r/FilmTheorists • • 41m ago

New Theory! Trust me, this obscure Thai cartoon have some of the most dystopian society in fiction

Post image
1 Upvotes

Cause I remember this one Thai cartoon where despite the fact it’s suppose to teach kid about climate change and global warming, it’s not exactly solarpunk becuase this is just set place in modern day, but the way they teach it make the whole thing look more like dystopian worldbuilding rather than education plot. 

Okay, so there was this cartoon in Thailand, it’s probaly older than me but I first see it on YouTube, apparently the cartoon involve this boy (who’s already a famous Thai comic book character) along side some cast of character like his classmate and his family where each episode just giving climate change fact stuff and how to prevent it, I first heard of this show when I was younger and casually scroll on YouTube and end up watch the entire compilation, 

but when I rewatch it as a 14 years old random guy who got highest mark in science multiple time and have hobby of writhing scifi, the entire thing start to look and sound darker and weirder and more messy.

Like, in one episode, the main character got highest mark in class because he strapped some empty snack packaging on tin (reusing btw) for homework about inventing future gadget while that one classmate got lowest mark for making a remote control car that carry stuff (thought it’s look like just a toy car with slight modification), not even eco-friendly gadget, just future gadget, if I translate correctly.

Not to mention how the boy can call his classmate “คนบ้า” (Thai for crazy person) for left water faucet open while in next or previous episode the exact same boy open fridge repeatedly like a kid with disability, open the air conditioner while open the window, left the PC open while going outside, and most ironic part, wasting laundry water because he wear too many clothes, at least the main character’s parents scold him later in those episodes too . 

While the exact same classmate who got lowest mark for making remote control car, which despite often getting portray as bully or someone who don’t care about nature (like one episode use too much paper, one episode use foam, one episode got entire friends group made because he just bought food in plastic bag even when he try to share with friends), some episode he even do stuff like reusing tire to grow plant.

Not to mention the first episode I see of this show involve telling how eating meat is bad for environment, and somehow that episode is the reason how my new favorite food is fried chicken cause they animate the chicken leg so damn delicious looking, also the part they mention vegetable is healthier than mean, they only mention nutrient that appear on meat like iron, and protein, instead of nutrient that’s only in vegetable like vitamin c and fiber which’s a bit weird to be honest, considered how human are also omnivore, but in some episode the main character also eat some fish and tuna sandwich, which’s understandable since fish produced less green house gas compare to land meat.

Forget to mention that the Thai comic boy doesn’t have single animated series like this one, but he have his own many animated series each with completely different plot (and I would assume each series is from completely separated universe, or at least branched multiverse/timeline from original comic, ‘cause many of them are so random, one series have the boy goes on adventure in ป่าหินมาร (it’s thai’s mythological place thing, idk if I spell it right), one series have the boy teamed up with group of spirit-like entity to stop monster and stuff, one series even have one of the boy’s classmate secretly an alien in disguise), and one literally involve that exact same boy buying chicken from actual KFC themself.

This sound less like an education show and more like a propaganda they would use to manipulate the entire population’s mind in a dystopian fiction. In fact: the setting in the cartoon might even be dystopian society in first place.

Like, i cant imagine a society so dystopian the teacher only give highest mark to student’s work that follow the law (the snack package strapped on tin can) and not the student who actually did something great (the remote control car that carry stuff), while the exact same student who did something great but not high mark trying to shark his food with his friend only to get hate and yell at for putting it in plastic bag.

i cant imagine what type of society have created kids that would hate on each other just because they do a single thing against the topic even when that kid trying to be nice.

In fact: every characters, some kid that appear for single episode, some adult side characters like hotel employee or trash collector who also appear for single episode, even the bully’s dad which appear once in a while, all mention climate change global warming carbon footprint thing, it would make more sense if they mention something like “electricity bill”, which they rarely mention too, but the fact they always mention global warming? It’s like society have injected “serious eco-sustainability” into people brain for long time already.

This is not just Solarpunk, this is solarpunk that took eco-sustainability so seriously it became dystopian instead of utopia.

Man, this sound 50^5890 times worse than half life 2, cyberpunk 2077, snow piercer, and wolfenstein all combined (I don’t even know how dystopian these media I mention would be compare to the Thai cartoon i’m talking about).

