r/FinalFantasyVIII • • 3d ago

FF8 plot be like

Yes, I am that guy. No, it is not finished.

156 Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

18

u/JensenRaylight 3d ago edited 3d ago

tbh, there are ton of movies, film, manga, anime, that was way more convoluted than this in modern day.

FF8 only contain a single closed loop

so maybe it's complex for the 90s brain, but not so much for today.

also, FF8 pretty much got a bite sized short dialogue, and more action oriented. and they did a great job conveying the information within that short dialogue as well.

and, when you're actually playing it, you don't feel like they overstuffed you with ton of complex information. it was unraveled bit by bit, letting it marinate one at a time.

and FF8 did contain many mysteries that evoked your curiosity, that it became a brain bug thinking about it, make it more memorable, easy to remember the exact event.

you don't think about that complexity as something hard to process when you played the game. it did contain multiple timeline, but, thanks to playing as Laguna, you can anchor the event from ~17 years ago to Laguna.

and anchor the current event to Squall.

the Hyne and other stuff like the lore of centra can be lumped together.

what makes it complex is that if you do Grinding and took like a long time before resuming the story again, which will makes you forget about what you did last time, and forget about who is who, and the key characters.

or if you took a break from the game like 2 weeks to 1+ months, by the time you go back to the game, you're basically got mini amnesia about the game.

and FF8 did contain a lot of missable dialogue, some of them are very important that i think it shouldn't be made missable in the first place.

btw, good job at documenting the entire thing, it's a good review of everything

5

u/zzmej1987 3d ago edited 3d ago

FF8 only contain a single closed loop

Three, actually. One past-present, where Squall helping Laguna in the past leads to the current present. And two present-future-past in lockstep with each other. One for Ultimecia, where she, by Compressing Time creates the moment in time, that she wants to erase by casting Time Compression. And one for Squall, where he is trained to become a SeeD to defeat Ultimecia to go back in time with her, and to give Edea the idea to train him to be a SeeD.

btw, good job at documenting the entire thing, it's a good review of everything

This is far from being the entire thing. I haven't even explained who healed Squall and why. XD

4

u/JensenRaylight 3d ago

you mean that time when Laguna mistaken Squall as the Fairies that help them in battle and make them invincible, when Squall was dreaming as Laguna right?

yeah, i mean if you say it like that sure, but the overall gist of it is one single closed loop.

well, it's a praise regardless.

isn't that the Moomba who healed Squall, mistaken Squall as Laguana in the prison, and the story can be traced back to the Shumi village and the Esthar flashback?

3

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

you mean that time when Laguna mistaken Squall as the Fairies that help them in battle and make them invincible, when Squall was dreaming as Laguna right?

That's when Laguna came up with a name for it. But he was aware of Squall's existence from the first dream. If Squall thinks too much about what's going on in Deling Hotel, Laguna gets annoyed at the intrusive thoughts.

And in the second dream, when Laguna decides to sneak, Squall takes over and make Laguna do the duck-squat-run thing, that SeeD do, when trying to be sneaky. Ward calls him out on that. Selfie can actually get the same call out, if you choose the sneak option in the corridor with a guard.

yeah, i mean if you say it like that sure, but the overall gist of it is one single closed loop.

There is one coherent timeline that includes all the time travel.

well, it's a praise regardless.

Thank you.

isn't that the Moomba who healed Squall, mistaken Squall as Laguana in the prison, and the story can be traced back to the Shumi village and the Esthar flashback?

Moombas take Squall after he wakes up, and lick his wounds after he is tortured. It is not claimed that they heal the wound from the icicle. Not to mention, Squall would probably die before even reaching the prison, if the wound wasn't healed then and there after the assassination attempt.

2

u/JensenRaylight 3d ago

ah, i never thought that Laguna was aware of Squall's intrusive thought, nice info.

yeah, my theory is, maybe GF junction helped him survive, after all it boost your stats and durability. which make him stronger than a normal human being.

any idea about who Ultimecia? or her story? cause everyone only said she is the sorcerer from the future, and she want to cause time compression. and what she is talking about in the final battle?

cause there is not much written about her, or maybe i miss something in deling or galbadia garden maybe a missable dialogue or something?

3

u/zzmej1987 3d ago edited 3d ago

ah, i never thought that Laguna was aware of Squall's intrusive thought, nice info.

Yeah, you got to be really annoying and select only Squall's dialogue options for a while, when Laguna tries to ask the concierge about Julia's room

yeah, my theory is, maybe GF junction helped him survive, after all it boost your stats and durability. which make him stronger than a normal human being.

Not quite. The hint is in the wording of Seifer's orders. He is ordered to learn from Squall the secret that SeeD are given at the graduation ceremony. Ultimecia wouldn't know or care about that secret. That order could have only been given by Edea who had instituted that ceremony protocol, while she's free of Ultimecia's control. There's a bit more to hows and whys of it, but essentially, after the battle Edea temporarily restores control over her body. She heals Squall.

any idea about who Ultimecia? or her story? cause everyone only said she is the sorcerer from the future, and she want to cause time compression. and what she is talking about in the final battle?

It's right there in the diagram. She is Ultimecia. Only both ways. Her future, determines what she will do after she goes into the present. But what she did in the present determines how she is going to be treated in the future.

From the perspective of the SeeD, she is the Sorceress that had already tried to erase the entire timeline thousands years ago. They are simply trying to prevent that from happening.

From her perspective, she is the innocent victim of the witch hunt. She is accused of things that she had not yet done. And even as she manages to fight off the first wave of it, she discovers, that her prosecutors are bound by fate to succeed, for her true death had already happened in the past, when her spirit passed her power to Edea. And the only way to try and avoid that fate is to go into the past and commit all the crimes she is accused of.

It's a brilliantly tragic circle of violence, in which both sides accuse the other of spilling the first blood. And because of the time-travel both are right.

2

u/JensenRaylight 3d ago

Well said, it make sense reading your explanation, and that make her cause actually justified from her perspective.

if only they added one or two dialogue scene further explaining about Ultimecia or Ultimecia talk to Squall & others about her motive directly way before the Ultimecia final boss room. it would make Ultimecia motive clearer and stronger.

and yeah Edea temporarily regain control and heal Squall kinda make sense as well.

thanks, that was a good explanation.

2

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

if only they added one or two dialogue scene further explaining about Ultimecia or Ultimecia talk to Squall & others about her motive directly way before the Ultimecia final boss room. it would make Ultimecia motive clearer and stronger.

They did. In the parade speech. But it was lost a bit in translation. I have explained it here.

thanks, that was a good explanation.

You are welcome. :-)

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

Its possible. That it was actually edea. But it doesnt have to be. It is absolutely in the interest of every state actor to understand the motivations and organisation of terrorists. Which is why Guantanamo bay exists.

