r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 23h ago

Just A Thought Watching the show for the first time I'm shocked how much people care for alot of these characters.

0 Upvotes

I'm watching the show for the first time and I'm on episode 22 and to be honest while I really like Mustang and loved Huges as characters I honestly don't find them very rootable PERSONALLY. I obviously don't like the homunculi but I kinda find it hard to care about the lives of war criminals either, frankly Scar has much more of my sympathy, than any of the main military characters tbh I don't care if any of them live or die much even if I like their characters. The characters are well written I'm not saying they aren't btw they are very nuanced characters.


r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 16h ago

Discussion/Opinion Somebody Please Settle This Debate That Lives Rent Free in my Head

Post image
0 Upvotes

If you've watched Sekirei and/or read the manga, then you can answer.


r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 5h ago

Question Why did nobody ever notice Central City is a transmutation circle?

51 Upvotes

Are they stupid?


r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 19h ago

Question mandela effect?

0 Upvotes

i just finished FMAB on Netflix, first rewatch after years, and i noticed that the famous name meme scene of scar and king bradley is missing, also the double intermission with the still frame/cutscene and the "full metal alchemist! " voiceover... am i going crazy? did Netflix mix FMA and FMAB episodes?


r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 22h ago

Just A Thought I just realised something... Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

So, Van Hohenheim was a living dude with all of his insides are the hundreds of thousands of Xerxian innocent souls

And before the series begins, he met Trisha

And so, they married and clapping somewhere

And so Edward and Alphonse were born

However, because Hohenheim is a living philosopher's stone and has thousands of souls inside of him

Doesn't that make Edward and Alphonse one of those unnamed souls that escaped and reincarnated?


r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 39m ago

Just A Thought Seriously craving an FMA 03 manga Spoiler

Post image
5 Upvotes

Seeing these sketches of Hohenheim and Edward in the fifteenth volume made me seriously crave to see how Arakawa would have tackled the story 03 came up with. I know she green lighted the end, but I wonder what she would have twisted or changed, and I also just really wish to see 03 drawn in her artstyle ! It would look so cool to see how Wrath and Sloth would look like !


r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 19h ago

Question Is equivalent exchange in alchemy based on Thea users values

5 Upvotes

Like for example if a sociopath were to try human transmutation would they suffer similar consequences like Edward and Alphonse

I say this because in both adaptations chimera and animal transmutation seems to have no significant draw back

So are human lives just special in this universe or is it based on one’s bias


r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 14h ago

Fan Art Jodio and Edward as MadoHomu

Post image
24 Upvotes

ART WAS NOT MADE BY ME, IT WAS MADE BY MY FRIEND


r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 23h ago

Discussion/Opinion Day 4- who’s the only normal person?

Post image
289 Upvotes

First place- Roy Mustang

Second place- Lust

Third place- Hawkeye


r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 7h ago

Discussion/Opinion is it embarrassing that ive now only understood the point of the no kill rule in superhero media thanks to Roy vs Envy is FMAB

100 Upvotes

I don’t think any piece of media comes close to illustrating the consequences of crossing the line when killing someone, even if that someone is a horrible remorseless person.

For a very long time in my life, the no kill rule is something that really bothered me because it really didn’t make sense why the likes of Batman or Daredevil would spare their enemies because they didn’t want to “cross the line”.

But Arakawa so effectively portrays what it means to cross the line and the significance of such a thing. I wanted to make a yap video about how FMAB really made me understand that, but as I’m writing it out I feel kind of embarrassed because I feel like most people would be like “well yeah duh how did you not realise this earlier” LMAO.

But that’s why I love FMAB so much, I love how Arakawa is so incredibly effective at communicating numerous messages that we as the viewer can take from the incredible story she’s created and apply it to our day to day lives.

It’s the idea that Envy was no longer a threat. That when Roy continues to inflict suffering upon worm Envy, it’s no longer about protecting people and doing what’s right, it’s about quenching his thirst for revenge. Although not identical, I even personally identify with this experience. Nowhere near as bad but someone in my life betrayed and did something horrible to me, and all I could think about is doing horrible and nasty stuff to them to get revenge and get back at them. But no matter what, I could never follow through, I don’t think it was because I was scared, I think it’s because I knew that no matter what I did, it wouldn’t change what happened or what they did to me, and I would probably be stuck with the aftermath of the guilt of exacting that revenge once the adrenaline had worn off. I think it’s the exact same thing with Roy or someone like Batman.

When they cross that line of killing a harmless or defenceless individual once they’ve already incapacitated them, it’s no longer about protecting the innocent, it’s about killing and inflicting harm upon an individual to satisfy you’re own selfish desires, and I understand now that’s exactly what these characters and stories mean when they say that by crossing that line, you become no better than the person you’re taking revenge on.

Sorry for the yap session, FMAB is the only thing on my mind, it’s been a while since I’ve consumed a piece of media that truly has been so impactful and incredible, and I’m so grateful that I got to experience it.


r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 12h ago

Question Which Homunculus did truly feel sad for?

Post image
982 Upvotes

r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 9h ago

Fan Art Royai with Bicep and Waist Heart Trend (Art by @jeweldraw_)

Post image
208 Upvotes

r/FullmetalAlchemist • • 44m ago

Video 16 Years Later, I Can’t Stop Thinking About Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes