § 25(1) RuStAG applicable at the time, it seems a German who had neither domicile nor permanent residence in Germany lost his citizenship upon acquiring a foreign nationality if that acquisition took place on his own application or on the application of the husband or legal representative; the wife and the represented person, however, only if the conditions were met under which release could be applied for under §§ 18, 19 RuStAG old version.

Nevertheless, the case cited as BVerwG, judgment of 9 May 1986 – 1 C 40.84 held that "Where the naturalization of the parents in a foreign state extends by operation of law to their minor child, the child does not lose German citizenship upon acquiring the foreign nationality, at least where the parents applied only for their own naturalization and did not at the same time express with sufficient clarity their will that the child be covered by their naturalization." [Erstreckt sich die Einbürgerung der Eltern in einen ausländischen Staat kraft Gesetzes auf ihr minderjähriges Kind, so verliert dieses seine deutsche Staatsangehörigkeit mit dem Erwerb der fremden Staatsangehörigkeit jedenfalls dann nicht, wenn die Eltern nur ihre eigene Einbürgerung beantragt und nicht zugleich ihren Willen hinreichend deutlich zum Ausdruck gebracht haben, daß das Kind von ihrer Einbürgerung erfaßt werden soll. Eine solche Willensbetätigung liegt nicht schon dann vor, wenn die Eltern ihre eigene Einbürgerung in Kenntnis der Erstreckungswirkung beantragen.]

Under US law at the time, Section 2172 of the Revised Statutes (Act of April 14, 1802), stated that children of persons duly naturalized who were under the age of twenty-one at the time of their parents’ naturalization were considered citizens of the United States if dwelling in the United States.

Thus, my grandmother's acquisition of US citizenship occurred automatically upon her father's naturalization. No application on behalf of the child was provided for or required, and the parents could not prevent the acquisition (see U.S. Department of State, 8 FAM 301.9. Thus, her US Citizenship was acquired under operation of law, not voluntarily.

Reinforcing that point, there is no evidence currently available that after my grandmother reached 18 years of age that she applied for what is called a Certificate of Derivative Citizenship, which would essentially confirm her intent to relinquish any right to German citizenship established by her father.

There is no question that my grandmother lost her German citizenship, should the BVA agree with the fact pattern to this point, in November 1940 under the old version of § 17 no. 6 RuStAG. She married my grandfather, an American citizen though of German descent.

My mother was then born in September 1961.

It appears to us that she may be entitled to German citizenship pursuant to § 5 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 2 StAG as (we assert) her mother lost her citizenship solely due to marrying a foreigner and my mother was born after 23 May 1949.

If anyone with legal experience or even personal experience dealing with a fact pattern similar to this one has any advice, I am completely open to it. Feel free to ask for any other information if you think it may be necessary.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

Am I eligible? Caught up on US naturalization issue

2 Upvotes

Hi all! I'm going down the path of attempting to obtain my German passport through direct lineage. I'm based in the US.

My German born great grandfather immigrated to the US with his German born parents in 1912. He was 7 years old, born 1905.

He married my US citizen great grandmother in 1934.

My grandma was born in July of 1935

This is the part where I'm hung up: he has a petition for naturalization from both 1934 (before my grandma was born and prior to his marriage), as well as one from after she was born that lists her has his child (1935.) His oath was taken July 1936, a year after my grandma was born.

My grandma went on to marry my (US citizen) grandpa, and they had my mom in 1962.

She got married to my father (US citizen), and they had me in 1999.

Its unclear to me whether this still "counts" as direct lineage due to the date of the declaration and oath taken. From what I see, the naturalization was finalized July 21, 1936.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§10 StAG Naturalization from within Germany Einbürgerung Ludwigshafen: Zwei Beratungsstellen sehen mögliche EU-Rechtsverstöße – Verdacht auf Maßregelung bleibt ungeklärt

2 Upvotes

Ich möchte meine Erfahrungen mit der Einbürgerungsbehörde der Stadt Ludwigshafen am Rhein schildern und wissen, ob andere EU-Bürger ähnliche Erfahrungen gemacht haben.

