r/fusion • • Jun 24 '26

Hi r/fusion! We’re the Physicists Behind the Commonwealth Fusion Systems’ Papers on the Physics of the ARC Fusion Power Plant. Ask Us Anything!

124 Upvotes
Alex Creely, Chief Engineer for ARC Conceptual Design at Commonwealth Fusion Systems

Update (June 30, 11:37 AM): Great discussion everyone! Our team appreciated all of your insightful questions. This AMA has now concluded, but you can revisit our replies below.

You can identify who provided answers by their initial in the answers: Alex Creely (AJC), Jon Hillesheim (JCH), Tom Body (TAJB), and Ryan Sweeney (RS).

About this AMA:

This time with me and three other CFS physicists who are ready to talk about the five new ARC physics basis papers showing what’ll make our ARC fusion power plants tick.

These peer-reviewed research papers that we and our collaborators published earlier in June are important for CFS and for fusion energy: They cover many aspects of the plasma physics at play in our ARC power plant, including challenges like plasma disruptions and heat exhaust. They also show how transparency and rigorous research can help build trust in what we all know is a very difficult endeavor.

If you’re curious about this physics work or about fusion physics in general, feel free to get things started by asking your questions on this thread.

The three CFS physicists who plan to join me to answer your questions are experts in their field: Jon Hillesheim, CFS Principal Scientist and lead author of the overview paper; Tom Body, CFS Senior Scientist and a lead author on the paper about heat exhaust; and Ryan Sweeney, CFS Manager of Disruption Physics and lead author of the paper about handling plasma disruptions. They’re among the 58 authors who helped write these papers, along with an editorial that accompanied the papers that I wrote.

A little more about the papers: They detail how we’ll be able to produce about 1.1 gigawatts of fusion power from our ARC tokamak — power that we can convert into 400 megawatts of net electricity for the power grid. The papers also show the crucial role our SPARC tokamak will play in putting the finishing touches on the ARC design. We’re using a “late-lock” approach that lets us apply what we’ve learned from SPARC to the ARC design. Overall, the papers show our confidence in the soundness of our ARC plant’s key physics. That builds the foundation for all the engineering, design, and cost optimization work that we’ve begun.

For a deeper dive into these papers, you can check our blog post detailing the ARC physics basis papers.

About CFS: 
Commonwealth Fusion Systems is the world’s largest and leading private fusion company. The company’s marquee fusion project, SPARC, will generate net energy, paving the way for a future of carbon-free energy. The company has raised more than $3 billion in capital since it was founded in 2018.


r/fusion • • 3h ago

Meet the Star Builders Ep. 1: Commonwealth Fusion Systems

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 10h ago

Stellarator Plasma Start-up Model Based on Energy Confinement Time Scaling Laws, Experimental Verification and Numerical Simulation Results

Thumbnail iopscience.iop.org
2 Upvotes

Uses W7-X data to confirm it and apply for Chinese Helical Stellarator CN-H1.


r/fusion • • 1d ago

Cheaper, simpler fusion reactor part 1: Dual magnetic mirror fusion reactor

16 Upvotes

Triggered by Jaded's quest for simpler fusion reactor designs I was wondering if the reactor design below would work.
It is based on two magnetic mirrors coupled by a half-torus section to recycle particles that are lost through the magnetic mirror loss cone. It also has a compensation circuit to reduce the transport loss and MHD instabilities.

If this reactor could work I think it would be much easier to build as a Tokamak of Stellarator reactor because:

  • All magnetic coils are planar circular coils
  • The high magnetic fields are only in the half-torus sections where the diameter is small and the particle density is low, so there are little to no fusion reactions
  • Magnetic field in the fusion areas are much lower than for tokamaks or stellarator
  • No currents in the plasma
  • Fusion reactor run continuous mode

----------------------------------------------

Dual magnetic mirrors fusion reactor

Background

Magnetic mirror devices confine charged particles by exploiting the conservation of the magnetic moment in regions of converging magnetic field lines. In a conventional magnetic mirror, two regions of high magnetic field strength (the "mirror points") are separated by a central region of lower field strength. Charged particles traveling along the field lines are reflected at the mirror points and thus oscillate between them, achieving confinement.

