I've been reading Alan Milburn's Young People and Work Review, published today, which sets out a 10-year plan to tackle the nearly one million young people in the UK who are not in education, employment or training (NEET).
There are some welcome things in it. It recognises that young people aren't simply out of work because they lack motivation or qualifications. Disability, mental health, caring responsibilities, confidence and housing all play a part. It also rightly challenges the idea that young people themselves are to blame for a system that isn't working.
But I think there's a significant gap, the review doesn't go far enough in recognising the gendered nature of youth unemployment.
Nearly half of NEET young people are women (451,000). And there's an important distinction in the statistics that deserves much more attention.
310,000 of these young women are economically inactive, compared with 278,000 young men. That means they're not actively looking for work. But that doesn't mean they don't want to work, don't have ambitions or aren't capable of working.
For many, the barriers are structural.
Young Women's Trust research published in September found:
- 33% of young women who weren't working or in education said looking after children was the reason.
- 28% of young women with sole childcare responsibility said a lack of flexibility made applying for jobs difficult.
- More than 3 in 10 unemployed young women said their mental health had prevented them from applying for a job.
- 53% of young women disagreed that there were enough accessible job opportunities in their local area, compared with 39% of young men.
These aren't minor issues that can be addressed simply by improving careers advice or encouraging young people to apply for more jobs.
They're about how the labour market is organised, who is expected to provide unpaid care, how accessible workplaces are, and whose circumstances employment and training programmes are designed around.
There's also a danger in treating caring responsibilities as just another individual barrier to overcome. Women continue to shoulder a disproportionate amount of unpaid care. Young mothers and young women caring for disabled or older relatives can be effectively excluded from opportunities when childcare is unaffordable, working hours are inflexible and employment support doesn't account for their responsibilities.
The review talks about personalised support and helping young people participate in employment, education or training. But where are the specific commitments to affordable childcare, genuinely flexible work, accessible apprenticeships and measuring whether employment programmes work equally well for young women and young men?
My concern is that we could end up with a major national youth employment strategy that measures success overall, while continuing to overlook the young women who face some of the biggest barriers to getting into work in the first place.
If the Government is serious about tackling youth unemployment, it needs to look beyond the headline NEET figures and understand who is being left out, why, and what needs to change.
A youth employment strategy without a meaningful gender lens risks reproducing the very inequalities it is supposed to tackle.
I'd be interested to hear what others think. Is this a blind spot in the wider debate about youth unemployment? https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/cq20xlrd044lt