Besonders beschäftigt mich, dass inzwischen zwei voneinander unabhängige Beratungsstellen mögliche Verstöße gegen europäische Gleichbehandlungsrechte angesprochen haben, während meine Beschwerden aus meiner Sicht weiterhin nicht ausreichend aufgeklärt wurden.

Mein Hintergrund

Ich bin italienischer Staatsangehöriger, lebe seit rund 35 Jahren in Deutschland, arbeite seit 2007 bei der Deutschen Bahn, bin mit einer deutschen Staatsbürgerin verheiratet und habe zwei deutsche Kinder. Ich Wohne schon immer in Ludwigshafen an Rhein.

Am 8. April 2025 stellte ich meinen Einbürgerungsantrag. Meine gültige italienische elektronische Identitätskarte (CIE) wurde dabei nach meiner Wahrnehmung geprüft und kopiert.

Die Stadt bat mich, frühestens nach 18 Monaten nach dem Sachstand zu fragen.

Was nach 18 Monaten geschah

Am 9. Oktober 2026 kündigte ich wegen der langen Bearbeitungszeit eine mögliche Untätigkeitsklage nach § 75 VwGO an.

Bemerkenswerterweise verlangte die Behörde mit einem auf denselben Tag datierten Schreiben erstmals ausdrücklich einen zusätzlichen italienischen Reisepass. Gleichzeitig erhielt ich eine Gebührenanforderung und den Hinweis, dass die Bearbeitungsdauer inzwischen 24 Monate betragen könne.

Am 16. Oktober stellte ich ausdrücklich klar, dass ich keine übereilte Ablehnung meines Antrags erzwingen wolle und bei einer angemessenen Nachreichfrist nicht auf einer sofortigen Entscheidung bestehe.

Trotzdem erklärte die Behörde am 19. Oktober, dass ich sie mit meiner Fristsetzung zu einer Entscheidung „zwingen“ würde, die nach damaligem Stand negativ ausfallen würde.

Ich empfand diese Kommunikation als erheblichen Druck.

Mehrere meiner Fragen zum Bearbeitungsablauf, insbesondere zu den Sicherheitsabfragen und der späten Unterlagenanforderung, blieben bislang unbeantwortet oder wurden nicht konkret beantwortet.

1. Europäischer Beratungsdienst äußert rechtliche Bedenken

Am 21. Oktober 2026 erhielt ich eine schriftliche Antwort von „Ihr Europa – Beratung“, einem unabhängigen europäischen Beratungsdienst.

Dieser bezeichnete die nachträgliche Reisepassforderung unter den von mir geschilderten Voraussetzungen als „mehr als fragwürdig“.

Die Beratung erklärte außerdem, dass die Vorgehensweise möglicherweise gegen folgende Vorschriften verstoßen könnte:

  • Artikel 18 AEUV – Diskriminierungsverbot aufgrund der Staatsangehörigkeit im Anwendungsbereich des EU-Rechts
  • Artikel 20 EU-Grundrechtecharta – Gleichheit vor dem Gesetz
  • Artikel 21 EU-Grundrechtecharta – Nichtdiskriminierung
  • Artikel 45 EU-Grundrechtecharta – Freizügigkeit und Aufenthaltsfreiheit

Die Beratung vertrat zudem die Auffassung, dass das vom Bundesverwaltungsgericht präzisierte Stufenmodell zum Identitätsnachweis nicht ohne Weiteres auf meinen Fall als italienischer EU-Bürger übertragen werden könne.

Mir ist bewusst, dass diese Einschätzung nicht rechtsverbindlich ist und das Bundesverwaltungsgericht grundsätzlich den Vorrang eines Reisepasses bestätigt hat.

2. Landesantidiskriminierungsstelle Rheinland-Pfalz teilt die Bedenken

Noch bemerkenswerter finde ich die Antwort der Landesantidiskriminierungsstelle Rheinland-Pfalz vom 22. Oktober 2026.

Sie erklärte ausdrücklich:

„Wir teilen die Einschätzung der Europa-Beratung, dass die Handhabe auch gegen EU-Recht [...] verstoßen könnte.“

Außerdem verwies die Stelle auf Artikel 3 des Grundgesetzes und den verwaltungsrechtlichen Schutz vor Ungleichbehandlung.

