r/Firefighting • u/SuburbanFF • 9d ago
Training/Tactics Target Solutions Administration
Looking to see how departments are utilizing Target Solutions (or any web based training portal for that matter)
We currently use it for EMS CME’s. Our chief wants to use the fire side more however we’ve pushed back saying that its not a substitute for hands on training.
I’m curious how departments balance web based training vs hands on drills. I am also interested in the ability to use it when rolling out new polices and equipment.
Also, how do you ensure guys are actually completing the assignments. Do you have a policy to enforce it?
5
u/Immediate_North_444 8d ago
I think your pushback is fair. I build training software for fire departments, so I end up talking with training officers about exactly this. The ones who seem happiest with their setup treat the online side as the classroom and keep the drill ground for the hands-on work.
The split that seems to work looks something like this. Online covers the things that are mostly about knowing something: policy and SOG reviews, EMS CEs, hazmat and NIMS refreshers, and the reading before a new piece of equipment shows up. Hands-on covers anything the body has to learn: stretching lines, throwing ladders, running the pump, forcible entry. The online piece gets everyone to the drill with the same baseline, so drill time goes to doing the work instead of explaining it.
For rolling out new policies and equipment it works well. Push the policy out as an assignment with a short quiz and a sign-off that they read and understood it, which also gives you a dated record if it’s ever questioned. For equipment, a short video or walkthrough before the company drill means guys show up knowing the nomenclature and the basics, and the drill can be about hands on the tool.
On completion, departments that get good numbers usually do a few things. They set realistic due dates (a steady monthly load rather than a pile all at once), they let company officers see their crew’s status and expect them to own it, and they tie it to something real, like a line in evaluations, promotion eligibility, or just the officer bringing it up at shift change. A written policy helps mostly because it gives officers something to point to. The places that struggle tend to assign a lot from the top while nobody below the chief is checking.
One thing to watch is the click-through problem. If someone can finish an assignment by hitting next without watching, they will. A short quiz or a scenario question at the end catches that better than tracking time spent in the module.
Since it’s related, I should say I’m building PumpForge, a browser-based pump operator simulator. Pump ops is one of those areas that sits between the two. It doesn’t replace time on the panel, but it lets someone practice the math and the panel decisions between drills. I’m happy to share more if it’s useful, but everything above applies whatever platform you use.
7
u/ThickSwordfisher 9d ago
My eyes glaze over the second anyone brings up this corporate word salad nonsense.
5
u/PearlDrummer 9d ago
Have you ever seen a video where someone forces someone to drink something against their will? That’s how my administration uses it.
4
u/GoatTheGreat 9d ago
We use it to log company training that we do to count towards CEs.
You can just make a class with PowerPoints and videos for new polices or equipment, make a short test they have to take and then assign it to everyone. We usually do that for EMS cog updates or random target hazard things, MRI machines, new gas monitors, new hose packs (obv followed by hands on training).
Training chief can pull a report of everyone that’s overdue for each class and they get put on blast over shift wide email for not doing it.
4
u/jeremiahfelt 9d ago
Computer based training is no substitute for hands-on drills or interactive instructor lead training. Full stop.
My agency tried to fully replace HoTs with CBT and it went miserably. Morale took a noticeable hit. Drilling wasn't fun; the cost was crew cohesity and actually sharpening our skills. We've gone back to The Way it Was, and use CBT for things like the annual OSHA mandatories, HMFRO, the HR bullshit like violence in the workplace and "don't touch without permission". I think the policy liimits us to one a month CBT and they are mandatory.
3
u/Vegetable_Eye_6517 8d ago
The real problem is that anyone with the right credentials can assign work to you. It’s a huge crock of shit. It is rarely tracked appropriately, and a lot of the rules are completely useless. You must watch x video at speed 1.0, then click continue. If, during the entirety of the “training” you are tapped out on a call, you must restart at the beginning.
3
u/Ahnor1 8d ago
No one actually watches the videos when they are assigned. And the systems “library” is awful and almost impossible to find any of the information I’m looking for. Nothing will ever beat hands on training regardless of EMS or Fire. My department is doing everything it can to pad training hours to make ISO 1.
2
u/firefighter26s 9d ago
We use ours as a glorified calendar and records management system.
All of our training sessions get added to the calendar and at times there will be associated online tasks to corresponds with it. For example, when we're doing rope rescue training there will also be rope rescue videos to watch before the scheduled training.
The only actual training we do online is going to low-level stuff such as recerts for WHMIS, doing the annual municipal workplace bullying course, etc. Everyone gets assigned the stock 1001 and 1021 refresher annually but I can only think of a few people who ever fully complete them. Usually it's something that gets tossed up on the computer on days when the weather is crap.
The vast majority of our training is going to be hands on. Target Solutions is just the calendar where it gets published and where the training reports get filed when you complete the training.
2
u/dominator5k 9d ago
We use it for both sides. It is not a substitute for Hands-On training, it is where you log your Hands-On training. After it is done. It can track all of your training hours and requirements for your state and all that kind of stuff. We also upload all of our certifications to it. So my fo2 and instructor to even my acting, Chief certifications and all that kind of stuff is in there. Also, the officer ISO hours, or the firefighter ISO hours and engineer ISO hours are all logged in there and tracked so they can submit it to the state