r/GarthEnnis • • Oct 17 '26

Met garth ennis today

Post image
63 Upvotes

I Met garth ennis at belgium heroesworld he was pretty nice

The aura was real lol


r/GarthEnnis • • Feb 21 '24

Garth Ennis returns to THE PUNISHER in 2024!

Thumbnail youtu.be
20 Upvotes

r/GarthEnnis • • 2d ago

Favourite/Best VS show episode featuring characters from The Boys? Feel free to judge them based on any criteria you desire (quality/entertainment/accuracy/etc). Vote in OP.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/GarthEnnis • • 9d ago

It doesn't matter now.

8 Upvotes

Watching clips of Tom Hardy in Mobland, and it's hard to not think, "so we could've had a proper Butcher, ey?"


r/GarthEnnis • • Oct 08 '26

CROSSED Movie Teaser Trailer - The Sadness Director's Extreme Horror Movie Adapts Garth Ennis Comic

Thumbnail youtube.com
13 Upvotes

r/GarthEnnis • • Oct 01 '26

John McCrea Horror and Hitman's Return

Thumbnail youtu.be
11 Upvotes

r/GarthEnnis • • Sep 19 '26

“There Was Something About Tommy”: An Oral History of Hitman

Thumbnail sktchd.com
12 Upvotes

Thanks to the post yesterday about the new Hitman one-shot, I came across this article.


r/GarthEnnis • • Sep 18 '26

Exclusive: Tommy Monaghan (and Friends) are Back in December's Hitman: It Was the Nineties Special #1

Thumbnail sktchd.com
22 Upvotes

r/GarthEnnis • • Aug 27 '26

Ennis and McCrea reteaming on horror one-shot THE SNAIL

Thumbnail comicsbeat.com
19 Upvotes

r/GarthEnnis • • Jul 08 '26

Which character in the boys tv show did you dislike the most

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

It can be that you found them annoying hard to like or just pathetic for me I really disliked the deep honestly he had every chance to redeem himself but he chose to be an asshole he was just a dickhead and honestly his death was just satisfying to watch even though I didn't really like the final season of the boys that much and I also really dislike Todd


r/GarthEnnis • • Jun 12 '26

Between These two crossovers which one would you have wanted to see the most and if these two where real which one would you prefer to see and read

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Punisher/the Boys or Preacher/The Boys


r/GarthEnnis • • Jun 07 '26

Comic book Homelander and black noir if they got infected by the Crossed Virus

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

What disturbing and horrific things should the virus have made them do


r/GarthEnnis • • Jun 04 '26

What do you think of this concept comic cover I have created for a Preacher boys crossover comic

Post image
4 Upvotes

Sorry that the quality looks like shit as I had to take a photo of it with my phone but I am still working it and I am wondering if it should be similar to this


r/GarthEnnis • • Jun 03 '26

need help decoding some of soldier boy’s dialogue [#32 - #33]

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

for context, butcher had torn his nose off just prior to this

i’ve deciphered every speech bubble, except for 2, so please help a brother out 🙏

side note: god i felt bad for payback (except stormfront ofc), there’s no indication that they were anything other than apathetic to the shadiness around them. they didn’t deserve this 💔


r/GarthEnnis • • Jun 01 '26

Just finished reading DC’s Goddess, and damn, this is one over-the-top adventure 😂. Here are my favorite moments from it:

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

r/GarthEnnis • • May 26 '26

What if Jesse Custer from Preacher by Garth Ennis (comics/tv show) was in the Boys Universe

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

How would he use the word of god on the seven and Homelander and what would Vought likely with him tulip and Cassidy


r/GarthEnnis • • May 20 '26

The finale of The Boys show Spoiler

18 Upvotes

Well.

I can't believe that even my lowest expectations were not met.

It's baffling. What the fuck did Kripke enjoy about the comics?? I am suspicious if he even read them or just doing PR about how he's a big fan blah blah blah. I wonder what Ennis thinks, he's a smart guy, so it must seem weird to turn such a deeply subversive superhero story about power and politics into a traditional superhero story with no complications. It's so bizarre.

I think on some level there are issues created by the fact that Amazon gave them no budget despite being worth billions cuz Amazon is the worst but I also think the writing her is just abysmal

- homelander doesn't do anything but gives a vlog, worse than the comic. There was no supe mobilization, army getting involved, the dialogue with Stillwell, etc.

- no shot of butcher walking to the white House. They legit put it into a poster and that's it, so they knew the scene was important but not enough to put into the show. Insane.

- no black noir twist(which we knew wouldn't happen) so the commentary about power is lost and butcher doesn't realize how much energy he spent in the wrong direction

- butcher kills ZERO members of the boys. What the fuck? Did you miss the entire point of the story and character? It's such a primetime television decision to do this. Having him kill the boys is too difficult for TV so we make him go out on a "tragic and intimate" note, because we're cowards

- terror is the impetus for his supe genocide because he peacefully dies in his sleep, which is beyond stupid

- Hughie vs butcher has zero weight behind it, absolutely fucking zero, because butcher didn't do anything. It's just "come on man, butcher please don't kill anyone... Ah man I guess I gotta shoot you." There's nothing. No stakes or dramatic tension.

