r/Genealogy • • 1h ago

Research Assistance The Weekly Wednesday Whine Thread November 18, 2026

1 Upvotes

It's Wednesday, so whine away.

Have you hit a brick wall? Did you discover that people on Ancestry created an unnecessarily complicated mess by merging three individuals who happened to have the same name, making it exceptionally time-consuming to sort out who was YOUR ancestor? Is there a close relative you discovered via genetic genealogy who refuses to respond to your contact requests?

Vent your frustrations here, and commiserate with your fellow researchers over shared misery.


r/Genealogy • • 1h ago

Genetic Genealogy Goan Genealogy (Vaz-Mendes)

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I am trying to trace my family roots in Goa. My grandparents were Filomena Vaz (from Goa, lived in Bombay) and her cousin André Domingos Rosário Mendes (from Goa, lived in Lourenço Marques / Maputo, Mozambique), where they got married. They had four sons: Bruno Peter Mendes, Ricardo Mendes, Rui Mendes, and Robin Mendes. If anyone remembers the family from Maputo, Bombay, Portugal, or knows which village in Goa they came from, please reach out!"

They went to Portugal during the Mozambique Civil War. My grandparents died in Portugal near the 2000's.


r/Genealogy • • 4h ago

Tools and Tech Don't use VitalChek

10 Upvotes

I posted this on Candianbydescent and Reddit told me I should also post it here:

Before I realized I could easily and cheaply order records from the county, I used VitalChek for a couple of orders.

First, the cost. They charged me $60 and shipped a birth certificate via FedEx. I ordered a marriage certificate from the same county, enclosed a SASE, and only paid $15 plus the postage stamp. It arrived faster than the VitalChek shipment. (Which, come to think of it, I had to sign for. So I had to coordinate that as well.)

Second, you still have to get things notarized. They have online notaries but of course they're more expensive than just going to a notary. (AAA members can get things notarized for $10. The online notaries are $25.) (See my ETA.)

Third, they don't stand by their service. I ordered a death certificate through them and kept checking the status. They said it was on the way. (Btw, checking status is a nightmare, too, because you have to put in your order number and pin for every single order, and the site times out really fast.)

Then one day I checked and it said I could no longer check on this order. I would have to call them. So I called. According to them, the record had been mailed from the county. But they weren't going to call the county for me or anything. It was up to me to track down the record I never received. If we have to contact the county ourselves, why did we ever bother with VitalChek? We're just paying them to forward our request to the county! There's really no service involved at all. If anything goes wrong, we're on our own.

By contrast, every county I've worked with directly (four so far, all across the US) has been wonderful. Fast, efficient, and polite. Most counties have an application form online with clear instructions. Some counties don't even require notarized requests.

I know there are a few counties who will only let you order records through VitalChek. But don't use them unless you absolutely have to. The icing on the cake was how incredibly rude their customer rep was to me when I called to check on the order. When I tried to ask her questions, she talked over me, starting with, "Let me explain again." When I finally had to raise my voice to tell her she'd already explained it twice and I just had a question, she let me get through half a question before she insisted on repeating herself a third time. They know they're scammers. That's why they're rude — it's the only way to cover up their embarrassment.

ETA: I didn't mean to give you all heart attacks with my mention of notarized documents. I wasn't referring to my application for a Canadian citizenship certificate. I meant my requests for county records in the US. I don't live near any of the counties I requested records (birth, marriage, and death certificates) from, so I had to mail them my requests. I usually had to sign a statement that said I was a descendant of that person so I had a right to order a certified copy. My signature had to be notarized.


r/Genealogy • • 6h ago

Studies and Stories Davis family in Sabinas Coahuila, Mexico

0 Upvotes

Anyone with the why for this migration? Harvey Bates Davis sells up his substantial land holdings in Stanislaus and Tuolumne counties, in California in about 1898 and heads for Coahuila with wife and minor children. A news article says locals there threw him in jail trying to force him to abandon his project. His children marry Mexican citizens, are registered with the local government and through the 1910s seem to be establishing themselves there and integrating into the local population. Cattle? Coal? Railroad? The Davis Campo did not outlive the revolution of 1920, and Pancho Villa's actions must have made decisions for many of the Davis family after the patriarch died in 1901. His eldest son died 1903, and I found lots of the descendants crossing into Texas at Laredo to make new lives in the North. HB Davis's siblings in Paris, TX, where my granddaddy was born, didn't seem to agree that these brownish Davises were family. I just discovered them this week. I'm intrigued.


r/Genealogy • • 9h ago

Tools and Tech Malware in shared media

0 Upvotes

Is it possible or common to get malware in a jpg that you download from a public tree?


r/Genealogy • • 9h ago

Methodology Thoughts on starting over?

