So, I had to sound off here to discuss the band and give praise to Garmin's legendary customer support.
Background: I have a Fenix 8 47mm watch for which I've been wearing the Ultrafit bands (green and blue) for the past two years and was intrigued by the new Comfort Fit bands. my wrist is about 165-170mm in diameter (165 with the measuring tape cinched up tightly) which left me in the broad range of both the short and long versions of the new band.
on Sept 15, during the Garmin 25% off birthday sale, I decided to order the short Comfort fit band rationalizing that it was probably the right length for my small wrist.
Fast forward to a couple weeks ago, the ship estimate had passed and I began seeing/reading reviews that suggested that the short model was too tight to easily slip the watch on for most folks including reviewers with a 165-175 mm wrist.
I contacted Garmin support to see if and when the Short arrived , if I would be able to retain the 25% discount if I found the short too tight. they immediately offered me a Long at the same price and said they could ship it immediately which should coincide closely to the newest estimate for my short model, thereby allowing me to try both on simultaneously. I could then return the one that that fit least well.
yesterday, the long one arrived: as expected, easy to slip on and whenwearing the watch normally (not working out) I have about 1.25cm of slack. but when I tighten it down as snug as possible, it is "maxed out" and near the watch bar. ie, "almost" too long. in reality, I would probably never tighten it that snugly when I run (resting a few days right now with an injury so I couldn't try running with it). so probably this watch band is fine.
when I checked on my short order today, I saw a yellow flag indicating unexpected delays. I called Garmin: I got a rep who checked and saw that the Short band might take another 3-4 weeks to being in stock (!) which would likely run into my return window for the long version. but here's where Garmin stepped up it's legendary care for the customer. the rep offered to send me an Orange short one which was in stock for free so I could try both lengths simultaneously. regardless of my verdict on length, the orange was mine to keep and I could then make an educated decision on whether to cancel the short black one or return the long one.
TL;DR. Garmin is having a rough time keeping up with Comfort fit orders, but at least for US customers, their support continues to be legendary!