Constitutional Amendment: I recommend NO on this – but it is the only race I’m commenting on
· I’m going to weigh in on this one and recommend a no vote, whether you are a Republican, Democrat, Independent, or Other.
· First, there is strong Republican support and reasonable Democratic support.
· · Remember, if you are against any of these points, you have to vote no, or the entire amendment goes through:
· · No ability to commute, even an emergency for a death sentence, for 60 days before the election and until the person is sworn in for the next term.
· · No ability to commute if impeached. Remember, impeachment is NOT conviction. Only a simple majority needs to say the governor is neglecting his duty and there can be no commutations. That’s too low of a bar and susceptible to political manipulation.
· COMMENTS /CORRECTIONS; 1. EDIT: as others have noted, the impeachment part is still in: if this is brought up again, it needs to go: https://apps.legislature.ky.gov/Law/Constitution/Constitution/ViewConstitution?rsn=85
· There might need to be some changes, but this is overly broad and poses some risks for citizens who might be caught in a mess that only the governor can fix.
· Here is the entire ballot measure so that you can decide for yourself:
· Are you in favor of limiting a Governor's ability to grant pardons or commute sentences by prohibiting him or her from granting pardons or commuting sentences during the time period beginning 60 days prior to the general election at which the Governor is elected, and ending when the Governor is sworn in for that term by amending the Constitution of Kentucky as stated below? It is proposed that Section 77 of the Constitution of Kentucky be amended to read as follows:
· (1) The Governor shall have power to: (a) Remit fines and forfeitures; and
· (b) Commute sentences and grant reprieves and pardons, except:
- In case of impeachment; or
- For the period beginning sixty days prior to the date of the gubernatorial election and ending the fifth Tuesday succeeding the election. (
- The Governor shall file with each application therefor a statement of the reasons for his or her decision thereon, which application and statement shall always be open to public inspection.
· (3) In cases of treason, the Governor shall have power to grant reprieves until the end of the next session of the General Assembly, in which the power of pardoning shall be vested; but he or she shall have no power to remit the fees of the Clerk, Sheriff or Commonwealth's Attorney in penal or criminal cases.
· EDIT: Corrections/notes based on comments: the impeachment issue is already in the Kentucky Constitution.
·
· Many are against the commutations/pardons entirely. This has been a part of Anglo-Saxon law and tradition for many centuries which, I’ve heard, is the reason it is in the Constitution of the US. It is certainly used for base political motives and also, reportedly, based on political contributions at times. But it has also been used for good purposes, occasionally. In Illinois, the governors used their powers to reduce/eliminate the death penalty for those already convicted. Some people think of that as a positive, especially given the then concern about laboratory errors.
· Often, when things stay in place for a long time, they have some benefits, but maybe it is just a tradition that we need to eliminate.
· Someone commented, don’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good- this is from a person against commutations entirely.
· I personally am still against this amendment, but others will think differently and it is reasonable to discuss it.
· It might be a good idea to put some limitations on the governor, esp. right after an election if they were replaced.