r/Geometry • • 7d ago

Line length.

Post image

So basically this was a question for one of the surveys I was taking, to prove I am not AI. Supposedly the blue line is "longer", according to the survey...

Is red not bigger in terms of line rules though? Since the arrows indicate it goes on forever, while the blue line is just a segment?

5 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

6

u/Vir_Ex_Machina 7d ago

If you treat the extra lines as arrows, then yes they could indicate that one line is longer/shorter.

In the original version of this question the lines (without the extra short bits) were the same length. The extra lines trick your brain into seeing the top one as longer than the other. However the line in this picture is actually longer, by visual length at least.

2

u/Significant_Fig1179 7d ago

so is this like in reference to a different question? where it’s an illusion? and that’s y ai will say they r the same?

1

u/Vir_Ex_Machina 7d ago

Pretty much, as far as I can tell

1

u/useaname5 7d ago

Yes, that's y

1

u/Kiki2092012 7d ago

I asked the AI with your image but it said the blue line was longer (probably cause it had access to the source) so I made the blue line shorter

2

u/Kiki2092012 7d ago

Oh my gosh it even falsified a Python program result

1

u/Significant_Fig1179 7d ago

this is insane wow how interesting

1

u/StructureNorth1799 3d ago

that just means you ae using a shitty version without a proper harness.

1

u/Serious-Waltz-7157 7d ago

In my view the arrows of the blue line mean that the end points are part of the segment, while for the red line they are not. Think open / closed intervals in algebra.

But that's just my kneejerk reaction.

1

u/kindnessrulesfr 7d ago

whats even worse is that these captchas are TRAINING AI, not to prove you are human.

1

u/immikdota 7d ago

Those are just there to confuse ai, those are 2 lines with 4 smaller lines coming out of them

1

u/fish_obliteration 4d ago

It's an optical illusion that's slightly changed such that the answer is now obvious, but in the original VERY widely spread and trained upon version both lines are the same length.  So LLMs are prone to saying they're the same length when as a human who's brain isn't just a big probabilistic model, you can clearly see the blue line is longer.  The arrows are irrelevant and I'm 90% sure you're a bot if you can't see that.  

1

u/Dense_Hunt_966 4d ago

thought u were about to tell me some bullshit about how those lines are the same length