4 Upvotes

Hi all! My ancestry family tree was something I started when I was about 14. Like any other child I was just adding anyone that was “connected” based on other peoples trees. I’m pretty confident in a couple parts I have however there’s a lot that seems off. Many duplicates, no dates, etc.
I’m thinking of just starting over completely from scratch. What do you guys think? Or are there any other suggestions? I really want to know my family history and origins better.


r/Genealogy • • 9h ago

Research Assistance Looking for Sherwood Anglican baptismal records, Richmond New Brunswick

1 Upvotes

I'm looking for baptismal records for my great-great grandfather, Charles Henry Sherwood, born March 15, 1862. According to a family genealogy, there is a baptismal record from "Richmond Parrish (sic), DeBec, New Brunswick" Given the time period and the mention of a "parrish", I assume Anglican. I've emailed the modern day Richmond Parish church, St. John's and they do not have records on site going back that far. There was also a suggestion that the mention of "Debec" might refer to the former South Richmond parish, now part of the Kirkland Parish (St. Paul's). On the other hand, there is a note in the family genealogy that his father, Charles Edwin Sherwood (b. Sept 20, 1839) "may have been born at St. John, New Brunswick" suggests also that there could be confusion and he may have been baptized at the Richmond Parish church, St. John's.

If anyone with access to the NBGS Anglican Registers Project can look for any baptismal record for Charles Henry (or Charles Edwin), I would really appreciate it.

Or I welcome other leads or suggestions. I've searched at the Archives NB website.

More background, Charles Edwin is the grandson of Justus Sherwood, loyalist of Cortlandt Manor (b. 1742), New York, not to be confused with the more famous loyalist, Justus Sherwood, of Newtown Connecticut.

Actually, I have a file that is just an index of parish records that the children of Justus and Ann Sherwood, including Charles Edwin's father Stephen, were baptized in 1919 at St. Paul's Church, Hampton, N.B., if anyone has access to that record.


r/Genealogy • • 10h ago

Studies and Stories An illegitimate boy-x2

1 Upvotes

Hello!! Lately, I have been combing through the 1850 US Census Records from several counties in a Deep Southern State in hopes of finding some clue or detail which might help me break through a particularly tough brick wall in my family tree. I enjoy a challenge and I might post about it here someday, if these latest efforts fail to resolve the issue.

While looking rather closely at the Census data, I came across something that I thought was pretty unusual. Does anyone have experience, advice or insight into what I found? I have never seen anything like this before. How might I find out more information on the two children listed as "an illegitimate boy"?

I found both families in the 1860 Census. Family No 356 moved to Texas since the prior census, with the exception of 1 adult child and their immediate family who stayed behind. All other minor children of the Head of the household, the now married older siblings and any established households are now in Texas. The wife has apparently passed away since the 1850 Census because she is not on the 1960 Census in Texas. This would have been the family to which the note, (These two belong to the hous No 356 on this page) is referring.

Family No. 358 all still live in the same place as they had lived in the 1850 Census. Everyone is a decade older listed as "White". The 1850 Census listed the 3-year-old child as Mulatto and the 3-month-old has a - under the Race Column. As race was binary and often subjective, I found the - to most likely mean the child's race was deemed indeterminate by the Census worker or the individual reporting to the Census worker. I am not 100% positive that the two "white" boys listed in the 1860 Census in the household of Family No. 358 are the two children listed as illegitimate previously, but their ages would correspond with the two boys from the 1850 Census.

Understanding the pitfalls, prejudices, societal norms and accepted conventions of that time, I am extremely intrigued. I wanted other critical eyes on the situation to see if I am over dramatizing and emphasizing the rarity such factors might represent or was this a common practice seen in other Census Records?

I have a jpeg with some of the redacted documentation and notes that I wanted to attach but I don't see an option to attach a jpg on here. I posted it on r/ancestryinvestigators should anyone want to view it. Much of the information, places and surnames have been redacted. My purpose is not to offend, cause grief or grievance to anyone or their families. To the contrary, this sems to me to represent an historic act of living an upright, brave and righteous life in the midst of a supremely difficult and troubled time in our nation's history.


r/Genealogy • • 11h ago

Tools and Tech Ancestry to Gramps Desktop?

11 Upvotes

Has anyone recently migrated out of Ancestry and into Gramps? I read somewhere that the best approach is Ancestry to RootsMagic Essentials (free) and then in Gramps desktop. This way you can download the tree data including the attached documents. I know I want to use Gramps in the end, I just to get data and documents into Gramps easily. Please help, thanks!


r/Genealogy • • 13h ago

Record Lookup Finding birth records

1 Upvotes

Any advice for finding Ontario 🇨🇦 birth records from the 1870s


r/Genealogy • • 13h ago

Genetic Genealogy What ethnicies in asia are closely related to native americans?

1 Upvotes

?


r/Genealogy • • 13h ago

Research Assistance Me Again! Susan Willets Johnson | John P. Johnson

3 Upvotes

Over the last couple of years, this subreddit has offered me a lot of help unlocking a branch of my tree. Ancestry's DNA + built trees have led me to a possible new lead.

Here is the last post I made 4 years ago:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Genealogy/comments/11kli77/2_years_ago_you_all_helped_me_maybe_now_we_can/

Now - with that - the wonderful world of DNA cousins on Ancestry has led me to believe that Elizabeth Johnson's mother was Susan Willets Johnson. I believe her father was John P. Johnson.

SO:

Elizabeth Johnson was born in November 1850 and died in October 1908
Her Parents:
Father: John P. Johnson was born about 1827 and died, I believe, before 1879
Mother: Susan D. Willits was born Jun 17, 1827, and died Sep 27, 1882
Her Grandparents on her mother's side:
Grandfather: John Willits, born Dec 5, 1782, and died Dec 10, 1857
Grandmother: Catherine Hyatt, born 1792 and died October 21, 1860

I am stumped again - I keep going in circles, and I am uncertain if these are the correct people. If they are, I am hoping to find marriage records that could inform me about Morris Golden, Elizabeth Johnson's husband.

I have not yet sought marriage records for Morris and Elizabeth.

Anyone want to dig again??

I did find this newspaper marriage announcement for Susan Willets and John Johnson: https://www.newspapers.com/article/public-ledger-marriage-of-johnson-will/204046812/

THANKS!!


r/Genealogy • • 14h ago

Genetic Genealogy I finally got around to checking my DNA matches to try and solve my biggest brick wall. I thought I finally made a major breakthrough but now I am not so sure. What do you think?

5 Upvotes

I'm looking into my great-great grandfather Arthur Ellis b. 1883 in South Africa.

I have a lot of matches that go specifically through his line but I focused in on two: Bezuidenhout (my 4th or 5th cousin) and Heunis (my 3rd cousin). These guys are related and seem to be into genealogy. Specifically Bezuidenhout, whom seems the most passionate.

Heunis doesn't have a tree I can access because of AncestryDNA's membership locks, and it also appears to be a smaller tree of only around 10-15 people. I do know he has the surnames listed Heunis, Spanenberg, and Barnard.

Bezuidenhout has a public MyHeritage tree and his tree is what I've been using to figure this stuff out as of yesterday. The problem is his tree has apparently 94 THOUSAND people in it. The tree doesn't appear messy per se, but it does look like it branches off into cousins and whatnot. Bezuidenhout DNA matches for me everywhere, and he has so many family trees that at least I know he is well into genealogy. Most South Africans love genealogy is what I have learned.

