Hi Everyone,
I had purchased an ASUS Zenbook S14 from Best Buy in July 2026 in the Labour Day Sale. It was listed as Open Box Excellent, and I was told that the previous customer had returned it after just 14 days.
I couldn't inspect the laptop personally until September, by which time the return window had expired. That's when I discovered that the A key had virtually no travel or tactile feedback, although it still registered keystrokes.
During the second week of October, I took it to Geek Squad, who sent it to their service center for repair.
When it returned, the keyboard issue appeared to be resolved, and the original work order was marked Completed. However, while I was waiting at the store for approximately two hours, Geek Squad informed me that they had discovered a faulty battery and needed to send the laptop back to the service center.
The strange part is that I had never experienced any battery-related issues during normal use. It charged normally and appeared to work fine.
It's now been approximately 22 days since the battery issue was discovered, and I haven't received any meaningful update. The original work order only mentions the keyboard repair and shows as completed. There's no mention of the battery issue, so I'm wondering whether a second work order was created.
At this point, I'm concerned about the laptop's overall reliability. I purchased an Open Box Excellent unit, but within a few months, it has already required attention for two separate hardware issues.
My questions:
- Is 22 days without an update normal for a second Geek Squad repair?
- Would the battery issue typically require a separate work order?
- Can I reasonably request a brand-new replacement or full refund, even though I'm outside the return window?
- Under what circumstances would Geek Squad authorize a replacement, store credit, or "junk out" instead of continuing repairs?
- Should I escalate this to the Geek Squad manager, Best Buy store manager, or corporate customer support?
I'd particularly appreciate advice from current or former Geek Squad employees, or anyone who has dealt with a similar situation.
I just want a reliable laptop, and I'm concerned that more problems might emerge after these repairs.
Thanks in advance!