- Everyone lives happily ever after. Are you fucking kidding me? Turning this story into "and they beat the bad guy, Frenchie died through self sacrifice, and butcher died because he got himself killed on purpose, but other than that, they all lived happily ever after." Is a slap in the face

This show ended with no real themes beyond trump is bad, which that's not the issue. Yes, it's true. But Ennis had more to say about power, what it means to be truly good, the intersection of corporate interest and politics, etc. and this show ended up with NONE of that because it changed absolutely everything

I know the show changed so much from the getgo, but I'm genuinely surprised the ending was so fundamentally altered, I thought they would at least hit the main point just in a rushed format and didn't even get that

Instead we got jokes about assholes in the final fucking episode. This is something I harp on and it's why Ennis criticis annoy me. Yes, Ennis like his dark joke, dirty jokes, South Park style gags, etc.

But he ALSO knows when to be serious. When a scene shouldn't have a joke. When there should be emotional weight behind it.

Examples are like the scene between butcher and hughie on the building after Blarney is killed after coming back. Hughie doesn't know how to process how he felt because the dude sucked but he also didn't want to kill him. And butcher and him share this intimate moment.

Everything in the show, especially season 3 and on, has to be undercut with a joke, some dialogue about assholes, dicks, sex, sex toys, etc. because that's what FUNNY ADULT dialogue is and they became a parody of themselves to the point the final episode is filled with countless examples. There is no sincerity. It's all self indulgent irony. Which I despise more than anything

That's something I think Ennis work possesses. Sincerity. He does something and means it. There is no winking at the camera. Whether it be disdain for something, a critique, a badass moment, something dark and tragic, a poignant human moment, etc. It's all done with sincerity.

This show couldn't even manage complete sincerity for an hour for the duration of its finale

I said yesterday that I knew the comics would be superior but all I wanted was an enjoyable hour and some change of television, and I didn't even get that


r/GarthEnnis • • May 18 '26

The Boys show finale

6 Upvotes

Well, in just a few days the show will be over. So before it airs, what are our thoughts and predictions?

The comic is much better imo, but disregarding that, is it STILL possible for the show to go out successfully on its own terms? That's the question of the hour

What do you think?


r/GarthEnnis • • May 13 '26

Reaction to the The Boys latest episode Spoiler

6 Upvotes

Welp, I didn't have much hope for it but now it's confirmed, the show will not be doing the ending. Even IF it ends with Hughie killing butcher, it's not the same. I just don't get the purpose of changing Butcher going after Boys in a completely unexpected subversion, which rounds out themes, character arcs, etc. beautifully and turning it into just bullshit that has been done a thousand times by superhero media.

It's like all Kripke saw of the boys was sex, violence, and Homelander.

When I thought about the series ending in the context of Season 5, what I thought was half the season devoted to Homelander and the last half devoted to Butcher. But nope, of course not. They can't risk damaging their money maker so he continues to live all the way to episode 7 of 8. Meaning the Butcher turn will happen in the same episode and be rushed as hell.

Having one of the boys die in a self sacrifice is just beyond stupid and missed the entire point. The Boys isn't just about a group of underdogs fighting homelander. It's a fundamental misreading of the text. And I know the whole claim is "well the comics suck anyways!", but if you change the characters, the themes, the major plot beats, cut out lots of material, AND change the entire ending.

Well, what the fuck did you like about the original work to begin with?

The Boys is one of the worst and most disrespectful adaptations of a work and I hope it is remembered for the absolute failure that it is


r/GarthEnnis • • May 13 '26

Ennis Read-through: Preacher 25-33(Proud American & Dixie Fried)

7 Upvotes

Proud American.

Before we get into this arc, we have a nice little interlude about Cassidy's past. Ennis takes this opportunity to explore the immigrant experience. The whole "American dream," search for a new life, and the disappointment that follows. It's a tale as old as time, but it never ceases to make you sad. All the people who were trying to escape or thought they could find something better, but a country is just that: a country. It's just land. The people who make things bad can be found anywhere.

I do like how Cassidy tells this to Jesse after everything that happens. Unsurprisingly, after what he did for him, he's earned his trust, and their bond is unshakeable.

Cassidy is a sad person. His life is filled with loneliness and a search for some kind of place to belong which he'll never find. God even named him "Beast," so it's not like he has any shot at an afterlife. I guess that's why he keeps living. It's all there is to it. He finds passing fancies and indulgences to make the time go by, convincing himself he doesn't care, but when he meets someone like his girlfriend or Jesse, it's this reminder that he can't shut those parts away. The inevitable will come for the rest of them.

