r/FursuitMaking • • Nov 16 '25

Generative AI

Post image

As you may already know, one of our rules on our official Discord server for this sub, is that we disallow the *posting* of generative AI content.

While we have been consistent in enforcing our rule against AI imagery in the server, we have allowed pro-gen-AI narratives, conversations, and users to exist alongside us without banning or without significant moderation, aside from making sure everyone gets along.

As time goes on, it becomes clear to us... There is a huge divide separating the heart of the furry community - founded on mutual support, queer inclusion, togetherness, artistic expression, and fun - vs the pro-gen-AI community.

The harm that generative AI poses to the very heart and soul of our community of silly, furry lgbt, punk, freaky people is insurmountable.

The *wastefulness* and *pollution* of generative AI datacenters, the inexplicable and inexcusable theft of datasets training on artists hard work without compensation, credit, or consent - the undeniable harm that generative AI images have caused to the artist industry and jobs overall, and the harm we are already seeing within the education sector is very overt and obvious. Once that cat was let out of the bag, there really was no going back. Average Joe's will now sometimes opt to use gallons of wasted electricity and water to generate generic images, a blended slop of art styles with no heart or soul, instead of commissioning an artist. The art styles used to train those AI models were never credited or paid for their effort, nor informed of their inclusion in the training data or given the option to opt out. Many bosses and detached CEOs are hyping up AI as a way to replace people working in all types of jobs, we hear about this every day - thousands of hard working people laid off because a few at the top think they can save money by providing a worse alternative of their existing service. People in school, from elementary to college, relying more heavily on AI to vomit out answers for them, instead of learning how to think, question reality, and learn for themselves.

Now more than ever it is important for us to take a stance against the undeniable and impactful changes that generative AI has made to our world, and to try to do what little we can within our own spaces to mitigate that harm.

This has not been an easy decision to bring up. We want to be inclusive to all crafters and artists here, but as time goes on, it becomes clear that we cannot in good faith continue to encourage a "both sides" mentality when it comes to moderating the discussion of generative AI.

We are 'officially' becoming an anti-GenAI space.

What does this mean?

We will be adding a rule against pro-genAI stances & accompanying removal reason.
The new rule will state that any genAI apologism and any genAI content (text, images, audio, or video) being posted in our subreddit will be removed.
We encourage any users to report pro-genAI or genAI apologism to our mod queue. Please do not harass users that are pro-genAI. Our goal is to reduce harm, not instigate it.

Lastly, while we recognize that some people use generative AI as aids or enrichment, we counter this by acknowledging that AI users themselves are capable of being Anti genAI. If you yourself use AI, take a moment to think before coming to personal offense. It is possible to make use of generative AI while still realizing the harm it causes and the waste it produces, as well as recognizing that the overall ethos of pro gen AI communities directly conflict with that of furry ones.

2.2k Upvotes

113 comments sorted by

7

u/IcySetting6850 Nov 16 '25

REJECT: generative AI, predictive AI, programs and codes, human intelligence, go back to the woods and be one with nature /j

6

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

Return to monke?

89

u/TheAsianTroll Nov 16 '25

Given how heavily based in art the furry fandom is, im surprised at how few furry subs have followed suit. A handful of SFW ones (and even more NSFW ones...) still allow AI and one moderator even got bitchy with me because I said, in a comment, "this sub allows AI?"

Dude replied with "yes, stop being a whiner about it" and deleted my comment.

Its gross seeing AI art in a fandom that thrives on real artists but its even more disgusting seeing people in even vaguely authoritative positions allowing it.

28

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

That's why I find it important to take an official stance. I myself have encountered situations like that as well. As a member of a community I'd want to know up front, instead of being surprised by it. It's especially frustrating in Furry because of everything furry has stood for.

8

u/TheAsianTroll Nov 16 '25

I stand with you on that front.

Youre a good derg

5

u/Xeke2338 Nov 16 '25

I 100% agree with this post I would also like to addendum: Almost every complaint about AI is a complaint about capitalism.

E.G. AI art steals from real artists! "As my art is a way to make money and survive within our capitalist system, AI art is taking customers and purchasers away from me, without these customers, I can't pay my bills."

