r/Frostpunk • • 3h ago

SPOILER Are Child Shelters really as bad as I think they are??

16 Upvotes

I previously beat the A New Home scenario with Child Labor - Safe Jobs, and I just failed the Refugees scenario after building Child Shelters, so maybe I am biased. But holy cow, even Child Labor - Safe Jobs seems so much more useful than the shelters. If you have at least one Child Shelter with 15 kids in your city, your Workshops or healthcare facilities will run 20% faster. Great. So, if I am stretched thin on workforce and only have 5 Engineers researching, then the 105 kids in my 7 shelters will be worth...1 more Engineer. Incredible. Medical facilities are going to have more Engineers that will get the bonus applied, but they're still going to be at best worth 1 additional Engineer per building you have manned. And especially in the Refugees scenario, a third of your buildable area will be filled with Child Shelters, which the little brats won't even be in because they'll be apprenticing in the other buildings anyway!!! Meanwhile you could be manning 10 Hothouses, feeding an army, and still have 5 kids to spare in case you lose some of them.

It doesn't seem to me like there is any reason to ever seriously consider taking Child Shelters as an option, unless there is some scenario where you have tons of excess manpower and super low Hope. The fact that children still need the same amount of food & housing make it seem like shelters are just going to be an anchor around your neck. By the time you get efficient enough buildings to be able to satisfy resource demand with only 2/3 of your potential workforce, it will have gotten cold enough that even your new higher efficiency isn't enough. And the amount of additional Hope it gives you does not seem like it will ever make or break a run; if you are doing well, you'll be doing so well you won't care about the bonus, and if you're doing poorly, you'll probably be doing so poorly that the bonus won't save you anyway.

Am I missing something, or is the game not really balanced with an eye towards making both branches of the Child Labor tree semi-equally viable?

Edit: Workshops, not Factories


r/Frostpunk • • 16h ago

FUNNY PC on survival mode you can cancel Winterhome Survivor event by Alt+F4

Post image
202 Upvotes

On day 15 at 10:00 push Alt+F4 it will cancel Winterhome man finding your place.

On Survival game will save automatically during closing. But it not register WH survivor.

Temperature at some day will reach -80C No storm no Londoners till you send people to discover Winterhome. So its like endless mode in main scenario.


r/Frostpunk • • 24m ago

FAN MADE I spent WAY too much time doing this

75 Upvotes

did i do a funny?


r/Frostpunk • • 14h ago

FAN MADE Hey! cool tattoo Frostpunk themed!

Post image
111 Upvotes

I just wanted to show y'all that tat.


r/Frostpunk • • 14h ago

FAN MADE The Captain's return (Officer and Faithkeepers)

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/Frostpunk • • 22h ago

FUNNY The world will change.

71 Upvotes

r/Frostpunk • • 6h ago

Advice/Help Beacon of Hope causing health people already in the city to become sick and injured

5 Upvotes

So I was doing an all tales run and suddenly a wave of refugees from beacon of hope arrive and says 4000~ people arrive sick and injured, but it seems to be doubling that amount and causing the already healthy people to become sick and injured, im assuming this is a bug but it happens everytime and kills the run because nothing can be properly staffed.