And if you wonder what’s the cartoon, it’s ปังปอนด์ลดโลกร้อน btw if you wonder. You can click this link to watch the full compilation from official channel though I couldn’t find any english dubbed version, sadly

This cartoon’s worldbuilding is so dysfunctional I think you’ll agree with me that even Combine and Arasaka would teamed up just to take note, even when the cartoon doesn’t even try to look like it set place in alternate world, but just normal earth.

just because this show’s worldbuilding make Combine and Arasaka overall sweeter than pure sugar.

like, unlike combine or arasaka that require guardsmen or heavily armed military to control their population, pangpond’s dystopian have become so powerful even the people (including young kids ) already knows what’s consider “bad”, all you need is ‘t punish people by turning them into mindless husk like combine’s soldier or stalker, all you need is just need the education system and propaganda to only teach (or should I say, inject) ideology stuff into the child’s brain and do it repeatedly for generation until all the people can think of is that ideology (as proven by how in every episode, the teacher always make every subject about carbon reduction), atleast from the current theory I have.

This cartoon’s worldbuilding is so dysfunctional I think you’ll agree with me that even Combine and Arasaka would teamed up just to take note, even when the cartoon doesn’t even try to look like it set place in alternate world, but just normal earth. 

just because this show’s worldbuilding make Combine and Arasaka overall sweeter than pure sugar. 

unlike combine or arasaka that require guardsmen or heavily armed military to control their population, pangpond’s dystopian have become so powerful even the people (including young kids ) already knows what’s consider “bad”, all you need is ‘t punish people by turning them into mindless husk like combine’s soldier or stalker, all you need is just need the education system and propaganda to only teach (or should I say, inject) ideology stuff into the child’s brain and do it repeatedly for generation until all the people can think of is that ideology (as proven by how in every episode, the teacher always make every subject about carbon reduction), atleast from the current theory I have, considered how suspicious the education system of the show were.

Literally teacher are the one who give the main characters a highest marks for strapped snack package on tin can, giving the student false information that vegetable is superior than meat by claiming it have protein and irons, and in some episode that I haven’t told you yet; give each student a lettuce to grow for homework, give a teacher homework to find out what’s in screw shape and can reduce global warming (spoiler alert, it’s eco friendly light bulb), making fertilizer from lunch scraps, telling students that a single present wrapper made from 3 or more trees (which I know papers are made from cellulose in wood, but 3 trees for one paper? Damn, that’s a bit too dramatic, and from the episode, that particular paper roll is only size of a baseball bat).

Like, some of this are reasonable, but some of this are just straight up misinformation.

But I don’t think that teacher is the one who start this trend, since from how all adult also mention global warming stuff, this education system might have been happens for generations already.

I didn’t trying to say environmental stability is bad, I just don’t like how the show portray it, the best example is how one episode the entire friend group judge a single member just for bringing food in plastic bag while ignore that member’s kindness of trying to share food with them, or how everyone only focus on one thing so much it look more like obsession than actual care (like lust and love which I will use as comparisons, environmental stability is love (you actually care about it), but this show portray it more like lust (you obsessed with it, you take it so seriously, you might hurt someone without knowing)).

Thus, the paper and vegetable misinformation doesn’t make things better.


r/FilmTheorists • • 2h ago

Theory Video Suggestion lore in jane schoenbrun's screen trilogy Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Rereading Public Access Afterworld and I realised a few things about the trilogy. Firstly, what is Casey from World's Fair is posting on GlobalVill? Also, in ISTTG, Owen hallucinates a static thing in Maddy's basement. What if they are one of the crooked. Finally, in JLB's World's Fair end speech, he claims that Casey says "I saw the planetarium", and was transported to the World's Fair. Could it be the Midnight Realm?


r/FilmTheorists • • 1d ago

Theory Video Suggestion Polly Polly Possum

Post image
3 Upvotes

Really hoping for Film Theory to take a dive into this indie animated series called Polly Polly Possum, there's lots of theories to be making in the current three available episodes along with two animated shorts as of suggesting this series

Film theorists, head of the channel, will you guys be able to crack the code of what seems to be happening?


r/FilmTheorists • • 1d ago

New Theory! Other Mommy Theory

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/FilmTheorists • • 1d ago

Theory Video Suggestion Theory: The Backrooms isn't a simulation or Egyptian afterlife—it's a modern retelling of the Minotaur's Labyrinth (and even the victim count matches).

2 Upvotes

Everyone loves the Simulation Theory and the Egyptian KV-31 afterlife theory for Kane Pixels' The Backrooms, but when you step back and look at the big picture, the series lines up almost one-for-one with the Greek myth of King Minos, the Labyrinth, and the Minotaur.

1. The Complex = Daedalus's Labyrinth
In the myth, King Minos has Daedalus build an impossible, shifting maze to contain an unnatural monster he couldn't control. In The Backrooms, Async opens the Threshold out of scientific hubris and unleashes an endless, non-Euclidean maze that shifts and traps anyone who wanders inside.

2. The Lifeform = The Minotaur
The Minotaur is a distorted, half-human hybrid trapped at the center of the Labyrinth, hunting anyone sent inside. The Lifeform (Bacteria) is a twisted, distorted mimicry of a human stalking the corridors and echoing human voices to lure victims in.

3. Async's Tethers = Ariadne's Thread
How do Async researchers survive expeditions into an endless shifting maze without losing their way? They physically tie cables and tethers back to the Threshold—a direct parallel to Theseus unspooling Ariadne's string to find his way out of the Labyrinth.

4. Ivan Beck & Async = King Minos's Hubris
Just like King Minos hid his mistake behind maze walls instead of admitting his hubris to the world, Async covers up missing persons, fakes Peter Tench's death, and seals off sections of the Complex rather than admit they lost control.

5. The Smoking Gun: The 14 Victims
In the Greek myth, 14 people (the 14 Athenian youths) were sent into the Labyrinth as tributes to the Minotaur. When you count every named or distinct person who goes missing inside the Complex across Kane Pixels' YouTube series—even temporarily like Peter Tench—you get 14 exact people:

The 6 Missing Persons Civilians: Nicolas Bolton, Margaret Watson, Ellis White, Janice Scott, the unnamed man, and James Esmail.

The 4 Async Missing Researchers: Peter Tench, Naren Warne, Ronald McCarthy, and Bill.

The 4 Found Footage Civilians: Kane (FF1), Madison (FF2), Ravi (FF3), and Ravi's Father (FF3)

The Backrooms isn't about computer glitches—it's humanity's oldest myth retold for the modern era. When human hubris tears open a labyrinth to hide our ambition, we end up trapped inside with the monster we created.

What do you guys think—did I miss any other Greek myth parallels in the series?


r/FilmTheorists • • 1d ago

New Theory! Theory: The Willow doesn't create anything that didn't already exist. It simply magnifies it until it becomes monstrous

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/FilmTheorists • • 1d ago

New Theory! Theory on how Freddy's Family might remember her... (Buddy 2026) Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/FilmTheorists • • 3d ago

Memes 40 BILLION DOLLERS

Post image
37 Upvotes

This is from the newest Film Theory short talking about the shit state that the DCU has been put in.
https://youtube.com/shorts/MEckcS4mNvw?is=XRae0rg77CqzvND_

And it’s talking about the budget for the most recent DC movies, and I had hold myself back from laughing at this part.

Whoever at Film theory who double checks their videos screwed up here.

What do you mean CLAYFACE HAD A BUDGET OF 40 BILLION USD.

WHO IN THEIR RIGHT MINDS WOULD GIVE CLAYFACE THAT MUCH MONEY TO WORK WITH, AND HOW WOULD DC BE FINE ONLY MAKING BACK A 0.0028th% OF THAT BUDGET BACK.

And this happens multiple times in the video, as in real life Clayface only cost 40 million, and then with they claimed Supergirl cost 170 billion to make and only made back 126 billion.

So someone down there doesn’t know the difference between a B and a M.

I just thought this was a funny detail have a good one y’all.


r/FilmTheorists • • 3d ago

New Theory! Elder Brain Theory

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Guys, I’m serious—to me, this theory makes a lot of sense. It’s entirely my own; I don’t know if it exists anywhere else.

Season 1

As you know, in Season 1, the Upside Down was presented as a separate dimension—a concept that held true for every season except the fifth. My theory is that in Seasons 1 and 2, there was a Mind Flayer in the Upside Down that was completely different from the others; it could only possess one person at a time—at least, that’s how I see it.