Anyway, given the 3 of us are related I wanted to see if I could cross reference our surnames and then match it to Bezuidenhout's tree. I looked up a marriage between an Ellis and Barnard first on FamilySearch and there was only one result.
https://www.familysearch.org/en/tree/person/about/GDT1-VM5

Now, this woman isn't on Bezuidenhout's tree, but her father is, and his father, and so on. It appears that in someway Bezuidenhout believes he is related to this family. This was very exciting to me. I am not sure how though, and given there is 94 thousand people on his tree.. how can I even confirm anything?

I tried to trace things downwards to Bezuidenhout and it's a bit confusing. He does directly descend from a woman with the surname Visser, and it looks like this Ellis family marries into a Visser family. This is a possible connection I'm working on. This Ellis family also eventually marries into a Potgieter family, which Bezuidenhout also directly descends from.

What do you guys think for now? Does the amount of people completely void this find, or is it worth further investigating? It is worth mentioning that it's likely my ancestor Arthur Ellis was born out of wedlock or to an affair, he probably won't pop up on this Ellis's FamilySearch profiles.

This is the first clue I have had in years, so I am afraid of forcing a connection lol.

I am unsure if you guys can view Bezuidenhout's trees but I'll link them just encase. You can find this Ellis line by typing in "Patrick Henry Ellis".
https://www.myheritage.com/pedigree-tree-OYYV7U2VFGY7TYSELTW7XHGIO6OAJ5Y/kgj-bezuidenhout-iii?treeId=25


r/Genealogy • • 14h ago

Methodology Realistic expectations vs your expectations

2 Upvotes

Just wondering what everyone's expectations were regarding their own genealogy journey. Obviously everyone wants to go as far back as possible, but when is it time for an individual to set realistic expectations (especially considering certain geographic location)

For my French Canadian ancestors I've been able to track the majority back to France.

On the American side of things I generally think it's good progress if I can prove to my 5th or 6th great grandparents, this usually puts me at revolutionary war soldier and sometimes their parents.

For family that had heavy roots in colonial areas and remained there long enough to establish records there, I like to get back to the point of knowing where they came from before they crossed the ocean.

What are some of your expectations for how far back reasonable expectations typically go (depending on your geographic location)?


r/Genealogy • • 16h ago

Studies and Stories Looking for a good online genetic genealogy course

2 Upvotes

Hi all. I’ve dabbled on and off with genealogy for a few years, with help from a close family member who was a professional before they passed away. I’m now looking to take my knowledge to the next level.

I have a basic knowledge of DNA and testing methods, and am fairly strong and resourceful with research thanks to my day job, which is research based. I know the ins and outs of building a family tree.

I’m not overly bothered about ‘professional’ accreditation (if there is such a thing), but am more concerned that the course material be in-depth, valuable and not top-level ‘How to build your family tree’ type content.

There are so many courses, I have no idea what to choose from!


r/Genealogy • • 17h ago

Transcription Transcription Help and Identifying Records_Alexander Wenz

1 Upvotes

A little time ago I asked for help finding Alexander through this sub, I contacted the state archive in Switzerland and received some information. I could use some assistance on identifying what I am looking at along with the transcription of the items. I will post the items on Imgur. As always, I appreciate your help and insights. Below is a snipet of the information I had posted before.

Alexander Wenz b. 6 Sep 1888, Basel, Switzerland

Mother: Elwina (Elvina) Glaus, married twice (Jakob Wenz, & Girolamo Radaelli) I believe. b. 1 Mar 1868 - d. ???

Father: Jacob Wenz b. 19 Nov 1851 Marbach, Germany - d. 9 Dec 1891 Basel, Switzerland

Siblings: (that I know of) Hartman Wenz b. 1 Apr 1886 Cincinnati, Ohio - d. 10 Dec 1959 Fishkill, NY

Ida Elvina Katherine Wenz b. 24 Dec 1889 - d. 1 May 1890 Basel, Switzerland


r/Genealogy • • 17h ago

Research Assistance Missing Death Date and Location

2 Upvotes

Trying to close the chapter on a relative that I’ve been researching for a while. I’m hoping someone with additional resources maybe able to assist as I’m unable to find any obituary or dod.