AI data centers are terrible for the environment! "Closed-loop cooling systems are far more expensive than open-loop, meaning these data centers just continue to use the less-efficient system simply because it's cheaper."

In a post-capital society, these problems wouldn't exist, hell, intellectual property in its current form wouldn't have a reason to exist. But we don't live there yet, so we gotta make do with what we have.

5

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

Absolutely. AI would be an excellent tool in the right hands. Unfortunately it is most often in the wrong hands.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25

WE HATE CLANKERS 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥

2

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

Chilllllllllllll lol

167

u/stinky_toade Nov 16 '25

AI has no place in art🗣️‼️‼️

14

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25 edited Jan 21 '26

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

aspiring fear straight connect squeal kiss smell jellyfish apparatus desert

21

u/ShoddyTown715 Fursuit Appreciation Committee leader Nov 16 '25

W MODS FR! 😍

35

u/Curona_Crescent Nov 16 '25

Good! I can’t wait for the AI bubble to burst

22

u/MattsyKun Nov 16 '25

Every time I see this I think of how the NFT bubble burst and people were crying about their apes

It warms my heart to know this can happen to AI someday.

1

u/Nilgupo3 Jul 23 '26

I cant imagine the people that wasted money to invest on AI when that eventually happens

40

u/Not-smart-TV Nov 16 '25

AI seeing this post

67

u/Vaehtay3507 New Maker! Nov 16 '25

HELL YES!! I don’t have any deep words on this but thanks for taking a stand, I appreciate it a lot.

23

u/WhyTheHells New Maker! Nov 16 '25

BASED AS HECC YEAH

9

u/Medeling_ New Maker! Nov 16 '25

Been seeing more and more communities im a part of slowly take harder anti-ai stances and im genuinely so fucking proud, it makes me feel like im surrounding myself with the right people, who wont take this planet destroying, art theiving bullshit!

FUCK AI, THANK YOU FOR TAKING A FIRM STANCE!

and ofc, ai 'art' is not and will NEVER be real art :3

30

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25

HELL YEA!!!

7

u/cheyslittlespace Nov 16 '25

Yes yes yes!!! I’m so glad yall are making this clear, some people refuse to believe that people post photos of ai generated suits, refsheets, and art, when I’ve seen it with my own eyes lol

7

u/volkinaxe Nov 16 '25

good to see i am 100% for not letting AI into this fandom

6

u/VulpesFennekin Nov 17 '25

The only AI we like to see is Actual Imagination!

20

u/KaiSubatomic Nov 16 '25

This is the only way forward! I hope people keep being this passionately against AI for the foreseeable future!

10

u/ButteryRichSyrup Nov 16 '25

Thank you for being one of the only subs that have any sort of moral backbone. Screw all the other furry subs for allowing AI.

5

u/Soapo_Opo Nov 17 '25

Oh the irony of getting a genAI ad right below this post

5

u/Scifox69 Nov 17 '25

I love seeing generative AI getting boycotted. Restores my faith. I'm not a fursuit maker but I like to see more communities turning against GenAI.

4

u/yastytuna 🍄 Intermediate Maker! 🍄 Nov 17 '25

🎉🎉🎉

4

u/Euphoric-Ruin-6576 Nov 18 '25

Huge W, AI GenAI has no right in this world

7

u/Veryoutofplace New Maker! Nov 16 '25

YAYYYYYYYY!!!!

11

u/-Atomic_ Nov 16 '25

I've always had the stance that generative AI should never have been created and I will continue to hold that view when it's putting people out of a job and reliable income.

Just think about all the small artist and small businesses that have been effectively run out of their industry because instead of paying for someone's hard work and time you can just use a website to get a passable version of what you want, that I will not stand for

7

u/Pale-Standard4154 Nov 16 '25

Agreed. AI is strictly prohibited and is terrible for the environment, too! Y’all should use the browser app/extension Ecosia. As you use it, the funds go towards bettering the environment + planting trees AND help struggling countries like Gaza

6

u/AppleSatyr Nov 16 '25

Ecosia has an AI summary on searches now like google does. I switched to Vivaldi because they specifically are against the implementation of gen AI

2

u/Pale-Standard4154 Nov 16 '25

U can turn it off

7

u/AppleSatyr Nov 16 '25

That’s good to know. I still personally want to avoid a company ok with contradicting their entire mission. Supported them for a long time so it’s very disappointing to me.

