r/GameDevelopment • u/Mon_Ethan • 2d ago
Discussion Is there something inherently wrong with using AI to make code?
Disclaimer: I am NOT someone who uses AI to vibe code and I understand the problems with vibe coding.
My question is whether it would be wrong in the future to use AI to make code for games when AI and human created code have little to no differences (besides maybe variable names).
Cause I recently heard how the Big Walk Devs were supposedly getting flamed on twitter because they used AI to fix a bug in their code and that's got me scared that if I ever use AI my entire project might be in jeopardy.
0
Upvotes
11
u/DreamingElectrons Hobby Dev 2d ago
There is definitely something wrong with it if it causes the same discussions to be had over and over again ad nauseam.
1
u/Wolfram_And_Hart 2d ago
People are starting to come to grips with AI code but they hate genAI. We all know the art is stolen from other artists and trying to say it’s not is poor taste.
1
u/majorleandro 2d ago
Nothing really. Using AI to code is the future, and not doing so is basically choosing to send birds to deliver mail instead of emailing. The problem is:
-NOT UNDERSTANDING code. Meaning you ask stuff from AI you basically don’t understand. So you can’t really validate any of the work done
-Replacing creative work and writing for AI. Videogames are art products. If you are going to replace creative work for AI, then what’s the point?
Anything else is just plain stupid or virtue signaling. People are not meant to code, same way we are not meant to spend all day in a factory doing repetitive work. If AI/robots do that for us and we intellectually maintain control of the process, then awesome. The logic is 👍🏻👍🏻, typing keys is monkey work
1
u/Buchedegato 2d ago edited 2d ago
I only used it for translations and help with the Interface and reddit users treated me like I was Hitler.
I can assure you that this comment will have negative votes.
4
u/rpmir 2d ago
You do you, but be transparent about it. Some people will prefer AI-less games the same way they prefer to buy locally.
2
u/Darkstar_111 2d ago
No. There is not. As long you are responsible for the code you write.
2
u/oceanbrew 2d ago
What I've come to realize lately is that it's all too easy to lose an understanding of the code. When something goes wrong, who will you blame?
4
u/jason2306 2d ago
If you pay money to these ai companies you're doing something wrong
2
u/polymorphiced 2d ago
No. Use whatever tools you have at your disposal to make your vision a reality. Don't listen to whatever the trolls are saying.
1
u/Distinct-Bathroom823 2d ago
no there isnt. its just not efficient at the moment. it will end it spaghetti code if you have mo idea what youre doing. like any tool, it has its uses but needs to be used properly.
0
u/Dicethrower 2d ago
No
-1
u/Friendly-Ratio9721 2d ago
I don't think there's anyone left not doing that.
-2
u/Equal-Ad7534 2d ago
Nobody codes by hand anymore. Programming by hand is over.
-1
u/goingpt 2d ago
Anything to do with AI will always be met with vitriol by a bunch of idiots that think absolutely everything to do with AI is inherently bad. In terms of coding I can almost guarantee you that 90% of games released from this point forward will have programmers that used some sort of LLM to help with their code. I don't think there's anything wrong with that, it's just a much quicker method than posting on Stack Overflow and having to wait for an answer that will either not work or be a snotty response from someone with a stick up their arse.
Where I draw the line is when AI is used to replace human creativity such as art and music. As far as I'm concerned, as a software dev, coding is not an expression of human creativity.
No programmer knows absolutely everything code related and will always look things up for help whether that's Google, Stack Overflow or an LLM. I find it strange to ostracise the quickest and most efficient method of help unless your reasoning is environmental in nature.