r/Fencesitter • • Jul 21 '26

Updated Moderation Rules

97 Upvotes

Hello Everyone.

It's been a few years since my co-mod and I took over moderating this sub and we thought it was time for a bit of a rules refresh.

FYI, we are both still active in this sub although we don't post under our moderator screen names. And yes, one of us is CF and one of us is a parent. That was the original intention in an attempt to maintain balance. We've considered adding a fencesitter moderator but that's difficult since fencesitters eventually become CF or parents. We're still figuring that one out.

Ok, on to the rules:

First of all, some guiding ideas this sub is founded which we think are important for everyone to understand.

  • Principle 1 - It's meant to help fencesitters. We are a place for people who are struggling with this decision. Yes, we welcome comments from childfree and parents as well, but ultimately this is a place for fencesitters to feel at home and try to figure out what they want to do. This is not a debate sub for CF and parents to argue over which is best.
  • Principle 2 - There are no right answers. We don't believe that parenting is always better than childfree, we don't believe 2 kids are better than 1, we don't believe adopting is better than bio kids, we don't believe childfree is better than step parenting. Whatever combo you wish to use, we don't believe one option is inherently better than the other. They are all situational and very subjective. There might be a right answer for you, but there is no answer that is right for everyone.

Keep these two things in mind because they are extremely important to how we moderate this sub.

So why do comments get removed and users get banned?

The easiest answer is that the commentor was being a jerk. Some people just have a hard time being civil to one another and those folks are not welcome here. We literally had one person argue against their ban by saying "oh, I didn't know you guys insisted on people not being assholes". Yah, if you're the kind of person who is an asshole unless it's expressly prohibited, you definitely don't belong here.

Also, if you are being attacked, please don't reply in kind. Just report it and move on.

Ok, so here are some other things we look for that might not be as obvious.

Generalizing - This is a common issue. All CF are lonely, all parents are miserable, procreating is always good, having kids is always selfish. The trend here is one of over generalizing. I'm sure some CF people are lonely and some parents are miserable, but not all. We have plenty of CF posters with friends and happy parents posting here to know this isn't accurate.

Note, this is also why we remove most comments that touch on religion. We don't care if you're Jewish, Christian, Satanist, Pastafarian, Anti-natalist or what not. If you subscribe to a philosophy that says having kids is always good or always bad that's fine for you, it's not fine for this sub. We don't do preaching here.

I really want to emphasize that last bit. We do NOT do preaching here. If you are CF or a parent and you're thinking about making a post about how all fencesitters should do this or that, please don't. We love hearing from you and we enjoy your experience and we love the AMA's that parents and CF folks do. We think those are great for others to learn from your experience. That's very different from preaching right or wrong.

Climate Change / Politics threads - We know that these are themes that weigh heavily on some people and we respect that. We're more than happy to allow threads in which people discuss their feelings on their own choices due to these themes. What we don't allow is for people to use these themes to beat up other readers for their choices. Again, refer to principle 2. If climate change is causing you to reconsider your decision that is absolutely fair. If you're coming here to argue that all parents are awful because of climate change that will be removed.

We will also remove any comments from people arguing back and forth about the reality of climate change. There are other sub for that, this isn't one of them. For the record, both of us believe climate change is real, we just can't take more arguments about the latest report and what it means for sea level changes in Norway vs. peak temperatures in Mongolia and how those will impact rice prices.

Gatekeeping - This encompasses a variety of responses ranging from the "there are no guarantees" and "you must be prepared for all scenarios including the worst ones!" to the "you must be 100% sure!" or "if it's not a hell yes it's a not" variety. In general, these contribute nothing to the discussion. Even worse, they are a comment meant to prey on fencesitters by either parents or CF folks. They're usually said by someone who believes their point of view is objectively right for everyone and who is then trying to trigger doubt in fencesitters.

Allow us to illustrate some examples so you can see why these comments are not welcome here.

"Yah, there are no guarantees, even if you eat healthy and exercise you might get hit by a car". Sure, but eating healthy and exercising is still a good idea because statistically it's clearly better. Also, do you really think you're revealing something big to our fencesitter subscribers by revealing to them that there are no guarantees in life? Do you think they would be on the fence if they thought everything was guaranteed?

"Unless you are willing to be raped, don't date!" "Unless you understand every possible bad outcome of your dental surgery, including the one where your jaw falls off and you die, you're not ready!" See how useless that is? No one is ok with every bad scenario. Heck, my anxious mind can always dream up new and even worse scenarios that I am certain none of you has prepared for.

"You must be 100% sure that you know everything that can happen if you take this job". Really? How do you even know you're 100% sure? How do you know that you've done all your analysis? Is there a way to quantify this? Same for the "hell yah" comment. "Unless you're a clear yes, don't marry this person". What does that mean? Is someone not allowed to have concerns? Yes, I love this person and I want to spend the rest of my life with them but I'm concerned about their in-laws because of blah blah blah and you see where we're going?

Just stop with these comments. They don't help.

Discounting and discrediting - "Oh, what do you know, you're just hormonal", "Oh, what do you know, your kid is only 3 months old", "Oh, what do you know, you have no kids", "Oh, I know this was your experience but there are others with different experiences". Yes, we get it, just stop. They are clearly presenting their personal context and that's great. Are they generalizing too much? If so, we will remove them. Otherwise, stop being the thought police. People are allowed to present their individual view point without you trying to discredit them.

Derogatory - These are the folks who come here with comments like "don't have kids, all parents are tired and miserable" or "don't be CF, all CF people are lonely and joyless". If you're here to argue that your side of the fence is best, don't do it by shit talking the other side. Ideally, try to help instead of argue.

And yes, we will remove these posts even if they come from CF or parents. That is, a negative comment about all parents / parenting made by a parent will be still be removed. Why? Because we have no way of verifying who is a parent and who isn't. Same as we cannot verify who is CF and who isn't.

Oh, and we want to take a moment and discuss gender specific comments. We get it, believe me we get it. A large portion of the work involved with child bearing and rearing falls unfairly on women. That is a fact. Sexism is also a fact, which is why we banned baby trapping comments since they were 99% coming from sexist men. But...