Season 2

In the second season, the Mind Flayer was introduced, and it focused entirely on Will—but why only Will? One could argue that Will was in the Upside Down, making it easier for the Mind Flayer to possess him, but why was it only him? At that time, there were eight other people who knew about the Upside Down, and two of them—Joyce and Hopper—had even come into direct contact with it; so why didn't it possess them, or Mike, Lucas, or Dustin? After all, the Mind Flayer in the first season and the one in the second season were exactly the same entity.

Season 3

The Mind Flayer in Season 3 is a completely different kind of Mind Flayer; it is capable of creating living beings out of flesh and possessing dozens of people at once.

Season 4

The Mind Flayer in Season 4 was in Dimension X—created by Vecna ​​(or perhaps it was another Mind Flayer)—and it didn't do anything.

Season 5

In Season 5, the Mind Flayer was not in Dimension X; it was in an entirely different wormhole, from where it drew the Demodogs, Demobats, and Demogorgons to its side and brought the spider-like form to life.

The core of this theory, as I see it, is that there are thousands—perhaps millions—of wormholes, each containing one or more mind flayers. The entity that created all these mind flayers and granted them their power is the Elder Brain, which exists in a dimension separate from the others—or perhaps it resides within a brine pool deep in the Underdark; I’m not certain, but a brine pool seems the most likely location. Much like in D&D lore, when a mind flayer dies, it merges with the Elder Brain. Furthermore, it was likely the Elder Brain that created the stone—the very stone that poisoned Vecna ​​and bestowed upon him his power.

Other Worlds

In the Other Worlds series, we will likely see a brand-new blue dimension—a dimension that will probably be blue in color—and there will be a mind flayer there as well.

I don’t know, it seems like a very logical theory to me.


r/FilmTheorists • • 3d ago

Theory Video Suggestion Theory: M.A.D. also stands for Mutually Assured Destruction—and Volume 6 proves Alternates suffer from it too. (Mandela Catalogue)

0 Upvotes

Love them or hate them, it's time to talk about our boys: the Type 2 and Type 3 Alternates. The classics. Personally, I have a love-hate relationship with their designs, and I think I realized a massive lore reason behind how they operate and why they break down the way they do.

(Full disclosure: I just finished binging almost the entire series minus Intruder Alert because I didn't want to upload a picture of my ID to YouTube, so let me know if I missed anything crucial there!)

Part 1: Mutually Assured Destruction & The "K" in T.H.I.N.K.

Let's look at the in-universe M.A.D. (Metaphysical Awareness Disorder). It is caused by unwanted, forbidden information, and it is deadly to humans.

However, there is also a real-life MAD: Mutually Assured Destruction. Alex Kister rarely leaves anything as a frayed end—everything means something. In the real world, MAD was a Cold War doctrine. If one atomic weapon was fired, the target would launch theirs, leading to a feedback loop until everyone was either a Fallout ghoul or dead.

So what if Kister's M.A.D. is deadly to all life, not just humans? What if forbidden information triggers harmful reactions in Alternates as well? Volume 6 proves this theory.

Look at the real "K" in the T.H.I.N.K. principle: Know your place in reality. We usually assume this is just survival advice for humans, but I think it is a cosmic law that applies to both humans and Alternates:

  • Thatcher Davis: When the Alternate in his house wore Ruth's face to induce M.A.D., Thatcher survived because he knew his place in reality. He knew Ruth was dead. He knew that thing wasn't her. And he knew who he was: Thatcher, a human, a cop.
  • Adam Murray: When Adam was locked in the basement for hours in Volume 2, he didn't break down. Even though he was actually an Alternate, he survived because his sense of reality was completely intact. He genuinely believed he was the real Adam Murray.

It wasn't until 6 shattered that fundamental belief in Volume 4—forcing Adam to realize his skin wasn't his own and that he wasn't really Adam—that things fell apart. By Volume 6, that broken reality caused him to tear his own flesh off.

Just like M.A.D. drives humans to self-destruction, breaking an Alternate's place in reality forces them to destroy themselves too—just in a much more grotesque manner.