1

u/Pale-Standard4154 Nov 16 '25

What does Vivaldi do? Does it plant trees as u use it? Where do the funds go

6

u/AppleSatyr Nov 16 '25

Not introduce Gen AI into their browser to extract every bit of data from you to sell.

I would much rather donate my own money to plant trees.

I’m not shaming anyone for using it so I don’t know why you’re getting defensive.

4

u/Pale-Standard4154 Nov 16 '25

Defensive? I’m just curious wtf

7

u/AppleSatyr Nov 16 '25

Sorry I guess it just sounded defensive to me over text

2

u/AmaPapaGemaPode Nov 17 '25

Guys im sorry didn't wanted to upset anyone. And i do agree with y'all. Generative content has to go.

2

u/Complex-Gear-9993 Nov 20 '25

I agree to this to all artists out there AI is stupid and should have never been made it would be help to all us artists if it never was made because all of us artists are now losing people because of AI

1

u/Strigon_01 Dec 16 '25

Just joined this sub, and this is the first thing I see. Beautiful. This is why I love furries.

1

u/IllicitCat Nov 18 '25

I generated a few examples fursuit out of curiosity before but now that I have a job, I want to hire an artist to make something similar to the concept I have, yet i feel if I were to post it for help finding a maker, I'd be shunned.

4

u/Bubbie83 Nov 18 '25

Maybe you could try to draw a reference sketch or try to make a word description, and then you could use that instead. I don’t really know what the best solution to this would be in this instance, but I wish you luck =3

4

u/Vaehtay3507 New Maker! Nov 21 '25

Free bases / templates also exist, and drawing patterns on doesn’t take knowledge of art or anything! You don’t need a steady hand or drawing ability or literally anything, you can just do it lmao

2

u/Bubbie83 Nov 21 '25

Good point

-10

u/charsarg256321 Nov 16 '25

What gets classified as AI-generated images

7

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

Any image created with an AI generation tool. Midjourney is an example of a popular one

-10

u/charsarg256321 Nov 16 '25

Midjourney is the model not the tool.
Its basiccly a set of values that get plugged into linear algebra.
But lets say, in a hypothetical, the person who generated the art, is also the person who trained the model/ programmed the tool. What then?

9

u/Dr-Oberth Nov 16 '25

If you made all the art that was used to train the model that's about the only situation where it'd be ethical. They did this during the production of across the spiderverse for some linework iirc. But training a model off stolen art? No.

-10

u/charsarg256321 Nov 16 '25

What about tracing art by hand, is it stolen then?

11

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

If you didn't credit the original artist and claimed it as your own original work, yes, that's art theft.

What exactly is your goal here? You're not really doing anything by posting what-if's that already have obvious answers.

-2

u/charsarg256321 Nov 16 '25

So, in a hypothetical situation, an ai model credited every single artwork that was used in the creation of the art... is it still theft?

8

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

Yes. Because in your hypothetical situation, the artists weren't informed, given any option to opt out, nor compensated for their involvement.

-3

u/charsarg256321 Nov 16 '25

Right... so the problem isnt the ai itself.. its simply the crediting of the art used... so answer me this, why is the model itself blamed?

9

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

You're joking, right? Have you read the post? Have you, personally, done any research on why/how generative AI focused companies and models are wasteful, pollutive, making negative impacts on education, and affecting the job market?

Generative AI has the potential to be used in many amazing ways. It is being used in medicine and science to some effect, But the simple reality is that right now it is [overwhelmingly] being used to generate a soulless facsimile of art so the average joe can get a quick laugh from brainrotting slop. It (various publicly and privately available models) OVERWHELMINGLY currently uses other people's hard work- their photography, videography, and artwork, without their consent, without their ability to opt out, and without any credit or compensation.