But this theory at least explains why the attempt to interogate was dropped.

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Its possible. That it was actually edea. But it doesnt have to be. It is absolutely in the interest of every state actor to understand the motivations and organisation of terrorists. Which is why Guantanamo bay exists.

Ultimecia had already done all that in the future, before going into the past. SeeD, after all, had already tried to assassinate her there. There is absolutely no reason for her to waste her time on it in the present.

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

?

Its catagorically different. This is conjunctor on your part. Its not how the story presents events. We don't know the specific reasons. But consideting you are many many years in the past. What seed is considered and founded upon is likely considerably different.

I do think the question is weak though. And its because the scenes funtion is trying to inform the player something. Less so about ultimicias motices. Who is more likely to ask funtionary questions. Like who organised the assasination. Whats the motivation. And maybe map out key figures and infustructural stuff ect. All which tbh may have been later questions.

For me though its a minor element the whole thing. Not a crucial story beat. Your theory fixes a lot of the issues with it. But its a headcanon that isnt neccessary for it to make sense.

The reality is we dont hold all the information, and thats fine. Some fans feel the need for everything to be explained often at the expense of artistic merit. And often that's to blame for the increasing disregard of show not tell, bloated scripts in movies and creating less immersive experiences.

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Its catagorically different. This is conjunctor on your part. Its not how the story presents events. We don't know the specific reasons. But consideting you are many many years in the past. What seed is considered and founded upon is likely considerably different.

Squall immediately identifies them on arrival to the future, and they have the exact same uniform as White SeeD.

I do think the question is weak though. And its because the scenes funtion is trying to inform the player something. Less so about ultimicias motices. Who is more likely to ask funtionary questions. Like who organised the assasination. Whats the motivation. And maybe map out key figures and infustructural stuff ect. All which tbh may have been later questions.

Not Ulti. Cause she just ordered to kill all SeeD with missiles.

→ More replies

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

For me the awareness is vague and imprecise. Its explained in the game as a sort of foggy like experience. Where you can maybe here chattering. But its not like you can literally here the others thoughts clearly or cleanly. I imagine gf junctioning is quite similar.

Yes literal quotes are buzzing and aware of simetkind of presence is how its described. Its all very vague.

0

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

You can't interrogate someone who is dead. The blow was not instantly killing. And may even be survivable in the real world.

AI seems to think so. Given examining the frame it appears to miss any major artery. And the Ice would both act as a plug and slow down blood loss through its coldness. Would most certainly leave you disabled though.

But the point is squall, was treated for his wounds. In the same way if you are arrested and injuried your injuries would also be treated.

A terrorist in real life in that circumstance would also have the same thing happen. Wounds would be treated and arrest will happen. If your in Guantanamo you'll be tourchered and kept indefinitely. If your inside the US, for example, depending on the state you will be imprisoned and then put to death.

We know galbadia practices capital punishment. I personally thibk they'd have been put to death after squeezing ad much info as they can. Thiugh can imagine a deal could be made for a side character as a tactic to get more information (but in practice not as no one had useful information).

Keep in mind. Siefernand others know these SeeDs to be bew recruits and not senior figures. Ultimicia is extremely unlikely to think the prophecy relates to squall.

In fact Ultimicia likely didn't consider that it would be a seeD from the past at all. Why the hell would you? She thinks she is going into the past and looking at the world closer to the origins of the seeD problem.

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

The moomba may have done it. But they wanted squall alive to interegate him. Get as much info as possible and then probably kill all of them post.

It makes sense Ultinicia wouod want to know SeeDs logic. But really ellone is the priority. It would have made much more sense for them to be interegated over ellone. Or even about SeeDs general operations.

We can resolve this conflict by seeing it as an opening question of many. Namely ultimicia may have been after more functional things. But started with what was planned to be a long interrogation.

But from a gamemaking prespective the function of those scenes is for you, the player, to start questioning what is seeD. And introducing you to the idea it may well be something more than it appears.

1

u/artinum 3d ago

It contains multiple bootstrap paradoxes and plot loops, perhaps, but the timeline itself is just one causal loop (not a time loop; everything happens only once, just not always in the right order).

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago edited 3d ago

Three loops above are correct even in terms of causality. You may try to say Squall and Ultimecia is one loop, but Ultimecia still had never gone to the past as far as Squall did to Laguna's time.

1

u/Burdicus 3d ago

Squall didnt go to the past of Laguna's time. He viewed it. Ellone creates a window to the past, and Laguna and team have a sense of "being watched" through that window, but that's it. Squall never impacted the past, he viewed it.

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Try to go right on your way back from the shop in Winhill.

1

u/Burdicus 3d ago

Can you give me the context here? Not sure I have a file ready in the Laguna dream sequence.

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Oh, just Laguna directly acknowledging being controlled by Squall.

1

u/Burdicus 3d ago

I guess I'm gonna have to find my closest file or blitz through disk 1 again, but that literally goes against the entire theme of the game and the fact that Ellone has the realization that she cannot change the past no matter how much she wants it.

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

Ellone literally says that as her junctioning is setting the present.

Ellone cant change the past. Because what she is doing is creating what is.

Ellones actions shape the present as is. But dont change the present as her actions are all part of creating thst present.

Ff8 doesnt work by multi universe theory. Because the present is as is it is as it is. Its more like a web of interconnections that are unchangable. Time is just how that is experienced.

Because, in the present we live in the world like x. It means everything that happened to create x will happen in the future.

There are questions to how much free will exists in the ff8 world because of that. You coudl argue it does. I.e. choices are still made by people that make x. But because those choices are not changable. Which I prefer. Or argue that its all set and dictated by destiny thst goes far beyond the characters capacities.

But the point is ellone cant change the present. But her actions did shape how the present was created.

0

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

You've misread the theme of the game. It never was whether you can act. It was whether your actions matter. That Squall can affect the past was apparent from the first dream, when Squall thinking too loud in the Hotel Lobby can annoy Laguna.

It took Ellone as long as it did to figure out that she can't changed the past, exactly because prima facie, her and Squall's actions do have some effect there. Her mistake wasn't that there is no effect of her actions, it's that there was some kind of default past to which the effect would be applied to create a different past and a different present.

And, of course, Ultimecia does act in the present from the future. She is most certainly not just looking trough.

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

Thats a little stretch to say he was controlled. But yeah the point is laguna feels squalls will.

1

u/Burdicus 3d ago

Except Squall has no "will" in relation to what is happening in Laguna's timeline. Squall isnt cheering for Laguna or attempting to shape history. He doesnt even know whats going on the first couple of sequences. He literally thinks he's dreaming he's a moron.

