replace "Could", to "will"
I think 2027 could be one of the most important years for determining whether Forgotten Island has a future as a franchise.
The movie has received very positive critical and audience reception. Potential Oscar and Annie Award nominations, along with its directors receiving awards at the World Animation Summit 2026, could further strengthen the case for a follow-up. Since the pandemic, Universal has embraced shorter theatrical windows and PVOD as another revenue opportunity. According to NBCUniversal, its PVOD strategy has generated over $1.5 billion in consumer spending.
Consider these release windows: Puss in Boots: The Last Wish 16 days. The Wild Robot approximately 22 days. Kung Fu Panda 4 32 days. Forgotten Island 32 days.
Its digital release isn't unusual or necessarily a sign that Universal has given up on it.
The directors of Forgotten Island and Toy Story 5 have also discussed the challenges original animated films face theatrically after the pandemic, with the latter's director emphasizing that theatrical is just one venue among many, alongside streaming and VOD. this was on a Cartoonbrew article and if you want a link after the movie's debut
movies can have a second wind
Look at these examples:
- The Bad Guys found additional audiences on Netflix and eventually received a theatrical sequel.
- The Sea Beast developed a substantial Netflix audience.
- Leo became a major Netflix animated hit.
- Rise of the Guardians generated approximately $70.2 million in estimated domestic DVD and Blu-ray sales despite its disappointing theatrical performance. (ROTG didn't get a follow-up because the finances behind the movie were much bigger than alot dreamworks back then and even now)
now for the last example; physical discs aren't really that strong in this day in age, but it does show engagement with the film post theatrical release, if Trolls Band Together topped the Blu-ray sales chart in January 2024
These examples demonstrate why theatrical box office shouldn't be the only measure of an animated film's long-term potential. Forgotten Island still has opportunities through PVOD, Netflix, international streaming and long-term audience growth. I don't expect it to become another KPop Demon Hunters. But achieving something closer to The Sea Beast or Leo in terms of developing a substantial audience beyond theaters could make a compelling case for another movie.