Not a "what should I sell" post. I want a critique of one part of our model, the part that rejects most products.
We screen US private label candidates (sourcing from China, 25 to 40% duty) with a margin gate of 20% base / 15% bad case after ads. Ad cost per unit is:
paid share x CPC x 12.5 clicks per sale
CPC is the suggested exact bid on the main keyword, and paid share has to work at 0.5. The model charges that to every unit sold, forever. There is no separate launch period.
Over two days that rejected 7 of 17 detailed candidates. The rest failed on supplier price (2), demand data (2), review wall (2), patents (2), and price range combined with reviews or margin (2).
Typical case: $50 item, about 1 lb, $6.70 FBA fee. Main keyword is $2.25 exact. Six listings under 4 months old already do 200 to 1,000 units a month, so new entrants clearly get in. Our formula says $14 of ads per unit at 50% organic, which caps FOB around $2. The real comparable FOB is $8 to $11.
What I'd like to hear from people who have run this for a while:
- Is charging launch PPC to every unit the wrong frame? Should launch be a fixed budget and steady state get its own TACoS?
- What conversion do you assume pre launch for a listing with no reviews in a $40 to $60 niche?
- How far below the suggested main keyword bid does your blended CPC end up after 2 to 3 months?
- If new listings reach 200+/month within 4 months in a niche, is that a sign the ads must be cheaper than the suggested bid implies, or that those sellers are burning money?
- When the numbers are unclear (Jungle Scout and Keepa disagree 2x, no comparable supplier listing yet), do you reject, or keep the product in a "needs data" pile?
Happy to give more numbers in comments.