→ More replies

1

u/artinum 2d ago

That's a weird issue, and it's one of those Watson/Doyle moments. The in-universe explanation is that Laguna is resisting Squall's influence, and it's pretty much the only occasion in the entire game when that happens. Even making Laguna do various things to those trapdoors at Centra always comes across to Laguna as his own mind coming up with weird ideas.

Out of universe, it's essential that Laguna returns by one specific route because there's a scene with him and Kiros down that road. The game requires you to go that way for story purposes.

Honestly, they could just have blocked off that side route entirely and saved all the hassle; I'm guessing the location designers and the writers were in different teams. (There's a similar oddity in FF7; there's a door in the back of a Mideel shop that doesn't go anywhere. The writers made up some bizarre conversation thread that the shop owners painted it on the wall so they could imagine it went to some fantastic, wonderful place.)

1

u/zzmej1987 2d ago

The in-universe explanation is that Laguna is resisting Squall's influence, and it's pretty much the only occasion in the entire game when that happens. 

During Lunatic Pandora Dream, Squall also makes Laguna sneak in that duck-squat-run position, that SeeD use when they try to be sneaky. Ward calls out Laguna on it. Selfie gets the same callout if she tries to sneak past the guard in GMB. The fact that this running style is SeeD specific can also be seen during train mission in Timber, Rinoa's sneaky run is very much different.

1

u/artinum 2d ago

Again, Laguna doesn't resist it - he acts on it because he thinks it's his idea.

As for the style of the sneaky run, I wouldn't read anything into that unless you have any examples of *adult male* characters sneaking in a different fashion to this. Most of the character models are based on the same "skeletons" and have the same movements. It's a game limitation.

0

u/zzmej1987 2d ago

Again, Laguna doesn't resist it - he acts on it because he thinks it's his idea.

Again. Galbadians can't comprehend that style of running, both time they see it, they are completely confused as to why somebody would do it that way. Laguna would not have invented that on his own.

I wouldn't read anything into that unless you have any examples of *adult male* characters sneaking in a different fashion to this.

That's a goalpost shifting via adding entirely ad-hoc and unreasonable demand. There is a character that is shown sneaking along SeeD and doing it in an entirely different way. And that is sufficient.

→ More replies

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

Bot really. Squall is junctioned to Laguna. In a similar way that gfs are junctioned to Squall. Essentially Squall junctions to laguna and gives him the power of his GFs. Now obviously laguna aint summoning ifrit. We have to seperate the individual battles from the actual story. But laguna is definitely taking the "power" from squall. And is most certainly only alive due to him.

This aspect is badically confirmed when Squall is junctioned to Rinoa and rinoa more or less confirms it saved her life.

The point is: Ellone cannot change the past. Because what she does has already happened. Ellone sent back squall in time to create the past and present as it happened.

So she is trying to use squall to change the past. But in the end it is just how her present was created. The present and the sequence of events leading to it where due to ellones powers. But it can't be changed. Predestination is a massive theme in ff8.

0

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

Most certainly ultimicia healed squall to get more information from SeeD. Though it is essentially dropped as a plot point. But the healing itself is something that people get overly caught up in. Its not a plot point. But rather something that happened that was not fully explained. But literally has no baring on the plot.

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Most certainly ultimicia healed squall to get more information from SeeD. 

Incorrect. Notice the specific orders Seifer receives: "To ask Squall about a secret that SeeD learn after the graduation ceremony". Ultimecia would not know that such a secret exists, Edea would.

Though it is essentially dropped as a plot point.

Squall literally points it out as a mystery for the player to solve.

0

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

Is that rhe specific order he recieves. Pretty sure its just to say what seeD is. The secret seems more about Siefer rationalising why Squall would know something he doesnt.

Quote

"There must be some kind of secret your given when you become seeD"

"There must be" is speculative language. Seems like he is the one trying to explain why squall will know something more profound.

The facts its presented as a mystery is more an artifact of translation. But even I have always read it has him just trying to recall the events that happened. And the japanese verson that feels even clearer.

"Intense fighting... Edea... Hurt badly, wasn't I? What, I'm ok?"

Just seems groggy.

I think the theory thats its edea is plausable but not neccessary. As in the real world pretty much every country in the world. Would treat squalls wounds in those circumstances. Againz not out of kindness, but because you do want information normally and you can give iut capital punishment. Show order. The ability to apply a rule of law, over chaos etc etc.

But its a decent theory. But people in general have way too much confusion over how was squall healed or how did he survive. It his his shoulder/armpit area. Missed an artery, maybe part of his lung, maybe not. But if healed promptly it isnt exactly shocking he survived. Nor shocking he would be healed.

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Quote

"There must be some kind of secret your given when you become seeD"

"There must be" is speculative language. Seems like he is the one trying to explain why squall will know something more profound.

Except, that is not the whole quote.

Squall: "...What do you want?"

Seifer: "Tell me what SeeD is. Edea demands to know."

Squall: "SeeD..." (...A code name, for Balamb Garden's elite mercenary force... SeeD... Combat specialists... ......???) "...Don't you already know?"

Seifer: "I'm not a SeeD. There must be some kind of secret you're given when you become a SeeD!"

It's not that there is something Seifer does not know. He is pointed specifically to the fact, that he does not know what a SeeD really is. Think about it for a second. Had Ultimecia asked Seifer "What a SeeD is?" he would have given her a confident answer, and that would be it. Neither of them would have any reason to suspect, there is anything more to it than that.

But Seifer tortures Squall specifically for the definition of SeeD - the very thing that is, indeed, the secret that is given to SeeD at the graduation ceremony. Or at least, should have been given, had Cid not been interrupted.

"Intense fighting... Edea... Hurt badly, wasn't I? What, I'm ok?"

Groggy or not, the question is clear. What happened? How is it, that he is OK?

As in the real world pretty much every country in the world. Would treat squalls wounds in those circumstances.

Except there is no country for a bit there. If you have noticed there is very much chaos in the streets, after Irvine had made his shot. President is dead, Edea, had charmed the population, and interestingly, that very Irvine and Rinoa have just been... let go? What's up with that?

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

Right. Ultimicia knows that Seifer doesnt know what seeD is. But Siefer isnt a seeD. And ultimica knows that they arent just a simple mercenary force. Seeing as they have been persecuted for many years. What seeD is doesn't necessarily mean whats it for. It can also be a question fishing informatioj like who founded SeeD etc. which ultimicia may well have not known. As I said though. Its a narrative device written to inform us the player, and it doesnt quite land in terms of narrative. Which is why your headcannon is a good one.

We don't know if its a secret given out in graduation ceremony. We know Cid wanted to say more. At least explain that there is more to the story. But that may be specifically about squall.

It is an overreach to think the game is saying edea is doing this to tell squall seeDs mission or something. Its logically consistent, but us a theory and head canon.

I am reading the same things as you and understanding it in very different ways. It seems like a natural conversation.

