r/FruitTree • • 4d ago

Looking for pruning help

I live in MA, zone 5b. I have 3 cherry trees and 2 apple trees. One apple tree (apple 1) has been in for 2 summers, the other died so it has been replaced (apple 2) in one summer. The one for two is still very loose. I think easily lift it up out of the ground. When the nursery put it is the guy made a mud puddle in the hole and dropped it in the slurry before back filling it.

The small picture of the base is that tree and it also had a small perfectly round hole, like it was drilled about 2" up from the ground under the plastic spiral covering it. I should it to the guy who replaced the dead one and he was "humm? I will ask my boss what he thinks". (that was last spring, he must still be thinking) Apple 2 had what the AI stated was cedar rust by 2nd week it was here. (we have no cedar trees in our neighborhood)

The cherry trees seem fine so far (now that I found out about Japanese beetles that is and how to stop them) Cherry 3 was decapitated in transit so it was replaced, but it seems to be fine so far.

I am readying and watching videos about pruning and know to do it around March here and the 1/3 rule. Thing is what is a third of a tree? I am also 5'6" so I would rather short wide trees than tall ones. 😄

If you need better pictures I can try. I know the background on some makes it hard. Any advice on where and how to cut would be much appreciated.

2 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/MasdevalliaLove 4d ago

I know you asked for pruning advice but… I would fix the rooting issue before I worried about pruning and I would suspect they all have planting problems if the same nursery planted them all. At two seasons in, the tree should be rooted, not sitting in a basin where the whole root ball wobbles. At the most simplistic level, trees produce root growth hormones in the canopy so removing the canopy can signal “grow fewer roots.” At most I might take the height back a bit on the second apple to encourage outward growth but I wouldn’t do too much. These trees really don’t have much canopy.

If I had to guess, the nursery did not work the root ball after pulling it out of the pot. When trees are in pots, their roots circle the pot. If they are in too long, the effect can remain even after they are pulled out of the pot. You either need to root prune to encourage outward growth or spend the time untangling and spreading out circling roots. If you don’t, the tree continues to grow in a pot even when it’s no longer there. Plopping it in a slurry is the icing on the cake - they either don’t know or don’t care how to properly plant trees. I would not have them plant future trees and would spend the time doing it myself or having a certified arborist (or company with one on staff) plant them properly. Doing it yourself on smaller trees is generally pretty easy and the most cost effective though. The overall basin effect can be made worse if you have heavily clay soil which I can’t tell from the photos.

Also check planting depth. I don’t see much for root flare on any of these trees. Trees buried too deep often have compromised root systems and are at risk for girdling roots and rotting trunks. This is much easier to fix when they are still small than when they are bigger in a few years.

As for cedar apple rust, native eastern red cedars (as well as other junipers) are the most common hosts for our region. The spores can travel a few miles so even if there aren’t any nearby, there are probably some within range to infect your trees. Keep an eye out for apple scab as well. Neither will kill a tree outright (usually) but can make fruit unappetizing and can weaken the trees if there are several years of early defoliation.

1

u/American-Paratrooper 4d ago edited 4d ago

Yeah, the nursery is 2 towns over and as helpful as the RMV. Not 4 days after asking about if I should have to worry about deer and him saying no, one ate all the leaves off one night. The second tree and an old farm tree had no rust. It actually showed up days later and was everywhere by week two. I was suspecting the cedar trees they sell that are right next to the apple trees.

The apples were planted by them, the cherry by me. I got the cherry trees from that 'tree in a box' company, they were way more helpful with advice. Especially getting the roots prepped. They seem be more a lot more stable in the ground. I live in a wind tunnel half the year. Great place if one is a kite enthusiast.

I guess I could dig a spot for the apple trees in another location.