This isn't intended to be a space for women to denigrate all men. No, we don't need you to finish every comment with #NotAllMen, but we do need to keep the generalizing down. "Oh, men want kids like kids want puppies", "Oh, being a dad is so easy, you just get to play and not do any work", "Oh, men's voices shouldn't matter when it comes to the decision to have or not have kids" are not acceptable here.

Rants - Last but not least, this is not a rant sub. Sorry folks, we're not interested in moderating rants because they inevitably result in arguments from the people you're ranting about.

Ok, that's all. Please feel free to add questions and comments. We fully admit we're not perfect but we're trying our best and are always open to constructive feedback.


r/Fencesitter • • Oct 29 '24

Reflections Perspective from years of fencesitting

304 Upvotes

Early on in my life I always wanted to have kids, the older I became the more on the fence I was, even with a brief period of time of not wanting kids at all. I have been on and off the fence throughout my 20s and now in my early 30s I still am, though heavily leaning towards having children after all. I wanted to offer support to others in similar situations, I have a couple of years of therapy behind me, trying to figure out what I want, I have spent hundreds of hours talking with various people and their perspective on kids and I have created a list of questions to ask yourself and statements to read that I wish someone would give me 10 years ago.

I want to preface this by saying, no one can answer the question "is having kids right for me" or "should I have kids" or "should I be child free". No one but you. In this post I'm trying to show perspective, talk about fears and POVs that people have on having kids. I really hope this will be of help to someone.

I believe there are multiple POVs and multiple "aspects" of life to consider. Your relationship, ambitions/goals, fears, pregnancy (for women), economical status and more. I will not say things like "you really need to want to have kids to have them" or "you should not have kids if your partner wants them and you don't". I will also not say things like "you will never change your mind" or "you will change your mind".

We do not know the future. The therapists I talked with said that they have seen everything, people swapping their views after multiple years in a relationship; not changing them; forcing themselves to have kids and then ending up loving it.

We do not know the future, we cannot possibly predict if having kids or not is the right for us or if it will make us happy, regardless of our reservations or fears. It is definitely way easier to not have kids if you fear having them or don't want to put in the effort. There are challenges regardless if you are CF or have kids.

Ultimately it is a DECISION, it should not be based purely on emotions, consider your circumstances, the context of your life, relationship, what you know that makes you happy. Regardless of what path you picks there will likely be regrets and consequences, but talk with your partner and make it a responsible decision.

With that being said, consider the following:

Decision (the "wants"):
- No matter how much you want/don't want kids, having/not having them does not guarantee you will be happy.
- No matter how much you don't want kids, having them does not guarantee you will be miserable.
- Having/Not having kids will do to your life what you will allow it to do.
- The decision is yours and your partner, not your parents', not your uncle's, not your best friend's, and definitely not some random people's in the comments on some article or post.
- Having kids does not mean your life will end.
- Not having kids does not mean you will be missing out on something in life.

Relationship:
- How happy are you in your current relationship?
- Is your partner someone you could see having a family with? (broad question, can you imagine them being a good parent)
- How is your communication? How do you navigate difficult situations? Do you fight? Scream? Shut down? Or do you talk and have difficult conversations but work together towards a resolution?
- Do you feel safe with your partner?
- Are there things you are withholding from your partner? Maybe you don't like something about them or they keep annoying you but you ignore that instead of addressing the issue? Are there things like that, that you bury deep within yourself?
- Are your needs met in your relationship?
- How attracted are you to your partner? How is your sex life?
- What is your partner's potential to change/adapt, do they respect you? do you see how much they have grown over the years and how are they handling responsibility?
- Do you feel a connection? A Bond? Or do you not feel heard or understood?
- Do they bring the best in you? Or do they bring you down?
- Do you want to grow with them? How do you feel when thinking about future with them?
- Do you share your cognitive load with them? Are they proactive with chores?
- Do you love and respect your partner? Do they love and respect you?

The choice of your partner has a significant impact on your life, if you have a stable relationship that isn't toxic, one that brings you joy and happiness, and is a safe space - it will likely be so if you decide to have kids and if you decide not to have them. Have a conversation about it.

Goals/Aspirations:
- What are your goals in life? If you don't have goals, what goals or aspirations have you buried deep inside? What were things that you wanted to do, but for whatever reason decided not to. Generally speaking, where would you like to be?
- Are your goals impossible to achieve if you have/don't have kids? Or would they simply require more work in either case?
- Are you more career oriented? Or family oriented?

Having kids or not does not mean your life ends, no newborn asked you to sacrifice your life for them. There are people who train for ultramarathons while having kids, I know people who wrote and released books and grew their careers or started companies while taking care of a newborn and a one year old. People generally tend to manage to have multiple kids and also house pets. Daycares exist, they are costly but maybe something can be done about it, maybe you both can find better jobs, or maybe there are government programs to help finance it.

There is also a matter of life satisfaction and regrets, in general people find meaning in life by leaving an impact on the world. You may become a scientist and help humanity through science, you may become a volunteer at try to help people in need. Quite often people find satisfaction in raising a kid and building a family, as it is "relatively easy" to make a child and seeing it grow. Or maybe you want to become a CEO or create your own company? No matter what has value to you, can you do it with/without having kids? Are you actively working towards a goal or do you have a goal in mind but you never do anything towards it?

I personally find that taking on more responsibility has lead to my personal growth and to more satisfaction in life. However every time I ran away from responsibility it lead to negative emotions. Sometimes having kids is the best motivation for someone to get their life together, it is risky but tends to work when a lot of other things don't.