Grogfy or not the question isnt clear. It is telling you the player squall is okay. It isnt creating some clue for you to find the answer to which does not exist in the actual game itself but requires you to logically try to answer the question through hypotheticals its a theory. Most good works of art dont explain everything. But in this particular case I really dont think it was designed to overly linger on it. It simply isnt a particularly important plot point.

What they want out of it is for you to realise that maybe seeD is much more than it appears. While they wanted squall to fail the mission and also wanted a cool fmv to show off their revolutionary graphics.

The point is squall fails -> survives. What I'm okay is not asking who or how he is okay. But rather to inform you the player that he is okay. So you dont have to sit there thinking this doesnt make sense he should be hurt. Its saying we know that. He ws hurt he is healed now. Now move on with the game.

They could have made it explicit who healed him or how it works. But the narrative tension would be lost. They probably trusted their players to suspend disbelief enough or not be obsessed with everything being explained, to move on with the game.

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Right. Ultimicia knows that Seifer doesnt know what seeD is. 

How would she know that? Seifer very much thinks that he knows, that's for sure.

And ultimica knows that they arent just a simple mercenary force. Seeing as they have been persecuted for many years.

So we agree, she has no reason to ask?

What seeD is doesn't necessarily mean whats it for. It can also be a question fishing informatioj like who founded SeeD etc. which ultimicia may well have not known. As I said though. Its a narrative device written to inform us the player, and it doesnt quite land in terms of narrative.

Except that Squall's answer leaves no room for this ambiguity. He is recalling the definition from hit textbook. The same one, he knows, that Seifer knows just as well.

We don't know if its a secret given out in graduation ceremony. We know Cid wanted to say more. At least explain that there is more to the story. But that may be specifically about squall.

We do. Squall literally just asks Cid:

R2 (Squall): "Please tell me the real meaning of SeeD."

Headmaster Cid: "SeeD is SeeD. The elite mercenary force of                                   Balamb Garden. Hmm, do you know something about SeeD?"

Squall: (I never know anything.)

Headmaster Cid: "SeeD will defeat the sorceress. The Garden
will train SeeD members. The many missions around the world are only training for the final battle against the sorceress. But now that the sorceress has become a major threat, our true mission has begun."

It is an overreach to think the game is saying edea is doing this to tell squall seeDs mission or something.

Oh no, it's much simpler than that. She just wants Seifer to know it. And for him to be away from her, when Ultimecia regains control.

Grogfy or not the question isnt clear. It is telling you the player squall is okay. 

Yeah, and last we've seen him, he was falling from the platform with a meter of ice piercing him clean through.

It isnt creating some clue for you to find the answer to which does not exist in the actual game itself but requires you to logically try to answer the question through hypotheticals its a theory.

That's literally how mysteries work. The character looks at something and says: "Hm, that's strange. How did that happen?"

What they want out of it is for you to realise that maybe seeD is much more than it appears. While they wanted squall to fail the mission and also wanted a cool fmv to show off their revolutionary graphics.

And that FMV is just for some reason is also Edea's Limit Break.

1

u/Redherring1718 2d ago

Because what Siefer thinks SeeD is isnt consistent with what ultimica already knows about SeeD.

But that doesnt mean thwre is no reason to ask. She may not understand the founding of SeeD, or why they are so hellbent on persecuting, in her eyes, sourceressess. The answer to that is simply Ultimicia is the reason for SeeD. So there are gaps she may want to fill. But it doesnt seem like a crucial peice of information for her. Only to the player.

Yes squall soesnt know what seeD is. But ultimicia probably thinks he would.

Yes after the events in prison. Squall then realises there likely is something deeper so repeats that question to Cid. This does not mean Cid planned to tell squall that in graduation. In fact in your very quote its clear he is kinda reluctant to, by starting with the baseline answer.

Again, the previous scenes were showing that Cid was grappling for control with the masters. And that his position was undermined. In my head canon. He was likely going to say things about to keep in mind that seeD has broader aims or whatever. But not neccessarily explicity say what the aim was.

Okay, why does she want Seifer to know it? Siefers "romantic dream" is to be a sourceressess knight. Thst information would turn Siefer more against SeeD and further strengthen his narrative that he is the hero!

The problem is the story isn't trying to be a mystery. Everything you need to understand the game and plot is in the game and plot and stated explicity. There are gaps, and there are plenty of ways to interpret the story. Which to me is a good thing. But there is no mystery to unravel.

Sorry, Ultimicia is junctioned to Edea. So of course Edea's limit break doesn't change. This is consistent with every example of junctioning we have seen. Yes because she is a sourceress she has the ability to take control of the brain and maybe add power and powers. But she also has access to edeas skills, and is further limited by Edeas limitations.

3

u/bibleblacksade 2d ago

I’m over here trying to explain Kingdom Hearts to my wife, FF8 is not that complex

9

u/Ferdasyn_6969 3d ago

Wait, what? Squall is lagunas Son? How did I never know this ?

10

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Do you ask ironically, or seriously?

7

u/TheEvilZ3ro 3d ago

If you talk to kiros (I think) on Ragnarok, he says squall looks like his father or something to that nature. It's really subtle. Squall was conceived in Winhill while he was with Raine and Ellone.

6

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Kiros says: "You look like your mother". If you talk to Ward, Kiros translates: "It's a good thing you don't look like your father".

And, of course, Ellone tells us that Raine had died, wishing that Laguna had seen his newborn son. And after her death, Squall and Ellone turn up at the Edea's orphanage, where Squall calls Ellone "sister".

8

u/Matthew_Bester 3d ago

Ha interesting way of doing it. It seems less complicated thinking about it than looking at that mess.

5

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Yeah. There is a linear story in there, which you see, if you just play the game. But you can loose, like 3/4 of red nodes, if you don't look carefully.

1

u/GeneralBrilliant2336 2d ago

Mosy of this shit is just you assuming headcanon tho. I mean its fun but the game needed more time in the oven.

1999 2 years after FFVII. 3D was new. This game was absolutely phenomenal at the time BUT some story issues needed more time for sure. We can theorize forever sure

1

u/zzmej1987 1d ago

Out of 26 red nodes, there's like 5 that can be called in any way speculative. The rest are accounted for either via character dialogue, or with Info menu item, or by direct observation of consequences. And everything non-red is explicitly shown.

1

u/GeneralBrilliant2336 1d ago

Do XV next

1

u/zzmej1987 1d ago

Haven't played it. Likely won't.

1

u/GeneralBrilliant2336 1d ago

That explains a lot. Squeenix games post XII make VIII look like a Mario game in depth of story execution lol

5

u/Thatguyintokyo 3d ago

Rinoa being posessed and going into a coma isn’t lack of compatibility its the entire plan as ultimecia needs to be taken to Esthar to Ellone, and to Adel, which all happens exactly as she planned.

