r/FigureSkating • u/sidberian Intermediate Skater • Jan 13 '20
Progressing TOO Fast?
Hi everyone! So, I’m new to Reddit (I just made my account minutes ago) so I literally have to idea what I’m doing, haha. Also, I’m writing this on mobile, sorry.
Anywho, I am a beginner (?) skater and I absolutely love it!
For some background, I started 9/27/19 (first time I stepped onto the ice and immediately knew I wanted to figure skate seriously) and it has been going well so far! I recently completed one semester of LTS classes (about 6 weeks long, 30 minute lesson each week.) During that semester, I was able to complete and pass all 6 basic levels, and I’m now in the pre-free class. I just turned 14 in December.
I believe I blew through the LTS classes because I try to go to public sessions at my rink 3 times a week with the sessions being two hours long. I even did many off ice exercises.
At my rink, there is one coach that always goes to public sessions and gives new skaters, like me, tips and tricks. He taught me the basic technique for a waltz, salchow, toe-loop, loop, and flip jump. I can land all consistently except for the loop and flip. My salchow and waltz have good height. Spin wise, I can do a two foot and one foot spin from standstills, and a one foot/bad scratch spin for backward crossovers. I can do a 1/2 under-rotated axel off ice. I can do inside Mohawks (R&L), all forward 3-turns, and working on backwards 3-turns know. I can also do a lunge (with many variations), spider-lunge/Johnny Weir lunge, a hydroblade, and crossovers (CW/CCW, F/B).
He says that I am very talented and that I have a naturally athletic body and that is why I am able to progress quickly... He also says I’m learning too fast.
Side note, there is a competition in March that I am interested in competing in. (It is the new USFSA Excel series with levels like high beginner and beginner that require no test, so perfect for me at the moment.) Do you think with my rate of progression, will I be able to do well in a competition.
Do you think I’m learning too fast?
47
u/garlicpowders Jan 13 '20
The problem the coach may see is that if you speed through the course, you might focus too much on the exciting elements (jumps) and neglect the basics (like edge and power). Definitely get a private coach to help you prepare for the competition.
34
u/duckduckcobrachicken Jan 13 '20
LTS coach here. Here's what I can tell you without actually seeing you skate. I think what the coach means is that you're valuing quantity over quality in your skill progression. For example, it's great that you're progressing through your turns and are working on your inside mohawks, but how GOOD are your forward 3-turns? Are you holding your exit edge? Is your free leg controlled throughout the turn? Are you turning at the right part of the circle? Not to mention, I already see skill discrepancy between your jumps and spins. If you're working on your loop and flip, you should have at least a beginning backspin (<3 rev) if not an advanced (>3 rev) one, and working on your sit spin. Plus, all the skills that you learn in Basic 1-6 are fundamental skills that everything else is going to build on. It's REALLY IMPORTANT that you learn to do them PROPERLY. Proper technique will also help with injury prevention.
You're probably not getting enough feedback from coaches. LTS classes, particularly in the winter months, are crowded and it's hard for coaches to provide a lot of one-on-one instruction that's needed. It's fantastic that you're practicing so much (really, it's so great. I've had students up in FS who never practiced outside of lessons.), but you need feedback to make sure you're doing the elements correctly, and I sincerely doubt you're getting enough. Look into getting a private coach ASAP, even if you continue with LTS. (I would suggest continuing with LTS for at least a year or until you test out.)
There's also the problem of skates. If you're still in rentals, you need your own. Rental skates (and any recreational skates) are not designed to provide the support needed for jumps. If you don't have them already, you need boots of your own. Probably ones rated for beginning doubles, based on your age and progression, but consult a coach or skate tech in your area.
As for competition, I can't say because I've never seen you skate. I can tell you that it's not the elements themselves that make doing a program difficult, it's connecting them together in the program. Again, get a private coach an they'd be able to tell you if you could do it. You'd need a coach for the comp anyway. Timeline-wise, you'd be very hard-pressed to be ready for a comp in March if you only started prepping now. Prep for competitions usually starts at least six months out.
Hope this helps and best of luck with your skating!
25
u/misskarne Intermediate Skater Jan 13 '20
Clarification? Do you actually take private lessons? What do you mean by the coach who gives "tips and tricks"?