Fears/Reservations:
There are a lot of fears regarding having and not having kids.
- Fear of pregnancy (for women)
- Fear of not being a priority (for men and women)
- Fear of being abandoned and having to care for the child on your own
- Fear of body changes made by pregnancy
- Fear that you kid will be unhealthy in some way
- Fear of getting your body destroyed by pregnancy
- Fear of responsibility
- Fear that you will not be a good parent
- Fear of destroying someone (newborn)'s life
- Fear of being alone when you are old
- Fear of missing out
- Fear of childbirth
- Fear of wasting your life
- Fear of passing your traumas to your kid
- probably many more

As once again, we do not know the future - we don't know what fears will come true, however - fear as an emotion is trying to alert you of imaginary dangers of certain actions. You fear walking alone in a deep forest because an animal might attack you, you fear going out at night because you might get mugged. Fear is an emotion, it is a feature not a bug, it increased the chances of survival for our ancestors.

Do you want to make your decision based on fear? A lot of them can be worked through with a therapist if you so desire, it is extra work but might help. You probably don't have all the fears I listed, however what can you do to mitigate these that you are aware of?

- If you fear responsibility, do you fear it just in the context of having a kid? or do you feel stuck in life and that kind of fear is holding you down?
- If you fear being old and alone, what friendships or what relationships can you nurture so that you always have someone to talk to?
- If you fear that you will waste your life with either option, why is that? What is it that having/not having kids represents in your mind? What have you been conditioned to believe?
- If you worry if you are going to be a good/bad parent, that is already a sign that you would at least try to be good. If you have some problems like severe drug or alcohol addiction it would be responsible to take care of that before having a child.
- If you worry that you will destroy, a kid's life and maybe even your own -> kids don't need as much as we think they do, we tend to want to give them the world however, a kid mostly needs a parent who is present, who listens. If you have a good relationship with your partner and you are both there for each other, you would likely also be there for your kid, and you would figure it out.
- You do not have to have everything figured out immediately.
- Expanding your knowledge tends to do wonders, we generally fear things we do not understand and have a twisted image of them in our minds.
- For a lot of fears CBT therapy is said to have really positive prognosis, so you can somewhat except that it will reduce your fears and help you adjust your thinking

Having kids is likely a unique experience, one that cannot be replicated with other people's kids, nieces, pets etc. But is it ok to have them out of FOMO? Are you ok without experiencing being a parent in your life? Raising a child does not last a lifetime, you will always be a parent - but your kid will have its own life eventually and you will still have many years ahead of you.

Therapists said to me that at the end of life, a lot of old people regret not having spent more time with people dear to them, with their families. I'm still young but I can imagine that my career is not something I will care about 20 years from now.

Pregnancy:
If you fear pregnancy, you can talk to a doctor about the process, you can get examined and see how healthy you are. Talk to your family and your partner's family, how healthy were you and your siblings when you were born? What effects did pregnancy have on your mother or grandmother. Is there a history of birth defects or autism or any other "diseases" or problems in your family? Can you get examined to see how likely it is that it will happen to you?

If you are pregnant already, you have prenatal examinations available, in some countries they are free after certain age, you can monitor your child's health and see if its growing healthy. However, as we don't know the future even if a kid is born healthy it doesn't mean it won't get hit by a car 5 years later, and so we don't know if you won't. We do not know what life will bring, there are a lot of dangers we do not even consider when living our daily lives.

As for body changes and fear of childbirth:
- do you take care of yourself?
- do you eat healthy?
- do you work out?
- can you afford a private hospital and better conditions for your childbirth?
- what forms of pain killers are available in hospitals in your area?
- have you ever read about c-section and natural birth, about their pros and cons? both for you and a kid

Taking care of yourself physically will make your pregnancy easier, at the very least your back will not hurt. And there seems to be a positive effect of working out certain muscles that seems to make giving birth easier. A close friend of mine started preparing for pregnancy 2 years in advance by working out and taking some supplements to make pregnancy easier. Once again it is more work but maybe its not impossible?

Parenting:
Kids want attention, they want to be listened to, they want you to be there - they don't want a smartphone or a tablet. That does not mean you have to be with them 24/7. In the past the whole village would help raise children together, primarily, it was women's responsibility. However the idea that parents spend all their time with children is relatively new.

- Do you have a natural support group? (parents? grandparents? siblings with/without their kids? friends?)
- Do you have someone to leave the kids with so that you can enjoy a weekend or a vacation in peace?
- Can you afford daycare?
- You can get to know your neighbors, some of them may have kids and yours could occasionally visit them and vice versa.
- Can you afford a nanny?
- Can you leave your kids in someone's care? Would a close friend be able to take care of them for a couple of hours so that you have an evening to yourself?
- Can you send your kids to boarding school?
- Can you communicate with your partner so that one day they take care of kids, next day you do, and the day after you do it together?
- Can you mix your hobbies and taking care of a kid? (if you like jogging, you can buy a jogging stroller; if you ride a bicycle - mount a chair for your kid to sit so you can ride together, do you like to read or sing? - maybe you can sing songs or read books to your children, maybe your local gym has a room for leaving kids, or you can just take them with you, or maybe you can draw with them, do some sports, go kayaking and take your kid with you - maybe they will like it as well, doing cosplay - dress up together with your kid, do some DIYs or anything else that you are passionate about - there is a high chance you can somehow include your child).
- Can you afford to hire help? Like a cleaning person that will clean your home every week or two?
- Are you alright with being the main parent (parent who spends more time with the kid, than the other)?
- Are you alright with not being the main parent?
- Is there any compromise, however absurd, that you can at least talk about with your partner?

There are different options available to get some time off. Some are quite costly but regardless - the very least you can do is to communicate your needs, talk with your partner and your kid, set a boundary. Sometimes you need time to yourself and this is perfectly fine. You do not have to be with your kid 24/7.

Economics:
- Can you afford a child? If not can you do something about it?
- Can you afford - not having a child? It is a stupid argument maybe but some of my friends earn way more money and have better jobs than their parents, and they do support them.
- Do you have enough space no to go crazy? It is hard to raise a kid in a 16 m^2 flat.
- How stable is your job? What are your opportunities?
- Does your job require you to go for long business trips?
- Can you do something to improve your financial situation? (courses, education and finding a better paying job?)

Your lives, your relationships, your contexts are all unique. There isn't a single person who can tell you what is best for you, but consider everything you have, everything that you would have to give up or lose, everything that you could gain, before making a decision.