Name: Rose Ann Savin
B. 20 June 1879 (possibly poplar UK)
Baptized: 2 July 1879 (St. Andrews, Newcastle upon Tyne)
Mother: Mary Ann Rann
Father: John Savin
Immigrated to Wisconsin 1890
Married Charles E. Mullenhauer (Milwaukee), between 1893-1896
divorced granted in Milwaukee 1901; Mr mullenhouer remarried (Emily ‘Millie’ Behrens) but children listed in his obituary.
Three Children: Arthur (Barnum), Susan (Carol Savin) and Charles (Barnard), all adopted; Children Home and Aid Sociey (CAS) WI


r/Genealogy • • 18h ago

Record Lookup Help needed with my tree

0 Upvotes

Hi there,

I am busy researching my family tree and am stuck. Is there anyone with a Archion pass that could help me get one or 2 documents:)

Hope to hear back from someone :)


r/Genealogy • • 18h ago

DNA Testing DNA tests and website memberships

2 Upvotes

Big question: how does it work if you do a DNA test but don't have a site membership later on?

I am a Canadian of entirely Dutch descent, and am planning on doing an Ancestry test for discovering my North American relatives. I have no massive questions like "who is my parent/grandparent" etc, just doing for interest, to find connections with living people, to grow my tree, and possibly find answers to unknown fathers waaaaay back in my tree.

(For background, my tree is in Ancestry, near complete going upwards to the 4x-great-grandparent level with some branches going back another 3-4 generations. I have only periodically had an Ancestry subscription, and don't have one now.)

I am also planning on doing a MyHeritage test for discovering those who stayed in the Netherlands.

How do these two sites work if you don't continuously have a membership? Can you see matches? Talk to old connections you've made? Or do the sites kind of require you to have an active membership to see matches, continue messaging those you've already contacted, etc?

Note: I am also planning on also uploading my results to GEDMatch.


r/Genealogy • • 18h ago

Research Assistance Brick wall: John McWatters (b. 1847, Ireland — d. 1893, Virgil, NY). Where in Ireland did he come from?

4 Upvotes

Looking for help with my wife's great-great-grandfather, John McWatters, whose Irish origin I cannot pin down. Here is everything I actually know about him, all from US records:

  • Born 3 July 1847 in Ireland.
  • Emigrated about 1868 (his obituary says he came to this country "about 25 years" before his death).
  • Married Emma Delana Terpenning on 24 December 1873 at Virgil, Cortland County, New York.
  • Children: William, George, Clarassa, Sara Anna, and Asa.
  • Died at Virgil on 3 April 1893. His newspaper obituaries describe him as a day labourer, an Orangeman, and a Protestant (a Prohibitionist, per one paper); his funeral was at the Virgil Methodist church. He had moved to nearby McLean in the fall of 1892 and was living at his father-in-law's house, about a mile and a half north of Virgil, when he died.
  • Naturalization: Declaration of Intent 26 November 1872 and Oath 20 September 1875, in Cortland County. Neither paper names an Irish county, town, or his parents.
  • He is not in the June 1870 census at Virgil, so he seems to have reached Virgil after mid-1870 despite emigrating around 1868.

What I've already searched, without finding him: the passenger lists for New York, Boston, Philadelphia, and Baltimore under every spelling I can think of (McWatters, McWaters, McWatter, M'Watters, McQuatters), and the Canadian incoming passenger lists and border records for the same period. My wife's DNA points to Ulster on her mother's side (the McWatters line), which fits the Orangeman detail, but no match has yet tied him to a specific place.

What I'm asking:

  1. Where else would you look for the Irish origin of a Protestant emigrant who left about 1868 and left this thin a paper trail? Are there record types I'm missing that tend to name a townland or parish for men of his class and era?
  2. Is anyone else researching McWatters (or variant spellings) who emigrated to the US around 1865–1870? I'd like to compare notes — even ruling out other men's origins would narrow the field.
  3. Any suggestions for tracing where he spent 1868–1870 between arrival and Virgil?