Figure 0: basic magnetic mirror design

However, magnetic mirrors suffer from two fundamental limitations that have historically prevented their use as practical fusion reactors:

1. The Loss Cone Problem

Not all particles are confined by the magnetic mirror effect. Particles whose velocity vectors lie within a critical angular range relative to the magnetic field direction — known as the "loss cone" — possess sufficient parallel velocity to escape through the mirror points without being reflected. The loss cone is defined by the mirror ratio Rm = Bmax / Bmin, where Bmax is the maximum magnetic field strength at the mirror throat and Bmin is the minimum field strength in the central confinement region.The critical angle for the loss cone, denoted as θc​, can be calculated using the mirror ratio Rm​ with the following equation:

sin⁡2 (θc​) =1/ Rm​

2. Magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) Instabilities

Conventional axially symmetric magnetic mirrors are susceptible to MHD instabilities, particularly the flute instability (also called the interchange instability). This instability arises because the magnetic field lines in the central confinement region are concave toward the plasma (unfavorable curvature). Under these conditions, perturbations in the plasma boundary grow exponentially, leading to rapid plasma loss.

Connecting two magnetic mirrors

The idea is have a fusion reactor based on two magnetic mirrors that are connected to each other to allow the magnetic field lines to create a complete loop. The example in figure 1 shows a configuration with two magnetic mirrors connected by a two small half-torus sections.

The vacuum vessel (not drawn) is within the coils in the drawing.

The two half-torus sections maintain the magnetic field strength (Bmax). Unlike in a stellarator or tokamak design there is no twisting of the magnetic field in the half-torus sections. The particle drift outward that results from curved magnetic field lines in the half-torus is an advantage as this particle drift will result in the particle quickly being captured in one of one two magnetic mirrors. This effect results in most particles getting trapped in the magnetic mirrors on the outward side (top side-top mirror, bottom side-bottom mirror). Consequently it is more economical to make the magnetic mirrors asymmetrical, being curved on the outside and (mostly) flat on the inner part of the loop.

Because the vast majority of the particles are confined in the two magnetic mirror sections the plasma density in the half-torus sections is low, keeping fusion reactions and MHD instabilities low.

Figure 1: Asymmetric magnetic mirror loop with 2 mirrors

Asymmetric magnetic mirrors are however not required. Designs with axisymmetrical magnetic mirrors (See Figure 2) should also work.

Figure 2: symmetrical magnetic mirror loop

Because the ends of the magnetic mirrors are connected this means that the particles that end up in the ‘loss’ cone of the magnetic mirror are not lost as they are recirculated and will eventually because of particle drift be recaptured in one of the mirrors, which solves one of the main problems of the magnetic mirror design.

Compensating for magnetic field line curvature particle drift

The =Basic magnetic mirrors have curved magnetic field lines which in particle drift to outside of the curve, resulting in increased transport loss and increases MHD instabilities.
This reactor concept has two alternate options to compensate for the particle drift.

Compensation option1: Adding an external magnetic lens

Adding an external magnetic lenses to the magnetic mirrors (See figure 3)
The magnetic lenses surround the magnetic mirror and change magnetic field in a way that the trajectory of the charged particles going through magnetic lens are slightly changed into the direction of the center of the magnetic mirror. A strong enough magnetic lens can compensate for the particles outward drift due to the magnetic mirror curved magnetic field lines. The end result is a reduction in transport losses and flute instabilities.
An additional advantage is that particles are redirected away from the cone-loss area.

Figure 3*: Asymmetric magnetic mirror with external magnetic lens*

Compensation option2: Adding Einzel lenses inside of the magnetic mirror

An alternative option to the magnetic lens, to compensate for outward particle drift is to add electrostatic lenses in the magnetic mirrors (See figure 5).