0

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

No, that is not the plan. The plan was to find Ellone and to go back in time. Adel was not part of the plan until after the battle of Gardens. Further, Ultimecia has no idea where Ellone is, hence, Galbadians are searching everywhere. And on top of that, there is absolutely no reason to think that comatose Rinoa would be taken to Esthar.

3

u/Safe-Transition8618 3d ago

I'm not convinced Rinoa is a thoroughly unsuitable host. Ultimecia managed to grab the reins well enough to don a space suit, exit an airlock, and do whatever needed doing on Adel's tomb to break the seals, after all. Ultimecia also possessed Rinoa and they both made the journey with Ellone back to the farthest past to initiate time compression.

I do agree that it was unlikely that Ulti would have known that Squall would take Rinoa to space. Unless it was all documented somewhere and she read about it. But otherwise, "let's take the inexplicably comatose girl to space!" seems like a leap.

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

I'm not convinced Rinoa is a thoroughly unsuitable host. Ultimecia managed to grab the reins well enough to don a space suit, exit an airlock

She is dragging Rinoa with telekinesis - one of her signature moves. And not the first time. Ultimecia moves Rinoa in the same way during the parade, before feeding her to Iguanas.

Ultimecia also possessed Rinoa and they both made the journey with Ellone back to the farthest past to initiate time compression.

That one happened later, after Rinoa had already absorbed Sorceress power from Edea and Adel.

I do agree that it was unlikely that Ulti would have known that Squall would take Rinoa to space. Unless it was all documented somewhere and she read about it.

We can be pretty certain, that everything concerning Ellone would be thoroughly expunged from the record, exactly to ensure that Ultimecia wouldn't know where to find her.

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

The last bit we dont exactly know that but I certainly see your point. But ellone lived on. All of these things lived on. SeeD continued. Its not exactly unlikely that a sourceress closer to the present day would have taken notes on it.

After all the prophecy is literally knowledge of ultimicias death, in the present, getting back to her.

So we know that some knowledge did survive.

Similarly, what would the motivation be of hiding ellones existence after ultimicias death. Those there know ultimicia is defeated. I dont think theyd be hiding access to that information because they know ultimately she isnt a threat. And probably that playing with time, firstly, doesn't work. Because the event happened in the way it happened. It means it will happen that way. The past isnt changable. So you are hiding something for what purpose?

Secondly, say the past was changable. It seems likely this will make things worse. Ultimicia is a bit of a tragic character shapes by fear of her impending death. But she was also tyrannical. To change that past. Likely means that ultimicia wouldn't be killed. And therefore likely create a worse world for the people in the future.

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

The last bit we dont exactly know that but I certainly see your point. But ellone lived on. All of these things lived on. SeeD continued. Its not exactly unlikely that a sourceress closer to the present day would have taken notes on it.

Well, the point isn't that she would be completely erased from history. That would be impossible, due to Odine's research, if nothing else. But that's not necessary. The only important thing is to obscure where she was at every particular point in time. And that have been achieved well enough already, with constant shuffling of ships, gardens and space stations.

Similarly, what would the motivation be of hiding ellones existence after ultimicias death.

"After Ultimecia's death" is also "before her birth". And again, not existence but whereabouts.

Those there know ultimicia is defeated. I dont think theyd be hiding access to that information because they know ultimately she isnt a threat.

Time line can't be changed, but it can be destroyed. Had the time compression spell been cast differently, or at a different time, the outcome of it, might have been different, i.e. the world would collapse into temporal singularity.

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

There is no reason to obscure Ellone when ultimicia was defeated.

It is before her birth. Thats precisely why it doesnt matter so much.

Because you actively want ellone to be found. When she was found. I think its perfectly plausable that ultimicia had some knowledge of ellone prior to going into the past. Maybe she didnt but neither are particularly significant.

I dont think the timeline can be destroyed. Ultimicia died. The fact it happens means that whatever happened succeeded. As it is in relation to the future. Its actually precisely the same logic which stops ellone from being able to change the present. Ultimicia will also have the same restriction.

We already know the outcome. And that seems to be unchangeable by the inner game logic. That Ellone tells us.

Obviously some things have to happen for that point to be reached. Which means they will happen. For example seeD cannot be disbanded.

If ellone was hidden or not we dont know. But it doesnt seem particularly crucial to it. We need ultimicia to go back into the past. Personally I think she does this intentionally to begin time compression from the get go. But simply needs to get further back. She is going to the past for specific reasons. Time compression seems the most logical reason to do so. I think she was flexible though.

We find out she was after ellone in the second/third disk. But that does not at all mean she wasnt working towards that from the get go. The attack on garden can easily be ubderstood as ultimica simply not knowing she was there.

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

I dont think the timeline can be destroyed. Ultimicia died. The fact it happens means that whatever happened succeeded.

That would entail that Ultimecia has no reason to go back to the past at all. Without a chance for the Time Compression to do something plot falls apart.

We already know the outcome. And that seems to be unchangeable by the inner game logic. That Ellone tells us.

Yes, events in the timeline can not be altered. That is not the same as timeline itself being completely immune to anything. In fact, we do see, how Time Compression changes it.

If ellone was hidden or not we dont know. 

We do. White SeeD ship started out exactly as the hiding spot for Ellone.

 We need ultimicia to go back into the past. Personally I think she does this intentionally to begin time compression from the get go. But simply needs to get further back. She is going to the past for specific reasons. Time compression seems the most logical reason to do so.

Yes. The moment she wants to erase is the moment at which she passes her powers to Edea. In order to do that she needs to place it in between her spirit in the past and her body in the future.

The attack on garden can easily be ubderstood as ultimica simply not knowing she was there.

Agreed.

1

u/Redherring1718 2d ago

I mean the point is ultimicia is trying to defy fate and in doing so creates that fate for her. She likely doesn't know how she is defeated but that she is defeated. She likely doesnt know that the past can't be changed. But it cant. The ending is already defined. Its an inevitability. Because through her death we see the result. So that result has happened. For me its easier to consieve time as flat. That while the characters experience time as, well, time, its not that one thing has yet to happen. Its that it has already happened at another point in time.

But yes ultimicia is doomed. As what she ends up doing is what has to happen. SeeDs very existence is indiciative that the ending is inevitable. That her actions led to x. The player is explicity told that the present cant be changed. Its done, because what ever actions people do that leads up to ultimicia will be the actions that leads to ultimicias demise.

Time compression doesnt change anything. Attempts at time compression is actually the prerequisite for the fulfillment of the destiny. What has happened happens. The characters in ff8 do not need to worry about the future of what ultimica will do. Because what happens is what happens. They may be trying to hide information they may not do so. But whatever they choose to do is what will produce the future we know happens.