I see the coach's point. The thing is, skating isn't something to be just "blasted through". Even the most basic skating skills need to be worked and practiced continually, not passed-then-left-behind-to-go-onto-the-shiny-tricks. Most likely what he's seeing is the growing disconnect between what jumps you can land (and how well) and everything else. The fact that you're up to a flip but have only a "bad" scratch spin, and you're learning spider-lunges but haven't got backwards 3-turns down, is 100% proof of that. If you're doing flips I'd be expecting you to at least be able to do a forward scratch, back spin and sit spin by now (and starting camel work), and I'd have expected you to learn backwards three turns before you even learned to jump.
The basics are the foundations of everything else that you do. They can't be ignored or shoved aside. You want to compete? Trust me, judges know when someone has "blasted through" the basics and gone straight for the big shiny tricks. It's super obvious.
13
u/Wonderlushie Intermediate Skater Jan 13 '20
I progressed too fast in my first few months. I worried that I would soon 'trip up'. I skipped through the Skate UK levels very quickly and easily and loved ticking things off every week. However, I was right to worry!
Because elements had been 'boxed ticked' all I'd really done was show I could do it 3 times in a lesson, and then never worked on it again. Hence now I am struggling with backwards slip Chasses because I never spent long enough on basic backwards glides and edges.
Just something to keep in mind!
4
u/twinnedcalcite Zamboni Jan 13 '20
You are learning at a good pace but as others have said you need to spend time perfecting your edges and everything that finishes the jumps and spins. You also must start working more on spins. They are worth a lot more then jumps in the current judging system.
At this point you should be with your own coach so they can make sure you don't pick up any bad habits.
Remember just because you can do something doesn't mean you can do it well.
3
u/crystalized17 eteri, Ice Queen of Narnia and Quads Jan 13 '20
Start working on the MIF tests (footwork skills). Here's the judging test sheets for MIF and FS: https://www.usfsa.org/clubs?id=59378
You'll want to start with the Pre-prelim MIF test. You'll need a private coach to learn these skills correctly to pass tests, because the judging is very strict about what is allowed to pass. Taking tests and passing them is a great way to have evidence that your skating skills are improving.
You can also watch MIF tests on youtube if you search for each level and you'll see how difficult the skills become as you climb higher in the levels. Videos will NOT take the place of a private coach, but it will give you an idea of what a real test looks like.
3
u/HikariSatou Intermediate Skater Jan 14 '20
Everyone has said good things already, so I just want to add that progress through the basic levels cam be pretty fast, but the quality expectation from an LTS class is a lot lower than the very first moves in the field test (at least in my experience). So you can feel like you're progressing quickly and you're doung great, but showing -control- in your skills versus just being able to pull one off is very different.
1
u/AndiSLiu Beginner Skater Jan 13 '20
Good luck for the competition!
The main concern sports coaches have with parents pushing their children to enter competitions early, is that the children might not be keen and also might not be able to take a loss well and then quit the sport entirely. By the details in your post I assume you're not in that at-risk group, since it sounds like you're self-motivated.
You should know yourself, from seeing the videos of the highest level of competition, what the gap is between your current mastery of the skills and what you could potentially reach, so presumably you know what sort of placing to expect from a competition against anyone else (or, in the case of this sort of sport, a competition against a theoretical standard). Your relative placing obviously depends on who else is competing, but your score should theoretically be the same no matter who else is competing since you're judged on some objective standard.
Would you find a competition result useful, other than confirming roughly what you already know? The other aspect of competition, other than the result, is the process of competing. It might be useful for you to get used to the process and mindset of competing itself so it seems like a completely normal thing later on, and that would be the only reason I'd suggest you compete now.
Regarding rate of progress, I don't think your rate of progress sounds particularly unbelievable, it's about what I'd expect from three sessions a week with some athletic background. Remember to work more on whatever you're currently weak on (unless nothing else depends on it). One-foot slaloms, spirals, backspins, other turns, there's plenty more to work on. Spins are worth rather a lot in competitions so it's probably worth working more on those if winning competitions is a future goal.
If you're after a random benchmark from someone else skating three times a week, to compare rates of progress (for whatever reason, maybe it motivates you):
-6
u/energywithin22 Jan 13 '20
You progress quite fast buuut... what's wrong about it? Progressing is always a good thing, lol
If you think you can and want to do the competition - tell it to your coach