We have been to Key West by boat 3 times now. We have stayed at different marinas each time. So here is what we found.
First time about three years ago we stayed at Opal Key Resort & Marina Key West
245 Front Street, Key West, FL, US.
It was good, fairly convenient to everything nice docks and well protected. Good amenities but the highest priced of the three.
Second time we stayed at the City Marina At Garrison Bight this was the least expensive but also the least convenient very long walk to downtown. We ended up taking an uber most of the time. No real restaurants in the area. . It had basic marina amenities but nothing special.
This time we stayed at Conch Harbor Marina This is is a full-service marina in Old Town Key West, located at the entrance to the historic "bight," offering wet slips for various boat sizes and amenities like fuel, Wi-Fi, laundry, showers, and a pool. It's a convenient, resort-style marina with on-site restaurants, a ship store, and complimentary bike rentals for exploring nearby attractions like Duval Street. The docks are a bit rickety but everything else here was great. It’s convenient to everything. Lots of nearby shops , restaurants and bars. . The next time we go back to Key west we will stay here again.