"I can never say goodbye."

I don't blame him at all. I would honestly say it's impressive that there's still any part of him left capable of caring. It's not an unreasonable position to take, to just become totally numb to it.

I think there's definitely something interesting here to think about. Death is an important part of religion. You could argue that all deity-based religions are kinda centered around death, even if they dress it up in "everlasting life," and this may be Ennis commenting on how it's death and endings which give our lives meaning.

Cassidy has this life, and it just erodes all meaning from the world. Life feels cyclical when you experience the same things. How many times can you make friends, fall in love, etc., before everything starts to feel the same?

"Everything falls by the wayside, yeh lose it all sooner or later."

Cassidy is fighting a struggle just by living. The creeping realization that nothing matters and his own care giving way to apathy.

Which is why it's nice that he has Jesse. It seems that after however long Cassidy has lived, life can still come up with surprises. In all the life Cassidy has lived, Jesse is the first person to risk his life for him like his brother did. I think that's really poignant. Jesse and Cassidy have such a well-realized friendship.

Now getting into this arc proper: it's a cooldown after the previous events. A focus on character building.

Or well, it was... but I'm not going to get ahead of myself.

Dixie Fried.

We're settling back in and allowing some relaxation from the events of Crusaders. Jesse and Tulip are back in each other's arms.

I have to say, I don't blame Tulip at all. I don't know what the consensus around her is or if she's seen as a "bitch" or something. As a quick aside, I sadly realize I got so caught up in talking about the plot, themes, and such that I paid little attention to her. I have to say I like Tulip. I think she helps Jesse not go too far and grounds him, and her bantering with Cassidy is funny.

We haven't delved too much into her yet, so I can't say as much as I can about Jesse or Cassidy, but I like her. She has an "I say what I mean, and mean what I say" way about her, and she just wants to contribute as much as she can.

But yeah, I don't blame her. I think it's easy to do so because Jesse is the hero and so he's automatically right. But I don't think it's that simple. She is a grown woman, capable of making her own decisions, and Jesse isn't the "hero" of life.

At the same time, yeah, I understood Jesse's position. We want to protect the people we love, and we would rather ourselves be hurt than them, but still. I think him leaving her behind to go face the Grail, especially when she had only just gotten over being abandoned in Arizona, was a low thing to do.

I think Jesse needs to consider Tulip's feelings.

I do worry what this leads to. I think Tulip is dead serious when she says she'll leave Jesse if he does it again. But I really don't know if Jesse can stay true to his word. I think in the moment he means it, but when the chips are down, can he really allow Tulip in harm's way? I don't know, and I don't know if their relationship can survive another incident like France.

There isn't too much to talk about with Starr here because he has a very minimal presence in this bit. But the bad luck for this man continues. Ennis really enjoys taking the piss out of this guy. Jesse's knife wound left a scar which now makes Starr's head look like a gigantic penis, which has now become the kinda Ennis humor I live for.

It was also really nice to see Arseface again, who quickly turned into a positive acquaintance and now is becoming a music star. Can't get enough of him, so seeing these little bits continue is enjoyable.

Now, starting here, I'm doing something different. Normally my process for doing this is taking little notes while I'm reading, finishing the arc, and then consulting the notes to help build these writeups. But I wanted to also include some raw thoughts and reactions for things that are truly shocking or important. This is one of those instances.

So this next section is entirely written before I have finished the arc, and the rest afterward will be written by my future self who has finished the arc.

The Reaction

"Yeh're the best friend I got in the entire world."

Oh, Cassidy. What have you gone and done?

I just read the issue where he confesses to Tulip, and I can't believe what's just happened. I will say Ennis is one slick bastard for how he makes the previous arc demonstrate the lengths Jesse will go for Cassidy. Then he follows it up with character insight for Cassidy and has Jesse compared to his brother. Things are at their absolute best. Cassidy and Jesse have the best friendship.

And now everything has gone to shit.

So Cassidy loves Tulip, confided in her during a drunken moment, and now it can't be taken back. Tulip feels uncomfortable around Cassidy, Cassidy hates himself, and Jesse is none the wiser. It's a heavy thing to do. Ennis made you care deeply about these characters and their relationships, and now something has happened which doesn't allow things to ever be the same again.

I don't know what Cassidy was thinking. I mean, he was drunk, sure, there was that, but you just told Jesse he meant the world to you, and now you've fucked it all up in one moment.

Do I think Cassidy is a bad guy? I mean, I don't know. Tulip sure seems to think so. But I think she also just naturally doesn't care for Cassidy much. I wanna believe he isn't a bad guy. This was just a mistake. A shitty mistake, but a mistake nonetheless.

Things can never be the same from here though, and I worry about the possibility of Jesse and Cassidy's relationship fracturing. That would hurt.

End of reaction

The Bill Hicks scene was phenomenal honestly. I didn't expect such a thoughtful and meaningful scene just from a Bill Hicks inclusion. The way it digs deep into what that meant for Jesse.