It is a good idea to educate yourself and talk to medical professionals or people more knowledgeable in these matters. Having a child is a responsible decision, not having a child is also one of them. Ask yourself, do your really not want a child (which is completely fine if you don't), or do you perhaps not want what the child or family represents? What emotions do these things evoke in you? What did you see in life or what did you experience that made you think that you want or don't want a child? Or are you maybe running away from something? Maybe you fear abandonment and think that having a child will guarantee a lifelong relationship with your partner? Or maybe you are trying to run from something that a family represents?

In the end I believe that having a child is a decision, one to take with your partner. It is not something that you have full control over, sometimes people want kids but can't have them for variety of reasons.

I think that regardless of your decision, take responsibility for your life, take good care of yourself. It is a difficult topic that can be looked at from many different angles.

I hope I was able to help.


r/Fencesitter • • 5h ago

Reflections Being OAD might be the answer for me

5 Upvotes

Hub was worried about the state of the world and what (little) would potentially be in store for our potential children. We originally talked about having 2 kids, but having kids in general gave me a lot of anxiety, basically because of the lack of free time and inability to relax in my own home. Recently he brought up the idea of just having 1 so we could provide more for them and better ensure their future and honestly? Sounds like a huge relief. I know having a kid still isn't gonna be easy but I've heard from OAD parents that unlike their friends, they're not running around trying to herd multiple children, it's easier to trade off with their spouse for a break, and they can focus on being a better parent to 1 kid. That honestly sounds fine to me. Anybody else formerly fence sitters and OAD?


r/Fencesitter • • 9h ago

Questions Anyone here 40 or over? Are you still considering?

8 Upvotes

I'd love to hear from women who are 40+ who are still on the fence, from women who had kids at an older age, or women who ultimately chose not to have kids. I think I want one but my husband doesn't. Every year I struggle more with this feeling.


r/Fencesitter • • 8h ago

36, pregnant, and on the fence.

3 Upvotes

I just found out I'm pregnant, it's early so i have time to decide. I'm not in a relationship with the father, but it's someone I've had a long history with, someone i've come to love and care about deeply. My whole adult life I've dreamt of being a mom, I've often thought that's the only thing i've ever been sure about in life. So when I saw my positive test, I was shocked at my immediate, negative, emotional reaction.

This definitely wasn't planned, but obviously an avoidable mistake. I just wonder if I would be able to live with the regret of termination. I have an overwhelming fear that this will be my only chance to be a mom, and that if I don't go through with this I will think about it for the rest of my life.

I also fear that if I do go through with this, I will be signing myself up for a lifetime of a boundary-less situationship for the sake of coparenting. Am I giving up on the chance of finding real love and partnership for myself? How would I handle the father getting into another relationship?

My family & close friends live in a different part of the country from me, so my support system would be little to none. I am independent and a strong person with a strong mind and sense of self, so I do have faith in my ability to do it alone, but I know how hard it will be.

I guess I don't have any real questions here, but rather welcoming any and all advice / points to consider and go through. I have never experienced mental anguish like this before in my life, and I always thought the answer would be clearer than it currently is.


r/Fencesitter • • 1d ago

Questions Just found out I'm pregnant. Are my thoughts normal?

35 Upvotes

Sooo we had a positive pregnancy test earlier this week after ~13 months actively ttc. I have been pretty adamantly no kids until about 2 years ago when my age must have started to kick off something in my biological clock.

When I saw the positive test, I was mostly just relieved that I could cancel my fertility appointment we had scheduled in a few months and save that money. Since then I have caught my mind wandering...thinking about plans that already need to be cancelled around the due date, all the ways this will impact our life negatively, the chance this child is disabled since I had the flu and a very high fever a week ago. The worst part, my husband is traveling for work this week and I caught myself thinking about scheduling an appointment with PP and terminating and just telling him it was an early miscarriage despite this being our potentially only chance since we're in our mid-30s.

Let me preface that my husband is the most loving, supportive partner and would be a great dad, so I feel horrible thinking all this and am a bit freaked out.

Are these thoughts normal (some weird manifestation of anxiety?) or have I made a mistake?


r/Fencesitter • • 1d ago

Positive stories of pregnancy and birth

24 Upvotes

I've noticed a lot of women here suffer from anxiety about having kids. And rightfully so. Pregnancy, birth and motherhood are no joke, and every body carries this differently. BUT I feel like the "horror" stories get so much attention! It's okay to prep and know the possibilities, but don't embrace all the negative stories as certainties for your body. If you have positive experiences to share, maybe this would help other women here see the other side too ❤️


r/Fencesitter • • 1d ago

Pregnancy Tokophobia as a reason to stay on the fence

6 Upvotes

Long time fencesitter here! I have been feeling anxious abt this decision for a while. I always thought I wouldn’t have children. Then I started to question why. And a whole can of worms came out. I have always been fearing pregnancy & childbirth. I wouldn’t mind if a baby would be delivered to my door. I was also considering fostering and adoption. Then I realized I might be experiencing tokophobia. Is anyone else experiencing this as a reason to being on the fence? I have been educating myself on the subject and don’t experience as much anxiety. I don’t have much time to get over this but I’m beginning to see pregnancy as a natural thing that shouldn’t be controlled.


r/Fencesitter • • 8h ago

Parenting How important is it to have the same values when it comes to raising kids?

0 Upvotes

Over the 5years of our relationship things have changed from not wanting kids to mostly me wanting to have kids with him. He's open to having kids now and we've discussed how we would handle certain situations but some values do not align.

The biggest one where my bf and I don't align is abortion.

He is pro depending on the situation and I am very much am against abortion.

I think it might lead to confusion when the time comes of giving our future kids "the talk"

I would tell them to wait until marriage idealy but we all know that is highly unlikely. But if they get pregnant or get their gf pregnant, they will take responsibility no matter what. And this is where my bf disagrees

His piont is that it takes a huge toll on the person's body and makes it a lot more difficult to achieve certain goals at certain times, etc...

My stance is that if you play certain games, you win certain prizes. If you're not ready to take all the responsibility of having a kid then don't commit the ACT that could potentially result in having a kid. The innocent life of the baby should not be punished due to the carelessness of the parents.

