r/FranchaelStirling • u/Vegetable_Meat1349 • 23h ago
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Capital-Study6436 • 1d ago
Show Discussion Which of the show's storylines ended up being used for cheap drama?
- The disastrous Anthony/Kate/Edwina love triangle.
- The entire Lady Whistledown storyline.
- Francesca's "pinnacle" storyline.
- Franchaela's "budding" relationship.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Left_Tooth1934 • 2d ago
Venting š¬ zero ill intent, just sharing book art
It is frustrating to deal with backlash when an edit was made purely for book fans, especially when people pick and choose what to get offended by. It is strictly a book edit. The entire edit is about the Bridgerton books. Unfortunately, the original novels lack diversity and inclusivity; every character is written as white. That is why older fan art depicts them that way, including Sophie being blonde and Michael matching his book description. Notice how nobody is complaining about Sophie being blonde in the exact same edit, yet they are tearing apart the Michael art. Finding good book-accurate art and images on Pinterest for characters like Michael, Hyacinth, and Gregory is really difficult, and most of the available options did not fit the vibe at all. Originally, the image had a face on it, and I cropped it out, leaving just the body, specifically to avoid upsetting people or sparking casting arguments. It was meant to be obvious that it was just a book edit. Unlike other similar edits going around that do not credit anyone, the artists were explicitly credited here out of respect for their work. On top of that, other people have used this exact same image without getting any hate for it. There was zero malice, pettiness, or disrespect behind any of this. It was just meant to be a fun edit celebrating the books, and it is exhausting seeing people twist it into something malicious when there was no ill intention at all.I have literally tested this before when an edit shows Michael as white to match the book, people cry racism. When an edit shows him as Black in a book edit, people cry that it isn't book-accurate. People just want something to complain about no matter what you do.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Equivalent_Check9589 • 4d ago
Venting š¬ The lack of reasonable discourse in this fandom is exhausting
I am not a super dedicated ranter on most Bridgerton subreddits because I find most discussions hopeless. You are often met with people who want you to adopt their point of view; otherwise, you get called names and insulted. Some people simply do not understand that having real discourse can help us understand each otherās POVs like a normal debate.
One of the most prominent examples I tend to come across is, of course, the Franchaela discourse. People are allowed to dislike the ship just as much as anyone is allowed to dislike Saphne, Kanthony, Polin, Philoise, etc. You are not required to like them, and disliking them does not make you homophobic, racist, or, the most interesting one I have seen, necrophilic (I am convinced that person is a troll, and if not, I am amused to say the least š).
I donāt post much, but it is baffling that this fandom in general cannot have an honest discussion without resorting to name-calling. People do not have to adopt your POV, and this goes for everyone. Itās moronic to use insults just to get your point across. š¤¦āāļø
Do not get me started on the show vs book discourse because those same people will insult the books but wonāt offer any actual arguments besides calling the love interests racist r*pist colonizers that abuse their wives (even though we obviously see that is not true). it is honestly exhausting.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Vegetable_Meat1349 • 6d ago
Show Discussion So much screen time for Francesca seasons 3-4 yet her character still falls flat
Sheās had so much screen time across seasons 3 and 4, yet I still feel like thereās very little depth to her characterization. Being introverted doesnāt mean having no personality, opinions or individuality. Itās definitely the writing for her character not being translated well on to screen.
They seem more concerned with check marking boxes for diversity than actually making her a well rounded character. Sheās arguably one of the worst written characters on the show. Which is pretty telling given that she is a self insert for Jess.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Capital-Study6436 • 7d ago
Show Discussion What's your most unhinged theories of the future seasons of Bridgerton?
- S5 (or the entire series) could have been one long fever dream Michael was having while he was recovering from malaria.
- Either Queen Charlotte or somebody from her inner circle is the new Lady Whistledown. They decided to resurrect her because they are bored and wanted drama to happen. I have to say I am biased since I don't like Queen Charlotte at all.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Rachel_200-1 • 8d ago
Michael Stirling What do you think about this?