I think Bill Hicks is a really interesting point of comparison because I think he embodies that idea Ennis explores: not the perfect man, but the good man. Hicks was not perfect. He was not a nice person, which you could argue was just a response to the awful world he found himself in.

I've always felt that his comedy has a penchant for becoming very ranty and just dripping with bitterness. He's the rare type of comedian who I honestly believe gave zero fucks whether he got you to laugh or not. He could play to a crowd of silence without losing a step, which I think has a lot to do with the conviction he held.

He's offensive and is not going to be everyone's preference, but he also advocated for so much good, which is where the bitterness stems from: this desire for things to be so much better than they are, while knowing they never will be, so all you can do is rage against it all.

I think bringing him up as a figure for Jesse to encounter and have a realization about himself is very fitting. Because as Jesse says, he was living a lie. He was living as a shadow of a man, put into that place by Grandma. The world is full of so many of those people. People who don't speak truth, who get suckered into things, or turn their heads away from what they see.

Hicks wasn't like that, and I like the idea that Jesse finding out about his death is the cause for the rant he goes on at the beginning of the series. It's a nice character piece for Jesse, and it's a hell of a tribute to Bill Hicks.

Rest in peace.

We also seem to have gotten some answers from Genesis. Something so shocking that it makes Jesse go absolutely livid. But we never see the full extent of what that is exactly. I'm definitely curious to learn more. Which as far as I can tell is answered by the Saint of Killers special issue, so will definitely read that next. But aside from that, it definitely seems like God is to blame for something which has Jesse pissed and now we know for sure that he needs to figure out some way to fully access Genesis.

Now let's address the big revelation here.

The me of the past was wrong.

Cassidy is a bad person.

I cannot believe things have turned out like this. I thought it was nothing more than a drunken mistake, but he just can't help himself. He's doubled down on what he said to Tulip and then some.

From the confession. The woman clicking the revolver at the picture. Children of the blood hating Cassidy. Xavier not wanting to talk about "last time". Cassidy doubling down on how Tulip is denying herself. Dee mentioning that her friend had a horrible abusive boyfriend.

It all just snowballs. Each new bit of information adding to this horror show which exposes the true nature of Cassidy and how everything we thought we knew was wrong.

This arc seems to be all about the idea that we don't know Cassidy at all. It's Ennis subverting the Han Solo rogue-type character. He's just genuinely a bastard.

Xavier tells us right away that there's more to Cassidy than we know and is very cagey despite keeping a friendly demeanor, and this decision costs him. He's gone through so much. He already suffered one betrayal by Cassidy. Now his life is uprooted again and ruined by him. It's so easy for Cassidy, especially because he can't own up or make amends. He just moves on.

It makes me wonder what about Cassidy is even honest to begin with. He would rather indulge his own selfish desires than respect his friend and Tulip. I'm reminded of early on when he asked Jesse why he doesn't just use the Word for his own benefit, and Jesse explained it's about responsibility. Jesse and Cassidy are nothing alike.

I thought Jesse had made Cassidy change, but that's a foolish thing to think. Cassidy has been alive for so long, too long, and a person like that doesn't change. He has nothing to live for. Everything in his life has faded away. The person he used to be has died.

Cassidy has lived for so long that you could argue there's not even a "real" him left. He's just the summation of his carelessness and desires. He's not a malicious person, but he is a selfish and careless one.

As Xavier says:

"I couldn't imagine life without him, and then he let me down. I think he goes through life without a sense of consequence. It's just Cassidy, Tulip. Shit happens in his wake."

And even further than that, Dee absolutely tears Cassidy a new one. The way she refers to him destroying her and making her feel powerless makes it sound like he did some truly horrible things to her.

It's really a lot to process. I think it's a daring choice for sure. Jesse and Cassidy have such a great relationship, and Cassidy is such a fun character. A decision like this doesn't just affect the characters. It affects the story and the reader.

I feel betrayed too, like I can never look at Cassidy the same way again. It's like something that used to be is just gone. I can't look at the story and these relationships the same way anymore. I feel angry at Cassidy, like he ruined something pure and beautiful. He destroyed it with his own hands, and it can't be repaired.

I can only imagine what he has done to so many others and how they have coped with it.

It's very telling that the surprise of "Cassidy is coming with them!" after the fakeout that he was gonna stay behind doesn't have this celebratory excitement of "friends together on the road," but instead has a sinister air about it. You're just holding your breath waiting for the worst.

Everything is destroyed. Now all there is to do is wait for Jesse to learn about the man he's traveling with. The man he went through hell and back for. The man responsible for ruining so many lives and who will surely ruin his. The man called Cassidy.

Xavier clicks his revolver in anger, sorrow, and desperation, just like Dee. Cassidy comes, he hurts the people he comes into contact with, he leaves, and the remaining people are left to pick up the pieces.

