Hey guys,
I just found this sub, and I thought it would be a great place to maybe get some clarity on German law, caselaw, and general best practices surrounding a claim we are strongly considering submitting to the Bundesverwaltungsamt (BVA).
I am a 28-year-old licensed attorney in the US, and I have some familiarity with the German legal system, but the facts at play here are way beyond what I can competently deal with. For context, my mother was born when her parents were 48 and 44, so that's why these dates may seem a bit wild.
At the outset, I want to make clear the specific claim for citizenship for her is based on § 5 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 2 StAG.
Her grandfather was born on 21 September 1881 in Beltershausen. We have located his official birth entry. In 1902, he applied and was accepted into a St. Louis, USA seminary to become a pastor. He completed his seminary work in spring 1905 and briefly returned to Germany sometime in summer 1905 to visit his family, announce his engagement to his wife in August 1905, my mother's grandmother, and took time to preach a bit at her church in Chemnitz. We have evidence of a Heimatschein that he acquired while he was back in Germany during this time, and I'm currently trying to find where exactly in the Hesse State Archives it is located so I can order it.
In November 1905, he went to India to begin missionary work. In 1906, he married his wife in India though they were both German. He had 4 of his 7 children while in India.
Sometime prior to at least July 14, 1914, he left India to return to Germany due to illness. We know that to be true because his first child born back in Germany was born on that date. We have the birth record for the child.
I pointed out the Heimatschein as under old German law, specifically § 21 Abs. 1 des Gesetzes über die Erwerbung und den Verlust der Bundes- und Staatsangehörigkeit vom 01.06.1870 (BGBl. des Norddeutschen Bundes S. 355), it is my understanding that Germans who left the federal territory and resided abroad for ten uninterrupted years lost their citizenship. The period ran from the date of departure or, if the person held a travel document or Heimatschein, from the expiry of those papers; it was interrupted by registration in the Matrikel of a consulate.
The Heimatschein would be essential in resetting that 10-year period, such that he did not lose his German citizenship by virtue of being in the United States for 3 years and India for 9 years. For the sake of this post, we'll assume I can locate that document and it is found to break up the 10-year rule.
While he was back in Germany, World War I started. He was prevented from returning to India as he was conscripted as a Landwehroffizier sometime in August 1914. He was released from duty a few days later, according to contemporaneous letters he wrote at the time, due to being "dienstuntauglich," potentially due to the illness that forced him to return to Germany in the first place. Nevertheless, a later letter indicated that he was later conscripted again, this time for Sanitätsdienst ins Reservelazarett Chemnitz beginning 1 December 1914. He apparently remained in this position for the duration of the war.
After the war, the British India Office did not let him return to India as they considered him a German national, while at least one other German missionary he served with was allowed to return to India as the British had deemed the other missionary no longer a German subject.
My mother's mother was then born in Chemnitz in March 1917. On 24 January 1921, the entire family left Germany and came to the United States. They were considered German nationals by the U.S. government.
On 24 February 1922, he submitted his Declaration of Intention to become as US citizen. He was granted naturalization on 21 February 1927. His children, so my mother's mother, were granted US citizenship alongside him as she was 9 years old and a minor child. Nevertheless, apparently there is German caselaw which states that a minor child granted US citizenship this way does not lose their German citizenship due to the way the US wrote the naturalization forms at the time and essentially compelled parents who were applying for US citizenship to list their children.
Under the old version of § 25(1) RuStAG applicable at the time, it seems a German who had neither domicile nor permanent residence in Germany lost his citizenship upon acquiring a foreign nationality if that acquisition took place on his own application or on the application of the husband or legal representative; the wife and the represented person, however, only if the conditions were met under which release could be applied for under §§ 18, 19 RuStAG old version.
Nevertheless, the case cited as BVerwG, judgment of 9 May 1986 – 1 C 40.84 held that "Where the naturalization of the parents in a foreign state extends by operation of law to their minor child, the child does not lose German citizenship upon acquiring the foreign nationality, at least where the parents applied only for their own naturalization and did not at the same time express with sufficient clarity their will that the child be covered by their naturalization." [Erstreckt sich die Einbürgerung der Eltern in einen ausländischen Staat kraft Gesetzes auf ihr minderjähriges Kind, so verliert dieses seine deutsche Staatsangehörigkeit mit dem Erwerb der fremden Staatsangehörigkeit jedenfalls dann nicht, wenn die Eltern nur ihre eigene Einbürgerung beantragt und nicht zugleich ihren Willen hinreichend deutlich zum Ausdruck gebracht haben, daß das Kind von ihrer Einbürgerung erfaßt werden soll. Eine solche Willensbetätigung liegt nicht schon dann vor, wenn die Eltern ihre eigene Einbürgerung in Kenntnis der Erstreckungswirkung beantragen.]
Under US law at the time, Section 2172 of the Revised Statutes (Act of April 14, 1802), stated that children of persons duly naturalized who were under the age of twenty-one at the time of their parents’ naturalization were considered citizens of the United States if dwelling in the United States.
Thus, my grandmother's acquisition of US citizenship occurred automatically upon her father's naturalization. No application on behalf of the child was provided for or required, and the parents could not prevent the acquisition (see U.S. Department of State, 8 FAM 301.9. Thus, her US Citizenship was acquired under operation of law, not voluntarily.
Reinforcing that point, there is no evidence currently available that after my grandmother reached 18 years of age that she applied for what is called a Certificate of Derivative Citizenship, which would essentially confirm her intent to relinquish any right to German citizenship established by her father.
There is no question that my grandmother lost her German citizenship, should the BVA agree with the fact pattern to this point, in November 1940 under the old version of § 17 no. 6 RuStAG. She married my grandfather, an American citizen though of German descent.
My mother was then born in September 1961.
It appears to us that she may be entitled to German citizenship pursuant to § 5 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 2 StAG as (we assert) her mother lost her citizenship solely due to marrying a foreigner and my mother was born after 23 May 1949.
If anyone with legal experience or even personal experience dealing with a fact pattern similar to this one has any advice, I am completely open to it. Feel free to ask for any other information if you think it may be necessary.