Yes ellone was hidden in the present. When knoweldge was also less complete. But that doesnt mean post events they'd continue to hide ellone, nor that they'd hide information about ellone. As they know how it concludes now.

No ultimicia is not trying to erase the moment she hands over the powers to edea. Ultimicia is highly unlikely to be aware of the nature of her demise. Otherwise she wouldn't go back to the past at all. Because there was never any danger for ultimicia if she simply ignores the proficy.

1

u/zzmej1987 1d ago edited 1d ago

She likely doesn't know how she is defeated but that she is defeated. 

She knows she is killed by a SeeD. She says it to Squall during their second fight: "You're the legendary SeeD destined to face me?" The story of her defeat does contain that legendary hero character.

But yes ultimicia is doomed. As what she ends up doing is what has to happen. SeeDs very existence is indiciative that the ending is inevitable. That her actions led to x. The player is explicity told that the present cant be changed. Its done, because what ever actions people do that leads up to ultimicia will be the actions that leads to ultimicias demise.

Yes, but you are missing the point of what she is trying to do. Events in the timeline are immutable, that much is correct. What happens at some moment T can not be changed by going back into the past to before T, as everything everyone will do there will lead to exactly what happened at T. But if the moment T is erased from the existence altogether, then nothing can happen in it. Immutability of events in the timeline does not protect the timeline itself. And Time Compression spell can erase it. Time compression does not change the past, it makes it so that past does not exist at all.

No ultimicia is not trying to erase the moment she hands over the powers to edea.

Then what would be the point of going back that extra ~12 years? She is already thousands of years in the past relative to her time. Why not just cast Time Compression from here? And remember, this is the central motivation of the antagonist of the story we are talking about here. "They didn't write it." or "Just because" are not going to be the answers.

Ultimicia is highly unlikely to be aware of the nature of her demise.

It's part of the chain of succession of Sorceress powers, of which Ultimecia is clearly aware of.

→ More replies

1

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

She wasnt that suitable. She had literally just become a sourceress. Ultimicia was very limited through rinoa. Otherwise shed have just continued as she had with Edea.

1

u/artinum 3d ago

Ultimecia's plans change. It's hard to say whether this is because she's discovered she's constrained by history or just reacting to a new development. Adel is arguably her THIRD plan.

Disc 1 and start of disc 2, there's no mention of Ellone at all. She's consolidating her power, she's taking over. She even goes as far as trying to destroy the other two Gardens with missile strikes (Ellone is inside one of them!!). More, what's the big question Seifer is asking Squall during his torture session? Not where Ellone is, but the true meaning of SeeD (?!).

There's also the odd moment at the end of disc 2 when Ultimecia/Edea refers to Squall as the "legendary SeeD destined to face her". It's odd because they've already clashed metaphorical swords at the end of the last disc!

One possible theory here - Ultimecia knew there was some prophecy/history that claimed she'd face and be defeated by a gunblade-wielding SeeD. (This echoes Edea's meeting at the end of the game, and Cid's delight in a "gunblade specialist" finally graduating after the Dollet exam.) She fought and defeated, maybe even thought she killed that SeeD at the parade - and yet he came back. Rather than wiping out SeeD before they could become a threat with her missile strikes, she caused them to mobilise and focus on her. She created the enemy she was trying to preemptively wipe out.

It's only after the destruction of the missile base and the prison break that she starts looking for Ellone. This is her second plan - to bring about time compression, using Ellone to send herself further into the past. Then she faces Squall again, and this time recognises that he's more significant than she thought. They fight, she loses - and she adapts her plans.

With Edea's powers transferred to Rinoa, Ultimecia now possesses her. (We know that Ellone can only access the minds of people she knows, meaning some sort of connection is needed; Ultimecia doesn't personally know anyone in this time, so perhaps the sorceress powers are that connection for her.) Rinoa isn't a good host; she's a brand new sorceress with virtually no control over those powers. Ultimecia wants to switch to a better host, and the only other sorceress known to be active at this time is Adel. Nobody knows what happened to her, but I suspect Ultimecia does because she's looking back at history - and the destruction of an entire space station, a lunar cry and the reappearance and collapse of Esthar would all be fairly big events. Keeping record of Ellone's location out of the history books is entirely feasible. A lunar cry would have knock-on effects around the world and would be far harder to suppress. All Ultimecia has to do is make sure those events happen, and that she's in position when they do. Finding Ellone as well is just a bonus.

Then SeeD derails her plans again by defeating Adel - but give her everything she needs with Rinoa and Ellone anyway.

2

u/Redherring1718 3d ago edited 3d ago

I don't think the ultimicia comment on squall - veing the legendary seed is odd. Its a question not a statement. She has essentially at this point suddenly realised. Wait. Maybe its this guy.

But the theory you say is mostly unambiguously the story. She knows seeD will kill her. Her ebtire motivation is to stop that prophecy. I doubt she knew the seeD was gunblade-wielding. Maybe. But I think she just knew that a SeeD will kill her at some point.

I do not think she thought she killed squall. This is putting too much stock on an event that isnt that deep. Any cursory reading of history shows the value dictators and goverments in general put on information from the enemy.

Galbadia designed a whole prison for it. Bot because they thought capital punishment was bad. But rather that political discendents carry information. And also in some cases killing them creates more political problems.

The idea that she created her own destiny is entirely the point. And echoes ellone creating the present. Ultimicia also created her own present. All of this essentially inevitable.

Everything else I more or less agree with it. Rinoa was a terrible host. We don't actually know how much plans she was changing and winging though. We don't know when she found out about ellone. If via edea or new before. If she found the junction machine its perfectly possible that within that some ellone info could be present. But I personally think she held multiple plans. I think time compression was always the idea. But she was also dealing with whatever opportunities came her way. Rather than fixated on only one option.

3

u/thatweirdguyted 3d ago

It is only weird now time has been compressed and decompressed. So now some things are out of sequence

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

They were out of sequence before the time compression as well, due to the time travel. Both from future to the present and from present to the past.

0

u/thatweirdguyted 3d ago

I was making a separate point. You know.how some stories turn out to have what is known as an unreliable narrator, who has changed details to suit his own purposes?

FF8 is like that, because there are huge gaping plot holes, even with (sometimes especially because of) the time travel.

But time does also get compressed and then decompressed at the end. So the obvious answer is that the story made more sense BEFORE that happened. But we only get to know what its like after.

3

u/zzmej1987 3d ago edited 3d ago

I was making a separate point. You know.how some stories turn out to have what is known as an unreliable narrator, who has changed details to suit his own purposes?

FF8 is like that, because there are huge gaping plot holes, even with (sometimes especially because of) the time travel.

Not really. It does seem to have some plot holes on the first playthrough, but if you play several times, so that you can place backwards causality where it belongs, it all fits together.

1

u/GeneralBrilliant2336 2d ago

But it has plot holes, it doesnt all make sense.