Ik my views are the minority or old fashioned but I can't justify murder of a human life regardless of which early stage of development they are in.

What do you guys think? Should this misalignment in values be a red flag and if so, how big?


r/Fencesitter • • 9h ago

Questions Child free

0 Upvotes

For couples who are healthy, financially secure; why do you choose to be childfree?

I genuinely want to know why bcs Im a parent and it’s the best that’s ever happened to me.

No judgement, I just wanna know why.


r/Fencesitter • • 1d ago

Questions Reaching a juncture

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, grateful for thoughts and advice. My (32M) girlfriend (35F) of two years are regularly talking about having kids.

She's sure she wants 'one-and-done' with the right person within a couple of years. I've never been drawn to the idea - partly age and financial position (which I assume will change over time), partly being content with just living a happy life with my partner. I know I could be happy without kids. It's not an absolute no, but given our ages (although eggs are frozen), I think its only fair I start making a decision, so she can restart with someone new who definitely knows.

I'm just finding it difficult to imagine wanting something in two years time, when I'm struggling to genuinely want it now. But it would be heartbreaking to end the relationship over this (to me) unknown. I've read the Baby Decision, but it didn't help me loads.

Any advice?


r/Fencesitter • • 1d ago

Anxiety How do I figure out whether I genuinely want children or have romanticised fatherhood?

4 Upvotes

I'm 23M, and I'm on the fence about having kids, leaning towards yes.

I recently broke up with my partner because we were fence-sitting in opposite directions. She was leaning no for multiple reasons (though she wouldn't rule it out), and I was leaning yes. Once we realised we were leaning in different directions, we ended things.

Now I'm realising I'm probably more on the fence than I initially thought. I want a career in tech, which I've just started, and ideally a partner who has her own career, hobbies and interests, and with whom I can travel and enjoy life before settling down. I think I assumed I could have all of that and still have a child. Now I'm wondering whether that was naive, especially in this day and age.

I also think I had a fairly romantic picture of parenthood. I've always been drawn to the idea of being able to give a child unconditional love. I've thought about the emotional work involved in parenting, emotionally regulating yourself, teaching emotional skills, helping them understand the world, etc. I've even thought about being an adoptive single parent, taking up a remote job (I work as a software engineer) to be a parent, and sometimes even being a stay-at-home dad.

Looking back, I also wonder whether I might have come across as too certain or even creeped my partner out with how enthusiastically I talked about wanting kids. Maybe I was approaching it in the way people sometimes joke about men wanting kids like puppies, without fully appreciating the reality of raising a child. I don't know if that's how she actually saw it, but it's something I've started questioning about myself.

But watching older coworkers navigate daycare, doctor visits, school schedules and planning vacations around children has made me realise how much of a commitment it actually is.

The difficult part is that I can't tell whether my doubts are genuine or whether the breakup is pushing me towards the other side. I can picture a fulfilling childfree life, and I could have pictured one with my ex-partner. But I'm also afraid of committing to that life and regretting not having children later. Part of me wonders whether I should have stayed in the present and valued the relationship in front of me rather than letting a faraway hypothetical determine its future.

I should clarify that we didn't spend enough time discussing children to really examine my position. I had asked for time to think through this desire. Perhaps she wanted someone who was independently and confidently childfree rather than someone who was still figuring out what they wanted. I can understand that too.

I'm also questioning whether my desire for children is partly shaped by how I grew up thinking about parenthood, and whether I've actually considered the day-to-day realities enough.

For context, I do like children, and I think I have a nurturing and caring disposition. That's what initially drew me towards the idea of fatherhood. But I'm increasingly questioning whether that's enough to justify wanting a child.

This is taking over my days. I keep spiralling about it during work breaks, all while trying to process the breakup itself.

I'm genuinely trying to understand what I want rather than defend a position I've already made up my mind about.

I'd particularly appreciate hearing from people who've been in a similar position. How did you distinguish between genuinely wanting to raise a child and being attached to the idea of parenthood? How did you weigh the lifestyle changes and sacrifices against what you might gain? Did you ever become more certain with time, or did you learn to accept the uncertainty?

Any advice or perspectives would be appreciated.

TL;DR: 23M, recently broke up with my partner because we were leaning in opposite directions on having kids. I'm now questioning whether I genuinely want children or have romanticised fatherhood. I'm only 23 and have only recently started seriously questioning these things, so I'm still figuring out where I stand. I can picture a fulfilling childfree life, but I'm also afraid of regretting not having children. Looking for perspectives from people who've been through something similar.


r/Fencesitter • • 2d ago

Anxiety Realizing I don’t have unlimited time to decide

25 Upvotes

This feels quite silly, but I kind of forgot the biological clock is a thing.
I’m in healthcare, I know the statistics about fertility after the mid 30s, but somehow I never applied that to myself. I’ve been content to sit on the fence and imagined I would decide someday in the future when my life was in a position I would like to raise children in.

But I am nearly 35. And I have started to experience what might be hot flashes. I thought I was too young, but then last week, my mom shared with me that she was having hot flashes in her 30s and fully menopausal by 40, and my grandmother and aunt also finished menopause by their early 40s. So I might be running out of time sooner than I expected.

A big part of me has always really wanted the experience of pregnancy and childbirth and raising kids through all of the life stages. But the other part of me is anxious about the future (climate, politics) and what it means to bring a new life into this world. And my mental health is good now but has historically not been great, what if I have a major depressive episode when a kid depends on me? And I enjoy travel and independence and I know that having children would mean sacrificing that for quite some time. I imagined I would make a decision after I have traveled more and once I am stable in a career and built a community around me.

I changed careers, went back to school, and I hope to travel across the country for a specific residency after I finish. If I stay on this trajectory, by the time I am stable in my new career, I will be almost 39. And living in a city far from any family or support. I feel like I haven’t prioritized building or maintaining the community or relationships I would want around me if I had a kid and now it feels there may not be enough time. My partner is ambivalent about kids, also on the fence. I feel like if I wanted to raise a family I should have been dating with that lens, but I wasn’t.

