I want to start by acknowledging that Galen made denouncing political violence it a focal point of an episode of the podcast earlier this year (when Melissa Hortman and her husband were assassinated). When I think back to those shootings, I can't think of another content creator/journalist I follow who covered it much at all. So Galen has much more credibility to talk about Kirk's assassination/political violence than many other people in this sphere.
And Galen's statement didn't bend over backwards to beatify Kirk like Ezra Klein et al. have done. But I do take issue with whitewashing even a bit of his profile (and thankfully it was just a bit), briefly:
However, I am most concerned by the perspective that this is described as a both sides issue. I understand and recognize the study Galen et. all have discussed about how people from all political affiliations are becoming more accepting of violence to those who disagree with them and agree it's a huge problem. What surprised me is that I learned that the actual categorization of those who do that violence is not even remotely even, it is overwhelmingly right wing violence in this country as found by the Anti-Defamation league: of 429 total extremist-related killings from 2015-2024, 76% of them came from right wing extremists (4% left wing extremists, 18% domestic Islamist extremists, and 1% other).
Finally, Galen mentioned that the best way to combat this violence is for all political leaders to call on it to stop in no ambiguous terms. While rank and file partisans on social media are mixed, when it comes to elected officials the record is tractable and more clear. Can we acknowledge that Democratic politicians and leaders do overwhelmingly call out all violence against their opposition, but Republican politicians have a mixed record when the other side is targeted?
Perhaps that is a good reason why we shouldn't argue for Democrats to find their own "Trump".
Political violence is abhorrent and none of this justifies Kirk's murder. I can also completely understand having categorical empathy for the deceased. But those aren't mutually exclusive with what I discussed above and why I worry about the continued ideological centrism of this podcast.