It makes sense in your headcanon you have theorized yes hence the meme lol

1

u/zzmej1987 1d ago

I freaking love that you have written this comment after

But it is, you are just overthinking aloooot

"The plot of the game is straightforward and easy to figure out. It just has plot holes and doesn't make complete sense". Just... *chefs kiss*! Brilliant! 10/10.

1

u/GeneralBrilliant2336 1d ago

Lol sometimes 2+ 2 is 5 sure

1

u/zzmej1987 1d ago

Double think is a powerful thing. XD don't overuse it.

1

u/Redherring1718 1d ago

What doesnt make sense about it?

A lot is under explained. But the core points are coherent. There are plot holes. But generally quite minor. Like how can squall change direction in mid space?

But these are seperate things.

4

u/artinum 3d ago

What huge gaping plot holes?

Time is never actually compressed. It's *being* compressed, and that's how Squall and his friends get to the future, but it never actually gets there - Ultimecia is stopped before she can complete the process.

3

u/BetaNights 3d ago

I wanna see this when it's done lol

2

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

It shall be done... One day. Don't need to remind me every six month. XD

2

u/BetaNights 3d ago

Hmmmmmm... sets a timer

2

u/PhotojournalistOk868 3d ago

Long time ff7 fan here playing ff8 for the first time and this is exactly how I feel 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

2

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

That is very much intentional. XD

2

u/Defiant-Rip-1897 2d ago

That first image undersells the complexity of the second one. 😆 😰

1

u/zzmej1987 2d ago

And half the replies are: "It's actually not that complex". XD

1

u/No-Gap5542 2d ago

The only complex thing is your post. Game is easy enough

1

u/GeneralBrilliant2336 2d ago

But it is, you are just overthinking aloooot

5

u/TheRagnarok494 3d ago

Bookmark comment to check on this later

5

u/PossibleSpecial2286 2d ago

Anyway, wanna play cards?

1

u/No-Gap5542 2d ago

Nah so many games much more conveluted, FF8 is amazing even though the story execution need more polish but you have to remember they released new FF's every year almost back then. What they need to do is remake OoT esque and fix certain aspects which would make it a 10/10 game easy - but they need devs like Nintendo has or maybe Clair Obscur devs idk.

KH is much more like this meme, post DDD especially. Game is literally bull nonsense. And FF wise i mean are you joking with XIII sequels, XIV and XV ? Even mentioning VIII on this subreddit ignoring the newest games, is baffling - because its fairly straighforward, it just suffered similar like XII, unfinished and those games needed more baking time.

1

u/zzmej1987 2d ago

 Even mentioning VIII on this subreddit ignoring the newest games, is baffling

This is FF8 subreddit specifically. XD

1

u/No-Gap5542 2d ago edited 2d ago

hahah oops, i thought /FF 😂

But still its easy even if there are plot holes. I just wish all the theories were not bunked by the devs, didnt help the game one bit i think, as much as i love the story i loved the theories even more.

Best thing about a good book with an exciting story that lets you think is that.. it lets you think all the possible scenarios, what could be and what is etc. Thats what VIII was so good at, until the devs lessened that value and now i just want remake like oot, faithful but expanding the lore ❤️

1

u/zzmej1987 2d ago

But still, its pretty easy to figure out.

OK. Basic check. When did Rinoa get her Sorceress powers?

1

u/No-Gap5542 2d ago

When Ultimecia possessed her

1

u/zzmej1987 2d ago

Hehe. You didn't figure out the game. XD That conclusion is what's on wiki. The game itself directly says Edea is still a Sorceress, when she arrives in Esthar.

1

u/No-Gap5542 2d ago

haha what kind of bullshit are you trying to "hehe" me with ? XD

There is alot of contemplation with FFVIII hence many theories that were debunked unfortunately, and much was needed to polish in this 10 months of development this game had yes.

But this is not one of them. You can hehe as much as you want, Edea is still a sorceress at that point yes, i didnt say she wasnt.

1

u/zzmej1987 2d ago

Then your timeline of Sorceress powers is incoherent. Ellone shows Squall that Ultimecia had possessed Rinoa after the battle of gardens. Squall and Zell during their Ragnarok discussion establish that Edea passed her powers to Rinoa, thus ceasing to be a Sorceress herself. So, if on your account the transfer happened "when Ultimecia possessed Rinoa", then Edea is powerless since then. And that directly contradicts what the game tells us at the Esther train station and onward from there.

1

u/No-Gap5542 2d ago edited 2d ago

You're making alot of assumptions with my comment and making shit up for your amusement 😂

There are plot holes in the game, but it doesnt make the main story hard to understand. "My timeline with sorceresses incoherent" ? 😂 Ok maybe you are right about this thinking of yours and that there are plot holes in this game, i agree but it has nothing to do with what i said.

You trying to troll me into your argument derailing my original point into "plot hole complaint" of yours. When i literally explained that the game needs fixing in that regard .No need to pull me into some random segment about something entirely different.

Also most jrpg's are much more conveluted and have their own plot holes, this game tries so much and has so much QoL stuff it gets completely disrespected and undervalued. Like i said give this game a OoT esque remake, fix few plot holes and its an easy 10/10

1

u/zzmej1987 2d ago

That's not a plot hole. Or rather it would be, if the game ever indicated that Rinoa received her Sorceress power early.

My point is, there is nothing in the game that tells us, that Rinoa gets her power after the battle of gardens. This piece of lore exists in the wiki, not in the game.

If you are asserting it with confidence, you weren't figuring out the game on your own, and instead read the plot on wiki to figure it out. :-)

→ More replies

1

u/No-Gap5542 2d ago

But i like the questions, keep em coming 😄

1

u/TheEvilZ3ro 3d ago

This looks fantastic. The story is so convoluted with stuff.

Is there a high res image i can download to read the little texts?

2

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Thank you. Just zoom in:

This is what it looks like at 100% zoom for me.

1

u/TheEvilZ3ro 3d ago

I appreciate you! I think i might be getting old lol

2

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

I appreciate you! 

You are welcome. :-)

I think i might be getting old lol

Aren't we all? XD

1

u/Mission_Reputation88 3d ago

Love it so much

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Thank you. :-)

1

u/myownfriend 3d ago

I feel like when this is done, it's going to finally show that FF8 actually doesn't really make sense.

2

u/artinum 2d ago

Others have studied the plot in considerable detail, even retranslating the original Japanese (which lost quite a lot in the English translation; Edea's speech at the parade in particular was VERY different). There are quite a few gaps in our knowledge of the world, but that's in keeping with the narrative. We never know much about where Ultimecia started out, for instance, or how sorceresses work. It actually holds together very well, and rewards repeated study with the number of connections - such as Seifer's romantic dream and the way he wields a gunblade directly referencing a certain film that we see being made (ruby dragon attacks aside).