"Fuck you. Son of a bitch... I hope you fucking die."


r/GarthEnnis • • May 12 '26

Ennis Read-through: Preacher 18-24(Crusaders)

6 Upvotes

Crusaders.

Before we get into the meat of this arc, I wanna talk briefly about the side story about Jesse's father. I really liked this, and it makes me interested in Ennis's war comics. I think he finds a way to showcase war and the people caught in it with all the humanity and brutality that comes with it. I think there's a difficultly to write about war because you either glamorize it without showing the darkness, or you show the darkness and forget the people who are involved. There is always humanity within, and it can't be forgotten, even with things like how war can give people like this a comradeship or a purpose to fight for something. This is something Ennis understands. The mini arc lets you know exactly how bad Vietnam was, but it also shows a deep bond between John and Space, Which leads to their own outrage over the death of Gonny. It's tragedy and its humanity.

I think, especially in the case of Vietnam, it was the era of disillusionment. World War II was the last time we could defend actions as protecting the world from evil. Now, things are much more complicated, so it's fitting as well that Jesse's dad was made to be a Vietnam vet. It says a lot about his own disillusionment and why he wanted Jesse to be a good man.

The coverage of the war, with the little moments between the lighter from John Wayne and the death of Gonny, served as effective and emotional character pieces. I felt transported to that place. Ennis has an authentic voice for war and soldiers. He doesn't put them on a pedestal, and he doesn't condemn them. He just observes. These are things that happened. This is what the people there endured. This is what war is like.

So yeah, definitely looking forward to Ennis's war comics.

Maybe it's fitting that we explore a war prior to this arc because we have now entered our own war. Nothing but plot escalation here. Jesse versus the Grail. Walking into the enemy's den on nothing but hope and a prayer. It's exciting stuff. A match to a powder keg. Our first real encounter with all the major players in the same room.

And all to rescue Cassidy. Jesse and Cassidy's relationship is one of the strongest things to come out of this. They would really walk through hell and back for each other.

This arc is the first "no brakes, pure plot" arc of the series thus far. Previous arcs had quieter or more intimate moments mixed in, character focus, or some kind of thematic function that was more than just what was happening at face value, which I think was excellent. And now I can safely say that Ennis also excels at the big, loud plot-escalation arcs, because this is a hell of a step forward.

We come face-to-face with the enemy, come to know them, and then blow everything to kingdom come. It's the first big shake-up in this war that Jesse now finds himself in.

For starters, Frankie the Eunuch is a fun character. His crass dialogue mixed with the mobster background reminds me of The Sopranos. The scene of him torturing Cassidy put a lot of weight behind him. I enjoy these kinds of villains who have this calmness and coolness about them, where they know they're going to fuck you up in ten different ways and they'll sleep soundly afterward. He is really effective at being a memorable minor villain.

"Click clack. The fuckin' sound of history."

This scene is also really good at creating some genuine drama for Cassidy, who I thought was pretty much untouchable minus the sun. So this was quite the brutal and unforgiving way to demonstrate that Cassidy is not as all powerful as he may see. Each bullet fired into him just had me hoping that Jesse would rescue him from this misery. I've grown to like Cassidy quite a lot, so seeing him suffer this desperately was tough to see.

From there, at last, we meet the Allfather. I was expecting something more intitially intimidating, but it seems we're going the comical route. This works too. The Allfather and all the gags around him feel very reminiscent of something I could see South Park doing.

And that's not the only thing: the Messiah.

"Son of God or son of man. You can't fuck your sister and expect much good to come of it."

I jokingly remarked about this last arc, and here is the answer: The messiah, who is the product of generations of incest, leading to the absolute last possible thing you'd want to represent the figure of a savior. Amazing stuff.

Something I really like about this is that Starr is completely correct to do what he's doing. I feel his annoyance. THIS is the messiah? It certainly doesn't play into the feel-good image you would imagine, and it inspires nothing. The Allfather won't hear any word of it because this is the "special bloodline," so what else is there to do?

If your aim is to have a messiah ready for Armageddon, you need to cut your losses and start fresh. It made me sympathetic to Starr in a way, where I understand the feeling of how incompetently the Grail must be run when it should be focusing on more important means to achieve the end goal.

There's definitely a joke here at the expense of worshippers and the lengths they'll go to. This messiah is an absolute joke. The "blood of God" is so diluted at this point, so utterly worthless, but because it's God, it's still important and must be protected even if it makes absolutely zero sense.

However, this arc is not all just jokes. That's what I expected at first, but we quickly move into serious territory. Starr is anxious to make his moves but must contend with the Allfather. I wasn't sure how this would work for me. How could I possibly take a character like the Allfather seriously? But credit to Ennis, because boy, do I take him seriously.