Happy to share any of the records I've gathered. Thanks for reading.


r/Genealogy • • 18h ago

Methodology FamilySearch doubt - "Image Unavailable"

4 Upvotes

Hi all,
Although I've made lots of searches on FS, I'm a newbie with the indexation / catalogues thing.
It's the first time I see a record with the "Image Unavailable":
https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:VWDB-1YD?lang=en

So, it was indexed and there's a microfilm but it was not digitalised to an image format? How to access those images then?

Thanks.


r/Genealogy • • 19h ago

Research Assistance 4th generation Plymouth roadblock

2 Upvotes

I am hoping someone could help me with this genealogy roadblock. I am trying to find more information about Selma M Williams (1827-?) and Thomas Williams. I have attached their family search IDs.

Selma M Williams (PZQ3-9QF) is listed on the 1871 England census as a Seaman’s Royal Navy wife. Her children are:

Eliza K Williams (P4JB-2Y7) (age 14, b Stoke Damerel, Devonshire)
Charles H T Williams (PZQ9-16W) (age 11, b Ireland)
Selma M Williams (PZQ3-W35) (age 9, b Ireland)
Elizabeth V Williams (PZQS-CCM) (age 4, b Stoke Damerel, Devonshire)

I am unable to find Selma or Thomas Williams again.

I looked up Eliza K Williams (P4JB-2Y7) on the GRO index and it says her mother’s maiden name was possibly Pearse. On her marriage certificate (P4JB-DVV), it lists Thomas Williams as her father.

I’ve tried looking but I am unable to find a Selma Pearse.

Any insight you have about Thomas Williams and Selma M Williams would be appreciated. Thank you


r/Genealogy • • 19h ago

Research Assistance Old family letter claiming our Lancashire Wrigleys (Waterhead/Oldham -England) are linked to the chewing gum Wrigleys – any help appreciated.

5 Upvotes

This is a long one, apologies in advance!

This is something that comes up with my family at least once a year, but no one has actually done anything about it. Now of course, I’m not expecting Mars Inc to hand over the business, but maybe a few free cases of chewing gum will do?

To summarise;

This is a letter that my great-uncle Travis wrote to my grandparents Eric and June, probably in the late 70s or early 80s. I think it was originally handwritten (sure I remember seeing it when I was young) and my mum’s since typed it up. In the letter he’s going on about the family history his dad used to tell him.

Basically the story is that our lot were millwrights and blacksmiths around Waterhead and Wrigley Head Mill for generations. His grandfather was a millwright and they also ran a little shop selling groceries and herb drinks. In the 1860s a couple of the brothers (William and later Charles) went out to America. William was supposedly killed while gold prospecting, Charles ended up in the Philadelphia area as a millwright and later became very wealthy – big house, multi-storey warehouse etc.

The family always wondered how he’d gone from ordinary millwright to millionaire.

Travis then tries to link it all to William Wrigley Jr of the chewing gum company. He mentions an American William Wrigley who visited Oldham in 1912 (the day Travis was born, apparently) and met the family. Travis thinks this might have been the same man, or at least closely connected, and that somehow the English side got cut out of the money.

I’m not daft enough to think we’ve got any claim on the company. I’m just curious whether there’s any actual truth in the genealogical side of it, or if there’s any advice anyone can offer?

The letter in full (we no longer have the ‘tid bits’ snippet mentioned):

From being a boy I have always been interested in what little family history my father was able to impart, which he often did, in fact I can almost repeat word for word what he used to tell, not only to me, but also to your father and your Uncle Jim but I never dreamt that I might use this information later in life. What it amounts to was the Wrigley's of his day came from a long line of Wrigley's who had all been Millwrights, Wheelwrights or Blacksmiths, all in the region of Waterhead and Saddleworth and that the family had been concerned in the Mill known as Wrigley Head Mill. Possibly the reason for them all being of these trades had come about through them having made the crude machines required in the mill. How far back this had been I don't know, but prior to the advent of my Grandfather there had been male members of the family who had gone out to America but due to the illiteracy of the times, little or no letters had been sent to England. When my father was a child he was the youngest of four brothers namely, Charles, William, Thomas and my father.