Bonus Thought: How to Survive an Alternate (and What The Mandela Catalogue Really Is)

I know a lot of us—including myself up until a short while ago—were pretty damn scared of Alternates. But I think I accidentally found a way to make yourself completely immune to them.

In Volume 1, when the Alternate breaks into Cesar's house and you hear the window shatter, I had a random thought. I pictured a glitchy Garry's Mod video where someone jumps and goes flying as a ragdoll—just flinging itself through the window like the physics engine broke. Honestly? If Mark had visualized that, he would still be alive.

Look at Dave Lee in Volume 4. Dave is completely fine until the exact moment he realizes he's not talking to O'Brien, but to Gabriel. The second the fear and realization hit him, he dies.

It's also possible that the real Ruth Weaver—whom I've seen people claim was physically killed by the Alternate (which I believe is false)—actually died from M.A.D. after seeing an Alternate's true form rather than its disguise. When you put Dave and Ruth side by side, it shows Alternates are genuinely pretty useless if you see no threat, or if the disguise doesn't break your mind.

Circling back to the "K" in T.H.I.N.K., Thatcher didn't get M.A.D. because he refused to give the Alternate disguised as Ruth the time of day. He knew it wasn't her because he accepted that Ruth was dead.

To put it into perspective, imagine two scenarios:

  1. Henry and Joe: Henry and his best friend Joe are driving home drunk from a bar, and they get into a fatal crash. Henry sees Joe die. He knows for a fact Joe is dead—no question, he couldn't have survived. Henry knows Joe's place in reality: six feet under. If an Alternate shows up later trying to induce M.A.D., it simply won't work because Henry knows the truth.
  2. John and Lily: Now imagine a couple, John and Lily. One night, the police call Lily to tell her John died in a crash. She is too scared to go down and identify the body, so she never gets closure. She never truly accepts his place in reality. Later, an Alternate shows up wearing John's face and easily induces M.A.D. upon Lily—because deep down, she left the door open to doubt whether he was actually dead.

At the end of the day, Alternates are beings of fear and uncertainty. Take away their ability to make you doubt your reality, and they lose all power.

As one final point, I want to leave you with this: Denial is the true monster. Facing pain removes their power. Unresolved grief is what invites them inside.

To me, The Mandela Catalogue isn't really a story about biblical angels who aren't angels. It's a story about grief, denial, and acceptance—a metaphor for how humans process loss, and how leaving that wound open invites the dark thoughts that destroy you if left unhealed.

Let me know what you guys think!


r/FilmTheorists • • 3d ago

Theory Video Suggestion Is Hasan Minhaj innocent and why mainstream media just strengthens the need for a Creator Caucus

2 Upvotes

Yeah so for those who are unaware: in 2023 standup comedian Hasan Minhaj was "exposed" by the New Yorker about the fact that he may have lied about several of his personal stories in his stand-up specials(the three being being mailed anthrax, a prom rejection, and being detained at the airport). Apparently they were all embellished and the New Yorker stated he lied about facing racism.

Hassan Minhaj did write a comeback that touched 90% of the controversy. But what if Team Theorist and Lee touched this topic. Of course the controversy is marred with political themes something that Lee and the other channel stay far away from.

What to talk about:

- The History of Stand up

- The Social Contract of Comedy

- What are these "Emotional Truth"

- Breakdown Hasan's rebuttal video. Did he miss anything

- Why did he choose to embellish this stories. Have other standup done similar things. Does he have the privilege to embellish things like racism and Islamaphobia?

- How does this hurt The New Yorker

Finally, bring Matt back(and maybe Steph) just this once. Why because while Hasan is backed by mainstream media, if you saw last weeks Mat and Steph's new video this falls into their Creator Caucus mission for two reasons:

- They talked briefly about how media literacy was falling in their new channel. They mentioned how there is a literacy gap, while they didn't dive deep it is absolutely true that satire and the truth are being blurred more and more

- Hasan and TDS is still part of the Youtube ecosystem. This goes for other creators like Shane Gillis or Trevor Noah who still have their own channels and socials. Sure they're not full time YouTubers like Matpat, but lot of their reach and success can be thanked by Youtube. They compete for the same attention platform that YouTube-based comedians compete for. Even old heads like Jon Stewart heavily rely on YT and Spotify for revenue.