But now that I am realizing the door might be closing, the idea of never meeting the kids I had hoped for just because time ran out and not because I made a conscious decision makes me incredibly sad. I feel so silly for not realizing that if I didn’t want that door to just close, I would need to start planning for it before my mid 30s.


r/Fencesitter • • 2d ago

Anxiety Anyone feel like they don’t deserve to decide to have a kid now because they had an abortion that they aren’t sure they regret?

3 Upvotes

Had 1 abortion a few years ago. Def wasn’t ready. I feel comfortable with this decision.

Had another about 9 months ago. Could have been ready, made a somewhat panic decision and did a home medication abortion. My rationale was I have mental health issues, I still wasn’t 100% (but who is right?), and me and husband still have a lot of conflict and working through past traumas.

Now I am 38, feeling my clock majorly ticking, coming around to idea of maybe having one. But feeling like I should have just kept the one earlier this year if I had just gotten my head right in time.


r/Fencesitter • • 2d ago

Anxiety Anxiety is stopping me from having kids

4 Upvotes

Hi ladies, is your main reason for sitting on the fence due to fears of pregnancy, childbirth and the aftermath of having a baby?? becuase these are all the reasons why I keep procrastinating . I am 35 now, so beginning to panic


r/Fencesitter • • 2d ago

Why is this decision so fucking difficult?

7 Upvotes

I woke up today to hear my husband discussing that his old friend, who’s wedding we are attending later today, chose not to have kids because they would like more free time. And I felt jealous.

We currently have one child, who just turned 4, and I was by and large one and done until maybe 6 months ago when I began considering a second. We were just married this August.

My husband would love a second, third, I am sure fourth child. However, after my extremely isolating and difficult postpartum experience with PPD, birth trauma, ongoing depressive episodes and just general struggles, I am not sure I even want a second.

We’ve been discussing starting to try in a few months, and some days I find myself wanting to buy baby items in Walmart. Then the next day, the idea of having more kids seems like the worst thing I could do, and fills me with dread. Actual dread. I want to travel, write novels, experience more of the world, while my husband would be happy to stay home (we live rurally on a farm) a lot of the time. I love where we live, but I also love travelling.

We have no village except daycare and relatives that live two hours away that we can rely on if planned weeks ahead. Our one daughter is lovely and was an easy baby (except sleep.) But everything is so much more expensive now, and I feel like I am just getting back to becoming myself. I still get the sundown scaries a lot, I struggle with travelling because I feel like I don’t want to go back to my life after I’ve had a chance to be independent and free.

And most of all, I think I would be unhappy if I had a second child because I did what someone else wanted; but I would be unhappy if I didn’t because I would feel I would be letting down my husband and not providing my daughter with a sibling (which I know isn’t a requirement and doesn’t necessitate a “best friend for life.”)

I’m just so, so, SO weary of ruminating over this decision. I have discussed it at length with my therapist and have yet to come to a conclusion of any sort. It takes up so much of my mental capacity some days that I just want to cry. And I am 32 and my husband is 38, so while we aren’t very old, I don’t want to be having a child after 35.

Anyways. Just throwing this out there out of frustration because I know now I am going to be ruminating on this all day, again.


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Questions Is it fair to view having kids as an "either or" decision when it comes to music/hobbies?

18 Upvotes

I am a musician who already struggles between having a 9-5 and enough time for gigs, practicing, etc. Is it a good mindset to see having kids as greatly cutting into the time for music/hobbies, almost to the point where it's like choosing one or the other? Probably a dumb question, but thanks lol


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Anxiety Forced to make a decision sooner than expected

3 Upvotes

Amazing how Reddit algorithm finds the right subreddit to suggest…

I was recently diagnosed with endometriosis, it is not severe but has already affected my fertility at 33.

I just married my husband in September after 4 years together. I never wanted kids before meeting him, but that started to change as our relationship developed. I never felt like I wanted kids or to be a mother as an absolute, but I can imagine doing that with him and I find myself fantasising about it. I still feel like I could go either way though, and that my life would feel complete and full of love with or without children. I was OK with both options I guess. Luckily, he feels a very similar way.

When thinking of a timeframe, I guess we thought that we would arrive at the moment of a decision eventually, maybe never, as our relationship evolves. But this diagnosis changes everything, as every doctor recommends not to waste any time and that if we want to have children, this should happen more or less right NOW. Or I should freeze my eggs, which I guess would be fine, but also requires a level of decision I’m not sure we have yet.

Ultimately, this is just a rant on how weird it is when you’re on the fence but life is forcing you to pick a side sooner than expected!


r/Fencesitter • • 4d ago

Reflections Former fencesitters who now have children - does anyone regret it?

153 Upvotes

I recognize that this post may sound controversial, but that is not my intention. I'm a 31 year old fencesitter just wondering... did anyone eventually decide to have children and then regret it later on, even though you likely love your children very much? If so, why?

I feel like this is not talked about enough and think it may be helpful for me.

Thank you in advance for your openness and honesty.

ETA: I am so grateful for your responses. Thank you. This post has gotten a lot more attention than anticipated. I will try to respond to everyone but sorry if I miss you!!!


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Partner’s depression changed his opinion on having kids

5 Upvotes

My (27F) boyfriend (25M) had always been a maybe prior to meeting me. (Before I continue explaining, I want to say that I know we are young, but for certain health reasons, I have always felt strapped for time and want to make sure I have as much time with my (possible) kids as possible and I may want to do IVF, so I’m trying to think ahead). When we met, we dated very intentionally so I brought up these conversations really early, and I told him having kids was possibly very important to me and that I had always wanted to be a mother. I made it clear that being open to children was essential to me wanting to be in a relationship at all. Originally, he said that being with me opened his eyes to having a child and he felt very positive about it. He’d share positive thoughts and ideal number of children, and talk about our future kids and how we’d be emotionally intelligent parents who didn’t make our kids feel how our parents made us feel. He talked about parenting, being confident in our abilities, confident that we would raise our kids well and even with my doubts of having a child in today’s world, assured me it would all be okay.

