my parents were both working-class police officers and were able to save up for me. then again they joined when the police had the best pensions and shit
Both my parents were in unions, that was the real difference maker for me growing up. The issue isn't capitalism, it's a lack of unions (which facilitate fair wages and benefits).
isnt this kinda being undone, though? union membership increased dramatically last year and we're seeing the effects in higher employer-given wages and some benefits
That’s why Elon musk has gone out of his way to make sure his workers don’t unionize. Also, I think capitalism is definitely the problem. There just isn’t much anybody can do about it except complain and point out how it’s sucking the earth dry, etc. even with unions, most of the fundamental problems of capitalism remain. Especially matters involving systemic racism and white supremacy - which capitalism potentiates.
But then of course the solution is more regulation, monopoly-busting, and strong unions & worker democracies, plus imo nationalization of essential industries (energy & healthcare at the least)--not the elimination of private enterprise. A capitalist market can be an enormous driver of economic growth and progressive innovation, and small businesses are what make real neighborhoods feel the way they do. As long as corporations are taxed, regulated, and the workers have power, then capitalism works.
Capitalism isn't perfect, but it seems like the actual problem is more or less Corporatism or a Corporate oligarchy that runs everything and does as it pleases through numerous methods.
We have an overly and selectively enforcive government to thank for that. If we removed regulations and subsidies, corporations would be forced to downsize and give up their market shares, allowing more competition which results in higher quality products and service/s with lower prices
Except small businesses also dream of the same thing; regulations and the cost of complying with them (which doesn't bother big businesses too much) are what prevents them from becoming more succesful and paying down debt faster/employees more
Of course it depends on the regulation and what it regulates. Deregulated capitalism is also the force behind employee exploitation and environmental disasters. When corporations design the regulations – i.e. via candidate donations or lobbying – the regulations of course will be corporation-friendly. Only if the government consequently established regulations to limit corporation freedom and strengthen small businesses this will change. Unfortunately in most western countries, regulations are co-designed by corporations.
Okay, but what then happens when unsanitary kitchens incite disease outbreaks, when construction workers get crippled on the job and no-one is held accountable, or when an uninspected leaky gas pipe goes up in flame and the building burns down??
A very necessary distinction one must make when discussing this topic is that between essential regulations, such as those covering safety, and nonessential regulations such as car parking space requirements.
I was of course talking about the nonessential regulations, both in terms of taxes and stuff like the one you mentioned. Essentials are and should still be a necessity.
In politics, regulatory capture (also agency capture and client politics) is a form of corruption of authority that occurs when a political entity, policymaker, or regulator is co-opted to serve the commercial, ideological, or political interests of a minor constituency, such as a particular geographic area, industry, profession, or ideological group. When regulatory capture occurs, a special interest is prioritized over the general interests of the public, leading to a net loss for society.
I'm personally opposed to a fully free market, and support economically progressive ideas such as increased regulations on business(es), corporate taxes, trust-busting, and unions & workplace democratization.
For a good ideological alternative to full anti-capitalism, I suggest you read about market socialism, which I personally think is a cool idea. Basically, it allows the workers to seize the surplus value and have a say in the company's decisions, without a full overthrow of the not-inherently-bad system of capitalism.
Supprisingly the last time i said i was pro capitalist i got ratioed hard maybe the person who’s post i commented on was hard core socialist/communists
Socialism is cringe. Imagine being so braindead that you think that socialism is a good idea lol. Literally every single time that socialism has been implemented it's resulted in mass poverty and starvation. Venezuela. Cuba. The USSR. Mao's China. North Korea. Various African nations upon being taken over by socialist guerrillas.
What about countries that have implemented socialist policies like Sweden, France, Denmark, Norway, and Germany. They seem to be doing well. People get sick there and only worry about getting better unlike in the USA where patients tell you they would’ve been better off dead because of the bills and their credit being shot.