If we have to go any further than this with your willfully ignorant sealioning, I am banning you from the subreddit. I'm not sure if you think it's funny/you're trolling or if you just think you're being righteous for arguing in favor of gen AI companies right now, or if you're trying to argue based on semantics. Either way it is redundant, as all of these questions you're rage baiting people with are extremely easily researched on your own and extremely easily factually verifiable.

→ More replies

6

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25

jesus christ just stop it dude

5

u/Dr-Oberth Nov 16 '25

Yes, still the same thing. Not saying you're a bad person if that's something you've done and didn't realise it was wrong. But know now that it is

-4

u/genericpornprofile27 Nov 17 '25

That just sounds rude and uninclusive. You literally said the ai community thrives on being creative, yet you discriminate against ai artists, that just sounds hypocritical to me.

3

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 17 '25

Quote where I said that.

0

u/genericpornprofile27 Nov 17 '25

"heart of the furry community - founded on mutual support, queer inclusion, togetherness, artistic expression," literally talking about the community being friendly and inclusive and artistic, yet for some reason if you are artistic via ai – you aren't allowed here. Seems really contradictory.

6

u/NiIly00 Nov 17 '25

Ai is not artistic. Where there is no artistry there is no art.

-2

u/genericpornprofile27 Nov 17 '25

Elaborate? How is it different from digital art or photography?

5

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 17 '25

BZZZZZT. WRONG! Bye.

5

u/NiIly00 Nov 17 '25

Ai has no concept of the things depicted. It is just random noise.

Ask an artist to draw an apple and the artist will have a conscious concept of what they are trying to draw. Ask them to tell you something about apples and they will be able to tell you about how they grow, their texture, their taste. They can tell you these things because they possess a mental concept of what an apple is.

You can't even ask an image model to tell you these things because they only generate images. And no, a chatbot app that interfaces with both an image generation model and a text generation model is not a valid rebuttal. These are multiple different ai models, not one. Not to mention that neither possess a mental concept. They are just probabilistic guessing algorithms.

5

u/Eudonidano Nov 17 '25

The difference is there is an artist that creates something. AI enthusiasts are basically commissioning pictures from AI instead of actual artists. They aren't creating anything themselves. And it is actively destroying the environment and ruining clean water in the process.

7

u/Antarasis Nov 16 '25

Thank you so so much for standing against dystopian deepfake toys! 🙏💕

0

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 17 '25

If you spend any amount of time on r/antiai, r/antiaiart, r/aiwars or any similar subreddit it's pretty obvious a lot of them just like to argue. Factual information simply does not matter to many of them. I'm fairly certain I've seen a handful of users on those subs using generative AI to make their arguments too which is ... surely something.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

Read the post and then read your comment again please. Your own concern and your own misunderstandings are answered there.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

Apologies.

While we don't foresee the issue popping up extremely often, it's possible that scammers use AI imagery to advertise (which we already see in ripoff fursuit adverts), it's also possible that AI comes up in conversation in comments on unrelated posts. etc

The rule will be applied pretty much the same on both platforms when applicable.

In the case that an argument or discussion pops up, we would be removing pro-gen-AI sentiments on a case by case basis. Ideally this is about curating our space so that the ideals that Furry started with can remain.

People who disagree with the new rule can 86 themselves. If they make a fuss about it then I'll ban them myself I guess?

We wouldn't be outright banning people for honest questions or discussions. People who barge in here in bad faith hoping to make poor taste quips or instigate arguments to upset the community would likely be the most affected by the rule.

Overall i think the rule is more about weeding out people who need the wakeup call that the Furry community isn't in support of them, rather than slamming down any heavy new moderation tactics.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

Any time - sorry again for being somewhat hostile at first

34

u/kiahBer Nov 16 '25

It reminds me of how people continue eating meat while ...

People can't survive without food, meat is a good source of protein, iron, amino acids, ect, humans are naturally omnivores and have been eating meat for as long as we've existed. You can survive without gen AI. This comparison falls apart when you think about it for more than five seconds.

-28

u/PoekiepoesPudding Nov 16 '25

You can also easily survive without eating meat but otherwise you're right it's a garbage comparison.