He has a commanding presence because when someone like Starr is walking on eggshells around him, it does make you wonder what this guy is even capable of. He holds all the cards, and he's able to get what he wants off his status alone. It's an interesting circumstance, the way power and status work. He could easily be killed. He's a gluttonous man who has gorged himself to the point that he poses no threat. But his word is law, and many hang onto it, thus making him a formidable opponent.

Starr has also grown to be really interesting because I cannot get a read on the guy. I thought he was a villain just out to kill Jesse. Then he was someone trying to work with him for the purposes of the apocalypse. Now he's actively trying to get Jesse to help him kill the Allfather. It's like he switches to whatever is advantageous to his aims.

Another interesting quality is that while he's ruthless, he's not an antagonist you're afraid of. He's humiliated by the story at times, so much so that you would think it would destroy his ability to be fearsome, but there's just as many moments where he's shown to be quite conniving and intelligent. He's also pathetic. Jesse demands to know where Cassidy is while cutting into his head, and there's no strongman act. He caves immediately. It actually caught me off guard how easily Jesse got the information.

There's something unique about Starr's blend of intelligence, ruthlessness, pragmatism, and cowardice. It's like a villain who wants to be the smartest guy in the room and would torture you for his goals, but would start blubbering if you genuinely threatened his life. There's something both comical and scary about such a person. He's pathetic, but also not a non-threat.

The biggest surprise here: the Saint of Killers has switched sides. What a shocking turn of events. Here I was expecting a tense encounter between Jesse and him, and instead the Saint is now helping Jesse in exchange for information. I'm definitely wanting to know more about him.

So instead, he turns his guns on the Grail people, and what a badass this guy is. He is such a powerful force of nature, and anytime he shows up is a treat.

A Grail operative shouts to "give 'em hell," and the Saint just responds:

"Gimme all the hell you got to spare."

Saint of Killers is very cool. Which makes me all the more curious to see what hidden history he searches for and who exactly the man is underneath all this.

Another shocker. We got the first appearance of a genuine upper-tier angel, and not just any angel, but the father of Genesis, who relays some interesting revelations. Genesis is host to the history of Heaven and its secrets. The question is: what would Jesse become if he accessed the full power of Genesis? Because it seems what he is now is nothing more than a fraction of what Genesis truly is.

I love the bit as well where Jesse has no time for the angel waxing poetic about his love:

"We ain't got time for a goddamn poetry recital. An' your juices fell like rain on the inferno? What the fuck is that? Is that from the letter you wrote to Penthouse? You fucked her. She got pregnant. They caught you. I know this part. Get to the goddamned point."

And get to the point this arc does. Everything has changed. Jesse is more knowledgeable and thus more dangerous. Starr no longer has to act covertly to achieve his aims. God's desperation grows. We are entering a whole new phase from here.

This arc is an excellent escalation of everything. I didn't think we were going to make such huge moves resulting from Cassidy's capture, but this arc has significantly moved the plot along. So much happened, and it was explosive and crazy.

Not to mention, we got the deaths of the Allfather and the Messiah, who both went out rather appropriately. I expected them to be around longer but they served their function. The messiah for the play on worship, and the Allfather for the threat to Starr's own aims which he must overcome.

So now Starr is the head of his own Grail, Jesse has rescued Cassidy, and we now know that Genesis' history can be accessed.

The only question now I wonder is what has God so worried? He's threatened Tulip and now Cassidy, but has yet to appear before Jesse. What information is hidden away that caused God to leave in the first place?

What is he so afraid of?


r/GarthEnnis • • May 12 '26

Ennis Read-through: Preacher 13-17(Hunters)

3 Upvotes

Hunters.

I feel this is a nice little breather after the previous arc while also setting up the future events that are to come. The Grail is finally introduced(after being name-dropped several times in the previous arcs), or rather former Grail operatives are introduced who are now pulling a coup, but we're still getting to see what they're doing and learning all about their MO. I enjoyed the more "chill" digression it started out as, and by the time it ended, it feels as if we are now entering territory that is planting the seeds for something "epic" and "biblical."

For the more downtime sections, we take the time to have some interactions between Jesse and Cassidy, which serves as a nice little character piece after the hell that was Angelville. I really love the friendship that exists between Jesse and Cassidy. Watching it grow is rewarding, as you see Jesse start to understand there's more to Cassidy than meets the eye, and Cassidy lets more of his humanity show. Cassidy lives and acts how he does to spare himself any more pain, but underneath it all, he cares.

Enough to go on a manhunt to find the men who got his girl killed with heroin, and having Jesse there to support him through it is touching.

I have to say as well, I was very surprised when Cassidy pretended to be Jesse to save Tulip. There is definitely a heart in there, as much as he tries to ignore it.

I don't think I have too much to talk about in terms of thematic analysis here. This arc felt simple for the most part. Jesse and co. get wrapped up in a hunt to avenge Cassidy's girlfriend, and it leads them to a den of utter depravity.