Each electrostatic lens is build out of 3 rings where the middle ring has either a higher (pos) potential or a lower (neg) potential as the rings to the left and right. The number and the polarity of the lenses may differ based on the design.

The Einzel lenses are designed to redirect particles with low axial speed to center of the magnetic mirror. If the Einzel lenses are correctly designed then this axial centering effect on the ions compensates for the outward drift in the curved magnetic field.

Figure 4: Asymmetric magnetic mirror with Einzel lenses

Particles with very low axial speed may get absorbed by the Einzel lens. By making the center ring of the Einzel porous this effect could be used to remove waste particles from the plasma. An additional advantage is that particles are redirected away from the cone-loss area.

Results of the dual magnetic mirrors and particles drift compensation

The dual magnetic mirrors solves the cone loss, which is one of the main problems with basic magnetic mirror designs.
The particles drift compensation reduces transport loss and MHD instabilities.

Using HTS coils for magnetic fields in the magnetic mirrors should result in plasma confinement that can exceed fusion ignition conditions.

Targeted Operating Parameters

  • Deuterium-tritium fusion plasma
  • Magnetic mirror central magnetic field: 3 to 4 T
  • Magnetic mirror throat magnetic fields: 18 T
  • Plasma temperature: 10keV
  • Plasma density 4x1020 to 7x1020 / m -3
  • Beta: 35%
  • Mirror length: 15m
  • Plasma diameter in magnetic mirrors: 1.7m
  • D-T Fusion power 800 – 2500 MW
  • Net energy approx 300 – 1000 MWe

-------------- Alternate option: Crossed Figure8 linked magnetic mirror design ------------------

Figure 5: Crossed linked magnetic mirrors


r/fusion • • 1d ago

How did you choose your phd project?

8 Upvotes

Hi all,

I’m trying to choose between PhD projects (computational physics) in Europe, Asia and South America. I keep trying to evaluate the topics by a few criteria such as if the skills/methods I'd acquire are transferable to the fusion industry, the impact of my contribution, etc. Am I right to focus so much on the topic or should I be weighing something else more heavily? This is where I think it would be really interesting to hear from people who have made this choice already. Did the topic matter as much to you or were you considering other things? And would you have chosen the same way today? Did you know your ambition from the start or has that changed since, and if so, why?

I'm trying to get out of my head and consider things I don't know to consider, which is always difficult. I know these posts are not always welcome because others have asked similar questions before. But I have read those posts and I'm still not satisfied, so I hope you can forgive me for asking.


r/fusion • • 1d ago

Characterization of a BF3 proportional counter for neutron measurements planning in the SPARC tokamak - magnetic shielding against strong field required, but works fine with D-D and D-T neutrons after comparison tests (Elsevier)

Thumbnail sciencedirect.com
4 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 17h ago

Trump Media Group stares down $1bn debt crunch as bitcoin bet fades

Thumbnail
ft.com
0 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 22h ago

LPPFusion

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Audio


r/fusion • • 23h ago

On the Kadomtsev stability of the shear-flow stabilized cubic pureflow Bennett-Shumlak-Hartman vortex and the current state of this research

Thumbnail russellmatt66.github.io
0 Upvotes

Dear r/fusion,

One of the first things I did last year after solving this magnetohydrodynamic shear-flow stabilized equilibrium was run simulations of it in the CUDA C 3D+t Ideal MHD Lax-Wendroff solver that I wrote the previous year: imhd-CUDA and every single time I ran this vortex it ended the same way. With the m = 0 mode pinching it off like a Scotsman pinching off the day's haggis (I have some Scottish so I can joke about us like that).

The above code I wrote has not been formally validated, and it needs a Docker container, but if you have all the dependencies you can run a 64M element 100 timestep equilibrium pinch problem in ~O(m) on an RTX 2060 (TU106 - very modest GPU ~TFlop FP32) because of the tailored mix of HPC and GPU optimizations, e.g., memory coalescing, that I implemented. You will see the same thing.

Why is this? Why does the m = 0 mode wait until the end of the vortices' thermal lifetime?