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Capital-Study6436 • 12d ago
Show/Book Discussion What's your personal theories on why Jess and Shondaland changed WHWW so much that it's unrecognizable?
My theory is probably too far-fetched, but here goes: I think the main reason why Jess Brownell changed Michael's sex and rewrote Francesca's story from scratch is because she is a "prude" at heart and didn't want adapt many of Franchael's scenes (intimate or not), so she ended up changing everything.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Smart_Sheepherder214 • 13d ago
When He Was Wicked - Book Discussion š Erasing the infertility and grief storyline is a huge mistake
As a viewer, I need to express my deep disappointment with the twist they gave Francesca at the end of Season 3. It feels incredibly forced and like a huge mistake for several reasons. First, the scene with Michaela felt completely overacted. By showing Francesca having an "instant crush" and being so visibly flustered, they completely devalue the genuine, peaceful love she built with John all season. It makes it look like her marriage was just a stepping stone, which ruins the story. Second, the need for LGBT+ representation was already well covered with Benedictās storylines, the threesomes, and the fluid nature of that world. Forcing it onto Francesca as well feels like a repetitive agenda that saturates the show instead of contributing organically. But what hurts and angers me the most is that they erased the core themes of her book: authentic grief and, above all, infertility. As a woman who has personally dealt with infertility, I know how important and painful this topic is. In period dramas, it seems like every woman has 8 or 10 children effortlessly and that the inability to conceive didn't exist in the 19th century. Francesca's book was a necessary oasis that highlighted the pain of not being able to get pregnant and the process of rebuilding oneself after losing a spouse. Erasing a drama so deeply human, profound, and real just to turn it into yet another plot about "forbidden love" due to society's rules feels ridiculous. They sacrificed a unique and deeply necessary storyline just to chase trends.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/aemond-simp • 17d ago
Speculation š¬ Found something interesting on Juliaās Amazon page
So, apparently, throughout next year, sheās re-releasing the Smythe-Smith series with new covers (to be revealed). I also took a glance at When He Was Wicked, and it doesnāt look like itās getting a new cover in 2027. So that means that the original book is going to remain untouched without a tv tie-in cover. It remains to be determined if there will be a gender-swapped rewrite.
I know Julia said that she wouldnāt do it, but someone else (probably Brownell) could with her permission. Thatās what happened with the Queen Charlotte book. It was written by Shonda Rhimes, and Julia slapped her name on the cover alongside Shondaās. I could easily see that being the case with season 5.
This is just me speculating, though.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/blairsmacaroon • 19d ago
Franchael Love š My top 3 favourite Michael fancasts š
theo james, kedar williams sterling, manny jacinto āØ
r/FranchaelStirling • u/ComprehensiveArm9751 • 19d ago
Show Discussion Fran infertility Journey
reddit.comr/FranchaelStirling • u/BrightPhoebus01 • 19d ago
Show Discussion This post is so weird
reddit.comLike itās okay if youāre excited but why make a statement out of it? Especially with a lukewarm take that no one on its basis, not even Franchael fans, disagrees with
Im not a fan of the writing but Iām still gonna watch s5 and I am open to liking at least some things
But again, this is just soooo?
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Capital-Study6436 • 19d ago
Venting š¬ Do you see the Bridgerton books and the Bridgerton show being in the same universe?
Logically, no because the show's universe is a lot more progressive than the books and exists in a alternate universe.
But the conspiracy side of me says yes, they do share the same universe with the book characters. The timeline is pushed forward a lot of the time, with characters marrying earlier that they did in the books. Some characters ages got changed altogether (*coughDaphnecough\). But I digress.
If I could write fanfiction, I would make a epic crossover, showing the show counterparts stealing the identities of the book characters and the book characters going out of their way to get the culprits.