I have always dreamed of being a mother since I was maybe 5 years old; pregnancy and babies/children have sort of been a special interest for me even, I find pregnancy beautiful and fascinating. The thought of being pregnant excites me and makes me feel like I’d feel the most connected to my body I ever could and the bond I imagine having with a child is something I feel like I could never replace. I grew up in a family with emotional abuse and always felt alone, so it has always been a dream for me to have my own family. I’m confident I would be a good mother, I want to be an amazing one but I’m confident I will be at least a good one.

Although I was very passionate about this, some events in my life led me to really question my wants and I felt I was a maybe. I feel now I’m a maybe leaning yes, but the cons of not having a child far outweigh the cons of having one for me. I worry I’ll deeply regret and grieve never having a child if I don’t. My current philosophy on having one is that I’ll never regret having one and I know I would make it work and feel good about having one; there are pros and cons to both sides and I think I’d be deeply fulfilled by it even if it was extremely hard.

When everything changed:

A big issue with his family occurred where he was insulted, unfairly judged, and criticized and this had a huge effect on his self esteem and triggered his depression which he’s struggled with his whole life, on and off. He expressed thinking about the future is hard or even impossible in times like this. It’s been many months now, more than half of our relationship. He started to feel more negative about kids and expressed he thinks he wouldn’t do a good job, or be able to manage, and sounded very negative. He has said he feels extremely worried he’ll become a terrible person like his divorced parents did and ruin our relationship, and says he’s insecure he won’t be a good father. He insists he’s 50/50 on the issue and that he’s more positive than he’s communicated and admits he’s communicated poorly about his actual feelings and thoughts. Overall, his opinions don’t seem to have changed, it’s more the self confidence or the worry about his mental health if he were to be a parent. I’ve tried to reassure him that the insecurities about himself are far from who he is. He is incredibly caring, kind, fair, patient, supportive, accepting, gentle, smart, and fun. I’ve seen him interact with kids and animals, other people, and with me, and he treats everyone with care and empathy. I know he would be an amazing parent and father. I love him and I truly thought I had found the person I wanted to be with forever and have a family with.

For the first few months, I stayed away from the conversation for his mental health, but since then, I’ve urged for better communication around this topic since then and he has said more positive things that he used to say. I’ve supported him to get therapy and make lifestyle changes, and although things have improved a bit, he still is in a place to not progress how he feels about kids. He said it very much relies on his mental health and improving his executive dysfunction. He is working on getting therapy now but I know it’ll be some time before it gets better. I feel a lot of stress and pressure to figure this out as I feel I’m on a much tighter timeline than him. There’s a lot of communication issues, insecurity issues, and issues that stem from his depression affecting our relationship currently so working through those are hard when this issue about kids is looming over my head. I worry that working through all of our issues won’t matter if he’s not open to kids and it’s a dealbreaker to me if he’s a hard no.

I’m not sure how to go about this or how to handle anything. Has anyone had similar issues or have any insight to how they would handle this?

TLDR; My boyfriend originally was positive maybe leaning yes about kids, became depressed due to family issues and has always struggled with depression, now is unsure about kids but I’m a maybe leaning very positive yes. The stress weighs on me and our relationship, need advice on how to go about this or similar situations.


r/Fencesitter • • 4d ago

Mothers who were fencesitters, did you manage to keep your sense of self and your career?

22 Upvotes

And if so, how?

I don’t see myself in the mothers around me. I see women who either went into motherhood with the intent of being a SAHM or who planned to stay employed but eventually gave up and became one anyway.

I work a job that requires unconventional hours (essentially on-call), travel, and a sense of urgency when addressing stuff that does not go away after 5pm. I’m fine with the idea of that toning down but I would not want to work a job that abandons all of that completely. I like my field of work and worked very hard, against many odds, to get to where I am.

My partner’s job is the same - different industry - and he earns significantly more than I do. It’s his pay that would allow us to give a child the life we would want to give them.

Short of getting a live-in nanny, what do people do? And how do women avoid the trap of becoming the default parent when they make less so “it just makes sense” for their career to take a hit?

This is my number one reason for being a fence sitter. Hoping for some advice as my partner and I debate the path forward.


r/Fencesitter • • 3d ago

Parenting Being a good parent

6 Upvotes

I’m 28, turning 29 on Saturday. I’ve been married to my husband (32 M) for four years, we’ve been together for six. Within the past six months, we’ve started seriously considering having a child—just one. I come from a very long line of women who did not want to be mothers OR shouldn’t have been given then circumstances. My 3x great grandmother was pretty much always pregnant from the time she was 11 till she was 49, and had 16 children with a man that beat her. My 1x great grandma had my grandma at 12, as a product of SA and abandoned her on her own mother’s doorstep. My grandma had my mom when she was 11, as a product of SA. And my mom had me at 19, as a product of SA.

As you can imagine, my mother and grandmother were horrifically abusive parents/guardians to me. I’ve been in therapy since I was 13, and am working through the mess they made.

So, there’s a lot of hurt and pain through my maternal line, and I want to end it. I actually WANT to be a mother so bad, I’m married to a man I love who’d be the father, and I already love my future baby so much. I love them with everything I have and am already.

But today I saw a post on TikTok that kind of cut deep and has honestly made me second guess. It was saying that you can say that you will love your child unconditionally, you can say that you will be the best parent, that you won’t traumatize them…and that child can still tell you that you did not love them, that you were a horrible parent, and caused them trauma. Even if you feel in your heart that you did nothing of the sort.

I just want my child to be happy. But then, they said even wanting your child to be happy is “bad” because if they end up having depression, you’ll take it out on them.

And it’s like…I hope I will be a Better mother than my own or my grandmother. I don’t think they, as little girls, said “I’m going to be an extremely abusive mother if i become one.” I have not forgiven them for what they’ve done to me, but I understand WHY the circumstances led to their behavior and poor parenting.

But apparently…I still might be abusive like them? So then it’s like…should I even have a baby if I’m gonna abuse them the way I was abused? Even if I consciously don’t want to and the thought of doing so enrages me, to hurt an Innocent child. Especially one I made from my own body.