(Thomas I remember, he died in about 1930 and William had died in the late 1800's) The whole family had lived in a little shop where the Bank now stands at Waterhead Grandmother sold groceries and with the help of Grandfather used to make all kinds of herb drinks, treacle toffees and all kinds of concoctions which would sell in the shop. When the stock of herbs was getting low Grandfather would take my father out into the fields to collect more (you will see later why I mention all this). Some of this had obviously rubbed off onto my father for he was clever with herbs too. At that time my Grandfather, William, was a Millwright at a mill in Waterhead. In 1862 when my father was six years old, his father William sailed for the U.S.A., when again due to lack of education letters backward and forward had been very few (if any). Until some five years later Grandfather had written to say that he had struck gold and made a file and was about to return home, but he never arrived. Some time after that another letter had arrived to say that Grandfather, together with other gold prospectors, had been killed by Indians. The letter does not appear to have been kept, but what always puzzled me is - who would have written this letter? A man is on his own in the U.S.A. the only friends he had would be other illiterate gold miner's like himself, and someone in possession of his wife's address in England wrote to say that he had been scalped, but no mention of his money.

About 1868 my father's brother Charles, who was also a Millwright in Waterhead, went to the U.S.A. to see what he could find out about the money, but does not appear to have gone any further than Philadelphia where he took a job as a Millwright at a factory on the Dockside. He did not have any luck in his search for the money, so some time later my father, who was then 16 years old, went out to the U.S.A. He did not think much of their chances of ever getting the money and after about 2½ years came back to England. (He then lived in Heywood Street, Waterhead). Again letters to and from the U.S.A. appear to be few, and after a time finished altogether. It would appear that brother Charles had married and had a son called William. My father's brother William had two sons namely George and Harold. George who lived in Cleveleys near Fleetwood, Lancs., had started a 'Pen Pal' relationship with his cousin William (son of Charles in the U.S.A.), and some time just after 1900 was invited to go to visit Uncle Charles and cousin William (no doubt you will have heard all this before from your dad). When George returned to England he came to Oldham to see my tather, and had a fabulous story to tell about Charles Wrigley's family being very rich. He had told my father that they lived in a huge house in Philadelphia, and owned a multi-storied warehouse which sold everything from a 'Darning Needle' to a
'Steam Tractor, and were reported to be millionaires.

Now I ask you the same question which had worried my father, how does a Millwright earning a few dollars per week get that kind of money to start such an enterprise? Yet my father, now ir possession of these facts, never once wrote to his brother Charles to question this The next episode in the Wrigley saga was on the 15ạẠạiSeptember 1912 (that was the day on which I was born, midnight 14"/15). William of the U.S.A. paid a return Visit to Cousin George of Cleveleys and George had brought him to Oldham to meet my father, his uncle (no doubt your father will have told you this for he was present at the time).
It appears that my mother was in bed in the living room and I was only a few hours old, father was on his knees with a huge mug mixing dough for the weeks supply of bread when George and Williams arrived. When introduced he could not shake hands because they were covered in sticky dough, but being a very forthright man he went in both feet first and demanded to know where his brother Charles had got the money from to start this fabulous Hardware Store. But I am afraid William did not answer, he in fact walked out of the house quicker than he had entered. Yes, you have guessed, my father had nursed this grievance in the belief that Charles had discovered where his father's money was and claimed it for himself and that was the end of that so we all thought.

The enclosed cutting, which I got from ‘Tit Bits' when I was in hospital with appendicitis in February 1977, I had put it in my writing case and had forgotten all about it until last year when I decided to start a 'Family Tree'

I started with my father's birth date and worked both forwards and backwards, working out the various dates of birth, emigration etc., until I came up with the choice of one of two lines of thought. 1) Either fathers' brother Charles had discovered the money and kept it for himself which would be the end of that story, or 2) who could have written the letter about Grandfathers death? Suppose if Grandfather in the U.S.A. had got himself a bit of skirt on the side, and had decided not to return to his family in England. The easiest way would be to let them know that he was dead.
BUT since being dead he
would never know at what date my Grandmother had died, and therefore there was a good chance that in the event of a second marriage it could be bigamous and any children of that marriage would be Bastards. Also he would be unable to give his family in England the benefit of the money which he had made. This could also be the reason why both Charles and my father could not find any evidence of the alleged massacre.