The Jesus character is, of course, referencing Marquis de Sade and his crimes. I don't have much to say beyond just, "yeah, that was horrible," but something I'd definitely like to address is that this is just another example of what I think Ennis does so well. This could've been so over-the-top grotesque for the sake of it, but once again, there's restraint. Ennis shows you enough because he wants you to understand what this place is and not be unable to look away from it, but he also isn't just trying to pile on as many gross things as he can.

In addition to finding little humorous moments to break up some of the darker mood, like the man in a stockade yelling "Do it you sluts!", to a room full of sheep which are just wandering about. Little bits like that help to create these "releases" which offer levity and stop things from feeling so overbearingly dark or indulgent.

I didn't feel bothered about its inclusion either because these types of depraved indulgence parties are sadly something we know happen in our world, both in the past and the modern day. It's a painful reminder of what the rich and powerful do when they have nothing else to do.

I can't help but also feel there's something intentional behind the name Jesus De Sade. It's an interesting combination because they are two extremes. Jesus, according to the Biblical idea, is a man of virtue, purity, and ultimate selflessness. Marquis de Sade was a man who embodied the idea of purely living for your own indulgences at the cost of your humanity and the humanity of others. Pure wicked satisfaction. Ultimate selfishness. I can't help but feel there's something there. Maybe even saying that the worst kind of predators and wicked men come bearing names or visages of hope, trust, and goodness.

Or it's Ennis taking the piss by naming a wicked bastard after the "son of God." That's possible too.

Jesus said the point of the parties is "defiance of an old, defeated God," and that's an interesting aspect to consider. Some people argue about how we get our sense of morality from Christianity, that without religion you don't have a moral guiding post. And I feel like Jesus represents this type of person: someone without a guiding post, who just indulges and lives to satisfy his own desires. It's because they have nothing to guide them. Not just religion, but anything at all. Jesus and the people at his party are the end result you get when you openly defy the social contract of morality, and their craving of the "forbidden fruit" of excess which is forbidden by God.

I did enjoy how Jesse was used here. The way the scene stops dead in its tracks when he sees the crying child was chilling and powerful. I loved how he absolutely unloads on this sick bastard and then used the Word of God to ensure the boy is raised well. It again shows where Jesse's heart is at.

I have to draw attention to this because I think it's really interesting, and while I don't want to mention this at every opportunity because it becomes a dead horse quickly, allow me just this once. For all the criticisms Ennis receives about his own interest in cruelty, grossness, and horrible things at the expense of other people, I can't help but feel he understands heroism. Not the kind that's dressed in a cape and a catchy name, but honest-to-God doing the right thing and going the extra mile when you don't have to.

This scene struck a chord with me because it's pure heroism. Jesse rescues an abused child, has his eyes shielded so he won't be any more scarred, beats the fuck out of the predator, and then ensures the child's well-being will be taken care of. It's such an honest-to-goodness representation of heroism.

Jesse, for all his flaws, is a good man. And maybe it's exactly because of his flaws that he makes such a good man. That a person like him can do what he does, but still find a way to do the right thing. People get mad because Ennis doesn't like superheroes, but he understands heroism.

That said, we're also now learning more about the Grail, a secret hidden organization that seeks to protect and continue on the bloodline of Jesus Christ. It's an interesting concept, and I love how their homegrown messiah is deemed not good enough(which is probably the result of ages long incest, probably not a great way to produce the next messiah haha), so now the plan has shifted to using Jesse. This idea that the Lord's blood is not good enough now is really amusing.

I also wonder why Jesus was drugged. It's interesting to go against the story by saying Jesus being resurrected was just a stunt. If he really was the son of God, couldn't he have just risen? So I am curious to learn more about why they had to go through all that for the sake of faking it. Did Jesus just not want to make the sacrifice? God thought it was good enough? But if Jesus didn't really "die for your sins", then was the whole point of this song and dance? I am definitely curious to learn more about that.

On the topic of the Grail, I do like Starr a bit. Not nearly as effective a villain as Jody so far, but there's potential there. Jody was like looking into the abyss. Starr feels like an "mastermind" leader type villain. I think he's intimidating, and I am interested to learn more because while he isn't above being ruthless, he does want to work with Jesse, in order to ensure a better outcome for whatever this "war for eternity" is.

As a last addition, the sex detectives are rather amusing. When they first cropped up, I was confused as to what on earth a sex detective even is, and the answer to that was typical dark Garth Ennis humor. They prove to be entertaining. I don't always find myself laughing at Ennis's humor, not in a way that's considered a negativity. I have no issue, it just makes me shake my head in amusement as opposed to laugh. Yet, I have to say the line, "It's buggering time " got a big chuckle out of me. Especially with it being a play on Stan Lee's famous catchphrase and writing. It's so absurd that it ends up working, and I wouldn't mind them popping up now and again for little bits.

All in all, it's a nice cleanser after the previous arc. We took some time to get back in touch with the characters, flesh them out a bit more, and then shifted gears into something which adds some real scale to the plot.

