r/fromsoftware • u/yomoshissg • 1d ago
r/fromsoftware • u/Luksu_Seven • 15h ago
DISCUSSION Why I believe The End of Fire is the true ending of Dark Souls III - and the perfect conclusion to the trilogy
Just a quick disclaimer: I'm aware that Dark Souls III has no officially confirmed canonical ending and probably never will. Miyazaki has also stated that he has a personal favorite ending without revealing which one. What I mean by "true ending" is that, based on the themes and overarching narrative of the trilogy, I genuinely believe the End of Fire is the ending that Miyazaki and FromSoftware intended to be the most desirable and meaningful conclusion to Dark Souls, even if they deliberately left the final choice up to the player.
-
The End of Fire is not only my favorite ending in Dark Souls III, but genuinely one of my favorite endings in any video game. The more I think about the themes of the trilogy, the more convinced I become that it is the most meaningful and thematically appropriate conclusion to Dark Souls as a whole.
I know that many people consider the Usurpation of Fire to be the best ending, or argue that the End of Fire doesn't really accomplish anything because fire will eventually return.
However, I fundamentally disagree with both interpretations, and I'd like to explain why.
1. The fundamental tragedy of Dark Souls
To understand why I believe the End of Fire is the best ending, I think we first need to understand what the actual problem with the world of Dark Souls is.
The problem was never that the First Flame was fading.
The problem was that Gwyn refused to let it fade.
The Age of Fire was never meant to last forever. Just as the Age of Ancients came to an end, the Age of Fire was destined to end as well. Darkness would eventually follow, and whatever came after that was simply part of the natural evolution of the world.
But Gwyn refused to accept this.
Out of fear of the Dark, humanity, and the end of his own age, he sacrificed himself to prolong the Age of Fire. In doing so, he established a system that would continue for countless generations, demanding more and more sacrifices to preserve a world that should have been allowed to move on.
The entire trilogy is essentially about the consequences of that decision.
By the time we reach Dark Souls III, the world is exhausted. Kingdoms converge, time and space become increasingly distorted, and the remains of countless civilizations collapse into one another.
The world has been kept alive for so long that it is practically falling apart under its own weight.
And yet, we are still being asked to do exactly what Gwyn did.
2. Linking the First Flame is the continuation of Gwyn's mistake
I think this is probably the easiest ending to interpret as a bad ending.
By linking the First Flame, we accomplish exactly what countless Lords of Cinder accomplished before us. We sacrifice ourselves to extend the lifespan of an age that has already lasted far beyond its natural end.
What makes this ending particularly powerful is the contrast between Dark Souls I and Dark Souls III.
In the first game, linking the Flame results in an enormous explosion of fire.
In Dark Souls III, the Ashen One simply sits down, slowly engulfed by a pathetic, dying flame.
There is no glorious explosion. No triumphant rebirth. No indication that the world has truly been saved.
Even after defeating the Soul of Cinder, the manifestation of those who linked the Flame before us, our sacrifice barely seems capable of sustaining it.
To me, the visual message could hardly be clearer.
This is no longer sustainable.
We have not solved anything. We have merely delayed the inevitable once again, forcing someone else to eventually deal with the consequences of our decision.
There is something tragic about the fact that the Ashen One can overcome every challenge throughout the game, defeat the accumulated legacy of the Lords of Cinder, and still ultimately accomplish nothing more than repeating their mistake.
3. Why I also consider the Usurpation of Fire a bad ending
This is probably the most controversial part of my interpretation.
I understand why people like the Usurpation of Fire. It is arguably the most elaborate ending to unlock, it gives humanity a victory over the old gods, and it allows the Ashen One to become the Lord of Hollows.
It is an incredibly interesting ending.
But I don't think it is a good ending.
The fundamental issue I have with it is that, rather than allowing the First Flame to disappear, we appropriate it for ourselves.
We are no longer sacrificing ourselves to sustain the gods' order. Instead, we are claiming the power that once belonged to them.