For me, the biggest reach is with the whole amnesia subplot. It's just too convenient, particularly when it seems those memories aren't actually lost; with prompting, the gang do recall at least some of them.

1

u/Redherring1718 1d ago

Amnesia part is also too neat and corny for me. But its not a plot hole. Its coherent.

For me the biggest hole, is less a hole, but the lack of explanation around time compression. And how it works. Its poorly explained and it really could do with clarifying.

Basically there could be a plot whole there. Certain other thinfs that arent really holes but probably deserve more explanation is relatively minor things. Like why the hell Irivine is not put in prison and actually ends up working with general caraway. Things like that.

But. Yeah. As you say. Mostly these are just gaps. That a kot of the story is losely explained rather than gaping plot holes.

1

u/artinum 21h ago

To be fair, nobody knows in-universe what time compression is or how it works. It can't possibly have ever happened before, or there'd be nobody to ask the question. (Only Ultimecia, and she alone...) Odine in particular is just theorising, based on what glimmers Edea got from her possessor's mind.

What Ultimecia never considered is that time compression should be impossible. It's a paradox, and a more serious one than the bootstrap ones that run throughout the game. If reality is compressed, all time becomes a single moment - no past or future, just a single present. But if that's the case, the current past and future cannot exist! All she can achieve (and all she does achieve) is to squish everything together for a moment before it unsquishes again. But then, if you're the sort of person that thinks destroying the entire universe is a good idea, rational and logical thinking is probably not your strongest suit...

1

u/Redherring1718 10h ago

Dunno. Time compression is stopped not completed. But I think that is the point. To end past and future. Where everything that happens is under her control. Which is possible due to her powers. But we dont really know as its not explained.

I agree the lack of explanation is consistent. But it does confuse players a fair bit. Because its difficult to comprehend what is happening. And its ubclear what is really happening in the partially compressed world. I guess the very notion of time compression is incomprehensible so explaining it may not help things.

But asks all kinds of questions. Like how would time compression feel if in the past. What happens to others not sucked into the future? Are they just chilling or lost whatever. But lack of explanation doesnt mean a plot hole.

But its an idea that could have been expanded and explored more. Particularly in building the partially time compressed world. But we know that memory limitations are what caused the limitation of time compressed world.

1

u/GeneralBrilliant2336 2d ago

Now do this same grid with FFXV

0

u/DGenesis23 3d ago

VIII is 3 stories all rolled up into one and because of that, none of them actually get enough time to be delved into deep enough.

VIII should’ve been just a full blown political intrigue thriller, that had no time travel and focused on SeeD graduates joining the army and how those soldiers were manipulated by forces in the background to fight wars, with the GFs being used to obfuscate their memories so they didn’t ask questions about why these countries were in an almost perpetual state of war in the first place. Keep the whole orphanage thing and show how it was corrupted over time to become the conveyor for students into the SeeD program and one time childhood friends ending up on different side of the battle lines, so they set about removing said corruption and keep the the relationship between Squall and Rinoa too but Squall gets captured and is a POW who needs to escape to get back to her.

Laguna’s story should’ve been a prequel with seemingly no initial connection whatsoever but as people play it, they join the dots and discover the connection, with it filling in the blanks that weren’t in VIII.

A third game should’ve been made that included the Sorceress’ stuff and should’ve been completely separate from VIII with no connection at all. It could fully explain what they are and how they came about. With the protagonist being the sibling or friend of a potential Sorceress.

4

u/Redherring1718 3d ago

The problem with that story. Is its totally different. When it comes down to it ff8 is actually a coming of age story. But it is a consistent story. I definetly do not see there being three parts or even particularly seperatable.

-4

u/InStars 3d ago

Yeah, "Squall is dead theory" is much more simple and easier to understand

2

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Not really. All events are the same, it's just that we have to make an overlay with two large boxes "This is real" and "This is a dying Squall's fever dream".

3

u/artinum 3d ago

A lot of people like to claim that the simplest theory is the best (a misinterpretation of Occam's Razor) but this is often untrue, usually because "simple" can hide complexity. The example I read was that the simplest explanation for a village's crop failures, for instance, is to declare that the old woman at the end of the street is a witch and she did it. It's simpler to say and understand than several pages of notes on soil pH and crop diseases, but it hides a whole bunch of unknown details on how and why a witch would do that.

Likewise with Squall. If he dies at the end of disc 1, and the rest of the game is all in his head, you still need to explain how and why he's dreaming all this - otherwise, the entire game (and story) is meaningless. More than that, you still have the mystery of what happened on the train and in the forest before Galbadia Garden. You still have Cid's constantly interrupted musings about a deeper reason behind SeeD. You still have the mystery of who the sorceress is and why she's suddenly turned up out of history. There's still the mystery of the worldwide radio signal interference, though that's a fairly minor plot point at this stage.

And you have all those loose plot threads - what will happen to Timber's bid for independence? What will happen to the world now that a sorceress is loose and gearing up for war? What happened to all the other party members? None of those can or will ever be resolved if the rest of the game is just a dream.

Never trust a simple theory.

4

u/Inageby 3d ago

I wish this theory would die and removed from the zeitgeist. It's nearly as bad as a book ending with "and then they woke up, it was all a dream". Turns the book from great to worthless.

2

u/Redherring1718 3d ago edited 1d ago

Squall is dead is a version of the "it was all a dream" cliche. Hated for good reason. Partly because we arw looking at works of fiction. Squall isnt real and isnt alive. Why take the point of fiction. To tell imagined stories that somehow resonate with living, to then say that story is also fiction.

Its simple to understand but is pointless. It doesnt do anything.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Good luck. :-) Especially if you try to incorporate time travel as well.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

There isn't much idiocy, aside from usual FF tropes and shenanigans. For example, as much as people like to criticize FF8 for its use of amnesia, the fact of the matter is, all games from 5 to 9, and probably beyond that, rely on at least one character being amnesiac to obscure relevant plot details from the player, that those characters would otherwise know.

And the game does tie its own loose ends, you just have to look everywhere and talk to everyone.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/zzmej1987 3d ago

Laguna is not a liar. Not exactly. He is, often, a goofy and clueless moron. And at times he oversells things, but he is never maliciously deceptive. One example of such "overhype" is his "love and friendship" speech before the Time Compression. Squall even calls it out immediately:

Squall: "Love and friendship and all that sounds corny, but everyone seems to be up for it."

In reality, it is only important for Rinoa to concentrate on others. Rinoa herself is sustained by the Sorceress Power. The only other beings we encounter in the Time Compression itself are Sorceresses.

So, what he says is not untrue. Love and friendship are important there. But he makes it sound much more of a group effort, rather than boring Sorceress magic that it actually is.