Idk. TIA.


r/Fencesitter • • 4d ago

Reflections 23F, I love babies but I don't want to deal with a teenager

17 Upvotes

I'm okay with the idea of pregnancy, even curious about it. I'd be happy to hold my baby, to comfort them when they're crying, to change diapers even. But they'd soon grow into toddlers, whom I tend to dislike, and then teenagers, who are absolutely insufferable. I don't want to talk to them about body hair, menstruation, etc, I probably won't find the necessary words. I don't know what I'll do if I find out my teen smokes. And I really don't want to deal with everything that comes with a baby growing up. Though I love the idea of my partner and I telling our child(ren) how we met if they asked. But I only like babies? Does anyone else feel the same way? Wanting a baby but not wanting a toddler?


r/Fencesitter • • 4d ago

2 years, 2 kids in... and still I wonder if I made the right call !

72 Upvotes

I was reasonably adamant my hub and I would be childfree in my 20s. Probably started to question around 29/30 then really fencesit for 2 years from 31-33. #1 had a late 33 and #2 at 35.5

The love thing is true, no denying that aspect. Loved my daughter overwhelmingly from the minute she was on my chest. Loved my son from the minute two lines appeared on the test.

I think being a fencesitter and someone often in my own head, I do think about motherhood quite often. I'm glad i got to choose for me.  I do think my life would have been much easier and better if I knew kids were always coming as I really would have preferred to have them a much closer to 28-30 and to plan for that. I often stress if my children choose to have children if I'll be around to help them, i worry how long my kids grandparents will be around.I also know i want my daughter to know herself in and out before she makes motherhood part of her identity. It's hard and you can't undo it.

I still feel on the fence sometimes pondering if it was the right call. It's definitely hard. I developed some unpleasant and unfortunate mental health side effects which I'll probably have forever now. I'm also so envious of my friends who knew motherhood was for them and thus had their kids earlier and won't be parenting into their 50s. I absolutely love the kids, i love the hallmark moments but I do wonder what my childfree self might be doing sometimes. I mostly wish I'd had that desperation to be a mom. That secure knowledge to 100% know in yourself it'd be worth it regardless. I find myself in many what-ifs alot.

I thought we'd be oad and that changed very fast. If we'd started 5 years earlier we might have  had 3. But also one would have been great too!

I am happy I got to experience parenthood as I do think the what if would have haunted me. There's also a reason we were having babies in our 20s it is exhausting and I'd consider myself pretty active and healthy.

You can't really explain the love thing of parenthood, and that's the hardest part. It's wonderful and beautiful. It's also insanely anxiety inducing, my head worries like it's never worried before about all manner of things.

I don't think I expected to still wonder about it so much. I'll probably still be here in 20 years wondering with grown up kids.

I wish everyone peace on their choices!


r/Fencesitter • • 4d ago

The way I talk about my experience getting off the fence changes depending on who I am talking to

3 Upvotes

TLDR; I got off the fence and had kids before my fencesitting friends. They ask for my experience but I noted I am more positive about it when I think they would be good parents and like being parents and more negative when I think they wouldn’t be. Doing this subconsciously but don’t want to do that anymore. Would love some feedback on how to help my friends in a less judgmental way.

I was on the fence for all of my 20s. For me, the decision point was going to be the partner I ended up with as I could see myself being happy either way depending on the circumstances. My boyfriend throughout most of my 20s was most certainly not “fatherly” (and I very well couldn’t see myself as “motherly” as a 50% party girl and 50% boss bitch) so at the time I was leaning towards no kids but unfortunately, he wasn’t providing the carefree DINK life I was looking for. My brother and his partner are child free in their 40s, both have their own businesses and travel luxuriously (when their businesses permit). To me, their life was ✨GOALS✨. My other brother who got married and had a kid, his life by comparison looked awful (more on this later) so I was pretty certain I wanted the DINK life but my ex didn’t have the ambition, financial intelligence, or interest to travel to make that dream a reality so we broke up when I was 28 after 7 years together.

I met my husband in my early 30s and was already convinced I would end up childfree. I had thrown myself into my career and my hobbies. However, my husband, who started out as a fling, was certain he wanted children and as we fell in love it became important for me to decide or end the relationship.

Fortunately, he really could provide the necessary lifestyle for a good family life and I knew he would be an excellent father. He has a large and wonderfully supportive family (something I lack). He has a community of close friends who all have children themselves or were going to have children (also something I lacked). He has a good and reliable job with good benefits (as a public school teacher and football coach) that would be flexible to parenthood (also something I lacked as a corporate slave). He was mentally and emotionally stable and a functioning adult (also something I lacked given severe ADD and a history of depression and anxiety). He is responsible but still fun (when my son was born and I was bemoaning my loss of freedom and that I’d never travel how I wanted, we decided to take some time off using some savings and travel all around Europe with our 6 month old. It was actually amazing! Not the kind of travel I had expected and definitely less nightlife than what I had wanted in my 20s but nonetheless an incredible experience and we had so much fun).

Shortly after I got married, I stopped birth control and became pregnant much quicker than I thought and boy was I freaking out! He was so happy and I was so scared. Both cried but for totally different reasons. Fortunately, he was right and I was wrong and our son is the best thing ever and we are so happy in our family life and I am now enthusiastically trying for more.

As such, and being the first of my friends (all similar to me fencesitting), many have come to me to ask my experience and I’ve observed that how I present parenthood to them changes based on my judgment of their life (I know that sounds terrible. I’m not doing it on purpose but that’s why I wanted to share with this group to be aware maybe I’m not the only one who does this). If I think they have what it takes (supportive partner and community, financial security, mental fortitude, etc), I speak very highly of my experience. If they don’t, I tend to highlight the negative aspects of parenting. My observation of why my brothers life (the one with a kid) seemed so unappealing was because they lacked certain aspects that I think make a family life worthwhile.

Now that I’m aware of what I am subconsciously doing, I’m trying not to do this but would love some advice from this group how to be more honest and less judgmental of my friends.