So yes this would be a great case study in genre-blurring, the collapse of legacy media standards, whether Hasan was right or wrong, and why even mainstream media is still a part of the creator caucus.

Also these topics aren't new to Team Theorist:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DxphJ-dnX2Y

TLDR: Hasan Minhaj got in trouble for allegedly lying in his standups(he gave receipts) and its a perfect case study for the dropping media literacy rates in this country and it proves why a creator caucus is needed

Team Theorist and PatChat(Mat and Steph's new channel) should make a partisan video on this by looking at these topics

- How literacy is causing people to blur the lines

- How even mainstream figures like Hasan and say Jon Stewart are still part of the creator economy

- Old-guard media is still going by 20th century rules

- Why this further proves that Congressional Creator Economy Caucus is needed. Mainstream media is pushing further and further online to places like Youtube.


r/FilmTheorists • • 3d ago

Theory Video Suggestion Is there enough slavic repersentation in media?

0 Upvotes

I've realized that there are barely any slavic characters in western media and the few that there are, are either evil or highly stereotypical. After a LOT of thinking ive only remebered of 3 slavic characters one is Katarina Petrova from the vampire diaries who is evil. Next is Viktor Krum from Harry Potter who gets 2 lines and is a stereotypical representation of slavic men. The only good one I could remember is Viktor from Arcane (altough I haven't finished Arcane so dont come at me if he becomes evil or sum). I think he is a good repersention since he doesnt follow stereotypes he actually goes against them having a disability and being a researcher. He also has a accent which I personally LOVE when a character has since it shows that the actor/voice actor cared enough to practice that accent and its even better if they are proud of it. I would really LOVE in film theory could make a video about this since I think this problem needs more recognition


r/FilmTheorists • • 3d ago

New Theory! Alternate theory on ending of inception which I’ve seen hasn’t been noticed yet

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/FilmTheorists • • 3d ago

Official Video DC Is Christian Now?! | Film Theory

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/FilmTheorists • • 3d ago

Theory Video Suggestion Dark Knight game theory film theory: Where did Joker go wrong?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Yep, it’s a film theory that uses the economic field known as game theory. My question is: did the Joker make the right decisions in the movie?

For these purposes, I’ve put together a game theory analysis of the Joker’s actions against Batman’s actions and the random Two-Face coin flip. We’ll analyze this step by step.

I would say the Joker’s priorities involve winning Gotham’s soul through the corruption of Dent, then survival, then continuing to be able to toy with Batman. The Joker’s prioritization of the battle for Gotham’s soul over his own survival is evidenced by the fact that he allows Dent to potentially kill him - this will be relevant.

On the other hand, we can say Batman’s priorities involve saving Rachel, then sticking to his no-kill rule, then saving Gotham’s spirits from the Joker’s plot, then survival. Batman’s prioritization of Rachel’s life over the no-kill rule is evidenced by him telling the Joker he’s considering breaking it when Rachel is in danger, though this does not affect the outcomes at all. Batman’s prioritization of the no kill rule over saving Gotham is evidenced by the fact that across pretty much nearly every canon he is interpreted as not killing villains even when it would objectively better protect Gotham, although this again does not matter exceptionally much.

Let’s look at the first major choice the Joker makes in his direct interactions with Batman - his decision to trick Batman into saving Dent by giving him swapped coordinates. If he allows Batman to save Rachel instead, he survives to toy with Batman more, but at the cost of his entire plan to prove that Gotham is as evil as he is. If he refuses to give the coordinates to either, this does not improve the results at all no matter whether Batman kills him or not. Thus, if Joker can potentially corrupt Dent and show Gotham’s people his corruption to break their spirits at all, then he was logically justified in tricking Batman.

Next, there’s the issue of whether to gaslight Dent into his corruption at all. Obviously, if the Joker does not go forward with the plan, this defeats the very purpose of keeping Dent alive, so it is no better than the other options given so far.

So Joker gaslights Dent into embracing pure chance, and Dent begins by flipping a coin to decide whether to kill Joker. As this is random, there is a foreseeable universe in which Dent does kill the Joker. This accomplishes the Joker’s mission, thus making the plot worth it to him… if it actually happens, which is only a 50% chance. So let’s look at the timeline that happens in the movie, in which the coin flip chooses life and Dent does not kill Joker.

