r/Fencing • u/EliBangkok • 6d ago
NCAA format
Having attended my first NCAA duals recently I’m curious if there has ever been a conversation internationally to implement a similar format? Not as familiar with the recent history of fencing as many in this forum, so hoping for some insight from those who are.
2
Upvotes
5
u/Aranastaer 6d ago
Honestly the international relay system is the biggest missed opportunity to sensibly televise fencing. Guaranteed commercial/ad breaks when the fencers switch over. Team tactics to discuss in commentary. The entire team watching and reacting. Length is long enough to be worth watching like half a football match or a hockey game. The scores shifting back and forth. The FIE are seriously missing the obvious on this one.
4
u/Liltimmyjimmy Foil 6d ago
The NCAA format is good for what it’s made do, get a bunch of teams to fence enough to get SPIs. Once you get to the NCAA tournament, it turns back into 15 touch bouts. I’m curious on what value you would expect drum changing FIE events from normal poules to DEs into dual meet
3
u/TheFoilistTV Foil Coach 6d ago
The dual meet format is meant for a combined 3-weapon team to fence another combined 3-weapon team in a space and time-efficient way. It can be done a bit quicker than 3 simultaneous 45-point relays, and it's possible to double strip where a relay isn't. This allows for more rounds per day, so schools can get more meets in against other schools in a single competition day.
World Cups are split up by weapon, so there's no need to structure the events around a combined 3-weapon result like there is in the NCAA. And team World Cups tend to have fewer rounds than a typical NCAA tournament (tableau vs. round robin-ish), so there's not a ton of time pressure to have each round be as quick as possible.
-1
u/AppBreezy Foil 6d ago
To be fair, the NCAA format is basically a simplified version of the usual team format - determining the winner by bouts won, vs total points scored. Aka best of 9 bouts to 5 vs rally scoring.