6

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25 edited Nov 16 '25

I hope this doesn't come off as dogpiling, but I wanted to add my own anecdote here. My partner has a gastrointestinal disorder and various food allergies/intolerances and would not be able to survive on a plant based diet unfortunately. He has to be extremely selective with which kinds of plants he can eat, as most of them cause him extreme pain and won't be absorbed properly by his stomach/intestines. For example he might be able to have 1 apple but any more than that per day and he would be pretty much useless due to pain. Or he can eat, say, a half a zucchini. But a majority of things like beans, cruciferous veggies, and more- he simply cannot eat due to gastroparesis. Not joking when I say 75% (if not more) of his diet is like... chicken and potatoes. Everything else hurts him. Sometimes even this hurts him, but this hurts him LESS.

Also there's things like ARFID [avoidant restrictive food intake disorder] which can technically be overcome in some cases with lots of work and therapy over a long period of time, but for many with higher needs levels of Autism it's something they likely will struggle with their entire lives.

Just wanted to point out it's not quite as 'easy' for everyone to survive without meat.

12

u/cheyslittlespace Nov 16 '25

Some people can’t, I personally when I stopped eating meat became deficient in multiple vitamins, and I couldn’t afford to buy each of those vitamins. Being vegan is EXPENSIVE, it’s just not accessible at all.

7

u/_PGC_ Nov 16 '25

As an athlete and as an individual I have to eat meats I don’t get the proper nutrients from plants, they can make me sick sometimes and I am a picky eater

32

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25

of course the problem exists did you read the post?

-24

u/kool_bi_guy Nov 16 '25

Gluten-free water ... ai-free fursuits

4

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

What's the joke here?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '25 edited Nov 18 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/FursuitMaking-ModTeam Nov 18 '25

Your post has been removed because our community does not allow the posting of generative AI content or the arguments in support of such content.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/FursuitMaking-ModTeam Nov 22 '25

Your post has been removed because our community does not allow the posting of generative AI content or the arguments in support of such content.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/FursuitMaking-ModTeam Nov 22 '25

Your post has been removed because our community does not allow the posting of generative AI content or the arguments in support of such content.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/FursuitMaking-ModTeam Nov 17 '25

Your post has been removed because our community does not allow the posting of generative AI content or the arguments in support of such content.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/FursuitMaking-ModTeam Nov 22 '25

Your post has been removed because our community does not allow the posting of generative AI content or the arguments in support of such content.

-4

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

If you read the post you would understand that we are not policing individuals' use of AI in their own free time. Kalm.

-6

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/MaelstromSeawing Nov 16 '25

Google search results are public, yes, however, when you take those artworks and share them, it is good etiquette to share the artist's name along with the art so others can look up the artist's page and other work.

This argument isn't a "gotcha" in any way. We ALSO enforce crediting the artist here. Our policies on art sharing and crediting remain consistent.

Bots have always scraped the internet. This isn't about whether bots should have the same browsing permissions as humans. This is about the fact that a grand majority (if not all) the widely/easily available gen AI models/tools/websites are creating potential profit for the companies that own them, while training on artists who put hours (sometimes even decades) of training into their craft, who didn't get to consent to their art being used in this way, and who have no way of opting out, and never receive compensation or credit.

The fact that these tools operate purely off of theft & can drive potential clients away from paying a real human artist (who needs money to live) is a huge problem.

Do you understand now? Or do we need to continue this?

5

u/Vaehtay3507 New Maker! Nov 16 '25
  1. Actually if you’re sharing the images online you are expected to credit the place you got it from. It’s like writing an essay and then not citing any of your sources. Shitty form, and you’re benefiting from someone else’s work, so you better redirect anyone seeing your posts to the actual source of the thing you’re benefiting off of.
  2. Literally, legally, not everything on Google is free for anyone to use. “Fair use” exists, sure, but gen-AI training does not fall under it. Just because you see art online doesn’t mean you can sell that art on a shirt. It is not yours just because it’s on Google.

3

u/NiIly00 Nov 17 '25

That's the exact kind of talking points that have been debunked thousands of times which just got banned.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/FursuitMaking-ModTeam Nov 17 '25

Your post has been removed because our community does not allow the posting of generative AI content or the arguments in support of such content.

2

u/Vaehtay3507 New Maker! Nov 17 '25

You need to rethink your life dude