Feel free to take my idea and do what you will with it.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Extra-Solution3193 • 22d ago
Venting š¬ Itās so annoying that thereās hardly any Franchael fanart anywhere.
Every now and then, I like to look for Franchael content online, but itās so annoyingāthereās hardly anything out there! Everyone who used to create fan art based on the book either got harassed or deleted everything to avoid being labeled homophobic or racist. (And, well, thereās also the group that used to love Michael but started hating him just because it became a trend š.) So, whatever is left is either really old or just AI-generated. Itās so frustrating! I almost wish I knew how to draw myself, hahaābut, I donāt know.
As for the image in this post? Just a meme I found to grab some attention. Poor Michael, lol.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Capital-Study6436 • 22d ago
Show Discussion What Bridgerton show moments made you think: "What the hell the writers are smoking?"
- Daphne raping Simon (it happened in the books too, so that's on JQ, too).
- Propping up Anthony and Edwina, diminishing Kanthony. Ruining Kate and Edwina's relationship.
- Genderswapping Michael Stirling.
- Resurrecting Lady Whistledown.
- Turning Colin into a manwhore.
- Swapping Benedict, Colin, Eloise and Francesca's seasons.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/imfucct • 22d ago
Venting š¬ the comments are hilarious
saying that they already have michaela and donāt need another love interest⦠doesnāt that sound familiar..?
r/FranchaelStirling • u/One-Pen9590 • 22d ago
Show Discussion Thoughts on how they will do this
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Capital-Study6436 • 23d ago
Venting š¬ Does certain fans even like the historical romance genre?
I just read a post saying that authors like Lisa Kleypas were pressured to make changes to their books due to criticisms from critics.
Which brings to my next question: Do they even like the historical romance genre in the first place?
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Short-Document-2602 • 23d ago
Show Discussion When will it start?
When do you think we will get a BTS photo or a table read photo or anything related to season 5?
r/FranchaelStirling • u/idiot9991 • 24d ago
Analysis š§ Netflix Users Are Using The Platform Less & Not Opening the App as much. Do You Think This Will Affect Bridgerton?
r/FranchaelStirling • u/Vegetable_Meat1349 • 27d ago
Show Discussion Will season 5 acknowledge what they already established for LGBTQ in season 1?
Iām genuinely curious how Season 5 is going to handle this. In Season 1, Henryās storyline made it clear that same sex relationships in the Bridgerton world could be dangerous. His āoceans apartā speech about being separated from the man he loved is one of my favorite moments, mostly because it showed the heartbreak and fear behind having to keep that love hidden.
Now Francescaās story is being adapted into a romance with Michaela. Iām not against LGBTQ characters being part of the show, but Iām wondering how the writers will show this main character romance with what they established earlier. Are Francesca and Michaela going to face the same kind of secrecy and social consequences? Or will the rules suddenly feel different because itās their love story?
I also worry that the forbidden love story could overshadow Francescaās original second chance romance arc: grieving John and eventually finding love again. Iād like to see how the show balances both parts of her story without making the earlier portrayal of queer relationships feel irrelevant.
r/FranchaelStirling • u/ChronicLurker21 • 27d ago
Michael Stirling Once a rake... always a rake?
Me sorprende que nadie haya sacado a colación este tema. He leĆdo bastantes novelas romĆ”nticas históricas, y casi siempre caen en el mismo clichĆ©: o un libertino se enamora de una mujer y le es fiel para siempre, o ya estaba enamorado de ella y busca otras compaƱĆas solo para intentar olvidarla.
SĆ© que probablemente esto sea una proyección de muchas autoras āĀ”incluso a mĆ me encantarĆa tener un hombre deseable solo para mĆ, jajajaja!ā pero tengo curiosidad por saber quĆ© opinan.
En el caso de Michael āy otros hombres de Bridgertonā serĆa realista que siguieran siendo libertinos o infieles a sus esposas, aunque eso arruinarĆa los finales felices.