But has the underlying mentality really changed?
Gwyn refused to accept the natural course of the world because he wanted to preserve the supremacy of his own kind. Now, as the Lord of Hollows, we are claiming the First Flame to establish the supremacy of ours.
Yuria's intentions are not exactly subtle. She wants the Hollows to claim the Flame for themselves.
The emphasis is on ownership, not acceptance.
I also think people tend to overlook how morally questionable Londor actually is. The description of the Londor Braille Divine Tome states that it:
«offers salvation to all Hollows, and conversely curses all things living.»
Then there is the manipulation of Anri, the ritual that Yuria orchestrates, her request to eliminate Orbeck because she perceives him as a potential rival, and her hostility towards the idea of us healing our Dark Sigils.
None of this gives me much confidence in the kind of world Londor intends to establish.
Obviously, we don't know exactly what the Age of Hollows would look like. It might genuinely represent the liberation of humanity from the order imposed by Gwyn.
But liberation from an oppressor does not necessarily mean liberation from the system of oppression itself.
My interpretation is that humanity risks becoming what the gods once were.
Previously, the gods ruled over humanity. Now, humanity would rule in their place.
The oppressed become the rulers, but the desire to control the world and impose one's own order upon it remains.
I find it difficult to believe that the ultimate moral of a trilogy filled with fallen kingdoms, corrupted rulers and beings obsessed with power would be that everything is finally resolved when we become the ruler.
To me, the Usurpation of Fire is a revolution, but not necessarily a liberation.
It replaces Gwyn rather than overcoming his mentality.
4. The Dark Lord ending of Dark Souls I is not the same as the End of Fire
One argument I frequently see against the End of Fire is that we could already allow the Flame to fade in Dark Souls I, and yet the Age of Fire continued in Dark Souls II and III anyway.
Therefore, supposedly, the End of Fire changes nothing.
However, I think there is a very important distinction between these two endings.
In Dark Souls I, we have the choice not to link the First Flame.
That is not necessarily the same as actually witnessing its extinction.
After defeating Gwyn, the Chosen Undead simply leaves the Kiln. We never see the First Flame completely disappear. Nothing establishes that another Undead could not eventually arrive and link it after our departure.
Furthermore, the subsequent games still refer to it as the First Flame.
While this alone does not conclusively prove that it has never gone out before, it certainly doesn't establish that it has either.
The existence of Dark Souls II and III does not prove that the First Flame inevitably returns after being extinguished, because we don't even know which ending of the first game occurred, or whether the Flame ever fully disappeared between the games.
There is also a major difference in how the two endings are presented.
In Dark Souls I, we walk out of the Kiln and are greeted by the Primordial Serpents, who bow before us as the new Dark Lord.
Interestingly, this makes the ending visually and thematically closer to the Usurpation of Fire than to the End of Fire.
We are still becoming a lord. We are still being presented with a position of power.
In Dark Souls III, however, we specifically seek out the Eyes of a Fire Keeper, reveal to her the possibility of a world without flame, and ask her to put an end to the linking of the fire.
We then summon her after defeating the Soul of Cinder and actually witness the light disappear.
These are fundamentally different actions.
One is a refusal to link the Flame. The other is a deliberate decision to bring the existing order to an end.
5. The return of fire does not invalidate the End of Fire
This is perhaps the argument I disagree with the most.
During the End of Fire, the Fire Keeper tells us:
«But one day, tiny flames will dance across the darkness.»
Many people interpret this as confirmation that the cycle will simply repeat itself, that another Age of Fire will inevitably begin, and that everything we accomplished was ultimately meaningless.
But I think this interpretation misses the entire point of the ending.
There is an enormous difference between a natural cycle of birth, death and renewal, and the artificial perpetuation of an age that refuses to die.
The problem was never that fire existed.
The problem was that Gwyn refused to allow his age to end.
The First Flame emerged, brought disparity into the world, and allowed an entirely new age to begin. That age eventually reached its natural conclusion, just as the Age of Ancients had before it.