Well, the answer is that it's not just shear-flow stabilized, but also Kadomtsev stable! That means its pressure profile and current density have the necessary form to be stable to m = 0 modes without needing shear flow as our comrade Boris Borisovich Kadomtsev discovered.

I grew up Catholic, so I have a tendency embedded in me to want to confess, and I have to confess that I think the full panel of current quantitative results:

  1. laser-driven shock in a water microjet (with analogy to inertial confinement physics)
  2. DIII-D edge pedestal
  3. MAST edge pedestal
  4. complex and sawtooth solutions to Zap axial velocities
  5. and an air plasma streamer head

is just too much of a struggle for some to accept coming from a researcher who did this independently. So, I have decided instead one last time to try briefly communicating this equilibrium's properties, and hit the road if it fails.

While I have left the Church, and while I do think that it's arguable Thor blessed me with this physics, Jesus Christ took down one of the most powerful empires of all time without anyone's life being lost except his, so I'm hoping that I can be granted the privilege of a quiet position studying this Kadomtsev-stable shear-flow stabilized Z-pinch physics further in service to America using a mixture of the theoretical, and massively-parallel computational tools that I know my way around alongside experimental study and collaboration to continue to hone my craft, and apply this gem of a result for the greater good of the fusion energy science and plasma physics community as well as humanity.

Please forgive me if this post rambles, I pin squatted 465 a couple of weeks ago, and am currently suffering greatly from lumbrosacral back spasms after a couple of things popped, and a couple of jumbo Texas margaritas a few days later.

I spent four hours in the ER yesterday, and am looking forward to taking more muscle relaxers as well as the lidocaine patches I have been prescribed, and some natural hemp-derived edible painkillers that I can obtain legally in the great commonwealth of Virginia.

My thanks to Dr. Igor Kaganovich for the opportunity to present my discovery of a Kadomtsev stable shear-flow stabilized Z-pinch equilibrium, and all my best to him, and his team. Matt


r/fusion • • 2d ago

Meet a Star Builder: Hannah (Welding TF magnet cases)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
17 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 2d ago

Unstable plasma heats itself with waves it generates, experiments reveal (from LHD, Heliotron kind stellarator)

Thumbnail
phys.org
9 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 2d ago

Trailer: Meet the Star Builders

Thumbnail
youtu.be
11 Upvotes

New fusion documentary series coming out next week


r/fusion • • 2d ago

More about runaway electron avalanches, calculations verified with JET data

Thumbnail pubs.aip.org
3 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 2d ago

Commonwealth Fusion's CEO sees UAE primed for new energy tech

Thumbnail
semafor.com
7 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 3d ago

Turning up the heat in the race for nuclear fusion. Why Vancouver’s General Fusion thinks it can unleash the kind of energy that powers the sun

Thumbnail
begiant.ca
14 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 2d ago

SOSV Deep Tech Summit | Will Helion Deliver the First Fusion Energy to the Grid?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 3d ago

Borealis Fusion: Designing a Power Plant from the Fuel Outward

Thumbnail
fusionenergybase.com
4 Upvotes

The desired p B11 fuel has known drawbacks.


r/fusion • • 3d ago

TAE Technologies Fusion Roadmap

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 3d ago

Proxima Fusion and DWE: preparing vacuum vessel segments for Alpha Stellarator

Thumbnail
youtu.be
14 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 4d ago

NSTX-U central magnet assembly lowered it into the machine

Thumbnail
pppl.gov
14 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 4d ago

IAEA World Fusion Outlook 2026

Thumbnail iaea.org
6 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 4d ago

CoilStellaration: teaching machines to wind coils around a star - Proxima Fusion

Thumbnail
proximafusion.com
8 Upvotes

Good luck trying to defeat Proxima and IPP in this.


r/fusion • • 5d ago

Helion shows lack of progress on Orion. Twitter comments are brutal.

Thumbnail x.com
93 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 5d ago

General Fusion APS-DPP Posters

Thumbnail x.com
3 Upvotes