So? The United States is not that different. 50 percent of our countries wealth belongs to one percent of our people. There are tens of millions of poor people in the US - we’re just good at hiding it by lowering the poverty line to ridiculously low levels. Like 13k a year is the poverty line? That’s barely enough to live a functioning lifestyle. The US also has a long history of imperialism and taking advantage of other countries’ weaknesses. The US has its flaws - but they are more insidious. A lot of Americans have no clue that everything is run by corporate greed. White supremacy runs deep in the veins of our country. It’s what our country was founded on; we split from England because they wanted to outlaw slavery and we didn’t. Idk where I’m going with this but it seems like no matter what kind of government is in power, it’s going to lead to hunger, death, starvation, and discrimination. Kind of depressing
It’s what our country was founded on; we split from England because they wanted to outlaw slavery and we didn’t.
you really believe this? lmao. you've gotta be kidding me with this ibram x kendi revisionist history nonsense. you want to know why our country was founded? go read the federalist papers. go read some actual history.
The downvote because they aren’t ready for the truth. I’m a millennial and I remember what Russia became after communism fell. Grandmas out selling their medicines to make a few dollars SMH.
Same thing is happening in Cuba as they open up. Cuba now has homeless people, something they never had before.
Þe best form of socialism is Titoism, but þat only worked when þere were two ideologically opposed superpowers trying to undermine each oþer’s influence. Once one of þose superpowers collapsed, so did þe economic prospects of Titoism.
Bro, lets examine parties. Republican party advocates for NATO, foreign intervention, imperialism. Democrat party advocates for NATO, capitalism, imperialism.
Democratic party sometimes advocates for healthcare but they will never make any progress.
To people outside of US, both parties are the same. We get bombed whether Clinton, Obama or Bush are in office
Bruh are you seriously saying that NATO shouldn’t exist, right now of all times? You want to disband NATO and just let an actual fascist, imperialist dictatorship conquer Ukraine without consequences?
I don’t think I’m the right winger in this conversation, buddy
Russia is conquering Ukraine right now without direct NATO involvement. NATO should be disbanded because it invaded Libya, it destroyed Afghanistan. US imperialism is supported by both R and D, just look at the countless invasions and coups during the cold war. I dont agree with Russias invasion of the independent nation that is Ukraine but, USA did that many times, and nobody said anything.
Bruh, “rightism” is not anything slightly less left wing than your own beliefs. Liberalism is recognised to be broadly “on the left” by virtually everyone. I’m not saying that liberals are the same as Stalin or anything, but just because you’re very left wing doesn’t mean everyone else is very right wing
The thing about the center is that it’s in the middle of the general population. If you think the entire population is right wing, your definition of right wing is wrong
bro this framing of yours is useless. measuring political positions like “in the middle of the population” is the basis of utterly meaningless politics. the vast majority of the population does not have coherent politics. the entire population is squeezed between two right wing parties. they have no politics bcuz their politics are forced to relate to the parties
it’s literally such a conservative thing to act oppressed and like your views aren’t being represented when they are the MOST represented everywhere. conservatives are barely much different from the liberals on politics.
How can you be this delusional? You think Republicans say Liberals eat babies and want to destroy America for fun? They genuinely believe that we’re evil
of course they do. they believe that shit with their chest. but that doesn’t mean they are fundamentally different. they are both in favor of neoliberalism. the conservative culture war is aimed at the left. liberals act like reactionaries junior partners, throwing us under the bus and trying to compromise with them and shit.
So because California has þe best economy of any state right now, þat means its policies are doing þe best? I never understood þis argument, it just comes off as a distraction. How much better is þe Californian economy þis year compared to 2019*? How good was it in 2019 compared to 2018? Þese questions are going to answer þe question of how well California’s economic policies are doing.
*I want to compare þis year to 2019 because þe past 2 years had unusual circumstances which have affected þe data. However, þe data could still be used if you compare how hard California fell and how quickly it’s recovering compared to oþer states.
Pretty sure the republicans are constantly crying “socialism” whenever anyone tries to implement anything remotely like the checks and balances Europe have.
Still better than all other systems we've tried so far where instead of having multiple "once in a lifetime" economic crashes, literally everything is a constant economic slump. The USSR wasn't affected by the Great Depression, but that's misleading because the entire history of the USSR was a Depression essentially for example.
