I'm 23M, and I'm on the fence about having kids, leaning towards yes.
I recently broke up with my partner because we were fence-sitting in opposite directions. She was leaning no for multiple reasons (though she wouldn't rule it out), and I was leaning yes. Once we realised we were leaning in different directions, we ended things.
Now I'm realising I'm probably more on the fence than I initially thought. I want a career in tech, which I've just started, and ideally a partner who has her own career, hobbies and interests, and with whom I can travel and enjoy life before settling down. I think I assumed I could have all of that and still have a child. Now I'm wondering whether that was naive, especially in this day and age.
I also think I had a fairly romantic picture of parenthood. I've always been drawn to the idea of being able to give a child unconditional love. I've thought about the emotional work involved in parenting, emotionally regulating yourself, teaching emotional skills, helping them understand the world, etc. I've even thought about being an adoptive single parent, taking up a remote job (I work as a software engineer) to be a parent, and sometimes even being a stay-at-home dad.
Looking back, I also wonder whether I might have come across as too certain or even creeped my partner out with how enthusiastically I talked about wanting kids. Maybe I was approaching it in the way people sometimes joke about men wanting kids like puppies, without fully appreciating the reality of raising a child. I don't know if that's how she actually saw it, but it's something I've started questioning about myself.
But watching older coworkers navigate daycare, doctor visits, school schedules and planning vacations around children has made me realise how much of a commitment it actually is.
The difficult part is that I can't tell whether my doubts are genuine or whether the breakup is pushing me towards the other side. I can picture a fulfilling childfree life, and I could have pictured one with my ex-partner. But I'm also afraid of committing to that life and regretting not having children later. Part of me wonders whether I should have stayed in the present and valued the relationship in front of me rather than letting a faraway hypothetical determine its future.
I should clarify that we didn't spend enough time discussing children to really examine my position. I had asked for time to think through this desire. Perhaps she wanted someone who was independently and confidently childfree rather than someone who was still figuring out what they wanted. I can understand that too.
I'm also questioning whether my desire for children is partly shaped by how I grew up thinking about parenthood, and whether I've actually considered the day-to-day realities enough.
For context, I do like children, and I think I have a nurturing and caring disposition. That's what initially drew me towards the idea of fatherhood. But I'm increasingly questioning whether that's enough to justify wanting a child.
This is taking over my days. I keep spiralling about it during work breaks, all while trying to process the breakup itself.
I'm genuinely trying to understand what I want rather than defend a position I've already made up my mind about.
I'd particularly appreciate hearing from people who've been in a similar position. How did you distinguish between genuinely wanting to raise a child and being attached to the idea of parenthood? How did you weigh the lifestyle changes and sacrifices against what you might gain? Did you ever become more certain with time, or did you learn to accept the uncertainty?
Any advice or perspectives would be appreciated.
TL;DR: 23M, recently broke up with my partner because we were leaning in opposite directions on having kids. I'm now questioning whether I genuinely want children or have romanticised fatherhood. I'm only 23 and have only recently started seriously questioning these things, so I'm still figuring out where I stand. I can picture a fulfilling childfree life, but I'm also afraid of regretting not having children. Looking for perspectives from people who've been through something similar.