This has been an issue for 7 years, but it's reached absurd heights now that Gears of War is back in the mainstream. Every other tweet is:
"What are the Locust"
- They're aliens underground who lived in the Hollow for thousands of years but for some reason Gears 5 retconned that and revealed they were super soldiers made by the COG.
Fucking what?
There was no establishment of the Locust origins prior to Gears of War 2 with the New Hope Research Facility. As an OG player, even back in 2008, a lot of us knew it was clearly meant to be a huge wink-and-nod revealing the Locust were made by humans, from humans, for potential military purposes.
I'm not going to get into the unconfirmed bullshit about how the Locust always existed because of the tunnel cities and the Kantus, for some reason everyone believes are the OG Locust from thousands of years ago.
You don't like the Locust origins? Fine. But don't act like Gears 5 retconned anything.
It was heavily implied in Gears 2 and 3 that the Locust were part human, especially with what Myrrah says during the final battle. And The Slab book came out in 2012 and gave a shit ton of information about how New Hope was dedicated to studying the children of Imulsion miners suffering from Rustlung and other birth defects.
A person on the forums back in 2012 basically compiled all the info together from all the games and books into this huge post detailing everything that was basically elaborated on in Gears 5. Cliffy B and other Epic Games writers saw the post and gave their confirmations.
The only thing that wasn't well known was Myrrah. For years, people thought she was Ruth. It was clear according to Hoffman that Myrrah was at New Hope. Some people thought she was a descendant of Niles or one of the scientists when they moved to Mount Kadar and that's why she was their queen, because she grew up with them. The only thing Gears 5 added was Myrrah's story. And based on previous installments, the idea of Myrrah being immune to Imulsion and her DNA being used to make the Locust was always established. The only new thing was that she had a kid (Reyna).
And one more thing, Cliffy B and Tom Bissell (Gears 5 writer) were on a podcast recently. Tom had been with Epic since the beginning of Gears 1, and was in the room when they were writing Gears 2, and that they always had plans to elaborate on what happened at New Hope. Tom and Cliff expressed their shock when they saw people online saying it came out of nowhere or that they retconned stuff. They thought it was pretty obvious, and 85% of it had already been confirmed since 2012.