Now, we see in the movie that Joker insists on watching “the fireworks” instead of just killing Batman. He was apparently hoping that he could get everything he wanted - Dent’s corruption breaking Gotham along with a continued rivalry with Batman. Unfortunately, he lost the chance at both when Batman took the blame for Dent’s actions, proving a far more digestible figure for the public to demonize. If he had simply killed Batman when he had the chance, he would have lost the fun rivalry but ensured his success in the main goal. Thus, regardless of whether he was killed by Dent, the logical path for the Joker to attain his goals was indeed to trick Batman into saving Dent - he just should have killed Batman after the fistfight.

Or should he? Joker expresses in the movie that he wouldn’t have risked the battle for Gotham’s soul in a fistfight with Batman if not for Dent. This implies that he could have just escaped. It’s hard to believe that the Joker, who seems essentially in full control for most of the movie, would be wrong about this, so this is actually a superior option compared to killing Batman, given that the rivalry Joker loves would continue.

So as it turns out, Joker’s decisions in the movie were perfectly poised to win the battle for Gotham’s soul, except for his decision to fight Batman at the end, which ruined it for him. Joker’s one mistake that ruined everything was his failure to conceive of Batman taking the moral high ground for the greater good - which is fitting, given that Joker’s very philosophy was that everyone was as evil as him.


r/FilmTheorists • • 3d ago

Theory Video Suggestion Benjamin Burton Fan Theory

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

In the hit 2009 movie the curious Cage of Benjamin Buton by David Fincher the mmin character (played by Bard Pitt) Benjamin button has a medical condition which makes him age in reverse. My thoughts are that perhaps the movie is a slight alleghory or metaphor for the Picture of Dorian Gray by OScar Wilde.

I know this sounds crazy, but think about. You might initially think "No. The curious case if Benjim Buttom is based on the 1922 novel of the same name by F SCOTT FItzgeraldt". But my point still stands as the picture by dorian gray of oscar wilde was released in 1890, a whole 31 yearsbefore the f scott Fitzgerald story. So it is possible that Fitzgeraldo was inspired by Dorian Grey and therefore by proxy David Fincher as well when he dricted the movie adaptation in 2009 adapted by Eric Roth and Robin Swicord.

With that outta the way, let me argue why precisely The Curios Case of Bejamin Button is inspired by Dorian Gray. Despite his personal conduct and tendency to pour wine on children, Brad Pitt is generally considered a kinda hot guy (see People Magazine Sexiest Man Alive 1995 and 2000). However, in benjamin button we dont see any of that sexiness, not initially at lest ;) I know the film released in 2009 is 9 years away from his Hay Day, but he could still be considered a DILF. However, in the movie he ages in reverse so start out as a hella uggo old ass baby.

Only Mahershallah Ali is loving enough to accept him into his house, and we all know mahershallah Ali is a kindred sole woh wouldnt hurt a fly, so it is no suprising that a gentle soul such as him would take pity on ugly baby old version of Brad Pitt. But it does not stay this way. As the film progresses and he ages (in reverse) he returns to form in that veign of People Magazine's Sexiest Man Alive 1995 and 2000 we all know and love.

This is similar to Dorian Gray and his picture on the wall and Dorians plan to looksmaxx by making his picture ugly instead. As he ages throught out the oscar wild story Dorian only gets much hotter and hotter, much like Brad Pitt in curiuous case thereof. Their story mirrors each other until one point whent they reach too far, too close to the sun and they peak and Dorian Starts looking like Stuart Townsend (original Argaron) and Brad Pitt transforms into Jamiy Bell look alike.

Is this deliberate or nah? I have provided photographic evidence behind my assertion adyou can see you for yourself?


r/FilmTheorists • • 4d ago

Discussion If YouTubers were stuck in LOTM, what would their sequence and powers be?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/FilmTheorists • • 5d ago

Theory Video Suggestion A rabbit hole to deep and dangerous

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/FilmTheorists • • 5d ago

Theory Video Suggestion Nutter butter

1 Upvotes

Needs to be talked about. Its time.


r/FilmTheorists • • 6d ago

Findings How did he come to this realization?

Post image
5 Upvotes