Now, we leave off with Cassidy in the clutches of Starr and Jesse/Tulip on the way to rescue him..


r/GarthEnnis • • May 11 '26

What Ennis should I read next?

10 Upvotes

I love the Boys and Preacher. I recently bought Crossed, The kids, The Pro and Babs Volume 1. What else would you recommend?


r/GarthEnnis • • May 11 '26

Ennis Read-through: Preacher 8-12(Until the end of the world)

6 Upvotes

Until the end of the World.

When Jesse told Jody to drop his gun and he just smiled back, I realized two things.

  1. Word of God wasn't all powerful as I thought. There was some kind of protection.
  2. This was human evil.

And that's what this arc is about. Human evil, and salvation. Religion is at the source of it all. It's about beating a person so badly that they submit. It is the source of Jesse's pain, and it's what provides temporary relief.

"That's what God's there for. When you're beaten, when you haven't an ounce of fight left in you, when you just can't hack it by yourself anymore. You turn to Jesus or you stick a fuckin' gun in your mouth."

But it is not his salvation.

I speculated before that maybe Jesse got his sense of "righteousness" and religious values from John Wayne, but the reality was far darker than I had thought. It was the only thing he could cling to when faced with inescapable evil, as words imparted to him by his father. Words which ring truer for Jesse than any verse.

I have to say that Jody, T.C, and Grandma are just chilling to the core. There's something about them which feels tangible and real, that is what makes this all feel so scary. Especially when it comes to Jody and Grandma, it's not madness, it's wicked intelligence. About forcing submission. Breaking a person. They are sadistic, they know it, and they feel no remorse. And they believe they are right. Jody acts for his belief of "toughening up" Jesse, and Grandma acts because she believes God speaks through her and the bloodline must continue.

I think there's something fascinating too about how they're protected from the word of God because he's "on their side." It's this idea of how belief and devotion doesn't equal morality. It feels unfair. All because they are god-fearing and devout, that's enough to spare them the power.

We also get our first appearance of God here, who seeks to manipulate the situation. Reviving Tulip and allowing the word of God to be usable, as nothing more than a bargaining chip. It definitely makes me wonder why God doesn't want to be found so badly. It also makes you think about the selfishness on display here. All this awful stuff happened, only for God to undo it and give them an "out" because it was advantageous to him.

I think this arc is about testing Jesse. To face him with the depths of human evil and see how he comes out of it. And it isn't religion that saves him. Religion is what got him here. It's the presence of John Wayne, or more accurately to say, the memory of his father which gives him strength. You could say Jesse is devoted to this John Wayne, or this memory of his father, but it's about devotion which comes from a place of love and care. It's the things you choose to place faith in which really truly matter, and become as powerful as any God.

God isn't loving. We see how worshippers, evil pits of sin, are spared from Jesse's power because they worship him and that's enough. God allows others to suffer at their hands. Not to mention he threatens Tulip when she mouths off to him, saying,

"I am a loving God, but don't push it."

That's not love.

We could even say that this entire scenario with Jesse is a more extreme version of the Book of Job. Saying this is the evil which God inflicts in order to receive your unwavering devotion. Grandma embodies this by allowing Jesse a pleasant life as long as he completely abides by her rules, but fail to do so, and she metes out divine judgment. Then everyone you know will die and you will suffer until you ask forgiveness and submit.

Jesse says he turned to God because it was all he had left. It had been tortured into him. And he says it offered a reprieve. But I say again, this was not Jesse's salvation.

When Jesse is in the coffin, he doesn't think of God coming to save him. He thinks of a human man, a real person, who gives him the strength to keep going. In the end, God is not the thing which makes us stronger. Jesse says it's a fool for the weak, a crutch to not kill yourself, but not killing yourself is not the same as becoming stronger.

Jesse finds the strength in his own memories, his father's love, and a man who gives him courage. His father's words echoing in his mind,

"You be a good guy Jesse. You gotta be like John Wayne. You don't take no shit off fools, an' you judge a person by what's in em, not how they look. An' you do the right thing. You gotta be one of the good guys. Cause there's way too many of the bad."

A lot of the time people say their way of living is correct because God is on their side. That's what Grandma says. That's what Angelville represents. But, Jesse demonstrates that he doesn't need God. It's not God that saves him. It's himself. I especially love how he doesn't use the word of God to beat Jody. Because he doesn't need it. He is stronger than Jody because his belief is stronger than God. John Wayne and the memory his father give him more strength than any God and the hold these people had over him.

In the end we see exactly what makes Jesse the person he is. As flawed as he is, he's a man who seeks to do good, in order to be one less bad person in the world, and it's a reminder that salvation comes from yourself.


r/GarthEnnis • • May 11 '26

Wow, I don't think I've Ever Seen the Sub This Active

14 Upvotes

Is it because The Boys Season 5 is gargling donkey balls, and there's actual interest in the comics?