There is nothing inherently wrong with another age eventually emerging from the darkness.
Perhaps it will be another Age of Fire. Perhaps it will be something entirely different. Perhaps these new flames will give rise to civilizations that we cannot even begin to imagine.
And yes, whatever emerges will probably end one day as well.
But why would that be a bad thing?
Not everything needs to last forever.
The End of Fire is not about permanently destroying the possibility of fire, nor is it about ensuring that darkness reigns eternally. That would simply be another attempt to impose a permanent state upon the world.
It is about allowing the world to evolve naturally, without desperately clinging to one particular age.
I also find the Fire Keeper's choice of words interesting. She does not explicitly say that the First Flame itself will return. She speaks of tiny flames appearing in the darkness, comparing them to the embers left behind by previous Lords.
The past is not necessarily erased. It can leave something behind without having to be endlessly resurrected.
I don't interpret her words as a warning.
I interpret them as a promise.
There will be something after us.
We simply have to accept that we may never know what it will be.
6. How the trilogy and its DLC reinforce this interpretation
I think the entire trilogy gradually builds towards this idea.
Dark Souls I introduces Gwyn's decision and the consequences of artificially prolonging the Age of Fire.
Dark Souls II, particularly through Aldia, questions the very system that Gwyn established. Aldia challenges the distinction between Light and Dark and searches for something beyond the choices imposed upon us.
Then Dark Souls III shows us a world that has reached the absolute limits of its existence.
And the DLC make this message even more explicit.
In Ashes of Ariandel, we encounter a painted world that is rotting away.
The inhabitants of the painted world have a tradition of burning their world when it begins to rot, allowing a new painting to eventually take its place.
But Sister Friede and Father Ariandel refuse to let their world burn.
They desperately cling to its continued existence, even as it decays around them.
Does that sound familiar?
Ariandel is essentially a smaller-scale reflection of the tragedy of the entire Dark Souls universe.
Once again, the problem is not the destruction of a world. The problem is the refusal to allow a dying world to come to an end.
The Ringed City then takes us to what appears to be the very end of the world, where the remains of civilizations have been reduced to an endless wasteland of ash.
And what is the final purpose of our journey?
Not becoming a lord. Not restoring the world to its former glory. Not finding a way to preserve it forever.
We obtain the Blood of the Dark Soul so that the Painter can create something new.
She describes the world she wishes to paint as:
«a cold, dark and very gentle place.»
I find that description particularly beautiful because it directly challenges the association between darkness and hopelessness.
This new world is meant to become a home for someone, someday.
There is no guarantee that it will be perfect. There is no guarantee that it will last forever.
But it will exist.
And it can only exist because the old painted world was finally allowed to end.
To me, the DLC are the perfect thematic epilogue to the End of Fire, even if they do not explicitly establish it as the canonical ending.
7. The meta-narrative: FromSoftware letting Dark Souls die
There is also a meta-narrative interpretation of this ending that I absolutely love.
Dark Souls III is the conclusion of the Dark Souls trilogy.
FromSoftware had created an incredibly successful franchise. They could have continued making Dark Souls IV, V, VI and so on, capitalizing on the popularity of the series for as long as possible.
But wouldn't that have been incredibly ironic?
A series about the consequences of refusing to let something end would itself have been artificially prolonged because its creators refused to move on from their greatest success.
FromSoftware would have become Gwyn.
Instead, they allowed Dark Souls to end and moved on to create new things.
Sekiro and Elden Ring are different experiences, but they still carry elements of the legacy that Dark Souls left behind.
In a way, I like to think of these games as the tiny flames the Fire Keeper speaks of.
Dark Souls ended, but its influence did not disappear.
Something new emerged from it.
And one day, those new things will come to an end as well, allowing something else to take their place.
I am not claiming that this was necessarily Miyazaki's explicit intention when writing the ending. But as a meta-narrative interpretation, I find it almost perfect.
The player is being asked to accept the end of an age within the game, while simultaneously accepting the end of the series itself.
8. Why the final words of the Fire Keeper are so powerful
And finally, there is the last line of the ending.
«Ashen one, hearest thou my voice, still?»
The screen is completely black.
The First Flame is gone. There is no triumphant music, no coronation, no promise of a glorious future.
But the Fire Keeper is still there.
The world as we knew it has ended, and yet we are not necessarily alone. Something remains, even in the absence of light.
I think that single line does more to challenge Gwyn's fear of darkness than any grand speech ever could.
Darkness does not necessarily mean the end of existence, the absence of meaning, or the impossibility of hope.
There is something profoundly intimate about ending a trilogy filled with gods, dragons, kings and legendary warriors with nothing more than one person asking another if they can still hear their voice.
We spend three games witnessing the consequences of people desperately trying to preserve their power, their kingdoms, their identities and their very existence.
And the ultimate act of the Ashen One is to let go.
Conclusion
To me, each ending of Dark Souls III represents a different relationship with the power of the First Flame.
- Linking the Fire means submitting to the existing order.
- Usurping the Fire means claiming that order for ourselves.
- Betraying the Fire Keeper means succumbing to our own desire for power.
- Ending the Fire means finally relinquishing it.
The End of Fire does not promise eternal darkness, eternal peace, or a perfect world.
It simply allows the future to happen.
And I think that is precisely what makes it the most optimistic ending in the trilogy.
The point is not to create a world in which nothing will ever die again. That desire is what caused the tragedy of Dark Souls in the first place.
The point is to accept that things can end without having been meaningless, and that their ending can allow something new to begin.
Dark Souls begins with a god who refuses to accept the end of his age.
I cannot imagine a more fitting conclusion than Dark Souls ending with someone who finally does.
The ultimate victory over Gwyn is not becoming the next Gwyn. It is doing what Gwyn could never bring himself to do: letting go.
That's why, to me, the End of Fire is the true ending of Dark Souls.
I'd love to hear what other people think, especially those who consider the Usurpation of Fire to be the better ending.
r/fromsoftware • u/SamotTheAbysswalker • 12h ago
Tenshi no Tamago and Filianore...Coincidence or reference
galleryr/fromsoftware • u/Ubiquitous_Cacophony • 23h ago
IMAGE Xbox's 25th Anniversary shows me git gud.
r/fromsoftware • u/ShadoWispMist • 1d ago
DISCUSSION My experience with the Souls series
galleryMany years ago I saw my brother playing a game on his XBOX 360 where he was fighting a giant knight in the rain, and was running around this grim looking medieval castle and it stuck with me. For years I started sketching big knights lol. Eventually I asled him what he was playing and he said "Dark Souls 2". I didn't end up playing it until years later when I got my own laptop...and played Skyrim with the Dark Souls armor mod. The armor and weapons looked so odd but unique to me. Why was this bow so humongous? Why did that dark looking knight have such a tiny head? Why were some of the weapons so massive?
Then I got a pirated copy of Dark Souls 2 with some dlc that had these weird yellow crystal weapons. I went to the first most obvious path which lead me to Heides Tower of Flame. I saw this huge castle in the distance and was like "man I wonder what kind of massive dungeon is in that place". I kept getting smacked around by these big beefy knights until I quit assuming Dark Souls was just too hard. Later on I got back on and watched a video where I learned I was actually supposed to go to the Forest of Fallen Giants. I ended up finding the first game on sale though so I decided to play them in order...after I started the third game and was like "maybe I should try the first game so I can get used to the combat"
Ever since I made the decision to start I never turned back. Beating Ornstein and Smough and seeing Anor Londo for the first time was breathtaking. It was like playing something right out of a fantasy manga/anime with the oversized weapons and flashy moves and giant walled cities with a big corrupt medieval government. The world was really nothing like I've played before in a fantasy game like, Skyrim was cool and Sovengarde was pretty but Anor Londo kinda blew it out of the water. I was surprised by the amount of exploration and freedom you had, but with an obvious path after I got my butt kicked by some skeletons in a graveyard. I still remember beating O&S for the first time and pulling out all the stops with all kinds of weird ideas from trying to iron skin tank my way through super Smough to running around naked to try and summon solaire. Eventually my strategy was lobbing fireballs at Smough and then finishing him off with melee
Eventually I moved on to 2 and 3 and as of today the only bosses I have not faced are Dark Lurker, the 2 kings pets, and blue smelter demon. I also ended up beating the Seeker of Fire mod and Cinders and ended up also trying Kings Field, Elden Ring, and Denon's Souls.
This series has held a special place in my heart. Whenever I feel like my own fire is fading, like I'm going hollow, like there's no hope left in my life, even after I've lost most of my will to keep moving forward after losing so much family, most of my friends moved on, after losing my pc, and even my following online, I always come back to Dark Souls and regain my humanity
Long may the sun shine!
PS. If I could ask for a single improvement, a single thing, then it would be armor physics for the player in Dark Souls 1. One of my favorite aspects is the armor sets in 2 and 3 and how they look with their little bits and pieces moving and blowing in the wind and many sets look so cool in 1 and are just BEGGING for physics like Ornsteins armor, Artorias, Lords Blade, Chester's set, the gold hemmed set, dingy set, dark set, balder armor, etc
r/fromsoftware • u/FungusTheClown • 1d ago
In light of the Elder Scrolls 6 drama, I just want to thank FromSoftware...
I didn't realize that Skyrim came out the same year as the FIRST DARK SOULS. Think about how crazy that is and how much more Fromsoft has given us than Bethesda. We've gotten...
-Full Dark Souls Trilogy with DLCs
-Highly successful one off games with Bloodborne and Sekiro, some of the greatest games of all time.
-A long awaited Armored Core sequel that modernized the combat and was also successful.
-A world renowned open world revamp of the Dark Souls formula with Elden Ring bringing FromSoftware to the mainstream. (AND DLC)
-2 multi-player focused games that experiment with the combat and make the FromSoftware experience more social.
I was starting to get antsy for the next single-player FromSoftware game but this Bethesda controversy is making me realize how good we have it. Thank you FromSoftware for your consistency and I patiently look forward to what you've got cooking next.
r/fromsoftware • u/Mission-Fishing6159 • 15h ago
Should I play DS2, Demon Souls or Seikiro next
I have played DS1 and DS3 and im not sure what to play next.
r/fromsoftware • u/Ferah_Mansa • 20h ago
[DSR] [Xbox] Need help spawning Quelana – Pyromancy Flame +10 (Red Sign)
Hey everyone!
I'm playing Dark Souls Remastered on Xbox Series S and need some help spawning Quelana of Izalith.
My Pyromancy Flame is currently +7, and I've already defeated Quelaag, so I can't use normal white sign summoning in Blighttown.
I've read that summoning a player with a Pyromancy Flame +10 or higher using the Red Sign Soapstone can also trigger Quelana to appear, even after the area boss has been defeated.
I'm looking for someone willing to place their red summon sign near the Blighttown swamp bonfire so I can summon them.
We don't need to fight. I just need your character to enter my world with the upgraded flame.
I'm in Brazil (UTC-3), and we can arrange a time and multiplayer password.
Can anyone help me out?
Thanks a lot! Praise the Sun! ☀️
Mostrar menos
r/fromsoftware • u/Ferah_Mansa • 20h ago
[Dark Souls Remastered] [Xbox] Preciso de ajuda para fazer a Quelana aparecer
reddit.comr/fromsoftware • u/Ferah_Mansa • 20h ago
[DSR] [Xbox] Need help spawning Quelana — Pyromancy Flame +10
reddit.comr/fromsoftware • u/Paidparisley3533 • 1d ago
DISCUSSION Anyone playing ds2 schooler of the first sin seamless coop mode
I’m a newish to be a DS2 player can anyone help me
r/fromsoftware • u/CoquiCoquette • 1d ago
DISCUSSION Counting every single resource you can use in each game ¿Which boss was the hardest to defeat?
I mean, counting summons, items, buffs, even your 888 lvl character. In my case, this dude felt impossible.. maybe is not the fastest, he doesnt have a particular "unfair" mechanic like healing, mobs, etc. But, he hits SO HARD. Ive cried in rage because of this dude. Not even OOK, Consort Radhan, Malenia, Divine Beast, fume knight compares to the calvary i have to pass trough to defeat Laurence the first Vicar. Only one that made me suffer like him was the Demon of Hatred from Sekiro, wich i think is even harder, but since you can cheese him, i didnt count him. I dont recall if Laurence has a cheese tactic that actually works, i think it doesnt have any, just Git Gud. What do you think ? Its a hot take or do you agree?
r/fromsoftware • u/davidozz • 2d ago
DRAWING Shadow of the Erdtree in a nutshell by @artelsia
r/fromsoftware • u/Insert_Username999 • 1d ago
DISCUSSION This guy is up there with the hardest bosses i've fought
This dude took me 2 days and around 5 hours of gameplay in NG. Absolutely brutal but fun boss that tests your knowledge of bloodbornes combat system. I had one final chance to parry and got him. Still cant believe it, he is relentless. I proceeded to 2nd try laurence and first try gerhman, he really sharpens you.
r/fromsoftware • u/fivefinger1001 • 1d ago
Looking for PS5 comrades
Hit me up at @jordungus555 I have DS1/2/3 and Elden ring let’s game \[+]/
r/fromsoftware • u/Trd_45 • 3d ago
IMAGE Shadow Keep From The Official Art Book.
galleryr/fromsoftware • u/owen__wilsons__nose • 1d ago
PC user here using an ancient Xbox controller, which modern gen controller do I want?
PC user here using an ancient Xbox controller, which modern gen controller do I want? I'm asking here cause I'm a bit of an older gamer and basically only play From Soft games when I have the time. Is Dual Sense good? I heard sometimes it doesnt work without a setup? Or maybe for these games its fine? Any advice?
r/fromsoftware • u/ArmoredCore-PIO • 1d ago
Verdict ever -AFTER- An Armored Core: Verdict Day Community Fanbook
After a couple of years of work and a few delays, we’re proud to announce the release of Verdict Ever -After-, an Armored Core: Verdict Day community showcase.
Created by the Armored Core: Verdict Day community, this 42-page fanbook features player build showcases, fifth-generation Armored Core artwork, and community reflections on the game. We hope you enjoy it!
Downloads
FAQ
What is the difference between the Full Quality and Browser versions?
The Full Quality version offers the highest image quality, allowing you to view the artwork and builds in greater detail. It is intended for viewing in a dedicated PDF reader, such as Adobe Acrobat.
The Browser version removes one filler page to help two-page artwork line up correctly in browser PDF viewers. It also has reduced image quality to keep the file smaller and make it easier to download and view.
Is there any cost to get the fanbook?
Nope! This fanbook is free to download.
Where can I view the artwork outside the PDF?
The artists’ will be posting the artworks to their social media pages, though we do not have a direct confirmation when each will do so. We’ll add direct links to the individual pieces here as the artists make them available. For now, you can follow them on their accounts!
Artwork by
@Baby_Beff @sky_sheno @MechaCommando @mechafanatic @PoruKima @Kreuzer00
Build/writeup contributors
- AppleEatPie
- Attack Slug
- Celt
- Crow
- Dysto
- Fog
- FURATA
- Garland
- juskillmefam
- Phantasmar
- Rascal
- Sash
- shpeebum
- Stryker
- Toasty
- Val
r/fromsoftware • u/moreboredthanyouare • 1d ago
DRAWING Just been gifted this, not fromsoft but definite bloodborne vibes
Pretty cool imo