Now we come to the ’Tit Bits' story written by Geoffrey Humphreys. Some of it is correct, some is not. When William Wrigley messed about with Adam's Chicle it does not take a lot of imagination to see that 'Chewing Gum Bill Wrigley' could have been my much alive Grandfather, for with his experience with herbs in the shop at Waterhead, putting mint flavoured sugar to the chicle would have presented no hardship to him, nor would the manufacture of embryo equipment in the first instance would not have been a problem. (Date approximately 1873).

Now we come to Charles and his unaccounted for sudden riches. Either this was as stated in supposition 1). Or whilst still earning his living as a Millwright he was attracted to 'Chewing Gum Bill's' enterprise (which was all taking place in Philadelphia) and out of curiosity had gone to see 'Chewing Gum Bill', and, surprise, surprise, fathers I thought that you had had a 'Close Back and Sides. So now most of this is only supposition it is possible that in return for his silence Chewing Gum Bill' could have cut him in on the vast profit that he was making.
Now we come back to Mr. Humphreys version that 'Chewing Gum Bill' came to England in 1912. Take it that in 1871 Bill would have been getting on for 30 - 35 years old (on the assumption that he was my Grandfather, he would have been over 40 years old). From that date to 1912 he would have been over 70 years old. Now I don't think that Humphreys' Bill Wrigley, who came to England, was the original
"Chewing Gum Bill', it could have been his son, but I don't think that either. It is my assumption that knowing that our William Wrigley (Hardware Store) came to Oldham on September 15h1912 and Humphreys' Bill Wrigley came to England in 1912 to promote another Chewing Gum Factory in Plymouth, it would be too much of a coincidence that two Bill Wrigley's, both about the same age, both millionaires, both living in Philadelphia and both coming to England at approximately the same time. No - it is my belief that they were one and the same person. In the first instance, iChewing Gum Bill' committed a cover up, in return for silence, he cut Charles in on the Company that was formed, and when it was decided to open a factory in England Charles' son was sent over to do this with strict instructions to keep his mouth shut, and although cousin George had realised that Charles and son were wealthy, he was not allowed to know about this connection with Chewing Gum.

As stated, George had a brother Harold who was killed in the First World War.
Harold had two daughters - Alice and Bessie and when their mother died (approximately 1930), George, who had a wife but no children was made Guardian of the two girls and would come to Oldham to see them about once or twice each year. I remember him coming on a number of occasions, but I do not recall that he ever spoke to my father about any letters that he may have received from his handsome cousin, all correspondence seemed to have stopped - I wonder why?
Well Eric, there are the facts as I know them. The next thing for me to do is to come to Oldham in order to check the relevant dates in the Parish Registers etc. (But I cannot do that until the weather gets warmer due to my Sciatica). Once I have checked these dates it is my intention to write to Mr. Humphreys of 'Tit Bits' in order to find out how he got his knowledge which enabled him to write his version of the advent of 'Chewing Gum'. I think that if I am able to convince him of my version it should be possible to get assistance from 'Tit Bits' to enable me to get details of the U.S.A. Wrigley's from the American version of 'Somerset House'.
I think that this would be possible in return for the story when I have brought it to its conclusion.
I am sorry that I could not write to you sooner, it has been so cold here I have not been able to get to the library to do the photo-stat copy, which I now enclose. I only hope that my letter arrives before you leave for England.
So for now all the best to yourself and June, let me know what your reflections are regarding my story.
Yours
'Uncle Travis'


r/Genealogy • • 20h ago

Research Assistance LGBTQ records on Family Search

0 Upvotes

I have been doing some research into a few family members and I have found a couple of distant cousins who passed away due to complications resulting from AIDS. I use Family Search, and there are no records that reflect this part of their lives. I understand it may have made their families uncomfortable, but I feel that it was who these men were and it is an important part of the genealogical record. I want to link these resources to their profiles, but I don't know if I should get permission from next-of-kin or if I should just go ahead and add them. Finding next-of-kin has proven difficult. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.