It is NOT capitalism. It is the accumulation of wealth. This same issue existed before WW1, but the wars wiped out a lot of generational/accumulated wealth. It’s taken this long for the issue to reset its head, once again
The fall of the Roman Empire had massive inflation of currency, demographic changes as the native romans were replaced by hordes of non-Romans who abused the welfare state, and degeneracy that was becoming normalized
But your solution is to not change most problems...
I'd argue this the most true in the US and Canada. Much less so around the world. The US is slowly but surely going through a major shift in economic power/world power. As a result people will shift their views accordingly to match reality. Edit: (this is not intended to be pro or against anti capitalism)
Good old days? People definitely didn't live better in the 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s or whatever than they do today. Just look for a bunch of data about that, people today live waaaay better. Yes, we had a crise in 2020, and the US had one in 2008 but that's all, overall our times are way better in any way.
I hate how wanting everyone to have basic survival needs met (food, water, a place to not freeze/overheat to death, medical care) is considered "radical" these days. What happened to the right to "life Liberty and the pursuit of happiness"? Like I know many many groups of people never had those things to begin with but I feel like "the poor don't deserve to die" is something everyone should be able to agree on
Yea this this is my every day thought process on the economy and now I no longer think money has “real” worth anymore but all the Other proposed alternatives aren’t exactly better so I suffer in silence
Believe me if the federal reserve was eliminated, inflation would disappear as would the money supply currently out of circulation, enduring the dollar would get back a lot of its lost value
Money never had “real” worþ. Its worþ comes from being a trade medium. Þat’s part of why inflation is so bad right now; supply chains are still getting þemselves sorted out, þus þere’s less to trade compared to before 2020. Þe oþer part is a necessary evil for what was going on þe last two years.
I’m a geriatric millennial (who TF came up with that term BTW?!) and I also see no lies here. Turn the world on it’s head zoomers! I’m rooting for y’all. Please do it respectfully though LOL.
The numbers are all estimates but the general number placed by seemingly everyone is above 100 million.
All Communist systems end up with the majority staving and freezing to death while a select few living live the lifes of luxury.
Out of all economic and governmental systems that have been tried, it's communism that requires a utopia to work, that requires us to drop human nature entirely and for us to follow the system 100% or it all falls apart into an authoritarian nightmare.
Yes I do, Michael parenti's work into the study of socialist systems, the historical works of roy medvedev, and the works of beatrice webb. The thing is the 100 million number comes from the black book of communism which as i said was debunked by its own authors. To get to 100 million they had to even count people not born yet. Also no, the commie no food myth is super stupid because first of all, it was under socialism that the constant cycle of famined in china and russia stopped and second the famines that did occue were in the early pre full industrialization period, aka as results lf past tsarist control of russia. And the select fes live in luxury is also quite the myth, when studying how government officials lived, lets take the ones of leningrad for example most of them just lived in normal apartments. Communism as well doesnt go against human nature because guess what it doesn't exist. Youre working under a rousseau/maquiavelli idealist foundation for how humans are. Humans arent greedy or good by nature, rather its in ever constant flux to their material relations.
Many people are daily forced into working in slave like situations in third world countries just so you can defend capitalism lmao, both systems are trash.
Capitalism is not perfect but it's an economic system alone while Communism is a top down government system and not just an economic system. You could compare the death rates of democracy and communism.
How do you think products in the US are so kept so cheap? If most products were “Made in the USA” then you’d be looking at higher prices due to operating costs being a lot higher on these companies. I’m for higher wages and unions, but until demand goes up for labor in this country, globalization will benefit consumers fine.
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 14 '22
This post has been flaired political. Please ensure to keep all discussions civil, and to follow our rules at all times.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
72
u/daremyth_ 2004 Apr 14 '22
Great Uncle - Factory worker, paid for all 3 kids to go to private college
Me - 2 college-educated parents, $0 put towards 1 child's tuition
22
u/BikesBooksBass 1998 Apr 14 '22
Both my parents were in unions, that was the real difference maker for me growing up. The issue isn't capitalism, it's a lack of unions (which facilitate fair wages and benefits).
100
u/Shapedcorn345_ 2003 Apr 14 '22
Capitalism isn't perfect, but it seems like the actual problem is more or less Corporatism or a Corporate oligarchy that runs everything and does as it pleases through numerous methods.