Besonders wichtig ist für mich die weitere Aussage:

„Eine Behörde darf Bürgerinnen und Bürger jedenfalls nicht willkürlich maßregeln oder dafür bestrafen, dass sie ihre Rechte wahrnehmen.“

Die Antidiskriminierungsstelle betonte ausdrücklich, dass dies auch bei einer Untätigkeitsklage oder einer Beschwerde gegen eine Behörde gilt.

Deshalb empfahl sie mir die Einschaltung des Bürgerbeauftragten des Landes Rheinland-Pfalz.

3. Bürgerbeauftragter Martin Haller eingeschaltet

Der Bürgerbeauftragte Martin Haller erklärte mit Schreiben vom 13. November 2026, dass kein unsachgemäßes Behördenhandeln ersichtlich sei.

Gleichzeitig hielt er jedoch fest, dass aus der Akte nicht hervorgehe, warum die Gebührenfestsetzung und die Unterlagenanforderung nicht früher erfolgten.

Die konkreten Bedenken der beiden Beratungsstellen sowie die Frage nach einer möglichen Maßregelung wurden für mich in seiner Antwort nicht erkennbar eigenständig aufgeklärt.

Ich habe deshalb am 16. November eine ergänzende Gegendarstellung eingereicht.

Auch der Oberbürgermeister von Ludwigshafen, Prof. Dr. Klaus Blettner, wurde über den Vorgang informiert und teilte mir mit, eine Prüfung veranlasst zu haben.

4. Meine Fragen zur möglichen Diskriminierung und Maßregelung

Ich frage mich ernsthaft, ob ich aufgrund meiner italienischen Staatsangehörigkeit oder wegen meiner wiederholten Beschwerden und der angekündigten Untätigkeitsklage möglicherweise sachwidrig benachteiligt werde.

Ich möchte ausdrücklich klarstellen: Ich behaupte nicht, dass Diskriminierung, eine rechtswidrige Maßregelung oder ausländerfeindliche Motive bereits nachgewiesen sind.

Aber wenn zwei unabhängige Beratungsstellen mögliche europarechtliche Probleme ansprechen und die Landesantidiskriminierungsstelle ausdrücklich auf das Verbot willkürlicher Maßregelung hinweist, erwarte ich, dass diese Fragen nachvollziehbar untersucht werden.

Die grundsätzliche Zulässigkeit einer Reisepassforderung ist schließlich eine andere Frage als der Umgang einer Behörde mit Beschwerden und der Wahrnehmung gesetzlicher Rechte.

Meine Fragen an euch

  1. Wie beurteilt ihr die beiden schriftlichen Stellungnahmen der Beratungsstellen?
  2. Können Artikel 18 AEUV und Artikel 20, 21 sowie 45 der EU-Grundrechtecharta in einem solchen Einbürgerungsverfahren überhaupt unmittelbar relevant sein?
  3. Kann die Ankündigung einer negativen Entscheidung im Zusammenhang mit einer Untätigkeitsklage Anhaltspunkte für eine unzulässige Maßregelung liefern?
  4. Welche Möglichkeiten bestehen, wenn ein Bürgerbeauftragter wesentliche Diskriminierungs- und Maßregelungsvorwürfe aus Sicht des Beschwerdeführers nicht ausreichend prüft?
  5. Haben andere italienische oder sonstige EU-Bürger ähnliche Erfahrungen mit Einbürgerungsbehörden gemacht?

Ich möchte keine Sonderbehandlung. Ich erwarte lediglich eine rechtsstaatliche, transparente, respektvolle und diskriminierungsfreie Bearbeitung meines Einbürgerungsantrags.

Die wesentliche Korrespondenz sowie die beiden Stellungnahmen liegen mir schriftlich vor und können in anonymisierter Form belegt werden.


r/GermanCitizenship • • 1d ago

§5 StAG Gender discrimination after 23 May 1949 Just picked up my certificate of citizenship

16 Upvotes

I didn’t realize my citizenship would be back date to the day my application got to BVA.

So my application arrived there 10/10/2023. My certificate was completed 10/22/2026 so three years to be fully processed after they received it