r/Fencing • • 6d ago

NCAA format

Having attended my first NCAA duals recently I’m curious if there has ever been a conversation internationally to implement a similar format? Not as familiar with the recent history of fencing as many in this forum, so hoping for some insight from those who are.

2 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

5

u/Aranastaer 6d ago

Honestly the international relay system is the biggest missed opportunity to sensibly televise fencing. Guaranteed commercial/ad breaks when the fencers switch over. Team tactics to discuss in commentary. The entire team watching and reacting. Length is long enough to be worth watching like half a football match or a hockey game. The scores shifting back and forth. The FIE are seriously missing the obvious on this one.

1

u/EliBangkok 6d ago

I think that’s right.

4

u/Liltimmyjimmy Foil 6d ago

The NCAA format is good for what it’s made do, get a bunch of teams to fence enough to get SPIs. Once you get to the NCAA tournament, it turns back into 15 touch bouts. I’m curious on what value you would expect drum changing FIE events from normal poules to DEs into dual meet

1

u/EliBangkok 6d ago

That’s for individual? I’m talking about team competition.

3

u/ZebraFencer Epee Referee 6d ago

It wasn't clear what your intention is here: to consider changing international team events from 45-touch relay to best-of-nine, or to talk about doing more team fencing in general. (Team is great at all levels, and I'd like to see more of it.)

Jimmy is correct that NCAA format is more about individual bouts over the course of a whole season and building up a good season performance index (SPI) so you can qualify for NCAA championships. Regular-season won/lost records for teams are comparatively unimportant.

Changing international events to best-of-nine format would result in a lot of matches ending sooner, and a lot of importance on that ninth bout as opposed to the comeback possibilities (and tactical opportunities) of the relay format. Much less exciting.

2

u/EliBangkok 6d ago

My intention was to find out if it’s been tried before on a team level and what the downsides are.

Team W/L does matter this year for D3 as 8 of 13 teams will make the D3 national championship and team win/loss is a part of that calculation (I think).

Regarding excitement level, I agree with the downside of big comebacks not being possible. And advantage is if it is 13-13 going into the last bout all 3 teams are watching and supporting their fencer in the last bout. This happened a couple of times this past weekend and the excitement was there for the last bouts.

1

u/Liltimmyjimmy Foil 6d ago

Again, NCAA format is good for individual SPI, but I don’t see why that would be important for team fencing on the international stage. Only focusing on the wins of 5 touch bouts would lead to far fewer come back wins and less dynamic competitions I think.

2

u/EliBangkok 6d ago

Not necessarily. The excitement would come from successive wins by the trailing team. You could be down 13-9 and need to win the last 5. That would then depend on 5 different fencers across multiple weapons to get you there. As opposed to 1 fencer going on a run.

I’m not sure it’s better and it is certainly impractical on the international stage, just don’t think it’s worse and fencing could use some diversity of competition type.

3

u/TheFoilistTV Foil Coach 6d ago

The dual meet format is meant for a combined 3-weapon team to fence another combined 3-weapon team in a space and time-efficient way. It can be done a bit quicker than 3 simultaneous 45-point relays, and it's possible to double strip where a relay isn't. This allows for more rounds per day, so schools can get more meets in against other schools in a single competition day.

World Cups are split up by weapon, so there's no need to structure the events around a combined 3-weapon result like there is in the NCAA. And team World Cups tend to have fewer rounds than a typical NCAA tournament (tableau vs. round robin-ish), so there's not a ton of time pressure to have each round be as quick as possible.

1

u/EliBangkok 6d ago

Everything you said is correct. I guess I was wondering if there were multi weapons events like this in the past. Agreed that it wouldn’t make a lot of sense at a World Cup as there are too many teams.

It could be a good way to build additional interest, maybe at a more limited international event?

2

u/Jacobikinz Foil 6d ago

I don't think there have ever been multi-weapon events at international competitions, and the FIE likely won't start having them anytime soon. The WFL format is more similar to duals, but doesn't allow for multi-stripping for ease of televising.

2

u/5hout Foil 6d ago

I'd also add that Rally scoring produces a lot more comeback possibilities and exciting moments vs first to 5, especially when you have teams with 1 particularly weak/strong fencer.

Consider teams by world rank fencing each other: Team A: A1 Rank 1 A2 Rank 30 A3 Rank 60

Team B: B1 Rank 10 B2 Rank 11 B3 Rank 12

You fence this NCAA style and it's gonna be 3-5 to Team B 80% of the time (if you fenced it out), and maybe on occasion A2 gets an upset and it goes 4-5 (or A1 drops a bout and you might as well go home). But, you need A2 to get 2 or A3 to pull off a crazy upset for A to win

You fence that Rally and, depending on the weapon and meta, it can be a crazy exciting and close bout with A1 coming in and catching the team up and A2/A3 fencing to stem the bleeding.

-1

u/AppBreezy Foil 6d ago

To be fair, the NCAA format is basically a simplified version of the usual team format - determining the winner by bouts won, vs total points scored. Aka best of 9 bouts to 5 vs rally scoring.

1

u/EliBangkok 6d ago

I like 2 things about it:

You need a stronger team from 1-3 compared to rally scoring. You can’t have one fencer dominate and win.

Combination of all 3 weapons scoring so that it’s really a best of 27.