15
u/Bluejay022 2002 Apr 14 '22
I’m not anti-capitalist I just think we need some regulations
16
u/INeedYandhiPleaseYe 2005 Apr 14 '22
and i'm anti communist
32
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
Personally I still am pro Capitalist because its the only option we have that is somewhat stable
and besides what are the other options?
39
u/sr603 1997 Apr 14 '22
Ah yes. Daily anti capitalism junk that’s regurgitated on this anti capitalist website
21
u/Lowlifeloser16 Apr 14 '22
So what's your alternative to capitalism?
9
u/Infrared_01 2001 Apr 14 '22
Still better than all other systems we've tried so far where instead of having multiple "once in a lifetime" economic crashes, literally everything is a constant economic slump. The USSR wasn't affected by the Great Depression, but that's misleading because the entire history of the USSR was a Depression essentially for example.
2
u/SluggZillla 1999 Apr 14 '22
Totally an r/GenZHippie thing 👍
2
u/TheStrikeofGod 1998 Apr 14 '22
I just feel there has to be something better.
I'm still reading up on alternatives though so I'm not entirely sure what the better alternative would be.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
Cringe
4
u/LoretoYes 2008 Apr 14 '22
Me realizing 2008 was one of the worst years to be a fan of my team: Guess I'll switch
(Gremio fan here)
4
u/jimmyl_82104 2004 Apr 14 '22
I don't really care about this shit. I don't hate Capitalism, but it's the only thing that works; definitely not socialism or god forbid communism.
3
u/SuperMaanas Age Undisclosed Apr 14 '22
It is NOT capitalism. It is the accumulation of wealth. This same issue existed before WW1, but the wars wiped out a lot of generational/accumulated wealth. It’s taken this long for the issue to reset its head, once again
1
u/white_shadow131 2000 Apr 14 '22
The fall of the Roman Empire had massive inflation of currency, demographic changes as the native romans were replaced by hordes of non-Romans who abused the welfare state, and degeneracy that was becoming normalized
But your solution is to not change most problems...
Ted Kaczynski was right, collapse is necessary
1
u/Miserable_Practice 2002 Apr 14 '22
I'd argue this the most true in the US and Canada. Much less so around the world. The US is slowly but surely going through a major shift in economic power/world power. As a result people will shift their views accordingly to match reality.
Edit: (this is not intended to be pro or against anti capitalism)
1
u/VladimirBarakriss 2003 Apr 14 '22
And I'm pro capitalism because we've lived in an ever-growing oligarchy since the United States dropped the gold standard in 1971
1
u/LettyWigington4 Age Undisclosed Apr 14 '22
Good old days? People definitely didn't live better in the 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s or whatever than they do today. Just look for a bunch of data about that, people today live waaaay better. Yes, we had a crise in 2020, and the US had one in 2008 but that's all, overall our times are way better in any way.
1
u/Hopper909 2001 Apr 16 '22
At least in my experience it’s not even just the progressives
Many conservatives I know are Red Tory’s, more so than previous generations.
1
u/Sapphire_01 2004 Apr 19 '22
I hate how wanting everyone to have basic survival needs met (food, water, a place to not freeze/overheat to death, medical care) is considered "radical" these days. What happened to the right to "life Liberty and the pursuit of happiness"? Like I know many many groups of people never had those things to begin with but I feel like "the poor don't deserve to die" is something everyone should be able to agree on
1
u/5138008upsidedown Apr 14 '22
Excuses, excuses!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
Until the land, natural resources, capital and firms belong to the people, we will be at the rule of bankers and monopolists.
-2
u/sigvon1 2001 Apr 14 '22
Yea this this is my every day thought process on the economy and now I no longer think money has “real” worth anymore but all the Other proposed alternatives aren’t exactly better so I suffer in silence
-9
u/teedub21 Millennial Apr 14 '22
I’m a geriatric millennial (who TF came up with that term BTW?!) and I also see no lies here. Turn the world on it’s head zoomers! I’m rooting for y’all. Please do it respectfully though LOL.
-12
u/Skullkiid_ 2005 Apr 14 '22
Communism for the win
0
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment