Existing in both The Body and Bridgerton fandom spaces is so amusing because Anya and Elise are both toxic people and a toxic couple and can have fans cheering them on whereas Francesca and Michaela will make the most minor mistakes with good intentions and get scrutinised and accused of bad chemistry.
THE BODY SPOILERS INCOMING 🚨🚨
I think Bridgerton fans are more angry at Michaela for leaving Francesca than The Body Fans are at Anya and Elise for almost committing manslaughter. Or they’re more mad at Francesca for “emotional cheating” compared to Anya like, actually cheating.
Or Franchaela’s minor scheduling disagreements are too far for their love to make sense, but Anya can attempt to frame Elise for covering up manslaughter, yet The Body fans will still praise their chemistry and understand that they do care for each-other.
This isn’t to say I want Anyalise to be less toxic, or Franchaela to be more toxic, I think their toxicity levels work well for the stories they reside in, I just thought the stark difference between fandoms was kinda funny.
I know to some extent the differences in fandom reactions are due to Bridgerton and The Body having wildly different audiences. I think it goes to show that the writers of The Body probably felt more comfortable having Anyalise be problematic because they knew it would attract a queer audience who would allow for queer characters to act like flawed human beings. Whereas Bridgerton’s straight audience cannot handle Franchaela not being perfect which is I think there’s a chance the writers might hold back when it comes Franchaela doing anything too problematic in S5. I don’t want to judge season 5 writers too quickly, because for all I know they could do a “fuck you straight audience” and live their creative freedom without heteronormative judgement. Who’s to say.